Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you actually care about the environment?

441 replies

HamsterKebab · 13/02/2024 16:17

I think a lot of people say they care, but do you really? Have you adjusted your life with wildlife or the climate in mind? Or does convenience come first?

Im genuinely interested in how much the general public truly cares about biodiversity loss, climate change, pollution. Does it bother you or do you just think ‘someone else will deal with it’. I’m not judging, I genuinely want to know how people honestly feel rather than what they say out loud.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Ilovelurchers · 17/02/2024 16:42

This is a really interesting thread, and I think a good discussion to have in real life too. I think almost everyone will care to come extent (the extent will vary hugely of course). Almost everyone will be willing to make SOME sacrifices/adjustments, but again these vary hugely. Consequently, where exactly we all draw the line if hugely important, and if discussion changes it even a little bit in the right direction - how great! Adjustments I HAVE made:

  • Don't fly anywhere - haven't since I became climate-aware.
  • stopped at one child.
  • but vast majority of our stuff (clothes, hooks furniture etc) second hand.
  • I don't drive, I use public transport.
  • degree of self-sufficiency (have an allotment) which we will increase as we get older.

Things I haven't done but know I should, ethically speaking:

  • become vegan - I know I should - I just don't like vegan food that much.
  • given up shopping new altogether (I still sometimes order pointless plastic shit for me or for gifts - I feel guilty but I do it.
  • I do have one child, the most selfish thing you can do in terms of harm to the planet.
  • my husband has vehicles (cars, vans, motorbikes) and I let him drive me around.
  • I have a pet dog and a cat and will have more pets when I can, tho again I know full well that the carbon footprint is HUGE.

So I'm pretty awful really. But I could easily just talk about the first bit and make myself sound saintly. It would be nonsense.

Personally I don't really think anything will change unless globally governments adopt a radically different policy - small personal changes in our individual lives can never be enough. Nontheless, it is better to light a candle than curse the darkness, always......

greengreengrass25 · 17/02/2024 16:19

SideBob · 17/02/2024 10:21

How is ULEZ a nightmare? All it did was punish a minuscule number of drivers with old and not-quite-classic cars or diesels.

Did not go far enough. Sick if seeing massive range rovers whizzing around. Usually to drop the kids at school 0.5 miles from home because people are allergic to walking.

It was a nightmare for those in the outer boroughs who were not well off and could not afford to replace their cars and those who bought a diesel in good faith a few years ago

Those stupid learner bikes are a liability

DistingusedSocialCommentator · 17/02/2024 15:18

More so as we get older did care before not as much
Me and my OH feel guilty re our cars, a massive/propery diesel Range Rover, a massive MB diesel - and big engined petrol 2 door sports car.

We have considered an EV - but lack of charging points, and battery life/mileage etc, we are not convinced.

Barbadossunset · 17/02/2024 15:15

DdraigGoch · Yesterday 02:14
Activists should glue themselves to private jets and superyachts. They'll actually have support from the public as well as making a real difference to emissions. I'd even buy the glue.

There’s another thread, an AMA by a poster who used to work at a private airport and she says it would be nigh on impossible to glue yourself to a private jet. Maybe you should take up the challenge?

SideBob · 17/02/2024 10:21

How is ULEZ a nightmare? All it did was punish a minuscule number of drivers with old and not-quite-classic cars or diesels.

Did not go far enough. Sick if seeing massive range rovers whizzing around. Usually to drop the kids at school 0.5 miles from home because people are allergic to walking.

Ohdeardddddeardear · 17/02/2024 09:09

greengreengrass25 · 17/02/2024 08:59

People still have to live.

I do think it is a way to control people and for the government to make money out of the electorate

Ulez is a nightmare yet we still have all those motorcycles from food delivery driving about suddenly appearing after lock down. Why are they necessary?

You know when the Government make money, that it’s for public services and infrastructure right? Sure, some MPs have fiddled their expenses. The current lot have a track record of cronyism. But the money made is public money. OUR money. We might not agree with how it’s spent but come election time we can use our vote to express how we want it used.

greengreengrass25 · 17/02/2024 08:59

People still have to live.

I do think it is a way to control people and for the government to make money out of the electorate

Ulez is a nightmare yet we still have all those motorcycles from food delivery driving about suddenly appearing after lock down. Why are they necessary?

Paulrn · 17/02/2024 08:55

Ohdeardddddeardear · 17/02/2024 08:33

Thats hilarious. I’ve given you facts. Solid evidence. You’ve not been able to refute any of it sensibly. If you decide not to care and not to change your behaviour then that’s a difference of opinion. I would accept that. But you are basically saying you are hanging on to your opinion, despite me pointing out that the facts show it’s wrong. Incontrovertible facts. Things you will have seen with your own two eyes. At least in the film ‘Don’t Look Up’ when people could see the asteroid they started to believe it.

Climate change IS happening. We are causing it to happen way too rapidly. Our survival is at risk. Life is going to get increasingly difficult. We could choose, collectively, to lessen the worst of it.

