Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This is a dire financial situation isn’t it?

313 replies

Whataballsupp · 13/02/2024 14:17

I’m recently a single parent. I own the home we were both in and now I’m obviously paying everything for it, mortgage and bills around 1,400 a month. The mortgage I owe is 290k, I’m 36 and it’s still got 36 years left to run on it.

At the moment I have a spare 1k a month. I am trying to save this as I am now a single parent and who knows what is going to happen. But I’ve just looked on an overpayment calculator and if I overpaid mortgage by 500 a month for example, it takes around 20 years off the mortgage. Even making that overpayment for a year would cut down a few years I have to pay it off.

Should I be saving or overpaying? I am panicking as it’s just me and I have only 5k savings overall at the moment. Don’t know what to do.

OP posts:
Peaceandquietandacuppa · 13/02/2024 18:41

Fuck me, if your situation is dire then I may as well give up.

By all means ask for advice but please try and limit your anxiety, £1k per month to play with is not dire. I’d also do a combo of overpaying as much as you can without penalty and building up savings.

TiptoeTess · 13/02/2024 18:38

Lovingitallnow · 13/02/2024 14:22

I would save for a year and build up a nice lump of savings for myself and then in a years time overpay.

This.

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 13/02/2024 18:37

2.5 year olds are really cheap to run......tbh these are the years I'd be ploughing the money into my mortgage. Its a no brained to me, when she's a teenager is when you'll need to fund a lot more so may be less able. I'd build my savings up to 10k then put the 1k a month into the mortgage, you can always adjust it for the months you need more cash.

Lalalaal · 13/02/2024 18:36

Mmm in your position I personally wouldn’t over pay. Just pay the bills and save what you can for a rainy day and get through the next couple of years and see where it takes you.

If you can save a little it’s probably more advantageous to have some money in the bank for if you need it quickly rather than overpaying the mortgage.

Just because your term is 36 years doesn’t mean that’s what it will end up being. You could downsize, sell, rent etc in the future. Who is to say you won’t go on to meet somebody new in a few years and set up home together?

Id just focus on maintaining stability for now.

Silvers11 · 13/02/2024 18:35

I agree with others - you can get more in interest on your savings than you are paying on your mortgage. So I would save it. However, when your mortgage fix ends and the interest rate becomes higher than the best savings rate you can get, then is the time to put it on your mortgage?

SilverBranchGoldenPears · 13/02/2024 18:35

Calvinlookingforhobbs · 13/02/2024 14:23

You sound really sensible and it looks like you can do both. £500 saving and £500 onto the mortgage. Having the entire weight on your shoulders and it sounds like you’re panicking. It’s normal to feel overwhelmed, do you have someone you can speak to? Or consider down counselling. It can really help. Best of luck.

This is a good plan. Do both. Breathe deep. You can do this.

Isitautumnyet23 · 13/02/2024 18:34

I don’t think your situation is dire and tbh, the state pension will be that age by the time you retire. Im older than you and its currently 68 and expected to go up. So realistically, a large proportion of people will be working till at least 70 from our generation.

Personally, I would save some more money (you sound like you are a sensible saver who isn’t going to splurge it) as you have so many years left of work and you are more than likely to meet someone else and circumstances change. I would say with only 5k of saving, what if you had a year of needing a new car/something big with the house?

anothernewstart9 · 13/02/2024 18:33

Lovingitallnow · 13/02/2024 14:22

I would save for a year and build up a nice lump of savings for myself and then in a years time overpay.

I'd do this. The x12 months savings added to your current £5k pot would give you a decent safety net. Then I would look into making overpayments on your mortgage.

Cucamelons · 13/02/2024 18:33

Glenthebattleostrich · 13/02/2024 14:22

I'd do half into mortgage and half into savings.

