Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sick of crap house layouts

193 replies

Naptrappedmummy · 13/02/2024 10:54

A moan thread but probably deserves to be on AIBU…

Looking to buy, 2 kids (boy/girl) so need 3 bedrooms. Every single house without fail either has 2 bedrooms plus a room so tiny you can’t fit a bed and wardrobe comfortably in it, or they’re 4 beds and slightly out of our price range.

Add to that rubbish uphill tiered gardens where you’ll trip and nearly break your neck every 5 minutes, a lack of storage in almost every house (no utility rooms, cupboards, pantries or porches), and just absurd layouts in general which make no use of the space they have and are completely counterintuitive.

All I want is an actual 3 bed with some storage, an ordinary downstairs layout and a flat garden capable of holding a swing and some chairs. Why can’t I have it????

OP posts:
JaceLancs · 13/02/2024 21:23

Where I live there are a lot of 50s and 60s built semi detached, bungalows or dormer bungalows with plenty of landspace - no en-suites or utility rooms though
Mine is 3 bed but all are double size, decent size kitchen/diner and large lounge
More modern houses always seem to have very small rooms, no parking and lots of toilets!

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 13/02/2024 21:16

I had 2 1970s houses.
One was 3 bed with a dog staircase, so no bulkhead. The smallest bedroom was 10x12.
The second was 4 bed with the 2 smallest bedrooms were 10 x12.

Papyrophile · 13/02/2024 20:58

It was Kremlin architecture @rc22 built for functionality and not for aesthetic points. But the layouts worked, and planting/cladding/windows can make silk purses out of sows' ears.

rc22 · 13/02/2024 20:47

Papyrophile · 13/02/2024 20:25

I think what you really need is a 1970s house. Yes, they tend to have limited kerb appeal, but the interior spaces were thought through to accommodate two parents and two children; they were generally decently built and energy efficiency was starting to be a factor. Rooms were also a better size normally and people lived in the same place for longer so tired 70s properties represent a lot of probate sales. I would always look at sq footage as a starting point.

Yes my parents are still in the house they bought in 1977. There's only one bathroom and the house is a bit grim-looking from outside (definitely lacks kerb appeal!) but has a big living room, reasonable sized kitchen, 2 double bedrooms and a third bedroom that comfortably holds a single bed, wardrobe and chest of drawers. Also lovely big windows so nice and light.

Papyrophile · 13/02/2024 20:45

In London (other cities exist), there are always trade-offs. But for what it's worth, it's difficult to find a place anywhere that is suitable to move down the scale. We are planning to find a smaller place that is worth less than our (IMO) lovely four bed family house (sorry, the garden ain't flat, but the view is stupendous) so we can give DC a deposit and still live somewhere that isn't cramped. Sadly the UK's assumption is that once you turn 65 or 70, you have no choices beyond sitting in one room and watching day time TV, popping tablets until you die. I just want two bedrooms, ideally both ensuite, with lots of storage and a big cooking-entertaining open-plan living dining kitchen, plus utility/bootroom. DH wants a garage. No ambitious outdoor space required.

rc22 · 13/02/2024 20:41

I love our ensuite but sometimes think the space would have been better used as storage/dressing room.

Usernamerequired123 · 13/02/2024 20:31

Parkrunprom · 13/02/2024 16:22

I don’t understand new build flats houses with zero storage. Where does the hoover / ironing board / Christmas decorations / camping gear / bike pump / garden games etc go??? And I’d never consider a room to be a room unless it’s at least 10ft x 10ft.

The UK has notorious cramped new builds. It’s embarrassing.

My new built has ample storage space. On every floor. Even a larder (like a small pantry). I have space for everything including Christmas decor

Papyrophile · 13/02/2024 20:25

I think what you really need is a 1970s house. Yes, they tend to have limited kerb appeal, but the interior spaces were thought through to accommodate two parents and two children; they were generally decently built and energy efficiency was starting to be a factor. Rooms were also a better size normally and people lived in the same place for longer so tired 70s properties represent a lot of probate sales. I would always look at sq footage as a starting point.

NoWordForFluffy · 13/02/2024 20:23

Wigtopia · 13/02/2024 20:14

yes I know they have doors. I understand what an en suite is 🙄

if you’re happy lit by bin bed with someone else taking a dump in a room with a door to waft the stench into your bedroom, enjoy!

Improve your diet, less chance of a 'stench' then!

kintra · 13/02/2024 20:22

Wigtopia · 13/02/2024 20:14

yes I know they have doors. I understand what an en suite is 🙄

if you’re happy lit by bin bed with someone else taking a dump in a room with a door to waft the stench into your bedroom, enjoy!

