Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To agree with Esther Ghey?

113 replies

ProfessorPeppy · 13/02/2024 08:44

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2024/feb/12/i-want-to-make-things-better-esther-ghey-on-her-hopes-for-online-reform

I’m a teacher in a secondary school. I believe that the massive uptick in social problems we are experiencing in schools results from unfettered smartphone use and access to social media. School refusal, eating disorders, gender identity issues, self harm, anxiety, depression. ASD/ADHD seems to be a common underlying starting point for such vulnerabilities, but neurotypical children are also adversely affected. So many of the children I teach say things like, ‘everybody is looking at me in class, it makes me anxious’ - surely this results from a life spent on social media? Cameras on phones mean that anybody can be recorded/broadcast themselves at the click of a button, perhaps without their permission.

DS1 is 11 and about to start secondary school. He doesn’t have a phone…yet. He has an ASD/ADHD dual diagnosis and is medicated. I can clearly see that he might be vulnerable to the adverse effects of smartphone access, so I’m thinking v carefully about my next steps.

YABU: these problems have always existed for young people, and this has nothing to do with smartphones/social media.

YANBU: smartphones/social media have amplified these problems, especially for ND young people.

‘I want to make things better’: Esther Ghey on her hopes for online reform

Brianna’s mother speaks about daughter’s life and death, and what she hopes will be her legacy

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2024/feb/12/i-want-to-make-things-better-esther-ghey-on-her-hopes-for-online-reform

OP posts:
WhatNoUsername · 13/02/2024 13:50

FancyJapflack · 13/02/2024 08:56

Just read the article. I despair. The last thing children need is being taught “mindfulness”. They need help to remove their focus from their navels, not help to increase it. It was partly this trend to gaze inward, to become obsessed with self, to be constantly monitoring how they FEEL at any given moment that can lead to children starting with the gender nonsense.

Mindfulness is not navel gazing. I completely agree with you on the navel gazing but mindfulness is different and something we can all benefit from. It's the opposite of modern life and is about focussing on one thing at a time and reducing the types of thinking that is really bad for mental health.

BreatheAndFocus · 13/02/2024 13:45

I agree @Ohnoooooooo Education is crucial. Not just education about the dangers and misuse, but education about a balanced life, etc. I do think that schools could make it easier by banning smart phones and only allowing basic phones.

Ohnoooooooo · 13/02/2024 13:33

What happened to her daughter was a tragedy and I admire her finding the strength to stand up for what she believes in - but I also do not agree with her. To me education is the most important weapon. I mean lots of things are illegal for teens - drinking, drugs, under age sex….does that stop them? Education is not going to solve everything but I think kids need to be taught what is in and what is not ok - and what to do or who to speak to for the not ok things.
I have been lucky in that I have older teens who I did let use WhatsApp when they were preteen because they were young enough they were happy to confide in me if issues arose. They don’t post on social media now. Their choice. I think they learnt too many negative outcomes.

ElBandito · 13/02/2024 13:29

I agree to some extent regarding phones. I do not agree with mindfulness taught in schools. Recent studies have shown it doesn't actually help teenagers when taught in schools (although it doesn't generally make their mental health worse either). Although the NHS link above says some people find it does make them feel worse.
To do it properly you need to be quite focused and analytical, these are not traits I would identify many teenagers as having in great abundance.

CarlaH · 13/02/2024 13:07

Thanks.

CarlaH · 13/02/2024 13:01

Can somebody please tell me what mindfulness is?

Magicpaintbrush · 13/02/2024 12:57

I 1000% agree OP - I have been saying this for years. Constant internet/screen access has ruined a generation of young minds. It ought to have been over 16s only from the very beginning, but it's out there now.

I don't think there's a lot to be done for the current generation of phone addicted kids - I think that if you removed their phones now a lot of them would self harm, melt down etc

HOWEVER, that doesn't mean we can't put a stopper in this shit show for the generation coming up behind them, the younger primary school aged kids we have now. They need to be phased out for kids. Put a ban on phones with internet access for kids under 10/11 and then gradually increase that age year on year, until it hits 16. So then you aren't confiscating smartphones for current teens but you are preventing the next generation from having them in the first place. Of course you will get some families who ignore and just give their kids smart phones anyway, but maybe with a threat of prosecution they would be in a minority and the overall amount of smartphone access to kids could be hugely reduced. Some families will always flout sensible stuff like that, but a lot wouldn't and it would make a massive difference. I think a lot of families would be happy to have this worry taken out of their lives - and brick phones might be cheaper and more affordable which might add to their appeal. Cheaper and safer.

FrontalHeadache · 13/02/2024 12:48

My kids have just left school but have had regular mindfulness at school from an early age. They and their friends absolutely hated it and found it a complete waste of time. I do not believe this stuff is actually helping children.