This definitely if you can

Mumof2girls2121 · 13/02/2024 18:32

Save half, pay half off the mortgage. Once you get a years bills in the bank continue to pay chunks off your mortgage.

laclochette · 13/02/2024 18:31

You really don't need to panic.
You can afford to overpay AND to save.
I would upweight saving until you have an emergency fund of 6 months' living expenses.
Then, slightly upweight your overpayments.

Your wages will increase even if only with inflation, meaning it will get easier and easier to overpay. Yes overpaying earlier on reduces your interest payments the most, but even small overpayments make a big difference.

Based on the stats you've given, if you overpay by £200 a month you will pay your mortgage off 8 years and 8 months earlier.

By £300 a month and you'll be paid off 11 months and 7 years earlier.

So I think...you'll be fine.

Don't worry about your debt. It's an efficient debt, and you are usually better off using money now (to invest etc), where it will work harder for you, than putting it into your mortgage. It's a "good use of balance sheet" to have a decently priced mortgage.

Bananasandtoast · 13/02/2024 18:30

Another vote to stash the cash.
I think you'd feel better emotionally if you saved the £1k pcm until the end of the year, now you've got a tidy 17k to bounce between the highest interest easy access accounts you find each year .
Then, in January 2025, all guns blazing to the mortgage not worrying that actually you might need that money if the shit hits the fan. Happy New Year to you!

JTRSOP · 13/02/2024 18:25

Eeepsh · 13/02/2024 14:23

Have you checked if there is an annual limit as to how much you can overpay? If so, that might help your decision.

Edited

There will be a limit. It’s usually around £10,000 a year so I’d be careful or you will end up paying a redemption penalty.

CheeseCakeSunflowers · 13/02/2024 18:25

Generally loans have higher interest rates than savings accounts, the difference is how the lenders make their money. At the moment you have a good deal with a low interest rate of 3% on your mortgage, take a look around and see what the highest savings rate is for an account that suits your needs, so check that you can pay in after the initial deposit and check what the withdrawal arrangements are. If you can find something suitable that pays more than 3% then it would be best to save than to pay off the mortgage. If in the future the mortgage rate rises to above the savings rate then you can use some of the savings to pay off a lump sum then, checking that no extra charges will be made by your mortgage lender.

Rokaswappa · 13/02/2024 18:22

Singleandproud · 13/02/2024 14:58

Being a single parent with all the financial responsibility is daunting whether you have 5p in the bank or £50k - obviousy not the same situation but feels similar to the individual

OP you are in a good situation, you have savings, spare cash and own your own home on a low interest rate. Your current financial situation will not stay stagnant IE I a few years nursery fees will disappear etc

Do you want to stay in your house? There is potential to downsize if you no longer need that size house decreasing utilities as you go.

Personally I would put it in a high interest account and transfer half over when it came time to remortgage at a higher rate. Leaving some for easy access, emergencys or treats. If you are young enough it's hard to beat a LISA with the 25% bonus for up to £4000 a year although as a home owner you won't get access to it until you retire.

You can access it but it incurs some penalties. I have one that I pay into monthly as well as an “easy access” savings account. I think the LISA is definitely a good idea as OP may well be absolutely fine and not need to dip in, but if she does it isn’t totally inaccessible. 😊

Yumyumyumm · 13/02/2024 18:22

Threads like this make me realise how out of touch people are. You have a thousand pounds spare a month you can either over pay your mortgage or save or do 50/50.

I have 40 pence until pay day. Which is in 10 days and I have no idea what I’m going to do. I’ve already gone without food today.

So no, your financial situation is not fucking dire. You are very much in a privileged position.

Bryonny84 · 13/02/2024 18:21

I'd overpay if you also have savings for emergencies. You don't want to be paying a mortgage in your 70's assuming you could even still work. I paid mine off at 55 and that was starting over in my very late 30's. Best thing I ever did.

Redballgreenball · 13/02/2024 18:15

You need around 6 months salary in savings as an emergency fund first. Only then would I overpay the mortgage. Because once you overpay the mortgage you can't get that money back out! Keep it in a high interest savings account instead.

