Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

to be shocked that TERFs should be raging against kids clothing?

187 replies

Preggopreggo · 13/02/2024 12:55

You cannot be anti-trans whilst also perpetuating a binary with your own children? AIBU?

Surely if the craziness around ‘boy clothes/toys’ and ‘girl clothes/toys’ ended and gender differences became less distinct, then far fewer children would grow up with gender dysphoria and want to transition?

I know very little about all this, so I may be wrong and just can’t find the threads. Please point me in the right direction if this has been discussed already 🙏

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
SoreAndTired1 · 13/02/2024 16:40

So-called 'terfs' (it's really MERFs - MALE Exclusionary etc) are NOT 'anti-trans'. They are pro-womens rights. So the whole premise of your post is based on a falsehood.

Helleofabore · 13/02/2024 16:33

On the other hand, there is a huge range of clothing that is available to purchase new or second hand in the UK. Why does there need to be a campaign specifically addressing this when no-one is forced to purchase from one place? I have found clothing that is gender non-specific in outlets quite happily.

Why should feminists have to campaign for something that is already available?

Considering just how many of the feminist leaders are gender non-conforming in any case, they are quite adequately modelling abolishing gendered clothing every time they leave the house and every time they appear in media. Feminists are not about to demand people buy particular styles for children. They are going to suggest that children should be free to wear whatever they want within reason.

Now, campaigning against a particular item of clothing that is overly sexualised or has an inappropriate message that can be immediately removed from sale, yes. That is a worthwhile and easy short-term win that is protecting children.

TheKeatingFive · 13/02/2024 16:32

What's the point of this thread? It's full of unsubstantiated speculation 😵‍💫

Helleofabore · 13/02/2024 16:26

@Preggopreggo I hope that you have realised that you are incorrect on many counts in your posts. And I agree with others that you really should be reading threads instead of headlines and actively engaging with them.

And please stop calling feminists 'Terfs'.

Either way. I recommend that you read up the Mermaids Barbie and GI Joe continuum. It is most certainly not 'terfs' who are out there declaring that clothes make a girl or boy. Have look at this shite and tell us that feminists fighting to abolish gender stereotypes are perpetuating those 'gender stereotypes'.

https://www.transgendertrend.com/questions-school-mermaids-training-teachers/

Perhaps what you are referring to is that feminists are also trying to point out the fetishisation of male adults who have autogynephilia. A paraphilia where that male person is sexually aroused with being treated or seeing themselves 'as a woman'. Meaning that when they don on what they, not feminists, but those male people, consider 'women's' clothes they find it sexually arousing.

Do you think that women shouldn't be raising the alarm about that? Is that what this thread is a reaction to?

Ever noticed just what clothes many of these male people choose as their 'woman' clothes? They are not dressing in a comfy t-shirt and jean and just getting on with life. It is all too often highly sexualised clothes. What they perceive is the epitome of womanhood. Because to 'some' of them the value of a woman is the fuckability and then secondly as a resource to be exploited in different ways.

I do suggest you go and find threads on the Sex and Gender board and read, read, read. Sure it takes time and effort. But it seems you have not even grasped the basics of what is happening. Read links from trans allies, read links from who ever posts them and then look for links 'debunking' those links and then ask questions.

And please, when you ask questions, don't assume you know what you are fucking talking about and insult and denigrate the very people who you want to answer your questions. It is hardly a good way to encourage any one to engage with you.

What Questions Should a School be Asking about Mermaids Training for Teachers? - Transgender Trend

A teacher analyses Mermaids training and suggests the questions a school should be asking about 'gender identity' training from external organisations.

https://www.transgendertrend.com/questions-school-mermaids-training-teachers/

Dancingontheedge · 13/02/2024 16:25

I rage that it is so difficult to buy clothing for babies and toddlers that isn't pink or blue. I try hard to buy neutral colours for them

It has got harder, rather than easier in the last couple of decades. Which as a second wave feminist, I find very depressing.