GoodlifeGlow · 13/02/2024 12:39

I have a 6 year old, before she hits 11 I would love to see social media access being for age 16 plus. It’s full of adult content and is as detrimental to their growing brains as smoking and alcohol are to their bodies. I can see value in a phone at age 11 for calls, texts but literally the basics.

It’s the government who needs to step up and say enough is enough, the time and money wasted in schools on problems arising from social media should be enough. Inevitably feckless parents will demand their kid needs access to Facebook, tik tok etc so they can contact x,y,z etc but we managed to have everything we took for granted shaken up in the pandemic when going out was essentially illegal so why can’t the government rip off this plaster and deal with the danger to our kids of social media?

DownWithBigBrother · 13/02/2024 12:34

I partly agree with her; but I do not think there is one cause. Part of the underlying problem is also parents who want to be their child's friend instead of their parent, and go along with everything they want to do.
Its not a new problem;

A hobo befriends a child and leads him astray. Who is to blame?
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0512535/characters/nm0341431

"The Andy Griffith Show" Opie's Hobo Friend (TV Episode 1961) - IMDb

"The Andy Griffith Show" Opie's Hobo Friend (TV Episode 1961) Andy Griffith as Andy Taylor

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0512535/characters/nm0341431

beAsensible1 · 13/02/2024 12:32

you can sync your child’s phone to your so you can monitor messages and phone calls. Block non age appropriate apps on their phones.

you can get phone contracts that don’t include social media apps as part of their package. Limit the internet access on their
phone.

safety and wellbeing of young kids on the internet is paramount, take a multi prong approach. So what if everyone else is doing it.
if your child is sneaking burner phones, find it and confiscate it. Tech and media companies are not concerned with children’s safety and they financially benefit from the opposite.

lots of things are not that easy, but why give up before even trying

theresapossuminthekitchen · 13/02/2024 12:26

user1497207191 · 13/02/2024 10:23

So true. Schools and teachers have put homework, homework apps, worksheets, homework planners, etc., on the internet, so pupils need access to the internet these days! Certainly they did at my son's school. They were also encouraged to get out their phones to take pictures of the white board, and take videos of science experiments, etc. Add into that apps for bus/train season tickets, an app to pay for school lunches, etc. I just don't see how secondary school children can operate without a smartphone!

At the school I work in, phones are banned. We do use the internet apps for homework but they are all accessible from an iPad or laptop, which is what they’re required to have for use in class. Timetables are emailed, but it’s hardly rocket science to have it printed or written out on paper. They can even print it out at school themselves. School lunches are paid for using an ID card which they are issued.

Schools that are making kids use phones all the time need to look at this very carefully, because it’s not necessary. Transport companies using apps will also need to rethink, in my opinion, and recognise that essentially requiring young teens to have a phone is not right.

bitofafix · 13/02/2024 12:20

Hereyoume · 13/02/2024 09:33

If smartphones didn't exist, and I appeared on Dragons Den with my "revolutionary" new invention, and I explained all about Apps and the idea of Social Media; and explained how everyone would have a Hi-Def camera in their pocket and that they could go around filming anyone and anything and put those images up on the Internet or livestream, very serious questions would be asked by the Dragons.

They would ask about child safety and content access. They would want to know about privacy and how it could lead to people being harrassed and bullied. They would definitely want to discuss
Data protection issues, and licencing and age restrictions, Peter Jones would quip:

"I could make one phone call to my guy's in China and by tomorrow I could have a piece of software that would get me inside that thing, it's not secure, it will cause huge safety issues for children, sorry I'm not investing. I'm out"

We have been "boiled like frogs" into accepting the most corrosive and damaging piece of technology into our everyday lives.

Great post! Brilliant summary!

And the worst thing is young people are just handing over the most rich and in-depth data to China everyday by using TikTok, to the extent that China knows precisely what makes Western populations fearful, buy more, engage, become angry, reject democracy, mistrust institutions and so on, and will be able to create something to perfectly manipulate whole populations very shortly.

Anewuser · 13/02/2024 12:15

I work with year 6 children. Every single morning, they come into school with their phones showing screen shots of their ‘friends’ being horrible to them the previous evening. Parents do not supervise or monitor their phones.

There’s not a lot we can do. Obviously we sympathise but remind them that whatever they put on social media is for all to see and do with as they feel fit.

Something has to change and I think Esther Ghey has a point.

T00manymugs · 13/02/2024 12:13

What are you checking on SM? They have multiple accounts, burner phones, can delete, hide, exchange ways to be one step ahead of parents and live streaming sites are just as dangerous if not more. Do you know all the dangerous sites, games , apps etc. they change continuously. They need smart phones for all sorts of things.

It isn’t that easy.

