Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

to be shocked that TERFs should be raging against kids clothing?

187 replies

Preggopreggo · 13/02/2024 12:55

You cannot be anti-trans whilst also perpetuating a binary with your own children? AIBU?

Surely if the craziness around ‘boy clothes/toys’ and ‘girl clothes/toys’ ended and gender differences became less distinct, then far fewer children would grow up with gender dysphoria and want to transition?

I know very little about all this, so I may be wrong and just can’t find the threads. Please point me in the right direction if this has been discussed already 🙏

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
nameXname · 13/02/2024 18:05

I agree with comments re half term. The only possible excuse for the OP is that they are under-educated - but I've known more intelligent comments from 14 year olds. So a bit of history mifght perhaps help them:

This history of clothing and societial expectations of gender identity - NOT SEX - that has nothing to do with clothing - is vast and complicated. Jut a few instances:

The OP might like to reflect on the fact that until really quite recently, pink was the preferred colour for boys. There's lots on this, if they care to look, for example: https://www.thevintagenews.com/2019/05/01/pink-blue/ or https://edition.cnn.com/2018/01/12/health/colorscope-pink-boy-girl-gender/index.html

And that a 'kilt' or wrap or sarong plus blanket (if it got cold) was the original clothing for a vast number of men in Asia - and also for the Neanderthals in Europe: https://www.newscientist.com/article/2100322-ice-age-fashion-showdown-neanderthal-capes-versus-human-hoodies/

And that tunic-plus-trousers (totally unisex) was probably the original clothing for many ancient peoples (m/f) who rode horses, and also in many parts of China and East Asia: https://www.grunge.com/141691/why-we-wear-pants/

There is VASTLY more on all this easily available online.

Etc etc etc. Just read and try to learn, OP

Here's Why it All Changed: Pink Used to be a Boy's Color & Blue For Girls | The Vintage News

Recent years have seen some big changes in terms of our perception of gender, with the age-old concepts of gender identities and "norms" being challenged

https://www.thevintagenews.com/2019/05/01/pink-blue

Helleofabore · 13/02/2024 18:03

GabriellaMontez · 13/02/2024 17:22

What do you mean by 'anti trans'?

Anti-trans = Anti-woman

Because the reality is, those who refer to feminists as 'anti-trans' when feminists are campaigning to protect female people seek to remove those protections for female people. Hence if they want to use the hyperbolic and overly emotional and false term 'anti-trans' then they must except the logical opposite label.

Because every time someone posts using that ludicrous term for women who believe in the prioritisation of sex over gender when sex matters, they simply show they have no argument and all they have is emotional manipulation.

Dogfisher · 13/02/2024 17:30

The poster who reminded us that it's half term had it right. I'm out.

GelatoPistacchio · 13/02/2024 17:30

I agree that this seems like a goady thread, built on a false assumption, but there might be a more interesting discussion in there somewhere.

Would focusing efforts on dismantling how gender dominates society be more effective than trying to get people to understand the difference between sex and gender?

What more could be done in the former area? How do we get more boys and men to wear typically 'female' clothes, and not as a sexualised gimmick? So that it becomes just another option and not a signifier of anything?

Or get rid of 'female' clothes altogether. Let's face it, dresses and skirts are impractical. I wouldn't put my baby son in a dress and tights because they would make crawling difficult and the headbands look stupid and are unsafe. So why are we putting baby girls in this stuff?

Clothes are just one example. Are there other campaigns that we could work on?

GabriellaMontez · 13/02/2024 17:22

What do you mean by 'anti trans'?

MouseMinge · 13/02/2024 17:19

I used to hate TERF almost as much as I hate CIS but these days it's so ludicrous that it seems to me that "TERFS" have just gone "You want to call us that? Have at it!" and run with it. The insult it offers has been diluted by the refusal of women for women's rights, same sex spaces, refusal to accept the pseudo-science that you can somehow actually change sex, to take it as anything but the ridiculous attempt to create a gaggle of wicked witches that it is. We're not wicked witches, just the sort who'll not be dealing with your bullshit.

User373433 · 13/02/2024 17:12

But that is exactly what trans exclusionary feminists are opposed to OP. We believe gender is a social construct. That the huge push to gender politics has taken us so far backwards in terms of fighting against gender stereotypes that it is no longer the thing the feminists board is flooded with. But is absolutely what we believe.

LondonJax · 13/02/2024 17:12

"Ever noticed just what clothes many of these male people choose as their 'woman' clothes? They are not dressing in a comfy t-shirt and jean and just getting on with life. It is all too often highly sexualised clothes. What they perceive is the epitome of womanhood. Because to 'some' of them the value of a woman is the fuckability and then secondly as a resource to be exploited in different ways."

Exactly. I was born female and remain female. But I can't remember the last time I wore a skirt and the only dress I've worn in the past 5 years has been to a wedding. I feel comfortable in trousers or jeans, prefer flats to heels (had enough of those when I was in my 20s and 30s). But I like wearing make up (sometimes), enjoy painting my nails (sometimes). When I was a little girl I enjoyed playing with my dolls and my pram. But I also had a toy garage as a male cousin had one which I loved so my parents bought one for Christmas (I'm now 60 years old so this is 50 years plus ago - hardly 'modern thinking').

I'm not a stereo typical 'woman' because there are no stereo typical women (or men). So putting on a dress doesn't make you a woman just like putting on a suit and tie doesn't make you a man.

CactusMactus · 13/02/2024 16:58

I'm so confused.

