Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To agree with Esther Ghey?

113 replies

ProfessorPeppy · 13/02/2024 08:44

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2024/feb/12/i-want-to-make-things-better-esther-ghey-on-her-hopes-for-online-reform

I’m a teacher in a secondary school. I believe that the massive uptick in social problems we are experiencing in schools results from unfettered smartphone use and access to social media. School refusal, eating disorders, gender identity issues, self harm, anxiety, depression. ASD/ADHD seems to be a common underlying starting point for such vulnerabilities, but neurotypical children are also adversely affected. So many of the children I teach say things like, ‘everybody is looking at me in class, it makes me anxious’ - surely this results from a life spent on social media? Cameras on phones mean that anybody can be recorded/broadcast themselves at the click of a button, perhaps without their permission.

DS1 is 11 and about to start secondary school. He doesn’t have a phone…yet. He has an ASD/ADHD dual diagnosis and is medicated. I can clearly see that he might be vulnerable to the adverse effects of smartphone access, so I’m thinking v carefully about my next steps.

YABU: these problems have always existed for young people, and this has nothing to do with smartphones/social media.

YANBU: smartphones/social media have amplified these problems, especially for ND young people.

‘I want to make things better’: Esther Ghey on her hopes for online reform

Brianna’s mother speaks about daughter’s life and death, and what she hopes will be her legacy

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2024/feb/12/i-want-to-make-things-better-esther-ghey-on-her-hopes-for-online-reform

OP posts:
CreateHope · 13/02/2024 11:49

OP, I 100% agree with you and the secondary teachers I know agree with you too. Social media is a toxic hellhole for most teenagers and I could weep for them 😢

User14March · 13/02/2024 11:48

@TOOmanymugs yes autism/ADHD make today’s environment very challenging but depending on your locale & personal situation also pretty hard to navigate pre tech. We were encouraged to ‘just get on with it’ with support.

I know that’s over simplifying but leaving an ADD teen etc to ruminate for hours and hovering outside their room on eggshells not the way. Generally our curtains were opened & we had to be up & out.

MILTOBE · 13/02/2024 11:47

I agree with the above - we need to bring back youth clubs. It would cost a bit to get them up and running but in the end if we want our children to be off their devices, we need to give them something to do.

T00manymugs · 13/02/2024 11:40

It only takes 10 minutes to be abused and groomed on line. Apps which feed anorexia are portable and addictive. You can’t fill every minute with expensive activities nobody has the money for. This needs proper sorting from those who are supposed to be governing. They are not safeguarding teens or children.

user1497207191 · 13/02/2024 11:36

User14March · 13/02/2024 11:06

Shouldn’t we be trying to keep teens busier, sports, clubs, etc? A ‘good’ teen is a physically tired teen. Far less room for rumination. We had youth club twice a week, Brownies, chess club, cookery, etc.

I really agree with this. Everyone keeps saying kids should be out more, but not everyone just wants to hang out randomly with strangers on street corners or kicking a ball - the quieter ones aren't going to muscle in on what they see others are doing - they're going to continue to be lonely and introverted etc.

They need organised activities, where they just get swept up into doing things the others are doing. We need a better range of clubs & societies, a bit like what they do at Unis, but at a far younger age. Get them working in association with schools, to try and break down the obstacles to the quieter kids doing other things.

We have to be realistic about the internet. We can't turn it off and can't really control it, so the next best thing we can do is occupy our children with other activities so that the default isn't always going on social media when they're "bored".

T00manymugs · 13/02/2024 11:34

User14March · 13/02/2024 11:28

@T00manymugs I think we’ve become too indulgent. Those with ASC etc, unless very severe, had to find skills and toolkit to cope & close friends would support.

You can’t switch autism off and today’s environment is hugely difficult for those of us with autism. Many will have ADHD too. Many won’t have close friends and will be struggling with masking, anxiety, sensory issues etc. A slower more mindful less tech orientated environment is do much better for autism and developing brains. I have a pre tech adolescence and years of work on myself to fall back on. Today’s teens ASC or otherwise don’t.

GoodOldEmmaNess · 13/02/2024 11:31

It was a very humane article. Just awful to read of all the various pressures that her child experienced online, and then to think about the online influences that may have shaped the minds and behaviours of the children who murdered her. What a horrible mess we are in.

