Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

to be shocked that TERFs should be raging against kids clothing?

187 replies

Preggopreggo · 13/02/2024 12:55

You cannot be anti-trans whilst also perpetuating a binary with your own children? AIBU?

Surely if the craziness around ‘boy clothes/toys’ and ‘girl clothes/toys’ ended and gender differences became less distinct, then far fewer children would grow up with gender dysphoria and want to transition?

I know very little about all this, so I may be wrong and just can’t find the threads. Please point me in the right direction if this has been discussed already 🙏

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
greendaisie · 14/02/2024 15:42

There's actually a lot of children's clothes and shoes/boots/wellies in red, yellow, green that are unisex.

We bought a yellow bike for our son and daughter, as well as brightly coloured Lego and marble runs etc for both of them.

You don't have to buy a pink unicorn bicycle for your daughter and superman wellies for your son!

But none of this has any bearing on their biological sex, so I don't really see the point of this thread?

newtlover · 14/02/2024 14:47

yes, I think we need to be careful about that

StephanieSuperpowers · 14/02/2024 14:39

ErrolTheDragon · 14/02/2024 14:34

Yes, except that all too often they actually are inferior as in less functional. Girls vs boys shoes (we liked mountain warehouse which has identical 'kids' footwear in a range of colours). Thinner t shirt material. The infamous pink product at the time of the inception of let toys be toys was the pink globe... shades of pink instead of clearly distinguishable colours.
It's the combination of colour coding and reduced fitness for purpose which is problematic.

Well, yes, that's a fair point. But the point I was (clearly not) making was that there can be a tendency for people to see things that girls might like (from music, to books, to clothes and beyond) as inferior because girls like them. Like they have a taint and must be unserious or lacking in some way. I reject the idea that any child shouldn't just like what they like and also that it's somehow less valuable if a girl likes it.

ErrolTheDragon · 14/02/2024 14:36

Hence why, despite the excellent Let Toys be Toys, we are not seeing a mass movement that rejects gender stereotypes. When we have fought off the current attack on women's rights, we may move on to that.

Or rather, move back to it!

ErrolTheDragon · 14/02/2024 14:34

StephanieSuperpowers · 14/02/2024 14:30

Incidentally, as an RF, I reject the idea that things coded "for girls" are inferior and to be avoided just as much as I reject the idea that things coded "for boys" are superior and to be promoted. There's nothing wrong with a child of either sex putting on a pink tutu and going off to play muddy dinosaurs. For girls, for boys, they're just things and we can all enjoy them if they appeal to us.

Yes, except that all too often they actually are inferior as in less functional. Girls vs boys shoes (we liked mountain warehouse which has identical 'kids' footwear in a range of colours). Thinner t shirt material. The infamous pink product at the time of the inception of let toys be toys was the pink globe... shades of pink instead of clearly distinguishable colours.
It's the combination of colour coding and reduced fitness for purpose which is problematic.

StephanieSuperpowers · 14/02/2024 14:30

Incidentally, as an RF, I reject the idea that things coded "for girls" are inferior and to be avoided just as much as I reject the idea that things coded "for boys" are superior and to be promoted. There's nothing wrong with a child of either sex putting on a pink tutu and going off to play muddy dinosaurs. For girls, for boys, they're just things and we can all enjoy them if they appeal to us.

newtlover · 14/02/2024 13:13

exactly

Kewcumber · 14/02/2024 13:11

@newtlover I also forgot to say that OP obviously doesn't have children as they are not inanimate props for us. Whatever we feel about the ridiculousness that pink is a "girls" colour, most of us will not force our boys to wear pink to school ( for example) as they will most likely feel uncomfortable and don't want to stand out. We respect our childrens wishes as they are individuals and don't use them as pawns in our desire to have a more equal world because they're not dolls for us to role play with.

newtlover · 14/02/2024 13:03

OP is muddling a few different things now-
'TERFS' - some of whom may be radical feminists, are mostly in everyday life 'deconstructing the gender binary' in 100s of ways, by role modeling, by providing children with a range of toys, activities and clothes, by gently or not so gently challenging stereotypes when they are voiced etc etc . But we don't use our children as political props and we chose where to put our political energies carefully, and it probably isn't picketing toyshops or boycotting clothing brands.
The vast, vast majority of people (I believe all) understand that sex is immutable. Many of these are untroubled by the 'gender binary' and recoil at the idea of a boy wearing pink or a girl with short hair.
Hence why, despite the excellent Let Toys be Toys, we are not seeing a mass movement that rejects gender stereotypes. When we have fought off the current attack on women's rights, we may move on to that.

