Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This is a dire financial situation isn’t it?

313 replies

Whataballsupp · 13/02/2024 14:17

I’m recently a single parent. I own the home we were both in and now I’m obviously paying everything for it, mortgage and bills around 1,400 a month. The mortgage I owe is 290k, I’m 36 and it’s still got 36 years left to run on it.

At the moment I have a spare 1k a month. I am trying to save this as I am now a single parent and who knows what is going to happen. But I’ve just looked on an overpayment calculator and if I overpaid mortgage by 500 a month for example, it takes around 20 years off the mortgage. Even making that overpayment for a year would cut down a few years I have to pay it off.

Should I be saving or overpaying? I am panicking as it’s just me and I have only 5k savings overall at the moment. Don’t know what to do.

OP posts:
Utterknowitall · 14/02/2024 09:25

Whataballsupp · 14/02/2024 09:17

Thanks. The other option would be downsize now but I only have around 240 equity so I’d obviously still have a hefty mortgage

Honestly, just overpay. You will be so pleased seeing the balance coming down.

Ceàrdaman · 14/02/2024 09:23

Dire is not having an extra £1,000 a month
Dire is not having 240,000 equity in a property

Dire is having to decide between heating and eating

GRex · 14/02/2024 09:23

Whataballsupp · 14/02/2024 09:17

Thanks. The other option would be downsize now but I only have around 240 equity so I’d obviously still have a hefty mortgage

You're coping fine. Don't act rashly and regret it later, moving house would cost a lot. Your wages will rise, inflation erodes aspects of the debt, you can pay some off... in even just 5 years it'll look very much easier.

Whataballsupp · 14/02/2024 09:17

Thanks. The other option would be downsize now but I only have around 240 equity so I’d obviously still have a hefty mortgage

OP posts:
NeedToChangeName · 14/02/2024 08:59

JollyHolly30 · 13/02/2024 15:07

I think it's completely tone deaf to call this financial situation 'dire' when there are people in rented accommodation who struggle to sleep at night and have to choose between heating their homes and feeding their children.

A little basic awareness would be prudent.

Absolutely agree

Appreciate it's tough to be single parent, but 1K per month is a lot of money

I'd focus on building savings to around 15-20K, then overpay mortgage. Look out for early redemption penalties. A way round that might be to vary the term of the mortgage, but then you are committed to paying the higher amount

As an aside, I'm surprised you have a mortgage due to end when you're 72. Is that common now?

HarrietTheFireStarter · 14/02/2024 08:40

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 13/02/2024 23:13

I think people are right to highlight that the “dire” language she used during a time when many are struggling even to pay bills, is offensive to a lot of people. Not to say she shouldn’t worry about her situation, get advice or try and plan. But it’s a bit tone deaf to say she is in a dire situation isn’t it?

I think what is "tone deaf" are the posts by those wedded to competitive poverty. Like, "If you have more money than me then no way am I gonna be anything but an arsehole". So bitter, so petty.

Anyone with so much as a shred of emotional intelligence can read the room here: OP is dealing with huge life changes and could do with a little encouragement.

And her situation is pretty dire. Anyone with a 36yr mortgage has a hell of a long road ahead to financial freedom.

Goldenhandcuffs · 14/02/2024 08:24

What I do is every month what is left over in current account goes into my mortgage offset account and I don’t pay mortgage interest rate on that amount. Then just before end of the tax year I divide what’s in there by 4
A quarter stays there as rainy day fund
A quarter goes to overpay mortgage
A quarter goes to retirement savings - pension and ISA/LISA
A quarter goes to renovation loan repayment.

the loan repayment is higher interest than mortgage so I should put half there an wait until that on paid off until overpaying mortgage but i just need to see both numbers coming down.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 13/02/2024 23:59

I’d open a cash ISA, before April, transfer the 5k and save the £1k monthly to the ISA. Savings interest rates are very good at the moment. It makes financial sense to save at present than overpay.
Unlike before, when mortgage interest rates were really low. It made sense then to overpay than to save.
You can revisit it later on.

Littlemisscapable · 13/02/2024 23:49

This is ages away. Stop worrying about this so much will change by then. Enjoy your life now and save what you can..

doingthebesticanover40 · 13/02/2024 23:46

all of this is fine - it is just dire is the wrong word and unkind to people who actually count piles of 20p pieces into one pound units

RafaFan · 13/02/2024 23:38

To be fair, a "spare $1000/month" does not sound that dire.

chrisaaaaa · 13/02/2024 23:36

My, I think of it as conservative view.

You have positive cash flow now, but very few people can guarantee income for decades, if you overpay you loose flexibility.

If there is an offset mechanism attached to the mortgage use that. Overwise some savings account (be that cash, shares etc. or a mix).

Should something happen to your income stream, and you have put lots into overpaying, then you will quickly be in trouble, even on a modest mortgage.

If you have the money under your control, ideally in an offset, you can use that money to keep things afloat, while you sort the income or downsize or do a moonlight flit, whatever it is, you get to do it on your terms.

ORLt · 13/02/2024 23:32

You are not in a dire financial situation. You are slaying it! Dire is a food bank and sleeping on a friend's floor.

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 13/02/2024 23:13

PrinceYakimov · 13/02/2024 22:18

I think people should give OP a break. You do feel financially vulnerable when you are recently on your own, particularly if a former partner had a much higher income, and I'm sure she knows there are people worse off than her.

