Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sick of crap house layouts

193 replies

Naptrappedmummy · 13/02/2024 10:54

A moan thread but probably deserves to be on AIBU…

Looking to buy, 2 kids (boy/girl) so need 3 bedrooms. Every single house without fail either has 2 bedrooms plus a room so tiny you can’t fit a bed and wardrobe comfortably in it, or they’re 4 beds and slightly out of our price range.

Add to that rubbish uphill tiered gardens where you’ll trip and nearly break your neck every 5 minutes, a lack of storage in almost every house (no utility rooms, cupboards, pantries or porches), and just absurd layouts in general which make no use of the space they have and are completely counterintuitive.

All I want is an actual 3 bed with some storage, an ordinary downstairs layout and a flat garden capable of holding a swing and some chairs. Why can’t I have it????

OP posts:
Panicking23 · 13/02/2024 16:04

Was the same in our area unless it was edwardian/victorian semis in more affluent areas than we could afford! The only ones with 3 decent sized bedrooms were ones with attic conversions, so maybe worth looking at 2 beds that have potential to convert?

BreatheAndFocus · 13/02/2024 16:00

My Edwardian house had 3 good-sized double bedrooms. One was big enough for 3 single beds. The reason it had these was that they’d put a kitchen extension on and, instead of putting the bathroom above it like they usually do, they’d put a third bedroom there and converted the original 3rd bedroom into a bathroom. This made all the difference.

So, look at older houses and be on the look-out for intelligent conversions. Ours was reasonably priced too compared with newer properties.

Randomsabreur · 13/02/2024 15:54

The downstairs toilet being "accessible" is required for new builds even when the house itself isn't (on a "street" that is steps rather than a road...).

Probably the biggest reason not to buy a modern new build!

We had to compromise areas to get a 4 bed because a 3 bed with 3 decent bedrooms and a downstairs that wasn't fully open plan did not exist! Ended up with a dated 5 bed project in a less fashionable area.

I'd also much rather have 2 family bathrooms than an en suite unless you've space to burn - to be fair I'd rather have an en suite guest room while the kids are young and still needing reminded to flush!

CurlyhairedAssassin · 13/02/2024 15:52

I don't understand all the fuss about box rooms not being bedrooms. Generations of families have all used them as a bedroom for a young adult offspring. John Lennon and Paul McCartney first started playing together in John's boxroom bedroom.

I agree that the third tiny bedroom in new builds often can only just fit a cot, chest of drawers and a chair in, and once past toddler stage they're too small really. However, in our 1930s semi, our box room fits in my son's single bed (extra long one for when he's fully grown - he's 17 now), drawers underneath it. A wardrobe. A narrow bedside cabinet. So it serves well as a bedroom. When the kids were younger we put bunk beds in and they slept in there and had the back bigger bedroom as their playroom. They had a massive Thomas train set permanently set up in there and had a whale of a time. Literally only used the box room to sleep in.

I suppose it's slightly problematic now that DS2 is wanting his own computer desk/gaming station - his bedroom isn't big enough unless you set up one of those high sleeper things with desk underneath (we decided against that as would only get a few years out of it). However we have an extension downstairs (so 2 living rooms really) so he has variously been in the front living room, and also in the back upstairs bedroom when DS1 is mostly away at university.

Plenty of people around here have had loft conversions too so the box room then becomes an office.

I just don't see a boxroom in a 1930s semi as being a major problem, so try looking for those.

LastRites · 13/02/2024 15:48

Snoken · 13/02/2024 14:04

I think the issue with UK housing is that you place too much value on how many bedrooms they have rather than the square footage. It's the only country I live in that advertise properties that way, everywhere else it price per square meter/foot that counts. By doing it your way you can get away with having tiny rooms (and they really are very tiny in many cases) as some ads don't even have the total square footage on them.

This is so true. We viewed four beds smaller than our last three bed SD, and ended up buying a 3 bed SD that had been overlooked by buyers like us simply because it has only 3 bedrooms. In fact, it is enormous with a big footprint, three double bedrooms and plenty of scope to extend etc. I fully believe it sat on the market due to not having a fourth bedroom, whereas it is easily more spacious than any new build 4 bed detached I’ve been in.

I’m not sure where you are OP, but in my city, if you can stretch your budget, there are clusters of large 1930s semi detached & detached houses in certain areas. They are easily bigger than any of the new builds by us!

user1497787065 · 13/02/2024 15:47

We are just selling a house we’ve been in for thirty years. We’ve extended and added loads of storage. Each bedroom has huge built in wardrobes, our utility room has floor to ceiling cupboards and as much as I am keen to downsize the lack of storage in every house I have looked it is a real sticking point for me. I really struggle to understand architects. The popular layout currently consists of a large open plan sitting/kitchen and every other room comparatively is small and no cupboards anywhere. No one seems to consider how it is to actually live in a house.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 13/02/2024 15:44

I used to watch Move to the Country, or whatever it was called around 25 years ago was was amazed that people with £1m budgets (a lot of money then when the average house price wasn't even £200k), couldn't find anything they liked.