Dancingontheedge · 13/02/2024 16:23

Freddie Mercury
David Bowie
Adam Ant
Prince
Boy George

Clothes and sequins and hair and heels and makeup…breaking the stereotypes of their gendered roles. I’d say that they are some of the poster boys proving that you can be male and wear whatever you like.

greendaisie · 13/02/2024 16:23

My daughter has always known that she's a girl and her brother is a boy - they have different genitalia!

Their clothes and the toys they shared had no bearing on this. I honestly don't know where the op is going with this

KvotheTheBloodless · 13/02/2024 16:22

Your point is clumsily put OP but I get what you mean. Most feminists dislike how gendered clothing is for children (e.g. tight trousers/leggings/tops for girls, loose ones for boys, glittery impractical shoes for girls, robust ones for boys). There have been active campaigns on these issues for years, but it's difficult to persuade parents from choosing highly gendered options (or from allowing their DC to pick them). It requires societal change, which is usually glacially slow on women's issues, especially when many don't see the harm.

Trans issues and the clash between trans rights and women's/children's rights are a relatively recent explosion, and the pushback has had to be relatively swift and loud. The clothing issue is a longer-running topic that runs alongside it.

greendaisie · 13/02/2024 16:19

I rage that it is so difficult to buy clothing for babies and toddlers that isn't pink or blue. I try hard to buy neutral colours for them.

But it doesn't matter what colour clothes they wear as babies! Who cares?

Their clothes have no bearing on anything, certainly not their biological sex.

FusionChefGeoff · 13/02/2024 16:14

I am a feminist and would fit most definitions of TERF even though I hate the term.

As with most women like me, I hate gendered clothing / stereotypes.

OP: why aren't you all raving against gendered clothing
Mumsnet: We are
OP: but gendered clothing and toys are awful why aren't you campaigning against them
Mumsnet: we are

I'm so confused!

Verv · 13/02/2024 16:06

Last time I checked it wasnt "TERFs" that thought sex changed according to what clothing they wore.

BreatheAndFocus · 13/02/2024 16:05

Preggopreggo · 13/02/2024 12:57

Doh error in the title, it should read:

’AIBU to be shocked that TERFS are not raging against kids clothing?’

We are! Haven’t you seen the Let Clothes Be Clothes Twitter/X account? There’s loads on the internet about clothing - the designs (pink unicorns for girls, dinos for boys), the length of the shorts (guess which are shorter) and the shoes (ballerina, frail little things with a thin sole for girls) and chunky, robust shoes for boys who, of course, are the on,y ones who want to climb and go on adventures 🙄

Sadcister · 13/02/2024 15:58

Er what???
I am Gender critical ( I believe if gender doesn't mean sex then it is meaningless)
My DS (almost 1) is regularly "misgendered" because he's wearing pink
My DD (almost 3) knows that she is a girl because she has a vagina, and her brother is a boy because he has a willy. She plays with trains, wears dungarees and dinosaur wellies etc...

GoodHeavens99 · 13/02/2024 15:52

Preggopreggo · 13/02/2024 12:55

You cannot be anti-trans whilst also perpetuating a binary with your own children? AIBU?

Surely if the craziness around ‘boy clothes/toys’ and ‘girl clothes/toys’ ended and gender differences became less distinct, then far fewer children would grow up with gender dysphoria and want to transition?

I know very little about all this, so I may be wrong and just can’t find the threads. Please point me in the right direction if this has been discussed already 🙏

Why don't you post this in the Sex and Gender section?? 🤨

Fionaville · 13/02/2024 15:43

MiltonNorthern · 13/02/2024 14:49

So because one poster said that her children mostly had clothes specific to their sex you extrapolate that 'terfs' in general don't care about gendered clothing?

TRAs really here scraping the bottom of the barrel for arguments here!

OP conveniently missed out the other points I made.
My kids dress for comfort mostly. I buy them clothes that fit their shape primarily. They've never worn clothes that say things like 'Girls are kind' and 'boys are born to rule'
But I suspect that doesn't fit in with the narrative that OP is trying to push.

