Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To agree with Esther Ghey?

113 replies

ProfessorPeppy · 13/02/2024 08:44

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2024/feb/12/i-want-to-make-things-better-esther-ghey-on-her-hopes-for-online-reform

I’m a teacher in a secondary school. I believe that the massive uptick in social problems we are experiencing in schools results from unfettered smartphone use and access to social media. School refusal, eating disorders, gender identity issues, self harm, anxiety, depression. ASD/ADHD seems to be a common underlying starting point for such vulnerabilities, but neurotypical children are also adversely affected. So many of the children I teach say things like, ‘everybody is looking at me in class, it makes me anxious’ - surely this results from a life spent on social media? Cameras on phones mean that anybody can be recorded/broadcast themselves at the click of a button, perhaps without their permission.

DS1 is 11 and about to start secondary school. He doesn’t have a phone…yet. He has an ASD/ADHD dual diagnosis and is medicated. I can clearly see that he might be vulnerable to the adverse effects of smartphone access, so I’m thinking v carefully about my next steps.

YABU: these problems have always existed for young people, and this has nothing to do with smartphones/social media.

YANBU: smartphones/social media have amplified these problems, especially for ND young people.

‘I want to make things better’: Esther Ghey on her hopes for online reform

Brianna’s mother speaks about daughter’s life and death, and what she hopes will be her legacy

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2024/feb/12/i-want-to-make-things-better-esther-ghey-on-her-hopes-for-online-reform

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
directemark · 15/02/2024 09:12

I fully support her, but given that many users on this platform are likely women, they understand that girls can often be quite harsh towards one another. This kind of situation will persist until individuals recognize the importance of taking breaks from social media, internet companies eliminate content that promotes harm, and we all respond proactively to aggressive behavior online. Relying solely on legal measures won't solve the problem; it merely drives hateful content into the dark web or onto another new platform.

girlfriend44 · 13/02/2024 21:28

BoohooWoohoo · 13/02/2024 10:42

I think that a lot of adults in authority have forgotten what it’s like to be a teenager and grow up in general.
”It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness, it was the epoch of belief, it was the epoch of incredulity, it was the season of Light, it was the season of Darkness, it was the spring of hope, it was the winter of despair.”
It’s ok that adults can not fix the uncertainties of growing up. We become stable adults because we go through the growing up experience and discover ourselves. It is often crap being a teen because of physical changes like hormones but it’s not something that can be fixed. Feeling worried or awkward is a common enough experience even amongst the NT who are fortunate to grow out of it with some life experience and age.
While I agree that smartphones amplify problems for some, it is often accompanied by naive or bad parenting too. The internet can not be scrapped or controlled as it’s international and makes money for the very rich. We can take individual responsibility to guide and filter it for our own kids to some extent but it’s not going to go anywhere. Has Esther Ghey commented on how she deals with the Internet with Brianna’s siblings? Has her approach changed in light of what happened to Brianna?

One older daughter.

T00manymugs · 13/02/2024 18:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What on earth does this have to do with what her mother is speaking about in the media? This ain’t the thread to start yet another trans debate discussion. It’s really not. Can you not have a bit of empathy.

NoMoreFalafelsForYou · 13/02/2024 18:04

So it’s getting out and doing stuff?

Well.... yes.
Learning to be present in the moment, which no screens and getting out into the fresh air and say going for a nature walk and "taking in" your surroundings would come under.

FancyJapflack · 13/02/2024 18:02

NoMoreFalafelsForYou · 13/02/2024 17:58

Still sounds like a form of overthinking to me
Confused 🤣🤣
It's literally the opposite lol

So it’s getting out and doing stuff?

NoMoreFalafelsForYou · 13/02/2024 17:58

Still sounds like a form of overthinking to me
Confused 🤣🤣
It's literally the opposite lol

FancyJapflack · 13/02/2024 17:52

NoMoreFalafelsForYou · 13/02/2024 17:48

@AllProperTeaIsTheft

Just read the article. I despair. The last thing children need is being taught “mindfulness”. They need help to remove their focus from their navels, not help to increase it. It was partly this trend to gaze inward, to become obsessed with self, to be constantly monitoring how they FEEL at any given moment that can lead to children starting with the gender nonsense.