So many houses are badly designed, even the expensive ones.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 13/02/2024 15:44

Years ago we bought an Edwardian terrace with what had originally been 3 double bedrooms. However, the previous owners had split the back bedroom to create an upstairs bathroom, then knocked the downstairs bathroom and kitchen together to make a larger kitchen.

It was fine whilst the dc were small. Babies don't need a large bedroom. They played downstairs all the time. The plan was to save up and do a loft conversion to create main bedroom + en suite for us, then the kids could have had a double bedroom each and the tiny bedroom would have become a study.

In the event, we ended up moving for other reasons, so never went through with it.

TerrifiedOfNoise · 13/02/2024 15:41

@Naptrappedmummy what you’re describing is ex-local authority 1950s homes. I live in one and even the third bedroom is a good size (a single but not a box), plus I have a pantry, airing cupboard, utility, old coal store, downstairs loo (not under the stairs so that is still free for coats etc.). If it weren’t for us wanting detached, a garage and 4 beds we’d be staying in this terrace as it’s fantastic and I am not snobby about it being ex-LA.

Wexone · 13/02/2024 15:39

Big downstairs loos are for wheelchair accessible now which is a legal requirement

Wexone · 13/02/2024 15:36

Naptrappedmummy · 13/02/2024 11:17

Omg yes the bathrooms off the kitchen. And what’s with en suites? Who wants to take a dump then open the door onto their bedroom? Or fill the room up with shower steam? They take up space the house doesn’t have most of the time.

Sorry living 20 years with my en suite - never had steam come into my bedroom( its a well ventilated room) nor an issue with takin a dump, its our bathroom no one esle uses it, even my parents had one when was growing up. Building a new house at mo and have a fab lovely big en suite in the plans.

LindaDawn · 13/02/2024 15:36

Naptrappedmummy · 13/02/2024 11:07

Yes who on earth sacrifices kitchen space for a downstairs loo, what are these ‘architects’ thinking?! It’s utter madness. Or having an unliveably small third bedroom so the master can have an en suite.

Totally agree! Can’t stand the obsession with an en-suite, especially when bedrooms are tiny.

SwordToFlamethrower · 13/02/2024 15:35

If a downstairs loo is to accommodate a disabled person, then they should factor it in and made the house bigger for the kitchen, rather than sacrificing kitchen space?

Baffling.

AntonFeckoff · 13/02/2024 15:35

LakieLady · 13/02/2024 14:25

DNiece and her BF looked at shared ownership and when they crunched the numbers, they worked out that with the service charges, rent and mortgage, they'd be better off renting and carrying on saving until they could afford to buy a flat in the normal way.

They'll be able to save a lot more, and her salary will take a big jump when she's qualified in 2 years time, so they'll be able to get a bigger mortgage. And it'll mean that they'll be able to buy a doer-upper, rather than a new build that's not very well built.

Not sure where your DNiece is, but where I am it works out much cheaper to do SO than to rent (around half the cost in my case, including service charge). I bought a SO flat coming up to 10 years ago and will make a nice little bit of equity too. Unfortunately I'm unlikely to be in a position to buy on the open market in the foreseeable future as I'm a single person on a public sector salary living in a county with high house prices, so I have to make do.

Puffalicious · 13/02/2024 15:35

Interestingly, it must depend on where you are. My 1930s end terrace is great: 2 large reception rooms; decent bathroom upstairs; downstairs shower room; garage; large back garden; small front garden but space for 3 cars in drive; 2 very large bedrooms; 3rd is much smaller but fits bed, wardrobe, drawers & space to play; converted loft of 2 rooms (eldest DC up there - one sleeping, other sitting/ studying/ music room) but still loads of storage in the eaves.

The only downside is small kitchen, but we're extending soon and the dining room/ 2nd reception is right off the kitchen.

Option for you might be a loft conversion?

Luhou · 13/02/2024 15:33

Would you go for a bungalow? Often bedrooms are good proportions and space is easier to re-purpose e.g. a dining room could be bedroom 3, the tiny bedroom is usually avoided as no need to accomodate a staircase.

Spaghettieis · 13/02/2024 15:02

FuzzyPuffling · 13/02/2024 14:59

Yes, look at older properties. Your Victorian house is tiny and crap, my Edwardian one has large rooms and storage.

Therefore it is worth looking at older ( than 1930s, which I never mentioned) properties.

I'll leave it there.

