Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sick of crap house layouts

193 replies

Naptrappedmummy · 13/02/2024 10:54

A moan thread but probably deserves to be on AIBU…

Looking to buy, 2 kids (boy/girl) so need 3 bedrooms. Every single house without fail either has 2 bedrooms plus a room so tiny you can’t fit a bed and wardrobe comfortably in it, or they’re 4 beds and slightly out of our price range.

Add to that rubbish uphill tiered gardens where you’ll trip and nearly break your neck every 5 minutes, a lack of storage in almost every house (no utility rooms, cupboards, pantries or porches), and just absurd layouts in general which make no use of the space they have and are completely counterintuitive.

All I want is an actual 3 bed with some storage, an ordinary downstairs layout and a flat garden capable of holding a swing and some chairs. Why can’t I have it????

OP posts:
Notcontent · 13/02/2024 13:39

This is a big problem in the U.K. and I think it will only get worse, because the whole drive to increase “affordable” housing means that developers are being incentivised to build very small homes without any thought being given to how people in those homes are supposed to live.

it is of course perfectly possible to have small homes that are fit for purpose but some thought needs to go into their design - bedrooms big enough for beds and storage, a dining area, a utility area to wash and dry clothes and store some household items, etc.

Flottie · 13/02/2024 13:36

Softycatchymonkeys · 13/02/2024 11:26

I heard that the large downstairs loos in new builds is to accommodate disabled people

I thought this too. We have a new build and the doors are all 90cm rather than 75cm, then massive downstairs loo and also back door to garden is completely flat. I always thought it was to accommodate disabled people.

GingerIsBest · 13/02/2024 13:35

Where we live there are lots of the semi-detached, 3 bed houses where the third bedroom is tiny. Layout all similar - hallway with stair case. Front room. Then to the back with a kitchen and dining room. Upstairs two good sized bedrooms, family bathroom and a box room.

All built somewhere between about 1945-1975.

I think the idea was probably that the children shared and/or one had the box room? We bought ours as a "starter" house - but 15 years later, we're still here! We were able to do a large loft conversion but the box room is now even smaller and can't be used as a bedroom at all - whereas before it could, albeit a small one.

Others have been able to do extensions to the back (we could do that but probalby only single story because of the way our house is positioned) and, not in our exact area, but more broadly in the area, lots of people have done side extensions - single or double story. But even when just single story they land up with a utility/downstairs toilet and an additional bedroom/study/tv room.

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 13/02/2024 13:32

aquarimum · 13/02/2024 13:29

Can we add shitty three storey new builds to the bonfire of crappy housing? Inadequate kitchen diner on the ground floor, weird second floor that has both a living room and a bedroom, alongside family bath, then 2 extra rooms shoehorned into the attic.

I cannot get onboard with a town house. The footprint is so small. Too many stairs. Who actually would use the living room upstairs? So much wasted space. I also would hate downstairs bedrooms. Just why?

2 floors for us all the way!

ps our new build has TONNES of storage so I do think they exist but different builder prioritise different things.

aquarimum · 13/02/2024 13:29

Can we add shitty three storey new builds to the bonfire of crappy housing? Inadequate kitchen diner on the ground floor, weird second floor that has both a living room and a bedroom, alongside family bath, then 2 extra rooms shoehorned into the attic.

HipHop63 · 13/02/2024 13:27

New modern houses have hardly any storage, its a nightmare.
Some of the retirement villages, where the two bedroom apartments are upwards of 350K have a tiny little broom cupboard and that's it. The one I worked on actually dedicated a room to hold peoples empty suitcases as they took up too much room. It was unbelievable.

SansaClegane · 13/02/2024 13:25

I know exactly what you mean OP. When house hunting (about 1.5 years ago) I was looking for a 3 bed, and it would always start out ok (ground floor decent size, one bedroom good size, one bedroom ok size) and then we'd come to the third bedroom and no space to swing a cat?! Hugely disappointing so many times. Even looked at a new build (couple of years old) in my desperation, but the downstairs was so small, you wouldn't have been able to squeeze two people in the kitchen at a time! And zero storage.
Ended up buying much larger than anticipated- ex HMO, 4 double bedrooms and converted garage which is now the gaming room plus utility room. Of course it was in a shit condition and I used up almost all my savings on the required modernisation, but was happy to pay that price in return for so much floor space! Which I'd never been able to afford otherwise. Will also add, my house has a lovely square shaped living room, which I like so much better than the usual "sock shape" (long and narrow).

dudsville · 13/02/2024 13:20

I was shocked when we viewed our 1930's home, the two main bedrooms have actual cedar lined closets, these two join up with a 3rd in the adjoining hallway that's an airing cupboard. All of this is the space over the entranceway below it - Genius! They're small but really useful spaces. Homes are so expensive now.