Milkandnosugarplease · 13/02/2024 12:09

Are parents willing to ban their children from having smartphones? Or willing to go through their child’s phone to check SM accounts?

beAsensible1 · 13/02/2024 12:06

Some parents need to stop giving into peer pressure don’t let your child get the app, don’t get them a smart phone. Learn how they work and monitor your children’s usage.

Make the effort, protect your kids, this includes the computer etc. media in all forms.

the girl who killed Brianna was watching snuff and torture rooms from the age of 13 in the same house as her parents.

Barney60 · 13/02/2024 12:05

Mainstream schools need to get out from under the yoke of Ofsted and league tables, and remember they’re teaching young individuals.

Parents need to put their own phones down and engage with their children.

Companies need to stop enslaving their workers so that they can be around more for their families while they’re at home.

Social media companies need to take some responsibility, and governments need to step up and regulate what young people have access to online.

Technology was meant to set us free, but it’s done the direct opposite.

This.

Locutus2000 · 13/02/2024 12:05

I don't understand why more people don't bother with parental controls. It really isn't that difficult and an easy way of at least restricting open access to the internet. They can even be set up at network level so all internet traffic i your home is affected.

Yes some savvy kids may work out ways to bypass, and there isn't much you can do about their access elsewhere but it's a good start and should be part of basic parental responsibility. It worries me that so many seem to be oblivious to it.

How to keep your child safe on their smartphone

Keeping kids safe from the harmful side of the internet is a big task. Doubly so in a world where smartphones offer unmonitored access to everything from graphic adult content to gambling sites.

https://www.uswitch.com/mobiles/guides/mobile-phone-safety/

APickUpFullOfPinkCarnations · 13/02/2024 12:05

GoodOldEmmaNess · 13/02/2024 11:31

It was a very humane article. Just awful to read of all the various pressures that her child experienced online, and then to think about the online influences that may have shaped the minds and behaviours of the children who murdered her. What a horrible mess we are in.

I agree. I had no idea about Brianna's background and how troubled she was. I'd only seen headlines before and not read the articles, now I completely understand where she is coming from. A therapist told me 20 years ago that the world is evolving faster than the evolution of our brains and I think about that a lot. It explains why everyone is so stressed, anxious, angry.

Srgchh · 13/02/2024 12:04

LunaNorth · 13/02/2024 09:12

The NHS trialled a mindfulness in schools programme a couple of years ago. I think it was the NHS, anyway.

It was dropped. The kids hated it and found it boring.

I work with teenagers in Alternative Provision. Some of the young people we work with actually have ‘do not take away X’s phone as this triggers anxiety’ or ‘allow X to check their phone every ten minutes’ in their EHCP.

Funnily enough, after a few weeks with us, we often find the phone addiction fading away - at least when they’re on site. One-to-one attention, care, understanding, activities like playing a simple board game, or just having a cup of tea and a chat or taking one of the school dogs for a walk fulfils the need for connection that the phone is an easy route to.

Mainstream schools need to get out from under the yoke of Ofsted and league tables, and remember they’re teaching young individuals.

Parents need to put their own phones down and engage with their children.

Companies need to stop enslaving their workers so that they can be around more for their families while they’re at home.

Social media companies need to take some responsibility, and governments need to step up and regulate what young people have access to online.

Technology was meant to set us free, but it’s done the direct opposite.

All of this

T00manymugs · 13/02/2024 11:57

User14March · 13/02/2024 11:48

@TOOmanymugs yes autism/ADHD make today’s environment very challenging but depending on your locale & personal situation also pretty hard to navigate pre tech. We were encouraged to ‘just get on with it’ with support.

I know that’s over simplifying but leaving an ADD teen etc to ruminate for hours and hovering outside their room on eggshells not the way. Generally our curtains were opened & we had to be up & out.

No we didn’t. I wasn’t. I was allowed to indulge my special interests which didn’t involve tech and were far more mindful. I didn’t have hoards of friends just one or two and didn’t live in a city. Rarely saw friends outside of teenage years and like many had landline usage limited. Bar Guides which I hated there was nothing to do. I found school incredibly hard and masked hugely. It had a massive impact on my life. Expecting autistic teens to just get on with it is not the way to go and doing sfa about what all teens are having to contend with now isn’t the way to go either. Unless that is you want more and more of a drain on services and the nhs.

Mamaraisedadoughut · 13/02/2024 11:55

I think the problems were brought to us by media, I think that to an extent 90s children had many of the same issues, however the Internet has exacerbated so many of the issues our teens are struggling with.

I would like to see many parents actually parent their teens though.
Unfettered access to social media, and not ever having their phones checked seems like an incredibly bad idea. I started to give DD a little more freedom with her phone when she reached 14, that freedom didn't last long because like many of her peers, she couldn't use the Internet responsibly or safely without guidance.

I wish that a lot of parents also ensured their kids weren't stuck to their phones all the time too, because social media is inescapable for many, and many of those children are being bullied on it.