Secondary sschool teacher here and I totally agree
Do either of you actually even know what mindfulness is?!
It's nothing to do with "navel gazing" 🙄
It's a form of clearing and calming the mind, pulling your mind to the present instead of sat ruminating or overthinking - it's a great tool for anxiety and something kids would definitely benefit from, adults too!

Still sounds like a form of overthinking to me.

girlfriend44 · 13/02/2024 17:48

Teens and kids just need a payg that does the basic texts and calling.

That's how it all started and should have remained.
Sounds like Brianna Gheys killer had access to all sorts sitting in her room and her parents took their eye of the ball.
Bet she had the latest phone bought by them.
Just a text and a call phone is enough.

NoMoreFalafelsForYou · 13/02/2024 17:48

@AllProperTeaIsTheft

Just read the article. I despair. The last thing children need is being taught “mindfulness”. They need help to remove their focus from their navels, not help to increase it. It was partly this trend to gaze inward, to become obsessed with self, to be constantly monitoring how they FEEL at any given moment that can lead to children starting with the gender nonsense.

Secondary sschool teacher here and I totally agree
Do either of you actually even know what mindfulness is?!
It's nothing to do with "navel gazing" 🙄
It's a form of clearing and calming the mind, pulling your mind to the present instead of sat ruminating or overthinking - it's a great tool for anxiety and something kids would definitely benefit from, adults too!

BoohooWoohoo · 13/02/2024 17:46

Do children in areas with middle schools get smartphones later? My guess is that many kids get a phone at 11 because of secondary school transition and if middle schools were the norm then first smart phones could wait a couple more years. I realise that some kids at middle school could need a smartphone for their bus pass but I don’t know is they are a minority of kids.

FancyJapflack · 13/02/2024 17:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MILTOBE · 13/02/2024 17:37

I really doubt her mother encouraged her to be trans. Why would she do that?

FancyJapflack · 13/02/2024 17:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MrsGlennBulb · 13/02/2024 17:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I was beginning to think I was the only one with this opinion.

That poor kid.

Naptrappedmummy · 13/02/2024 17:00

There are too many children with issues now to provide the gold standard of care for them. It’s about just patching things up as best we can now. It’s really depressing and I’m seriously worried about our workforce in 20 years - it seems half of it will be absent due to MH crisis or finding the workplace too triggering or a sensory overload. Things aren’t looking good at all.

PocketSand · 13/02/2024 16:57

The issues of the victim and the perpetrators are linked by late diagnosis of ND and the complete absence of support in early years. Brianna should have been diagnosed before it became a crisis. Including what led up to her being in an inclusive unit where she met her murderer.

The LA wanted to place my extremely vulnerable ASD son in a PRU because he was too anxious to attend mainstream. Over my dead body. PRUs/inclusion units place together the most vulnerable with the most likely to exploit vulnerability.

The boy should have received support before becoming selectively mute and his doing sudoku at trial was used against him. Perhaps then his vulnerability and behaviour would be better understood.

Yes, most DC seem to cope at primary so wait and see seems reasonable. Then secondary school and teenage years hit and what do you see?

Vulnerability to eating disorders, self harm, gender identity issues, reliance on social media when real life interaction seems impossible, fear driven obsessions with weapons and violence and breaking the norm because you don't feel safe. Kill or be killed.

This is what can happen when support is denied or delayed because the child seems fine in mainstream. I'm surprised it doesn't happen more often.

But if we imagine the problem is gender identity or social media influence then perhaps it will.

Combattingthemoaners · 13/02/2024 16:44

Also a secondary school teacher. I agree with you fully. It’s very worrying and only going to get worse, I’m afraid.