User14March · 13/02/2024 11:28

@T00manymugs I think we’ve become too indulgent. Those with ASC etc, unless very severe, had to find skills and toolkit to cope & close friends would support.

medianewbie · 13/02/2024 11:25

Dogfisher · 13/02/2024 09:11

The gender identity side of things has calmed down recently, at least in my school. It’s far less of a thing with teenagers these days. It tends to be part of an autism/ADHD presentation more generally, and is more popular with young people in their 20s than teenagers

I wish that this was correct where I teach OP but it's rife. And supported by plenty of young, desperate to be cool, staff.

It's absolutely rife here too. My Dd was 'outed' by her ASD support teacher who is obsessed with Trans rights. Teacher phoned me at home out of blue & used Dds 'new name & sex' / waffled on about changing register & exam titles. After a while Dd 'didn't qualify' for more support & was totally content with her bio sex again. She's just been re-referred (exam anxiety). I'm bloody dreading it starting up again.

User14March · 13/02/2024 11:24

@LadyBird1973 in my day there wasn’t so much of a shift, we were far more social as teens. We all went to the pub at Christmas at 16, etc, too & youth clubs, swimming, movies, squash, pool.

T00manymugs · 13/02/2024 11:23

The thing is you can’t force teens to do things, they need to want to do these things and so many cost £££ which families don’t have now anyway. An awful lot can of socialising now is done in their own bedroom on their phones. Teens with ASC often have solitary special interests and find social situations incredibly hard hence turning to socialising behind screens more.

TheaBrandt · 13/02/2024 11:22

Dd1 doing A levels and has entirely off her own bat downloaded an app that blocks her phone and records her revision time. Slightly breaks my heart that teens are forced to police and essentially save themselves from these addictive devices society endorses.

LadyBird1973 · 13/02/2024 11:17

@User14March I agree with this. At primary school age my dd went to loads of different activities - dance, gymnastics, rainbows/brownies. She was busy and tired at night.
But all the structured activities fall off in secondary - dd got too self conscious to go to gymnastics anymore and the way girls behave towards each other meant she felt uncomfortable doing team sports with them. Tech and online activities filled the gap.
I don't know what we as a society can do though - teenagers seem to become completely different kids to when they were little.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 13/02/2024 11:14

I'd respectfully suggest you don't quite understand the concept of mindfulness then.

I'm not the poster this was addressed to, but I had agreed with them that mindfulness in schools might not be the way forward. I do understand the concept of it, and have practised it myself. However, in my long experience of schools and the way they introduce and then ditch new initiatives and well-being ideas, it's very unlikely that mindfulness would actually be taught and used properly. It would most likely be a vague and yes, possibly navel-gazing 'Now let's all be a but more mindful of our feelings' thing.

User14March · 13/02/2024 11:06

Shouldn’t we be trying to keep teens busier, sports, clubs, etc? A ‘good’ teen is a physically tired teen. Far less room for rumination. We had youth club twice a week, Brownies, chess club, cookery, etc.

T00manymugs · 13/02/2024 11:06

EmberLight · 13/02/2024 11:04

I don't think you fully understand what mindfulness is.

I know. The utter ignorance shown by some is why we’re in this mess.

EmberLight · 13/02/2024 11:04

FancyJapflack · 13/02/2024 08:56

Just read the article. I despair. The last thing children need is being taught “mindfulness”. They need help to remove their focus from their navels, not help to increase it. It was partly this trend to gaze inward, to become obsessed with self, to be constantly monitoring how they FEEL at any given moment that can lead to children starting with the gender nonsense.

I don't think you fully understand what mindfulness is.

Naptrappedmummy · 13/02/2024 11:03

FancyJapflack · 13/02/2024 08:56

Just read the article. I despair. The last thing children need is being taught “mindfulness”. They need help to remove their focus from their navels, not help to increase it. It was partly this trend to gaze inward, to become obsessed with self, to be constantly monitoring how they FEEL at any given moment that can lead to children starting with the gender nonsense.

Yep, I agree. This obsession with introspection and feelings being king has lead to a lot of this IMO.

ani4ani · 13/02/2024 11:02

FancyJapflack · 13/02/2024 08:56

Just read the article. I despair. The last thing children need is being taught “mindfulness”. They need help to remove their focus from their navels, not help to increase it. It was partly this trend to gaze inward, to become obsessed with self, to be constantly monitoring how they FEEL at any given moment that can lead to children starting with the gender nonsense.

Stop on.