That said OP does not have a lot of savings and is vulnerable from that pov. £5k could easily get wiped out by illness, an accident or something going wrong with the house. She really needs to prioritise building up a buffer.

There is a lot of bad advice on this thread about overpaying. Even if OP just put her surplus in the current highest paying instant access cash ISA (an unimpressive 5.09%), she will be better off by £45k in the long run than if she overpaid £500/month. If she saves on overrepayment fees she will be even better off.

OP, take your time - don't rush to overpay. And make sure that whatever you do, you are happy that you understand the benefits/risks.

I think people are right to highlight that the “dire” language she used during a time when many are struggling even to pay bills, is offensive to a lot of people. Not to say she shouldn’t worry about her situation, get advice or try and plan. But it’s a bit tone deaf to say she is in a dire situation isn’t it?

Blinky21 · 13/02/2024 22:54

Could you not just sell up and buy a cheaper house with a smaller mortgage, you don't have much of a safety net at present

whoactuallyreallycares · 13/02/2024 22:29

There’s definitely nothing dire about having 1k spare every month or the luxury of being able to save/overpay the mortgage 🙄

TiredCatLady · 13/02/2024 22:27

You’re on a 3% mortgage at the moment which lots of people would give their right arm for.
First check how much you can repay without hitting penalties and then also what those penalties are.
Discount the idea of a lodger if you have a 2.5 year old.
On the face of it, save the money into a high interest or fixed rate bond at 4.5% + and then, assuming you don’t need to dip into it before, take a chunk off when your remortgage rolls around and go for a more favourable term. Then overpay month by month by whatever you feel comfortable with and squirrel the rest away.

Not a dire situation but 36 year mortgage is less than desirable.

stichguru · 13/02/2024 22:26

Honestly you are not in a dire financial situation if you have spare money each month and savings. Believe me I work with lots of people who barely earn what they need each month and have no savings. I would be overpaying the £500 a month. You will still be building up savings and you will have got rid of the mortgage by the time you retire. If something changed and you thought you might need bigger savings, say you got diagnosed with a disease that meant you would probably end up taking retirement on health grounds, you could stop the over payments to build up your savings more, but at the moment I would say to get to retirement with no mortgage would be the best thing to do.

morningtoncrescent62 · 13/02/2024 22:24

I speak as a single parent now in my early 60s with adult children now in their 30s (can't believe where the time has gone). I wouldn't worry too much about the mortgage. I don't know how old your children are, but in, say, twenty years' time, they'll be independent of you, and that's the time to make serious overpayments on your mortgage. For now, make sure you have that savings safety net as it will give you peace of mind, and spend some of the extra on doing nice things with your children. They won't be young for long. If you have £1000 margin every month, you're in a very good financial position.

I was comparatively late getting a mortgage, and when I took it out, I was due to pay it off at age 65. Once I hit my mid-50s and my daughters were financially independent, I massively increased my mortgage payments and paid the whole thing off quite painlessly by age 60. It's likely that you'll be in a similar position.

CheesecakeandCrackers · 13/02/2024 22:22

We can overpay 10% so we save in a high interest account then review every Jan and often pay off 10%. The rates for savings are currently higher than mortgage so some years we haven't paid over but on balance prefer to be reducing the mortgage. I think this option allows you flex, if you suddenly need cash you've got it to hand. Our mortgage doesn't allow holidays so that's a factor and we also then have to ring and ask to reduce the term rather than reduce monthly payments and doing that monthly is a pain, for some mortgages that's easier. I like to have the safety of the cushion through the year rather than sinking it into mortgage each month but you need to judge on your own situation

BungleandGeorge · 13/02/2024 22:18

1.4K for mortgage plus all bills is really low, the mortgage alone is over 1k. Does that definitely include everything? Insurance, travel/car, maintenance and repairs?
it is a long mortgage but you could consider just downsizing after kids leave home and being mortgage free at that point?

PrinceYakimov · 13/02/2024 22:18

I think people should give OP a break. You do feel financially vulnerable when you are recently on your own, particularly if a former partner had a much higher income, and I'm sure she knows there are people worse off than her.

That said OP does not have a lot of savings and is vulnerable from that pov. £5k could easily get wiped out by illness, an accident or something going wrong with the house. She really needs to prioritise building up a buffer.

There is a lot of bad advice on this thread about overpaying. Even if OP just put her surplus in the current highest paying instant access cash ISA (an unimpressive 5.09%), she will be better off by £45k in the long run than if she overpaid £500/month. If she saves on overrepayment fees she will be even better off.

OP, take your time - don't rush to overpay. And make sure that whatever you do, you are happy that you understand the benefits/risks.

Elphamouche · 13/02/2024 22:13

I would be putting £300 a month into my LISA to save towards a pension, and get the government top up. Then £350 savings and £350 over payment. All basis covered.

But whilst it’s scary, I’ve you’ve got a grand you can save/over pay a month, then no. You are absolutely not in a dire situation.

herewegoagainy · 13/02/2024 22:08

By 70 a lot of people are not able to work or only part time.

Braksonsboss · 13/02/2024 21:59

I’d definitely be looking to overpay. 72 is a crazy age to still have a mortgage