Applesandbananasandpears · 13/02/2024 13:19

I ended up with a three story new build. It’s a barratt kingsville. Two double bedrooms and a generous single which could take a double against the wall. Only way to avoid a tiny third room where I am. That said two bedrooms don’t have full height ceilings so it’s all compromise

GasPanic · 13/02/2024 13:11

I am in a new-ish build. I think the quality is OK but they failed on some things.

i) Not enough light in the hall. Common in semis, but judicious placement of an extra window in the front would have made all the difference.

ii) drive barely large width wise enough for 2 cars but can be extended. Should have done this from the start.

iii) Insulation very poor on the front of the house leading to significant heat leak.

iv) No mirrors over the sinks in ensuite and bathroom possible because they are placed against windows.

v) House is set too far back from the road. Could have had more room in the back garden and less space at the front making house worth more.

vi) Pipework in many places concealed and difficult to access making maintenance nightmare (common to most newish builds I think).

vii) No understairs cupbaord by default ? Why ? This is potentially valuable storage space.

SiriAlexa · 13/02/2024 13:08

I sympathise OP. I also find more expensive properties lack proper storage. In other countries having built in wardrobes, a linen cupboard and a cupboard for an ironing board a vacuum cleaner is standard even in small and inexpensive properties. The developers in the UK are greedy and get away with too much!

Talipesmum · 13/02/2024 13:03

We found similar and that was ten years ago so it was all more affordable than it is now. We ended up with a 1970 terrace, not beautiful from the outside but the third bedroom does fit a double bed, albeit sideways under the window wall to wall. All the other ones had tiny 6ft x 7ft “nurseries”.
We’ve now converted the loft as well and only lost a cupboard off the smaller third bedroom. It’s lovely. On street parking but nowhere near as challenging as the last place we lived for on street parking so that was one compromise we had to make.

Butterdishy · 13/02/2024 13:01

Post war excouncil! 3 double bedrooms, driveway, large garden, loads of storage. Ugly as sin though.

HighQueenOfTheFarRealm · 13/02/2024 13:00

I agree op. It's ridiculous. Just so nonsensical. How much better to have 3 decent size bedrooms as a standard.
Homes in this country are so stupid and small for the masses.

AhBiscuits · 13/02/2024 12:58

NomNomYum · 13/02/2024 12:53

You don't have to lose the 3rd 'bedroom' to the stairs, both my friends that had this done had the stairs above where the original stairs were.

Yes, this is what we did. We didn't have to sacrifice the 3rd bedroom.

NewKingontheBlock · 13/02/2024 12:54

Atethehalloweenchocs · 13/02/2024 12:49

House building standards in this country are terrible and builders get away with what they can - I think RIBA said we have the worst standards in Europe.

Are you sure about that? I think we have smaller houses than average but not heard that the build quality of newly built homes is the worst in Europe, have you got a link?

NomNomYum · 13/02/2024 12:53

Fredthefrog · 13/02/2024 11:18

I live in a town where most of the gardens are small to tiny and on street parking is horrendous. The older houses look cute and are 3 bed but the 3rd room is tiny and if you do the loft you lose that room any way. We've ended up in a modern terrace with 4 bedrooms and lots of stairs. Got to decide on your compromises.

You don't have to lose the 3rd 'bedroom' to the stairs, both my friends that had this done had the stairs above where the original stairs were.

NotMeekNotObedient · 13/02/2024 12:51

This is exactly why we are staying put in our 2 bed for now. I can't find any 3 bed houses with 3 decent size rooms and the downstairs space is just as small as our 2 bed.

With a 4 bed you get much more downstairs space plus proper bedrooms.

We do have the option to extend up and out but our secondary school catchments aren't great.

The only other option is to buy a small three bed and spend to extend/amend layout. Might be the better option as you'll get exactly what you want?

NewKingontheBlock · 13/02/2024 12:50

What you have described in your OP sounds like your average 1930’s semi, typical lay out for the time period, sounds like you will either have to extend a property or increase your budget.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 13/02/2024 12:49

House building standards in this country are terrible and builders get away with what they can - I think RIBA said we have the worst standards in Europe.

AhBiscuits · 13/02/2024 12:43

We converted the loft to get a large 3rd bedroom and the box room became my office.

Spectre8 · 13/02/2024 12:43

You cant help how houses were built which were in a time where that might have suited the way people lived and the size of families etc

Again the trend for open plan so now everything is and yet most people hate it and end up separating the rooms again.

Also people who have the houses u want, cant afford the houses they want so they aren't going on the market.

I have a house that would meet your needs (London though) but I'd only be moving if it was to a detached house and I can't afford it so I'm staying in my 3bed (all doubles) larder cupboard in kitchen, coat cupboard, downstairs loo under stairs and under stairs storage as well plus a flat garden.

Naptrappedmummy · 13/02/2024 12:41

Thank you for the very kind offers of doing a search for me, where I live is quite small though and this is my regular username so worried about outing 😬 perhaps I should start another thread next week under a new username and take you all up on it!

OP posts:
Jessforless · 13/02/2024 12:34

What’s your rough budget and where do you want to live? Maybe someone can find it for you?