Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

to be shocked that TERFs should be raging against kids clothing?

187 replies

Preggopreggo · 13/02/2024 12:55

You cannot be anti-trans whilst also perpetuating a binary with your own children? AIBU?

Surely if the craziness around ‘boy clothes/toys’ and ‘girl clothes/toys’ ended and gender differences became less distinct, then far fewer children would grow up with gender dysphoria and want to transition?

I know very little about all this, so I may be wrong and just can’t find the threads. Please point me in the right direction if this has been discussed already 🙏

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
TheMarzipanDildo · 13/02/2024 21:10

greendaisie · 13/02/2024 20:00

If a boy likes dancing, it doesn't make him a girl. If a girl likes football, it doesn't make her a boy

Obviously not. Is there ANY child or adult that actually thinks that?!

Jazz Jenning’s parents. The parents on the Mermaids chat board.

PrincessTeaSet · 13/02/2024 20:17

SomethingUniqueThisTime · 13/02/2024 14:30

I don’t understand what the issue is OP?
I would consider myself a Gender Critical feminist and loathe genderised clothes, toys, behaviours and stereotypes. Therefore avoid pushing gender specific clothing onto my children. This is also why I’m uncomfortable with men putting on what they consider extreme ‘feminised’ clothing, make-up, and mannerisms and declaring they are now an actual woman.
Surely they are the same issue, and I have no doubt that some of the reasons behind the growing cult of trans is because we have created a culture of gender specific clothing and behaviours.

Remove the gender stuff from society and there is no need for anyone to identify as trans. There is just sex, gender identity is just a social construct.

Of course this is a rather simplified stance which ignores the needs of those poor men with AGP (!!) and the structural disadvantages of being a biological women throughout the world.

Edited

So what does that mean in practice? Do you dress your boy in a skirt or does your girl never wear a skirt? Or do both own exactly the same range of clothing and sometimes wear skirts?

Does your girl have short hair or does your boy wear bows etc?

Toys is one thing but I'd say that after babyhood, 99% of children own and therefore wear clothes marketed to their sex. Toddlers are not buying their own clothes therefore someone (their parents probably) is "pushing them into gender specific clothing".

Or do you just mean girls clothes that aren't pink and frilly?

I don't see boys in skirts or even girls with short hair ever really so can only think that people who don't agree with these gender specific things are very rare!

therealcookiemonster · 13/02/2024 20:04

what on earth?!

OP are you maybe confusing mumsnet with other forums? and not sure what you think feminism is?

StarlightLime · 13/02/2024 20:03

greendaisie · 13/02/2024 20:00

If a boy likes dancing, it doesn't make him a girl. If a girl likes football, it doesn't make her a boy

Obviously not. Is there ANY child or adult that actually thinks that?!

Where have you been?!

greendaisie · 13/02/2024 20:00

If a boy likes dancing, it doesn't make him a girl. If a girl likes football, it doesn't make her a boy

Obviously not. Is there ANY child or adult that actually thinks that?!

greendaisie · 13/02/2024 19:58

In fact, I was wondering the other day what a 5 yr old boy, for example, thinks a girl is.

Don't parents explain/show their children that girls and boys have different genitalia?

It's really not complicated Hmm

NeedToChangeName · 13/02/2024 19:50

IAmAWarriorPrincessHonestGuv · 13/02/2024 13:37

That’s odd, all the stories from parents with children that identify as the opposite sex start with clothes and toys.

In fact, I was wondering the other day what a 5 yr old boy, for example, thinks a girl is. I have heard stories about a young girl who told her mum she wanted to be a boy and when asked to elaborate, she reported that boys get to sleep in a bunk bed and she wanted a bunk bed. I can see how the undeveloped categorisation skills and logic of a child would lead them to that conclusion.

And then I wonder how many kids have been deemed trans by their parents on that basis.

@IAmAWarriorPrincessHonestGuv I wonder about this too. If a boy likes dancing, it doesn't make him a girl. If a girl likes football, it doesn't make her a boy

I often think the trans movement actually reinforces gender stereotypes eg biological male wants to wear a dress = OK wirh me, but doesn't make him a woman

Abbimae · 13/02/2024 19:22

Why are we taking away gender?

popebishop · 13/02/2024 19:21

It might be that the OP isn’t trying to provoke. I once had a frustrating Twitter conversation with a person from the US who thought that Gender Critical people liked gender stereotypes, er, because they thought they were critical

Ah that's brilliant! Gender is Critically Important! I've heard it all now.