You can choose to block your ears and eyes but it won’t stop it happening. I’m sorry.

So pleased I bought happiness and hilarity to your morning shall we stop now.

Ohdeardddddeardear · 17/02/2024 08:33

Paulrn · 17/02/2024 08:20

I seem to have become your pet project. Let’s agree to disagree from my perspective the whole thing is led by activists and their willingness to bring chaos to society just gets my back up. So I will keep my views and will defend your right to have yours.

Thats hilarious. I’ve given you facts. Solid evidence. You’ve not been able to refute any of it sensibly. If you decide not to care and not to change your behaviour then that’s a difference of opinion. I would accept that. But you are basically saying you are hanging on to your opinion, despite me pointing out that the facts show it’s wrong. Incontrovertible facts. Things you will have seen with your own two eyes. At least in the film ‘Don’t Look Up’ when people could see the asteroid they started to believe it.

Climate change IS happening. We are causing it to happen way too rapidly. Our survival is at risk. Life is going to get increasingly difficult. We could choose, collectively, to lessen the worst of it.

You can choose to block your ears and eyes but it won’t stop it happening. I’m sorry.

Paulrn · 17/02/2024 08:20

Ohdeardddddeardear · 16/02/2024 22:08

So you are right that theories emerge and then new techniques and evidence emerges that refute or add to the existing understanding or theory. But this is different. There is an absolute global consensus of scientists (bar a very small number who have vested interests) that climate change is happening faster and more ferociously than ever and that the cause is man made. There is may be 0.0001% doubt. We could cling to that minuscule hope or do something to avoid the worst.

So far the vast majority of climate models have underestimated rather than over estimated the effects. It’s happening quicker and more extremely than was predicted.

Not only that, but you can SEE the effects already. You must have seen the news reports of dreadful floods, heatwaves and fires, exacerbated by climate change? You can’t really doubt the increase in mortality linked to climate. That’s just statistical facts. If you doubt the science you are either massively misinformed, stupid or just want to try and pretend this isn’t happening. But it is.

I seem to have become your pet project. Let’s agree to disagree from my perspective the whole thing is led by activists and their willingness to bring chaos to society just gets my back up. So I will keep my views and will defend your right to have yours.

Halftermhalf · 17/02/2024 07:16

Do people think if we all made changes collectively it would make a difference? I have, don’t drive a car, vegan, recycle every thing, stopped flying I can but I could do more. I hate the idea of DC living in a world that we’ve collectively fucked up and can’t be arsed to do anything about.

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2024/feb/17/february-on-course-to-break-unprecedented-number-of-heat-records

February on course to break unprecedented number of heat records

Rapid ocean warming and unusually hot winter days recorded as human-made global heating combines with El Niño

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2024/feb/17/february-on-course-to-break-unprecedented-number-of-heat-records

weregonnagetrelagetedthistimeforsure · 16/02/2024 23:22

Beezknees · 16/02/2024 15:19

Yes, I accept that. There's very little I can do as an individual. I don't even own a car. I could give up flying and eating meat, but I don't want to.

I do plenty but I also accept that my DC are going to live in a very different world. In fact (and I know this will be unacceptable to some people) I have always been fairly honest with my DC that the future is looking pretty bleak and hectic and there are likely to be fires, flood, mass migration and a lot of unrest. But I am building their compassion, their community strength and told them we are all in the same boat, they have to be strong, look after other people and do what they can.
I know this sounds flippant but . . . millions of people all over the world are already in a living hell. What makes us in the west think we are immune?

We're just gonna have to suck it up, lose loved ones. lose our homes, lose our land, lose our livelihoods, fight for our survival - like millions of other humans are having to do every single day because of our collective complacency.

Wittyname10 · 16/02/2024 22:45

I do care, sort of.

We live rurally so can grow our own food, burn renewable wood instead of coal
in fires, recycle as much as possible, make our own compost and spent £12k putting solar panels on our house.

Ultimately it won’t be enough. Not enough people can do enough, we probably don’t even do enough.

We have two diesel cars, one 11 years old and one 4 years old. We still cook with gas, I love to bbq on gas and we frequently do in summer, I cut my lawn with petrol and maintain it using organic fertiliser.

WTF are you supposed to do, short of becoming a hermit?

Ohdeardddddeardear · 16/02/2024 22:24

Theonlylonely · 16/02/2024 08:12

Personally I think it’s consumerism and keeping up with the jones that’s the problem… if you live a slower more local life and stop buying stuff, put your efforts into developing connections with people/ animals/ nature, prioritise healthy eating and getting in the great outdoors and enjoying cultural experiences on your doorstep, you’ll probably be happier and your carbon footprint will be lower without having to think about it very much.

I agree. I think we would all be happier if we stopped chasing the short term high of buying something and learned to get joy from connections and belonging. I think unfettered capitalism is the root of many of the things that are wrong in our society.

Ohdeardddddeardear · 16/02/2024 22:17

ChiefEverythingOfficer · 16/02/2024 02:38

I care a lot.