Rokaswappa · 13/02/2024 18:12

Absolutely not dire! I’m a single mum too and have a quite a bit less left “spare” at the end of the month, but a much shorter and cheaper mortgage. Swings and roundabouts. I’d work out what you need to overpay to get it finished by age 60/65 (depending on how long you plan to work). Anything else split between a LISA and whatever other savings you pay into, in whatever proportions suit you. 5k is a nice amount to have as back up for unexpected expenses/ car trouble/ boiler repairs etc.

Sounds like you’re in a really strong financial position to me and you must be pretty financially competent to even ask the question. You’ll be fine! 💪💪💪

Ophy83 · 13/02/2024 18:11

How big is the house? Remember circumstances change- if it's a large house you may want to downsize when your child is grown, or you may meet someone new etc etc. Sounds like a good idea to save and maybe pay a bit extra on the mortgage if you won't be penalised

purplehotdogs · 13/02/2024 18:09

3%?? Don't need to overpay that mortgage at that rate, put your money into a high interest savings account so it earns you instead of costing you. You can always pay off a lump sum when you come to remortgage with the money you saved and that has been earning interest, and shorten your mortgage term that way.

Keepitsimple1 · 13/02/2024 18:08

Save until you have 6 months expenditure in an ‘emergency pot’. This is how much is usually recommended to keep you afloat should something go wrong. Best to have it in something cash/instant access.

What is more important is protection for your mortgage and your income should you become ill. You may have those through work. You can take these out privately which is usually not expensive at your age or take out additional policies to top up anything your employer provides. Bear these benefits in mind if you move jobs.

In terms of paying overpaying a mortgage,
there are usually limits on how much you can overpay in a year but it is usually the case that you can cancel the overpayment at anytime. If you used your emergency pot, you could stop the payments temporarily to top it back up.

Making additional pension payments has a similar benefits to over paying your mortgage in that paying in more now makes you much much better off in future. This is because of the investment growth in the long term.

Other things to consider are that you may receive lump sums in the future, inheritance or lump sums from your pension which can be used to pay off lumps from your mortgage. Money paid into your pension isn’t accessible until your 60’s, whereas you could always remortgage to access some of your mortgage overpayments if you need to.

Also, interest rates may decrease over the next few years whereas the tax relief on pension contributions is 20 or 40% which is high. In some cases your employer will match some of the additional contribution you make.

Also, ask if your employer has free financial advice available. It may also be prudent to check what type of pension you have and if it is invested the best way for you. People often forget this and put money in and don’t understand how it’s actually invested ie low risk/high risk.

Generally - the rule of thumb for priority is…

  1. emergency pot/cash (6months)
  2. protection
  3. mortgage
and/or pension (maybe pay 50/50 from what’s left of your £1000).

Make sure you have a Will in place and update any letter of wishes for pensions and life insurance with your employer.

Review your plan in few years or if something major changes in your life.

samarrange · 13/02/2024 18:02

As long as you have sufficient cash saved for emergencies, overpaying on your mortgage is one of the best returns for your money that you can get. If the average interest rate over the lifetime of the mortgage is 3% versus 2% on a savings account, you are locking in 1% extra for every year left on the mortgage for the overpayment amount, in one go, today. That's a lot.

Remember, the money that you have overpaid is still yours, it's just harder to get at quickly. But if something truly major arises you can still get at your equity, either by remortgaging or if needs be by selling the house.

Also, it will show the bank that you are a financially serious customer, and they like those. If you have been overpaying, your bank may look more favourably on the idea of some kind of payment holiday if you can't make the full monthly payment for a while.

Jk8 · 13/02/2024 17:58

How is having £1000 a Month left over for savings + your own home "a dire situation" ????

Just pay the fully grand onto the mortgage & re-draw if it allows you too in an emergency

IsthisthereallifeIsthisjustfantasy · 13/02/2024 17:57

You could also downsize at some point? Now or when your child grows up and leaves home?