BreatheAndFocus · 13/02/2024 19:16

It might be that the OP isn’t trying to provoke. I once had a frustrating Twitter conversation with a person from the US who thought that Gender Critical people liked gender stereotypes, er, because they thought they were critical 🙄

This person was non-binary and explained why by telling me they were “AMAB” but liked wearing skirts! And yet they thought we were the regressive ones! I suggested they could wear skirts and still be a boy and linked them to about a million 80s New Romantics 😂

WhollyGlorious · 13/02/2024 19:09

I do rage about this too (although I reject the term TERF, I do not exclude trans people in my feminism - I include trans men and exclude trans women).

There’s plenty on the internet pointing out the gender bias in children’s slogan t shirts, the length of shorts, the availability of pockets. I go out of my way to buy STEM toys for the female children in my life and toys geared towards nurturing (like tea sets and dolls) for the boys.

3beesinmybonnet · 13/02/2024 19:05

@popebishop
I suspect the OP is too busy gorging on Mum's pancakes - or maybe they're 'educating themselves' on FWR.

catsrus · 13/02/2024 18:58

Preggopreggo · 13/02/2024 14:14

@EmmaGrundyForPM ‘OP why start a thread with such an inflammatory statement if you don't know what you're talking about?’

In the hope of gaining enlightenment. I couldn’t find any article or thread that explained why there is such a disconnect between the Mumsnet-heavy movement which I shall not name for fear of getting it wrong and the desperate need to deconstruct the gender binary. What am I inflaming?

If society stops telling little boys that they can’t be pink glittery unicorns then surely fewer little boys will ask to be girls??

There seems to be an awful lot of noise about children transitioning, but so little about gendering of children.

Gendered toys etc. is an easy, tangible campaign target. Simply boycott brands that perpetuate this, yet it seems to have the status of a fringe issue. Let Toys be Toys looks great but I can’t see a mention of the implications for gender identity.

Edited

The campaigning group "let toys be toys" was started by a mums netter and supported by many other Mnetters.

we've been campaigning against stereotyping in clothes and toys for fucking decades. just because you've not been aware of it doesn't mean it's not been happening.

most of us have, admittedly, been rather more engaged in fighting to stop kids being sterilised / having their healthy body parts removed etc over the past few years but we absolutely still point out the sexist shit in the children's clothing world when we see it.

TheMarzipanDildo · 13/02/2024 18:42

TheMarzipanDildo · 13/02/2024 18:16

The answer to your question is: we’re not.

Oh ignore me, I see that you got the q the wrong way round. In which case, we are! Maya Forstater led a campaign about this back in the day.

Didshejustsaythatoutloud · 13/02/2024 18:33

😴, why can people not just let kids be kids instead of having to define or label them.
FFS!!! Bore off

popebishop · 13/02/2024 18:27

What are you going to start a thread on next OP - why vegans aren't raging against the consumption of animal products?

VampireWeekday · 13/02/2024 18:25

I honestly have never met a feminist who reinforced stereotypes on their kids. My children have clothes that are neutral or conforming to their sex because given the existing binary, dressing my sons deliberately as girls would be confusing and reinforce the idea that they are girls, as they'd be frequently mistaken for girls. But I also avoid very boy coded clothes: no scary animals, diggers, army theme or camouflage. The exception to both of these rules is any clothes they particularly want, they can have. So my sons have Elsa / frozen clothes, some sparkly jumpers they wanted from girls section, and so on. In our house we don't believe in gendered toys, activities or books. All the children get to try any activity and we buy the toys that interest them.

If ever a son of mine says he wants to be a girl I'll be ready to tell him it's not possible, but of course he can do / wear / play with whatever girls do.

Kewcumber · 13/02/2024 18:24

GelatoPistacchio · 13/02/2024 17:30

I agree that this seems like a goady thread, built on a false assumption, but there might be a more interesting discussion in there somewhere.

Would focusing efforts on dismantling how gender dominates society be more effective than trying to get people to understand the difference between sex and gender?

What more could be done in the former area? How do we get more boys and men to wear typically 'female' clothes, and not as a sexualised gimmick? So that it becomes just another option and not a signifier of anything?

Or get rid of 'female' clothes altogether. Let's face it, dresses and skirts are impractical. I wouldn't put my baby son in a dress and tights because they would make crawling difficult and the headbands look stupid and are unsafe. So why are we putting baby girls in this stuff?

Clothes are just one example. Are there other campaigns that we could work on?

Because I'm afraid girls are still valued for being pretty.

I think it will take decades possibly longer to change this but we can only keep trying.

AS a grammar school girl in the 1970's I participated in a debate entitled "A woman's place is in the home", I kid you not - in a girls grammar school which ought to have been a bastion of equality for women.

My working class mother was right on the cutting edge (though not knowing it) as she said in reposnse to my question whether she agreed with that was...