Helleofabore · 14/02/2024 11:24

Radical = meaning ‘the root’. Not radically behaved.

Kewcumber · 14/02/2024 11:12

Preggopreggo · 14/02/2024 01:33

Thank you @GelatoPistacchio, this is what I meant.

My post was clumsy, inadvertently goady and posted in the wrong place, for that I am sorry.

It’s obvious that gender critical feminists are critical of binary children’s clothing and aim to dress their children neutrally, as lots of PPs show.

But I’m wondering if some of those who have embraced the TERF label are really very R or even F, if they perpetuate the gender binary through their own children’s clothing choices. And of course there’s the paradox of being trans exclusionary and feminist that has been pointed out by PP.

Let Toys be Toys is a fantastic campaign - but that’s aimed at marketing. I’m wondering why there isn’t a tidal wave of parents deconstructing the gender binary on a personal level.

It’s clear that outlooks like that of Mermaids reinforces gender stereotypes, but I assume there aren’t many mermaid supporters here to ask, hence why the question wasn’t directed at them.

"But I’m wondering if some of those who have embraced the TERF label are really very R or even F"

Which highlights that you don't really understand what you're trying to debate. RF is not a description it is a brach of feminism. You do not need to be radical to be RF (though to do need to be a feminist).

RF is one of many feminist philsophies.

greendaisie · 14/02/2024 10:15

Of course anyone can wear what they want.

And of course that doesn't change their chromosomes or biological sex.

I don't really understand what this whole thread is about.

Helleofabore · 14/02/2024 10:11

If society stops telling little boys that they can’t be pink glittery unicorns then surely fewer little boys will ask to be girls??

There seems to be an awful lot of noise about children transitioning, but so little about gendering of children.

Gendered toys etc. is an easy, tangible campaign target. Simply boycott brands that perpetuate this, yet it seems to have the status of a fringe issue. Let Toys be Toys looks great but I can’t see a mention of the implications for gender identity.

This really does show that OP has not been actually reading, or is trying to misrepresent what feminists are attempting to do.

NO ONE should be telling little boys that being a pink glittery unicorn means they are a girl in the first place.

The feminist perspective would be:

Anyone can be a pink glittery unicorn. Anyone. It doesn't make the person a girl if they are a boy.

And this is something that feminists have been saying very loudly now for decades. But even more loudly now for the past years. If OP hasn't seen this, then OP has not been paying attention.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 14/02/2024 09:55

If society stops telling little boys that they can’t be pink glittery unicorns then surely fewer little boys will ask to be girls?

So you are gender critical then op? Your posts do seem rather terfy.

Well done for seeing how bad gender identity ideology is by it's insistence that boys wearing dresses or girls having short hair etc somehow magically means they must actually be the opposite sex.

Gender critical feminists don't care what clothes children wear or want to enforce sexist sex role stereotypes.

Those stereotypes are however, required and enforced by genderists so they can convince themselves that a grown man is magically a woman because he wears a dress or 'feels' feminine.

OceanicBoundlessness · 14/02/2024 09:29

Haven't read the whole thread but have read all the ops posts and don't really understand what they're getting at.

I'm not raging about clothes because as a peri menopausal woman I've got to conserve my energy and save my raging for things that will make a difference.
What are we meant to be doing? Picketing M&S?

Beyond not dressing our own girls in clothes that say 'be kind' and 'good vibes only' and boys in camo and making sure they're dressed comfortably and practically what else should we be doing?

When let clothes be clothes and let toys be toys started off we didn't have a whole host of gender confusion in the mix. The social context has now moved on. Rest assured that if you have a 14 year old son who is struggling with fitting in and looking for his tribe, there'll be a new rainbow tribe willing to love bomb him if only he is prepared to question his gender identity. That time he dressed as a princess when he was 4 will take on a whole new significance as he looks back over his history for any clues that point him to why he might feel a bit of a square peg. I'm certainly not sayining equal opportunity for clothes should be discouraged but for some it will now form part of a new backstory as they head off down an erroneous and damaging path.