My company is B-CORP certified.
Travel only when essential.
Recycle and reuse - actively participate in a Buy Nothing community group.
Buy local (food).
Low red meat diet.
Just spent a whole year without buying anything new (except food, toiletries and toilet paper).
If I did need to buy something new, I would shop consciously.
We do not use pesticides or commercial cleaning products.

Will it do much to help - probably not. I work on the premise that if we all take responsibility for ourselves then collectively we might have a chancem

It has made a difference. I just read that and thought ‘buy nothing new for a year’ sounds like a great challenge and I’m up for it! I’ll probably talk about it with around 40 people as and when I see them. If five of them get inspired they might inspire another 5. And so on. Before you know it your efforts and sharing it on here has saved billions of tonnes of carbon.

Go you!

Ohdeardddddeardear · 16/02/2024 22:08

Paulrn · 15/02/2024 21:03

To be honest I don’t care that you think it’s bonkers. I am not convinced by the “science” I remember when I was young the environmentalists were trying to convince us that we were headed for an ice age. And when diesel cars were good for the environment etc etc it’s just nature.

So you are right that theories emerge and then new techniques and evidence emerges that refute or add to the existing understanding or theory. But this is different. There is an absolute global consensus of scientists (bar a very small number who have vested interests) that climate change is happening faster and more ferociously than ever and that the cause is man made. There is may be 0.0001% doubt. We could cling to that minuscule hope or do something to avoid the worst.

So far the vast majority of climate models have underestimated rather than over estimated the effects. It’s happening quicker and more extremely than was predicted.

Not only that, but you can SEE the effects already. You must have seen the news reports of dreadful floods, heatwaves and fires, exacerbated by climate change? You can’t really doubt the increase in mortality linked to climate. That’s just statistical facts. If you doubt the science you are either massively misinformed, stupid or just want to try and pretend this isn’t happening. But it is.

Beezknees · 16/02/2024 15:19

Halftermhalf · 16/02/2024 02:36

Interesting thread OP.

For those of you saying you’re not, or just not interested, if you have DC how to you reconcile that? Do you just accept that you’ll do nothing now and they’ll almost certainly live in a very different world.

Yes, I accept that. There's very little I can do as an individual. I don't even own a car. I could give up flying and eating meat, but I don't want to.

SideBob · 16/02/2024 15:15

DdraigGoch · 16/02/2024 13:19

The idea of an individual 'carbon footprint' was originally pushed by BP, a major fossil fuel company. It was a very successful tactic of shifting the blame of climate change onto the average person.

Where do BP get their money from?

From people buying hydrocarbons from them. The less you buy, the less they pollute.

Although FF companies are shitty and have vested interest in diverting blame/undermining climate DH change efforts..

Carbon footprint is still very relevant. Some things aren't a choice.

Hearing home in freezing weather = not a choice.
Hearing home to 25C so you can wall around in shorts = choice.

Needing a may not be a choice.
Concreting over your front garden = a choice.

Needing stuff and clothes occasionally = not a choice
Choosing to buy plastic tat from Temu that you saw on a instagram reel is a choice.

Having children = a basic right, a life aspiration for many.
Having 6 of them instead of 1,2 or even 3 is = choice.

And so on. Both can be true.

DdraigGoch · 16/02/2024 13:19

The idea of an individual 'carbon footprint' was originally pushed by BP, a major fossil fuel company. It was a very successful tactic of shifting the blame of climate change onto the average person.

Where do BP get their money from?

From people buying hydrocarbons from them. The less you buy, the less they pollute.

MercanDede · 16/02/2024 09:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MercanDede · 16/02/2024 09:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Theonlylonely · 16/02/2024 08:12

Personally I think it’s consumerism and keeping up with the jones that’s the problem… if you live a slower more local life and stop buying stuff, put your efforts into developing connections with people/ animals/ nature, prioritise healthy eating and getting in the great outdoors and enjoying cultural experiences on your doorstep, you’ll probably be happier and your carbon footprint will be lower without having to think about it very much.

greengreengrass25 · 16/02/2024 07:52

Yes I know where you are coming from

I think we can all do what we can but we still have to get on with our lives.

Theonlylonely · 16/02/2024 07:47

@greengreengrass25 haha yes! I remember attending a measuring your carbon footprint meeting with environmentalists c 2006 when it was quite a new concept.

They did an audit and actually measured the carbon release from bike tyres and wondered about rubber shoes emissions while walking. I just thought wtf is this nonsense… these zealots were well travelled and privileged, probably had investments which were high carbon supporting.

It all just felt so ridiculous and petty, while I have always had a simple lifestyle (except travel when younger) it’s difficult to hear such patronising nonsense from environmentalists who always come from the same sort of background. I do wonder where is the diversity and why it’s such a middle class pursuit? Probably because everyone else is already low carbon by necessity!

greengreengrass25 · 16/02/2024 07:37

@Theonlylonely

Yes have to agree

I remember a couple of people involved in ER on rallies

Neither on them seemed to have a 9-5 job as their dhs had high paying jobs etc

Swipe left for the next trending thread