Dogfisher · 13/02/2024 15:41

OP - feminists (the sensible sort) are absolutely not in favour of gender stereotypes and often actively try to subvert them. Let boys and girls wear what they want and be who they want but know that no human can change sex.

The transactivist crowd are the people you nee to speak to. They are so mired in gender ideology that they think that a boy who wants to wear glitter is actually a girl. Regressive nonsense.

Fionaville · 13/02/2024 15:39

AndThatWasNY · 13/02/2024 15:07

I do actually agree with the OP on this point. I always told my kids that their sex has nothing to do with their clothes. I dressed all of mine in generic clothes very like I wear.
None of them like stereotypical "girl" clothes and would be in what you consider boy clothes. But this should have nothing to do with sex. A boy can wear a dress and a girl trousers. These are only considered girl or boy things down to a socially constructed gendered bollocks.

A man wearing a dress does not a woman make. But a man can wear a dress if the fancy takes him.

That's the point I was making though. They have mainly been in clothes that I bought in the departments for each sex. My eldest has always been big lad who lives in joggers, jeans, tshirts and hoodies from the boys/mens section. Why would I have tried to squeeze him into leggings from the girls? My girls wear his hand me downs, and clothes that are very much neutral but also pretty dresses and flowery leggings if that's what they want. The fact is, kids clothes are segregated in shops. There's nothing in the girls section that would appeal to my son, he's a big lad who likes sportswear. My daughters can pick from whichever section they want to. They currently like cargo pants, hoodies and football kits. So hardly walking round like mini Kardashians, but if there's a party you bet they want a sparkly dress!
I'm a fan of let clothes be clothes and let toys be toys. I've always tried to live by that, without making it a massive deal. But the fact is, when buying clothes 99% of the time you still have a decision to make on which aisle to buy them from.

Hollyhead · 13/02/2024 15:39

It was mumsnet feminist chatting that alerted me to the ludicrousness of gendered toys/clothes in the first place. I’d say it’s a solid home base for discussions and agreement around it.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 13/02/2024 15:36

Let Toys be Toys looks great but I can’t see a mention of the implications for gender identity.

One of the founding members of either Let Toys Be Toys or Let Clothes Be Clothes, I believe, was well known gender critical campaigner Maya Forstater. Made famous globally by JK Rowling tweeting about her case.

https://amp.theguardian.com/society/2022/jul/06/maya-forstater-was-discriminated-against-over-gender-critical-beliefs-tribunal-rules

ZiriForGood · 13/02/2024 15:35

The whole girls and boys clothes is marketing - trying to force people to buy more, just because perfectly good clothes doesn't match teh social expectations.

However, as teens and adults, it makes sense to distinguish sex for some of the clothes, shoes, personal protection equipment, heavier backpacks and other items of daily use, because male and female body types do differ and so called unisex is often more targeted to average male than average female body.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 13/02/2024 15:33

Isn't 'TERF' just a misogynistic acronym designed to shame women into accepting those born male as 'women'?

Yes.

MorningSunshineSparkles · 13/02/2024 15:28

Congrats OP, I’ve never seen someone get a Wally Of The Day medal before.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 13/02/2024 15:25

Every single thread about gender identity is going to have comments on clothing not making the person.

Maybe read some of the threads instead of just the headers?

Dancingontheedge · 13/02/2024 15:23

Many of us have been fighting the battle against ‘This is what a girl looks like and this is what a boy looks like’ since before you were born. Along with ‘Girls can’t be….and Boys can’t be…’
It’s the chromosomes, not the clothing, make up or occupation tnat makes you either male or female.

porridgecake · 13/02/2024 15:22

OP. You admitted in your first post that you know very little about this.
That is clear.
Perhaps you could have a look on the FWR board and do some reading.
You seem confident to use the word Terf, so you must have an idea what you think it means, or maybe you are being disingenuous.
MN places restrictions on discussion of gender ideology, it is mostly confined to FWR.

Swipe left for the next trending thread