Helleofabore · 14/02/2024 09:01

Preggopreggo · 14/02/2024 01:40

And my point is, if so-called TERFism (for want of a better term) is becoming mainstream, why is this approach still so rare amongst parents?

You obviously have not had this term used at you as a form of abuse. I suggest that you do find a better way to describe the group you refer to. Many of us reject it. Some people attempt to reclaim it as a source of defiance. Some people who are new to the movement may adopt it because they haven’t yet had it used as abuse.

“if so-called TERFism (for want of a better term) is becoming mainstream, why is this approach still so rare amongst parents?”

Again this sentence is unclear in what you mean.

Are you saying TERFs are not mainstream? Well, no ‘Radical Feminism’ is not mainstream. Gosh! Who knew?

Or are you saying that the majority of parents don’t agree with the radical feminists that sex is immutable but that children should be allowed to be whatever they want and do whatever they want regardless of their sex? This might also be true. But then again, I know of few parents who impose gender stereotypes on their children, and many of those do it via religion. So, I would say that many parents do it without ‘being TERFS’.

Because as we say, the term TERF was never accurate at all.

popebishop · 14/02/2024 08:55

why is this approach still so rare amongst parents?
The answer is boring.

Sexism is deeply, deeply ingrained among entire societies. More than you ever thought.

We have people on here (and everywhere) day in day out saying that girls are just like THIS, boys are just like THAT. Their parents thought it, their grandparents thought it. The same behaviour is viewed differently when a boy does it vs a girl (authoritative/diva?)

And it's hard to disentangle socialisation from natural differences. Choices aren't made in a vacuum. And people aren't that interested in anything that doesn't confirm what they already believe.

Helleofabore · 14/02/2024 08:47

@Preggopreggo

Can you tell us all what you expect women who are campaigning for women’s rights to be doing exactly to ‘deconstruct the binary’ of clothes that we are not doing already?

Your updates don’t seem to be have gained any clarity and you still seem to be struggling to grasp the basics.

“I’m wondering why there isn’t a tidal wave of parents deconstructing the gender binary on a personal level.”

What do you see this entail? Please be specific.

Your post is still clearly accusing women of not acting the way you expect on an action you still lack understanding of. So tell us what you expect feminists to be doing.

Do you have children? Because frankly my own child was brought clothes of both sexes whenever they wanted them. However, from 3 years old insisted on copying other friends and did this until covid lock downs when they, as a teenager, developed their own style. But have you tried to dress a child who absolutely refuses to wear clothes they hate and has melt downs because they feel they will be judged for the clothes you have purchased over the ones they wanted?

Children have their own tastes. Their own style and personalities.

Plus sometimes they have a need to fit in. I know of not one feminist who would advocate distressing a child to enforce the feminist view of clothing, unless the clothing was immediately risking harm. Eg the clothing was inappropriate for the weather, or for the planned activity.

Again, as I said above, if enough stores in an area are offering a wide selection of clothes, what is there to protest? Do you expect feminists to protest because a store has the clothes separated into girls and boys clothes? A store layout that makes it easy for others to find clothing that works to suit a human body type in cut and size? No? Then What? What do you expect?

Or are you trying to say that feminists should photograph their boys in dresses and shirts and splash that all over the media using their children to spread a message that ‘clothes are just clothes’. Is the fact that feminists are saying their children are already happily wearing whatever they want at home not enough, and do you expect feminists to actively promote their children on line to prove at point?

Because if this is the case, maybe you really don’t have much idea about feminism. I don’t know any radical feminist who uses their children as media props. And certainly you wouldn’t have even a smidge of understanding that no feminist at this point in time is exposing their children to abuse from extreme trans activists doxxing and attacking their children.

Or do you think feminists are not modeling everyday that clothing is a personal choice and you can be a woman and still wear whatever you wish? Because all being a woman means is being an adult human female? Because if this is what you are talking about, you haven’t been paying attention at all.

Or maybe you don’t know who these ‘terfs’ are.

Please enlighten feminists as to what they should be doing .

VampireWeekday · 14/02/2024 08:47

Preggopreggo · 14/02/2024 01:40

And my point is, if so-called TERFism (for want of a better term) is becoming mainstream, why is this approach still so rare amongst parents?