There are also modern houses which are good though. You can’t generalise about a specific period, because there are good and crap layouts in homes from all periods. So yes, do also look at older and newer homes, no need to write off specific periods, but equally looking for older homes in particular won’t help the search.

FuzzyPuffling · 13/02/2024 14:59

Spaghettieis · 13/02/2024 14:53

You said look at older properties- I was saying that older properties also frequently have crap layouts so there’s no point looking for a particular period. Unfortunately I think you have to sift through dozens of properties of all types before finding a non-crap gem.

Yes, look at older properties. Your Victorian house is tiny and crap, my Edwardian one has large rooms and storage.

Therefore it is worth looking at older ( than 1930s, which I never mentioned) properties.

I'll leave it there.

VeryGoodVeryNice · 13/02/2024 14:54

You’re right. I lived in a rented 3 bed semi detached new build. It was a tiny house but had THREE toilets. Tiny kitchen, small living room, downstairs loo, garage. Crappy garden that was on a hill and wasn’t big enough for any play equipment. And then upstairs 3 bedrooms that were quite similar in size, I’d say small double. But the ‘master’ bedroom had an en suite that was almost as big as the bedroom itself. And completely pointless because there was also the family bathroom upstairs, and from the only possible place I could put the bed in that room, it was half the distance to go to the family bathroom than it was to get to the en suite. I ended up using the en suite as a storage room as there was no storage space anywhere else in the house!

Spaghettieis · 13/02/2024 14:53

FuzzyPuffling · 13/02/2024 14:50

Not generalising, just describing my house, which is not the same as yours.

You said look at older properties- I was saying that older properties also frequently have crap layouts so there’s no point looking for a particular period. Unfortunately I think you have to sift through dozens of properties of all types before finding a non-crap gem.

FuzzyPuffling · 13/02/2024 14:50

Spaghettieis · 13/02/2024 14:39

You can’t generalise like this. My Victorian terrace has no built-in storage other than the kitchen, no under stairs cupboard, landing is 1x1m. Loads of period houses also have crap layouts from being badly extended over time.

People have also mentioned 1930s semis, most of those I’ve seen also have the tiny 3rd bedroom!

Not generalising, just describing my house, which is not the same as yours.

Spaghettieis · 13/02/2024 14:39

FuzzyPuffling · 13/02/2024 11:03

My Edwardian terrace has 3 double bedrooms plus huge understairs/ landing cupboards. We moved from a modern house that was very short on storage. Maybe look at older properties?

You can’t generalise like this. My Victorian terrace has no built-in storage other than the kitchen, no under stairs cupboard, landing is 1x1m. Loads of period houses also have crap layouts from being badly extended over time.

People have also mentioned 1930s semis, most of those I’ve seen also have the tiny 3rd bedroom!

HowMuchSchoolAdmin · 13/02/2024 14:32

@sleepyscientist it's a 1930s terrace. We'd had the plans drawn up for a loft conversion, along with the savings - used some savings in lockdown (self employed) and then long covid happened, along with Truss and mortgage deal renewal, so not sure what happens when kids get older now.

LakieLady · 13/02/2024 14:25

AntonFeckoff · 13/02/2024 12:18

I'm flat hunting and also fed up of stupid layouts. I can only afford shared ownership which is 99.9% new or very recent builds.

The lounge layouts are the worst. They're all open plan living/kitchen/dining. with an ugly strip separating the laminate kitchen area from the carpeted living area, often diagonally. No thought to where you would put a TV or sofa, often with radiators in the way of the most obvious places. So many flats with walls at odd angles.

Hideous dark grey carpets throughout. Likewise grey-tiled bathrooms. Limited storage.

The 1 bed flats are tiny. I've lived in many Victorian conversion 1 bed flats which have provided more than enough space, but new build 1 beds are half the floor area.

It feels like no thought or consideration has gone into any of it. Just knock them up, meet the quota, inflate the price because people are desperate and stick on an astronomical service charge while doing fuck all in maintenance to add insult to injury.

DNiece and her BF looked at shared ownership and when they crunched the numbers, they worked out that with the service charges, rent and mortgage, they'd be better off renting and carrying on saving until they could afford to buy a flat in the normal way.

They'll be able to save a lot more, and her salary will take a big jump when she's qualified in 2 years time, so they'll be able to get a bigger mortgage. And it'll mean that they'll be able to buy a doer-upper, rather than a new build that's not very well built.

JustlikeElllie · 13/02/2024 14:25

I know exactly what you mean op. When we bought our house we looked at probably 30 houses and all were as you describe.

We wanted it all though, 3 decent sized bedrooms, a large hallway, good sized back and front, built in storage cupboards, garage.

We found most of what we wanted in our 1950s house. But there were compromises.

Swipe left for the next trending thread