Sounds like we have a little more class than your family, not least as we'd never use that term 🤢

Usernamerequired123 · 13/02/2024 20:16

SwordToFlamethrower · 13/02/2024 15:35

If a downstairs loo is to accommodate a disabled person, then they should factor it in and made the house bigger for the kitchen, rather than sacrificing kitchen space?

Baffling.

I know. I'm in a new build as well. And it's bonkers! I'm thinking of moving my washing machine to the downstairs loo as it already has water / electricity. And hopefully should not be costly. This will free up a lot of space in my tiny kitchen.

Wigtopia · 13/02/2024 20:14

kintra · 13/02/2024 20:01

You know they have doors? 🙄 It's the same as how using the family bathroom doesn't feel like going to the toilet in the hallway...

I thought I hated ensuites until I got one. Love it! And we're a couple in a 4 bed detached with no kids (DINK life), I can imagine they're so helpful if you have kids. New builds can be fine, but you do need to size up. We were looking at 3 bed semi detached older properties, but it made more sense in the end to go for the 4 bed new build. Our smallest bedroom is 9x10 foot, so not even that small, and we have reasonable storage plus a garage. However, the three beds in the development are tiny! Downstairs space is small and the third bedroom can be less than 7 foot wide. I just wouldn't pay what they're asking for what you get.

I agree that you probably just don't have the budget for what you really want. Like most of us! Would I have chosen this house if I had 500k more in the budget? No, but you compromise.

yes I know they have doors. I understand what an en suite is 🙄

if you’re happy lit by bin bed with someone else taking a dump in a room with a door to waft the stench into your bedroom, enjoy!

Crikeyalmighty · 13/02/2024 20:11

@Lourdes12 yep- it was similar when we rented in Copenhagen- and houses in Sweden are even better. Virtually every house we looked at was really lovely- I had a laundry room in the basement that was much bigger than the average master bedroom in the uk-complete with clothes lines strung up. I also had 2 huge dry useable store rooms in the basement complete with full size freezer plus shelved and an outside 'shed' you could have lived in.

Echobelly · 13/02/2024 20:04

Yes, we found quite a few houses had 'half bedrooms', you couldn't even get a cotbed in the smallest room.

In some houses it was because there had a been a loft extension and the stairs to that had cut a chunk out of a bedroom.

kintra · 13/02/2024 20:01

Wigtopia · 13/02/2024 17:40

I hate an en suite. Would never have one. If I we ever moved and bought a place with one, it would first thing to be gone! I just can’t imagine how it doesn’t feel like taking a crap in the bedroom 😂

You know they have doors? 🙄 It's the same as how using the family bathroom doesn't feel like going to the toilet in the hallway...

I thought I hated ensuites until I got one. Love it! And we're a couple in a 4 bed detached with no kids (DINK life), I can imagine they're so helpful if you have kids. New builds can be fine, but you do need to size up. We were looking at 3 bed semi detached older properties, but it made more sense in the end to go for the 4 bed new build. Our smallest bedroom is 9x10 foot, so not even that small, and we have reasonable storage plus a garage. However, the three beds in the development are tiny! Downstairs space is small and the third bedroom can be less than 7 foot wide. I just wouldn't pay what they're asking for what you get.

I agree that you probably just don't have the budget for what you really want. Like most of us! Would I have chosen this house if I had 500k more in the budget? No, but you compromise.

Lourdes12 · 13/02/2024 19:30

Too many people on a small surface and a lot of privately owned land is why house are like dolls houses here. I am from Sweden, all the bedrooms are big, lots of storage, utility room (no washing machine in the kitchen), big hallway when you come in with lots of clever storage for coats and shoes. Just big and practical houses. Sweden is 3 times bigger than UK but only has a population of 8 million

Jaxhog · 13/02/2024 19:19

Naptrappedmummy · 13/02/2024 11:07

Yes who on earth sacrifices kitchen space for a downstairs loo, what are these ‘architects’ thinking?! It’s utter madness. Or having an unliveably small third bedroom so the master can have an en suite.

It will be a builder not an actual Architect. Architects study how to design usable space etc., builders just know how to put bricks together. Most new housing developments in the UK don't use actual qualified Architects, so we end up with unusable homes.

AntonFeckoff · 13/02/2024 18:58

OnlyTheBravest · 13/02/2024 17:58

@AntonFeckoff This drives me insane. My DC are starting to looking at SO properties and the vast majority of flats with just one living area and virtually no storage but sky high prices.

Who wants a kitchen right behind a sofa. The noise alone would drive me insane. Washing machines are not as quiet as they are made out to be.