Honestly all the parents I know who consider TERF a compliment are like me in this respect! Might see a big difference in the coming years.

I agree with your main point though, I'd happily see the gender binary for childhood smashed.

Preggopreggo · 14/02/2024 02:06

Sorry @Fionaville, I did take your words out of context.

I will leave this thread now and return to gorging on my Mum’s pancakes

OP posts:
Preggopreggo · 14/02/2024 01:40

VampireWeekday · 13/02/2024 18:25

I honestly have never met a feminist who reinforced stereotypes on their kids. My children have clothes that are neutral or conforming to their sex because given the existing binary, dressing my sons deliberately as girls would be confusing and reinforce the idea that they are girls, as they'd be frequently mistaken for girls. But I also avoid very boy coded clothes: no scary animals, diggers, army theme or camouflage. The exception to both of these rules is any clothes they particularly want, they can have. So my sons have Elsa / frozen clothes, some sparkly jumpers they wanted from girls section, and so on. In our house we don't believe in gendered toys, activities or books. All the children get to try any activity and we buy the toys that interest them.

If ever a son of mine says he wants to be a girl I'll be ready to tell him it's not possible, but of course he can do / wear / play with whatever girls do.

And my point is, if so-called TERFism (for want of a better term) is becoming mainstream, why is this approach still so rare amongst parents?

OP posts:
Preggopreggo · 14/02/2024 01:33

GelatoPistacchio · 13/02/2024 17:30

I agree that this seems like a goady thread, built on a false assumption, but there might be a more interesting discussion in there somewhere.

Would focusing efforts on dismantling how gender dominates society be more effective than trying to get people to understand the difference between sex and gender?

What more could be done in the former area? How do we get more boys and men to wear typically 'female' clothes, and not as a sexualised gimmick? So that it becomes just another option and not a signifier of anything?

Or get rid of 'female' clothes altogether. Let's face it, dresses and skirts are impractical. I wouldn't put my baby son in a dress and tights because they would make crawling difficult and the headbands look stupid and are unsafe. So why are we putting baby girls in this stuff?

Clothes are just one example. Are there other campaigns that we could work on?

Thank you @GelatoPistacchio, this is what I meant.

My post was clumsy, inadvertently goady and posted in the wrong place, for that I am sorry.

It’s obvious that gender critical feminists are critical of binary children’s clothing and aim to dress their children neutrally, as lots of PPs show.

But I’m wondering if some of those who have embraced the TERF label are really very R or even F, if they perpetuate the gender binary through their own children’s clothing choices. And of course there’s the paradox of being trans exclusionary and feminist that has been pointed out by PP.

Let Toys be Toys is a fantastic campaign - but that’s aimed at marketing. I’m wondering why there isn’t a tidal wave of parents deconstructing the gender binary on a personal level.

It’s clear that outlooks like that of Mermaids reinforces gender stereotypes, but I assume there aren’t many mermaid supporters here to ask, hence why the question wasn’t directed at them.

OP posts:
PillowRest · 13/02/2024 21:27

People can wear what they want, traditional in recent years clothing for their sex or not.
It doesn't change their sex if a man wears a dress or a woman wears baggy tracksuits though.

Helleofabore · 13/02/2024 21:24

BreatheAndFocus · 13/02/2024 19:16

It might be that the OP isn’t trying to provoke. I once had a frustrating Twitter conversation with a person from the US who thought that Gender Critical people liked gender stereotypes, er, because they thought they were critical 🙄

This person was non-binary and explained why by telling me they were “AMAB” but liked wearing skirts! And yet they thought we were the regressive ones! I suggested they could wear skirts and still be a boy and linked them to about a million 80s New Romantics 😂

I tried to have a similar discussion with a group of extreme trans activist protestors at a women's rally while I was standing hand in hand in a line around women to protect the women speaking. (the police were interspersed between our line trying to keep these protestors back a few metres). They honestly believed that we wanted to enforce stereotypes and that they were the ones who were 'bending' them. All the women laughed and we tried to point out the truth but those young protestors were too busy literally screaming and yelling to bother to listen.

But yeah. It is quite hilarious the complete twisted things that these activists think because someone told them it was true and they never thought to check the facts.

PrawnDumplings · 13/02/2024 21:11

Eh?

Swipe left for the next trending thread