LaPalmaLlama · 13/02/2024 15:02

I think smartphones are problematic at society level, but I also think it’s more complicated than just “smartphones bad”. I would definitely support schools being phone free- my dc will be at schools with this policy all the way to end of year 11 and I think it really works in terms of their social skills, mental health, activity levels and engagement with non screen activities like music or art club etc. I also discourage them from taking phones out and about if they don’t need them, like if I’m just driving them to rugby practice, they don’t need to be scrolling on the journey. There is a middle ground between “no phone” and “full and unfettered access to the dark web and tiktok trash” but it requires active parenting and sometimes having to be the bad guy. No phones in bedrooms overnight is my hill to die on and the dc know if I catch them the phone is confiscated for a week, no exceptions. I also don’t allow days where they are just on screens ( and especially phones) all day.

I also think peer group has a massive impact on use of phones- ds is 13 so I do allow social media but tbh he’s not that interested in it, possibly because his friends aren’t really either. They all play a lot of sport or are big into music ( youth orchestras/ bands etc) and I think having “real life interests” definitely combats the impact of excessive SM, both because less time to scroll, but also more time spent with RL people and broader RL experiences and networks which is good for mental health and confidence/ resilience etc . I know some MNers worry about peer influence but I have to say my dc’s friends are a positive influence if anything.

re mindfulness, yeah, I mean I do it sometimes but I’m not sure it’s helpful on a mass basis.

T00manymugs · 13/02/2024 14:55

For goodness sake the judgement because a murdered child was trans. Just stop. She was murdered and her mother is trying to make things better for future teens. Stop trying to make this into yet another MN trans witch hunt.

MissRheingold · 13/02/2024 14:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

WhatNoUsername · 13/02/2024 14:35

Namechangenamechange321 · 13/02/2024 12:56

I’ve recently come across this organisation
https://delaysmartphones.org.uk/about/#:~:text=Our%20aim%20is%20to%20protect,their%20mental%20health%20is%20today.
some people on this thread might be interested

What a brilliant initiative.

Phones have been banned in a few schools. I think this needs to be rolled out countrywide. Gives children an all day break including at break and lunchtime encouraging them to be present and also means other children aren't worried about being recorded or photographed.

Bookist · 13/02/2024 14:23

Parents need to be there for their children - but in a way that teaches their children how to face up to what life throws at them with resilience. Encourage them not to be afraid of the world. Life is frequently unfair. People aren't always 'kind'. Be your child's advocate but not in a way that suffocates them and infantilizes them.

Parents need to start being their child's safety net. And stop being their child's straight jacket.

CranfordScones · 13/02/2024 14:11

User14March · 13/02/2024 10:57

@CranfordScones to touch on last point, READING…Does silent reading still happen in Primary schools? We had silent reading for about an hour a day. It was an escape. A wonderful escape, we were addicted, to paper, books.

Those ‘star reader’ type quizzes to further underpin & encourage reading, still going on?

Absolutely this. Reading is a crucial influence on the ability to focus.

Last figures I saw, the average American spent 17 minutes a day reading books and 5.4 hours on their phone. The proportion of Americans who never read a book in any year has more than tripled since the 1970s.

Lots of evidence exists that kids reading from books are more focused than when reading from screens - the difference is almost a full year's development in reading comprehension.

WhatNoUsername · 13/02/2024 13:56

I completely agree OP. Mobile phone use and social media is ruining the world!

"Cameras on phones mean that anybody can be recorded/broadcast themselves at the click of a button, perhaps without their permission."

I was thinking this the other day. It must be so hard growing up at a time when anything you do or say could be recorded and published on the internet. The pressure of that must be awful as a teen.

Bookist · 13/02/2024 13:52

Too many parents wanting to be their child's best friend, rather than, you know, an actual grown up parent.

Too many parents too weak willed and inept to set firm but fair boundaries and stick to them.

Too many parents giving far too much serious credence to every passing whim and whimsy expressed by their child.

Too many parents wrapping up their children in cotton wool and effectively hamstringing them in the process.

Too many parents desperate for their children to like them rather than respect them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread