Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

to be shocked that TERFs should be raging against kids clothing?

187 replies

Preggopreggo · 13/02/2024 12:55

You cannot be anti-trans whilst also perpetuating a binary with your own children? AIBU?

Surely if the craziness around ‘boy clothes/toys’ and ‘girl clothes/toys’ ended and gender differences became less distinct, then far fewer children would grow up with gender dysphoria and want to transition?

I know very little about all this, so I may be wrong and just can’t find the threads. Please point me in the right direction if this has been discussed already 🙏

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
LoveAHamSandwhich · 13/02/2024 15:21

Well done OP, you win today's Most Disingenuous Post Of The Day award 🏆

CorylusAgain · 13/02/2024 15:19

So, to clarify, you've started this thread to chastise posters here for not making a campaign against gendered toys and clothing their main priority?

Is that right?

Woozey · 13/02/2024 15:17

I'm not sure what you're getting at?

I'm a TERF, by definition.

My daughter wears clothes exclusively from the boys section and when my son was a toddler his fave thing to do was dress up in Princess dresses and wear headbands.

Clothes do not define your sex. Wearing clothes that are tradionally for the opposite sex you are doesn't not give you a different 'gender identity' to your sex.

They're just clothes.

GreyCarpet · 13/02/2024 15:15

Both my son and daughter wore nail polish and pink glittery clothes as children when they wanted to. My son had a doll, a pushchair and a toy kitchen. As did my daughter. Because they asked for them.

My son aged with Thomas the Tank Engine too. My daughter didn't because she wasn't interested in it.

See - children allowed to pursue their interests.

None of which had any bearing on their sex.

Men can't become women. Women can't become men. Their interests/clothes have no bearing on this either. A man in a dress is still a man in a dress.

RocketPanda · 13/02/2024 15:15

I think the OP has fallen for the TRA lies that gender critical women want men to be big strong men and women to be at home in a nice frock and frilly apron. That's kind of the TRA stance, that if a person likes baking and pink they must be a woman and if they like cars and beer they must be a man.
GCs know that these are mere personality traits/societal stereotypes and have zero to do with a person's sex.

aitchteeaitch · 13/02/2024 15:14

Whenever I read threads like this I find myself either losing the will to live, or wanting to scream the place down in frustration. Sometimes, as in this case, both.

NumberTheory · 13/02/2024 15:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

SwordToFlamethrower · 13/02/2024 15:13

I rage that it is so difficult to buy clothing for babies and toddlers that isn't pink or blue. I try hard to buy neutral colours for them.

In 2024 it is unacceptable. Same goes for styles of shoes for boys and girls.

GreyCarpet · 13/02/2024 15:09

Preggopreggo · 13/02/2024 14:14

@EmmaGrundyForPM ‘OP why start a thread with such an inflammatory statement if you don't know what you're talking about?’

In the hope of gaining enlightenment. I couldn’t find any article or thread that explained why there is such a disconnect between the Mumsnet-heavy movement which I shall not name for fear of getting it wrong and the desperate need to deconstruct the gender binary. What am I inflaming?

If society stops telling little boys that they can’t be pink glittery unicorns then surely fewer little boys will ask to be girls??

There seems to be an awful lot of noise about children transitioning, but so little about gendering of children.

Gendered toys etc. is an easy, tangible campaign target. Simply boycott brands that perpetuate this, yet it seems to have the status of a fringe issue. Let Toys be Toys looks great but I can’t see a mention of the implications for gender identity.

Edited

Unless I'm very.much mistaken, it seems you have assumed that because GC feminists assert that men can't be women and women can't be men, that that also means we ascribe firmly to gender stereotypes of what a boy and a girl should be.

That's not the case.

I didn't enforce pink clothes on my daughter and blue clothes on my son. They were able to pursue their interests regardless of whether society deemed those masculine or feminine. They have never been told they must do something because of their sex. Nor have they been told they can't do something because of their sex.

There are a great many trans stories that start with, "I knew my son was really a girl when he asked for a doll and not a trainset," just as their are vocal transpeople who, when their backstory is revealed, were told they couldn't wear/play/do x, y, or z because it was "for girls" so they concluded that, if they still wanted to wear/play/do x, y or z, they too must be a girl.

But that is not what GC feminism promotes.

You have misunderstood.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 13/02/2024 15:08

Gendered toys etc. is an easy, tangible campaign target. Simply boycott brands that perpetuate this, yet it seems to have the status of a fringe issue. Let Toys be Toys looks great but I can’t see a mention of the implications for gender identity.

You know what else is an easy, tangible campaign target? No male bodies in women's spaces. You know what another one is? No irreversible hormonal treatment or surgery on children unless medically necessary.

I'm not saying I'm necessarily in support of these targets, but you can't tell me they're not clear and tangible. They can both be enforced by law if there's a will to. Not so much de-gendering clothes, I mean how do you actually define or enforce that? Sounds to me you could spend a lot of time chasing your tail trying to do anything about pink for girls and blue for boys.

What I'm wondering is, why would you prefer feminists (or 'TERFs' if you prefer) to be directing their energies towards the rather more nebulous and indirect goal of de-gendering children's clothesas a way of chipping away at the numbers of children wanting to transition?

AndThatWasNY · 13/02/2024 15:07

Fionaville · 13/02/2024 13:00

I don't know what you're talking about.
I could probably be described as a TERF. My kids have mostly had clothes specific to their sex, once they got past baby wear. However there have been plenty of exceptions with the youngest wearing hand me down hoodies, tshirts and sportswear from her brother. And she's had a few tops from the Next boys department because they've been cool designs.
What's your point?

I do actually agree with the OP on this point. I always told my kids that their sex has nothing to do with their clothes. I dressed all of mine in generic clothes very like I wear.
None of them like stereotypical "girl" clothes and would be in what you consider boy clothes. But this should have nothing to do with sex. A boy can wear a dress and a girl trousers. These are only considered girl or boy things down to a socially constructed gendered bollocks.

A man wearing a dress does not a woman make. But a man can wear a dress if the fancy takes him.

Toseland · 13/02/2024 15:04

Trans is the ultimate in conforming to stereotypes. Mermaids have said that if you are a girl that likes trucks and trains that means you are born in the wrong body and are actually a boy and you need medication (used to castrate sex offenders) and extreme genital surgery to make you conform.
I don't agree with this at all.
I've also been sexually harassed by men dressed as women, pleasuring themselves in the ladies loos.
I think that makes me a TERF.

MrsTerryPratchett · 13/02/2024 15:03

Isn't there fairly good research that societies that traditionally were more accepting of GNC people and gay people didn't commonly have a 'third sex'? I thought someone did a study of First Nations People that showed it. Essentially if you don't shove people into little, tiny, restrictive boxes, you don't need another box for all the people that can't make themselves fit. Also see late-transitioning men from the army.

DOWN WITH BOXES.

WhichEllie · 13/02/2024 15:03

Preggopreggo · 13/02/2024 14:14

@EmmaGrundyForPM ‘OP why start a thread with such an inflammatory statement if you don't know what you're talking about?’

In the hope of gaining enlightenment. I couldn’t find any article or thread that explained why there is such a disconnect between the Mumsnet-heavy movement which I shall not name for fear of getting it wrong and the desperate need to deconstruct the gender binary. What am I inflaming?

If society stops telling little boys that they can’t be pink glittery unicorns then surely fewer little boys will ask to be girls??

There seems to be an awful lot of noise about children transitioning, but so little about gendering of children.

Gendered toys etc. is an easy, tangible campaign target. Simply boycott brands that perpetuate this, yet it seems to have the status of a fringe issue. Let Toys be Toys looks great but I can’t see a mention of the implications for gender identity.

Edited

You’re a good 20 years too late to this, OP. If it doesn’t seem visible enough to you that’s likely because it has long been common sense to just let kids carry on with what they like, and as such people haven’t really felt the need to pontificate about it in recent years.

MouseMinge · 13/02/2024 15:02

In the hope of gaining enlightenment. I couldn’t find any article or thread that explained why there is such a disconnect between the Mumsnet-heavy movement which I shall not name for fear of getting it wrong and the desperate need to deconstruct the gender binary. What am I inflaming?