LOL my kitchen is behind my sofa, and the washing machine does indeed drive me completely insane despite being ‘ultra-silent’ (it really is not). I aspire to a washing machine in a cupboard.

Naptrappedmummy · 13/02/2024 18:48

@Thriwit yes I’m contemplating buying a 4 bed and knocking 2 of the bedrooms through (we are viewing one on Friday). Hallways are also very underrated. Ours is really narrow, you have to squeeze past all the coats hanging up to get through!

OP posts:
Ebeneser · 13/02/2024 18:39

Modern houses are rubbish. They also put no thought into the layout. For example instead of house layouts being e.g stairs/hall/bathroom against the party wall to minimise noise they put bedrooms against bedrooms or living rooms against living rooms which can cause problems especially if one side decides to do something shite like mount a telly or speaker on the party wall.

Thriwit · 13/02/2024 18:36

When we were looking a couple of years ago, we found that the 4 bed houses were almost as useless as the 3 bed ones. They usually had 2 double bedrooms, and 2 tiny bedrooms. You’d have to knock the 2 small ones together to get 3 decent bedrooms! But at that point you’re massively devaluing your house, and paying a huge amount of money to do so.

We ended up with a 1950s 3-bed semi, and I’m pretty happy with it. 1 big double, 1 ok double, and 1 good single (you could fit a double bed in if needed). And it has a good hallway! So plenty of space for shoes & coats. Downstairs loo, & a separate kitchen (I loathe open plan).
The 1930s ones round here have the tiny box room; the 1950s ones have a more usable 3rd bedroom.

NoWordForFluffy · 13/02/2024 18:35

AntonFeckoff · 13/02/2024 16:38

I hope it works out for your son. There's more protection in place for shared owners now, too, like allowances for repairs. A lot of people on here turn their noses up at SO but many of us don't have a choice, so we do the best with what we can.

Unfortunately there's not an awful lot on the market where I am at the moment. Plenty of 2-4 bedroom houses going up in the middle of nowhere but very few 1-2 bedroom affordable flats anywhere near town or city centres. A luxurious development went up in my city a couple of years ago and for some reason they've made a sizeable portion of it SO, presumably as it wouldn't have got permission to be built without 'affordable' options otherwise. Their 1 beds start at £450k full market value, which even for this area is laughable. No wonder they aren't shifting them.

I hear a lot of complaints from people about how these blocks of flats are going up and sitting empty so there's obviously no need for them... err, no, it's that even people who are desperate for a home can't afford them!

We're in a SO house. I think the people who are very anti don't know the protections there are in place now (such as the 990 year lease and allowance for repairs etc).

Our house was never meant to be SO, but the developer couldn't sell it post-Truss, so the HA bought a load from them to shift on to the likes of us. It's a style and spec not usually offered to SO (and ours is the ex-show home, so we got it with carpet / Amtico / vinyl for bathrooms throughout). The developer of the apartments you mention may have done similar (there were always SO on the development, but it wasn't intended for there to be so many).

OnlyTheBravest · 13/02/2024 17:58

AntonFeckoff · 13/02/2024 12:18

I'm flat hunting and also fed up of stupid layouts. I can only afford shared ownership which is 99.9% new or very recent builds.

The lounge layouts are the worst. They're all open plan living/kitchen/dining. with an ugly strip separating the laminate kitchen area from the carpeted living area, often diagonally. No thought to where you would put a TV or sofa, often with radiators in the way of the most obvious places. So many flats with walls at odd angles.

Hideous dark grey carpets throughout. Likewise grey-tiled bathrooms. Limited storage.

The 1 bed flats are tiny. I've lived in many Victorian conversion 1 bed flats which have provided more than enough space, but new build 1 beds are half the floor area.

It feels like no thought or consideration has gone into any of it. Just knock them up, meet the quota, inflate the price because people are desperate and stick on an astronomical service charge while doing fuck all in maintenance to add insult to injury.

@AntonFeckoff This drives me insane. My DC are starting to looking at SO properties and the vast majority of flats with just one living area and virtually no storage but sky high prices.

Who wants a kitchen right behind a sofa. The noise alone would drive me insane. Washing machines are not as quiet as they are made out to be.

Stayeduptoolateagain · 13/02/2024 17:49

Some beautiful new builds near us. Gorgeous big bedrooms. Lovely downstairs space. But they've gone for garages and not office space 🙄

goldneedle · 13/02/2024 17:48

YANBU

We’re not talking about the typical box room that I grew up with, that fit a single bed and wardrobe. I could live with that. The three bed houses around here have the third bedroom so small that they literally don’t fit a single bed in them!