A woman's place is where she wants it to be.

Not really relevant but any excuse to quote my wise old mother sadly not with us any more.

popebishop · 13/02/2024 18:23

LenaLamont · 13/02/2024 13:00

Have you ever met a feminist who enforces pink for girls, blue for boys? Because I haven’t.

I enforce it so much I designed a flag for my movement entirely around it!

Oh no, wait, I didn't. That would be the trans activists. But they're not regressively sexist, honest!

Kewcumber · 13/02/2024 18:17

to paraphrase my above post in the words of a good friend of mine.

"the joy of being a post-menopausal woman is that you've stopped giving a fuck what anyone thinks"

Pretend you're a woman/man if you want to but stay out of single sex spaces of the sex you "identify" as.

newtlover · 13/02/2024 18:16

TERF=Tired of Explaining Reality to Fuckwits

I agree the charitable interpretation of the OP is someone young who is new to all this, so hopefully it's been an education for them

having said that, I know that TRAs do accuse us of being 'biological determinists', and misappropriate Simone de Beauvoir to that end, but lets not muddy the waters

TheMarzipanDildo · 13/02/2024 18:16

The answer to your question is: we’re not.

Kewcumber · 13/02/2024 18:11

nameXname · 13/02/2024 18:05

I agree with comments re half term. The only possible excuse for the OP is that they are under-educated - but I've known more intelligent comments from 14 year olds. So a bit of history mifght perhaps help them:

This history of clothing and societial expectations of gender identity - NOT SEX - that has nothing to do with clothing - is vast and complicated. Jut a few instances:

The OP might like to reflect on the fact that until really quite recently, pink was the preferred colour for boys. There's lots on this, if they care to look, for example: https://www.thevintagenews.com/2019/05/01/pink-blue/ or https://edition.cnn.com/2018/01/12/health/colorscope-pink-boy-girl-gender/index.html

And that a 'kilt' or wrap or sarong plus blanket (if it got cold) was the original clothing for a vast number of men in Asia - and also for the Neanderthals in Europe: https://www.newscientist.com/article/2100322-ice-age-fashion-showdown-neanderthal-capes-versus-human-hoodies/

And that tunic-plus-trousers (totally unisex) was probably the original clothing for many ancient peoples (m/f) who rode horses, and also in many parts of China and East Asia: https://www.grunge.com/141691/why-we-wear-pants/

There is VASTLY more on all this easily available online.

Etc etc etc. Just read and try to learn, OP

Can I just add that the pink/blue thing isn't just a historical thing. I have many photos of DS in a pink velour babygrow when we were in Kazakhstan - they were slightly bemused by the idea that women or men had some kind of monopoly on certain colours. Countries where people have less disposable imcome tend to be somewhat less hung up on such things when perfectly good hand-me-downs exist

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 13/02/2024 18:10

Kewcumber · 13/02/2024 18:08

I am not a TERF. I am a MEW

Male Exclusionary Woman.

I don't care what anyone wears or if they wear makeup or not (80's girl and proud of it - been there done that). I don't think girls need to wear pink or glitter to be female and I don't think boys need to wear blue or camoflage to be male. My son wore cinderella dressing up wigs and had a pink pram. Still a man now.

When I was a girl society was much more sexist - no mortgages for women without being guaranteed by a man but childhood was much less gendered, tomboys and unisex lego and hardly any glitter.

We are now so "gendered" that if you don't buy into the pink/blue crap that you are miraculously the opposite sex.

I really don't care how you identify and will even use pronouns you choose (if I feel like it) but single sex spaces are the law for a reason and as a victim of sexual abuse I will uphold the law vocally in this regard.

I'm guessing you're quite young if you don't remember the Mumsnet let toys be toys campaign.

👏 👏 👏

Kewcumber · 13/02/2024 18:08

I am not a TERF. I am a MEW

Male Exclusionary Woman.

I don't care what anyone wears or if they wear makeup or not (80's girl and proud of it - been there done that). I don't think girls need to wear pink or glitter to be female and I don't think boys need to wear blue or camoflage to be male. My son wore cinderella dressing up wigs and had a pink pram. Still a man now.

When I was a girl society was much more sexist - no mortgages for women without being guaranteed by a man but childhood was much less gendered, tomboys and unisex lego and hardly any glitter.

We are now so "gendered" that if you don't buy into the pink/blue crap that you are miraculously the opposite sex.

I really don't care how you identify and will even use pronouns you choose (if I feel like it) but single sex spaces are the law for a reason and as a victim of sexual abuse I will uphold the law vocally in this regard.

I'm guessing you're quite young if you don't remember the Mumsnet let toys be toys campaign.

Swipe left for the next trending thread