You couldn't find a thread so you decided that "TERFS" are all about the pink and the blue? Feminists have talked about the ridiculousness of gendered clothing for children for decades, they've talked about the sexualised clothing for pre-teens since that became a rather unsavoury thing. What you're doing, which seems to be at the heart of this "debate" all to often, is blaming women. If women just said and did the right thing then this wouldn't be happening, therefore women are to blame. If it were as simple as every child wears unisex clothing then no one would believe they were somehow the opposite sex and the TERFS would be happy, what a simple and wonderful world that would be. Alas, the current cultural situation is such that there are many factors at play, including capture of so many aspects of society that there are people who truly believe you can change sex, that some women have penises, that some men give birth and that the moment a little boy wants to play with a Barbie doll he is clearly dysphoric and needs to go on a medical path so he can finally be the little girl he should have been born as.

I get the need to learn more, but your opening question, which you changed, fair enough, was basically throwing out blame. It's the TERFS fault! No.

Rainbowshit · 13/02/2024 15:02

You got it totally ass backwards OP. Trans ideology reinforces stereotypes. Gender criticism tries to do away with pink and blue clothing. HTH

takealettermsjones · 13/02/2024 15:01

This is not a new idea. Toys are no longer gendered in most major toy stores following campaigns such as Let Toys Be Toys. Categories are now usually "outdoor," "role play," "dolls and action figures," "arts and crafts," etc etc.

Clothes are more tricky since the stereotypes are more ingrained, but in my experience baby clothes at least are seeing a bit of a culture shift - there are now far more retailers that just sell clothes for babies, not baby girls/baby boys, than there used to be.

It's a pretty well established idea among the gender critical that what is often referred to as 'gender' is in fact personality, and that there are no good reasons why we need to split society in half based on personality, whereas there are very good reasons why we sometimes need to split society in half based on sex.

LentilFaculties · 13/02/2024 15:01

Wtf you on about?! You think it's TERFs buying "Boys will be boys" t-shirts?

This isn't academic for me. I'm sure I'm not alone in bringing up my children with as few gender bullshit stereotypes as is possible in our sexist society. As a consequence my kids are the ones the whole class will stare at when receiving their (misogynist, homophobic) training in gender ID.

If you're the boy who wanted to keep his hair long half the kids tell you to get a haircut and the other half tell you to go and use the girls loos.

If you're after more threads in the feminism board on this a) start one and b) tell your mates with dicks to stop inserting themselves unwanted into spaces where women are vulnerable so as to free up a bit of headspace for talking about clothes.

solidarityname · 13/02/2024 15:00

If you ever listened to the feminists that you call TERFs, you would realise they are not anti-trans.

So YABU for waging into a debate without 'educating yourself' first.

Lwrenn · 13/02/2024 14:59

misses point of thread

Anyone want to start a band with me called "rage against the peen".

Sorry, I'll see myself out.

CorylusAgain · 13/02/2024 14:59

The point OP is that the force of TRA influence have steamrollered past simple solutions like 'if clothing wasn't gendered the number of children identifying as opposite sex would be reduced".
Their narrative of "identity" embraces clothing and toys and relies on them being "gendered". And this has lead to a total breakdown of safeguarding.
The arguments against this need to be focused on fighting back against the abuse of children and young people via medical interventions, and the destruction of safeguarding for girls and women.
The subject of 'gendered' clothes, toys, societal expectations etc.etc. occur throughout the discussion. Gender critical individuals don't accept the notion of gender as anything other than a social construct based on stereotyping.

There is nothing for you to be shocked about with regards to this.

Hummusandstuff · 13/02/2024 14:58

Love that flow chart. 😁
Not loving the OP’s insinuation that she or he has stumbled across some sort of cognitive dissonance amongst feminists.
I would be called a TERF. I have BG twins and they just wore the nearest thing to hand until they expressed a preference. I’m not on mission to force my children into any issues around clothing so they often wore gendered stuff.

ElaineMBenes · 13/02/2024 14:57

I do 'rage' against this and 'gendered' toys. So much so I've actually delivered lectures on this.
HTH

EasternStandard · 13/02/2024 14:56

CocoPopsAddict · 13/02/2024 14:48

Isn't 'TERF' just a misogynistic acronym designed to shame women into accepting those born male as 'women'?

Usually yes

Although some women do choose to reclaim it I find it a slur still

Sex based reality for me and dd wears a range and does a range of things, no stereotyping here

roarrfeckingroar · 13/02/2024 14:54

I am TERF. My boy wears a sparkly unicorn costume and pirate costume with similar regularity. I mostly put him and his sister in trousers because they're practical.

Swipe left for the next trending thread