Snowdropsarecoming · 13/02/2024 16:58

TummyTuckNameChange · 13/02/2024 13:00

In the nicest way, are you new here?

🙌

GrumpyPanda · 13/02/2024 16:58

Ereshkigalangcleg · 13/02/2024 15:36

Let Toys be Toys looks great but I can’t see a mention of the implications for gender identity.

One of the founding members of either Let Toys Be Toys or Let Clothes Be Clothes, I believe, was well known gender critical campaigner Maya Forstater. Made famous globally by JK Rowling tweeting about her case.

https://amp.theguardian.com/society/2022/jul/06/maya-forstater-was-discriminated-against-over-gender-critical-beliefs-tribunal-rules

Thanks for pointing out that particular connection - wish I'd known back when I got into a Twitter spat with Tarek Aboud-Chadi about their ridiculous survey research into "gc" attitudes which their entire team at Oxford seemed to associate firmly with the European right wing (tbf understandable in people who cut their teeth working on Orban et al back when "anti-gender" was still anti-"feminazis" and trans didn't really figure on anyone's radar screen.)

I'm wondering though - how about later campaigns following in their footsteps? I know for a fact that at least the German offshoot of the Pinkstinks campaign, for all the valuable work they do against gendered clothing, is rabidly TWAW and full of inane references to "people with uteruses", "read as female" etc etc. (Can't access the main UK site right now to verify due to some technical snafu blocking my IP address.)

StephanieSuperpowers · 13/02/2024 16:57

This is a very strange thread, @Preggopreggo . I can only imagine that you are attempting to discredit women who don't believe in this stuff by making nonsense up.

Joleyne · 13/02/2024 16:57

Oh of course! Half term!

BMW6 · 13/02/2024 16:56

I am afraid OP that you've got hopelessly muddled up somewhere.

Dogfisher · 13/02/2024 16:53

Yes educate your boys, but what about predatory girls? They do exist. I am terrified about girls who use the power of false accusations

🙄

Ponderingwindow · 13/02/2024 16:53

Um…

gender critical means you don’t believe in things like boys clothing or girls toys. It means that people shouldn’t be constrained by sex-based expectations. It means that a dress is simply an article of clothing that can be worn by a man or a woman.

Oneofthesurvivors · 13/02/2024 16:51

nearlyemptynes · 13/02/2024 16:47

As a mother of two boys- and a girl- all this predatory men stuff really worries me. Yes educate your boys, but what about predatory girls? They do exist. I am terrified about girls who use the power of false accusations. Lets educate our boys and girls. Not all boys are predators and not all girls are victims. Heres an idea lets join together for the better good.

Oh god, shut up.

SpikeGilesSandwich · 13/02/2024 16:51

My DS loves pink and purple and sparkles, he waltzes around in all kinds of fabulous outfits. It doesn't make him any less of a boy though, and anyone who thinks it does has another think coming.

GoodHeavens99 · 13/02/2024 16:50

TheKeatingFive · 13/02/2024 16:32

What's the point of this thread? It's full of unsubstantiated speculation 😵‍💫

That's a very diplomatic way of saying that their post is shite!

SoreAndTired1 · 13/02/2024 16:49

nearlyemptynes · 13/02/2024 16:47

As a mother of two boys- and a girl- all this predatory men stuff really worries me. Yes educate your boys, but what about predatory girls? They do exist. I am terrified about girls who use the power of false accusations. Lets educate our boys and girls. Not all boys are predators and not all girls are victims. Heres an idea lets join together for the better good.

False accusations are LESS THAN 1%. Less than one percent. 98% of all assaults are by males on women and girls. So lets cut this 'whataboutery' crap blaming women and girls. There are almost no predatory girls. Your post is disgraceful victim-blaming about something that doesn't really exist.

backinthestoneage · 13/02/2024 16:49

I have raged at the sexualisation of children in some clothes but have no idea what op is going on about

Helleofabore · 13/02/2024 16:48

SoreAndTired1 · 13/02/2024 16:40

So-called 'terfs' (it's really MERFs - MALE Exclusionary etc) are NOT 'anti-trans'. They are pro-womens rights. So the whole premise of your post is based on a falsehood.

Absolutely! Because as feminists, those being called 'terfs' campaign for protections for ALL female people. Even those female people who have chosen to never be called 'women' again. They need those protections still because they are female.

Male people who declare they are female need their own unique protections perhaps, and should spend time campaigning for them and making sure they do not conflict with the needs and rights of female people.

I use 'male people' and 'female people' to avoid being deleted and for clarity.

The term 'terf' was never really accurate at all.

StarlightLime · 13/02/2024 16:48

Nobody is anti trans, op. Stop shit stirring.

nearlyemptynes · 13/02/2024 16:47

As a mother of two boys- and a girl- all this predatory men stuff really worries me. Yes educate your boys, but what about predatory girls? They do exist. I am terrified about girls who use the power of false accusations. Lets educate our boys and girls. Not all boys are predators and not all girls are victims. Heres an idea lets join together for the better good.

HermioneKipper · 13/02/2024 16:44

I’m tempted to report this thread due to the inflammatory use of the word TERF - clearly meant as an insult in this context.

But actually yes, I do object to hugely gendered items and statements insulting girls written on their clothes etc. but my daughter wore blue, my sons wear “girly colours” and plenty of her hand me downs and one of my boys loves his dolly and baby toy when his sister couldn’t have given two hoots about dolls etc.

doesn’t mean either of them are the opposite sex though does it!