T00manymugs · 13/02/2024 11:01

BoohooWoohoo · 13/02/2024 10:42

I think that a lot of adults in authority have forgotten what it’s like to be a teenager and grow up in general.
”It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness, it was the epoch of belief, it was the epoch of incredulity, it was the season of Light, it was the season of Darkness, it was the spring of hope, it was the winter of despair.”
It’s ok that adults can not fix the uncertainties of growing up. We become stable adults because we go through the growing up experience and discover ourselves. It is often crap being a teen because of physical changes like hormones but it’s not something that can be fixed. Feeling worried or awkward is a common enough experience even amongst the NT who are fortunate to grow out of it with some life experience and age.
While I agree that smartphones amplify problems for some, it is often accompanied by naive or bad parenting too. The internet can not be scrapped or controlled as it’s international and makes money for the very rich. We can take individual responsibility to guide and filter it for our own kids to some extent but it’s not going to go anywhere. Has Esther Ghey commented on how she deals with the Internet with Brianna’s siblings? Has her approach changed in light of what happened to Brianna?

I totally disagree with you. What has happened to my children was absolutely not down to bad parenting. We’ve had so many professionals tell us that.

We are/ were very proactive parents. There were boundaries in place, tech was monitored and we were quite tech savvy at the time.

It could happen to anyone.

2dogsandabudgie · 13/02/2024 11:00

I think what children have access to on the internet is very scary. You don't even need the dark web to be able to see torture videos or other gory stuff. Even if you have parental controls on your child's phone you can guarantee that another child won't.

I remember when my child was at school 14 years ago and there was a video doing the rounds showing someone being killed, I don't think it was in the UK. I don't know if the video was fake. The problem is that when children are exposed to this sort of stuff they eventually become desensitized to it.

User14March · 13/02/2024 10:57

@CranfordScones to touch on last point, READING…Does silent reading still happen in Primary schools? We had silent reading for about an hour a day. It was an escape. A wonderful escape, we were addicted, to paper, books.

Those ‘star reader’ type quizzes to further underpin & encourage reading, still going on?

CranfordScones · 13/02/2024 10:48

These problems have always existed, and they've been amplified by phone use.

I think we need to get away from Esther Ghey. We all feel for her tragedy, but people in those circumstances are often the least able to objectively view the problem.

There is overwhemling evidence that smartphones and social media have caused an epidemic of poor attention in everyone, not just children. The tools to manage that simply won't work for young people attempting to learn this stuff, and who in many cases can't see how it's adversely affecting them. Many young people really believe they can attend to six apps/screens at once, and Big Tech loves that because it can serve them six times as many adverts.

There are other issues too: poor diet, lack of exercise and poor sleep are also to blame.

ADHD may have been underdiagnosed in the past but not to the extent that explains current levels. An ONS study found that financial problems at home led to a 50% rise in diagnosis, and a serious illness in the family increases that to 75%. Exploring those issues with well resourced professionals and looking at kids' environment would work much better than mass medication.

It's multifactorial and complex. Johann Hari's book Stolen Focus gives an excellent overview, if you have enough attention to actually read a book.

ThesmellofLulushairdo · 13/02/2024 10:46

I absolutely agree that children need to get off their phones and spend more time in reality, thinking outside of themselves and their inner worlds. However, this might be controversial but I feel like Esther Ghey is failing to join some dots here and acknowledge the elephant in the conversation, which is the impact of online grooming in convincing children that they are trans.

BoohooWoohoo · 13/02/2024 10:42

I think that a lot of adults in authority have forgotten what it’s like to be a teenager and grow up in general.
”It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness, it was the epoch of belief, it was the epoch of incredulity, it was the season of Light, it was the season of Darkness, it was the spring of hope, it was the winter of despair.”
It’s ok that adults can not fix the uncertainties of growing up. We become stable adults because we go through the growing up experience and discover ourselves. It is often crap being a teen because of physical changes like hormones but it’s not something that can be fixed. Feeling worried or awkward is a common enough experience even amongst the NT who are fortunate to grow out of it with some life experience and age.
While I agree that smartphones amplify problems for some, it is often accompanied by naive or bad parenting too. The internet can not be scrapped or controlled as it’s international and makes money for the very rich. We can take individual responsibility to guide and filter it for our own kids to some extent but it’s not going to go anywhere. Has Esther Ghey commented on how she deals with the Internet with Brianna’s siblings? Has her approach changed in light of what happened to Brianna?

Swipe left for the next trending thread