Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not pick up dog poo...

757 replies

Moonfishstar · 13/02/2024 05:54

... when in a quiet forest, but to flick it with a stick into dense undergrowth instead?

I don't see any issue with this, but I've got a feeling lots will disagree with me, so I wanted to get some other opinions.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
29
Elber · 14/02/2024 18:26

“It’s a bit gross, but poo also attracts foxes that eat it and they can then turn their attention to the eggs and chicks of the ground and low nesting birds like nightjars and Dartford warblers. “

Elber · 14/02/2024 18:25

@MontyDonsBlueScarf

But that’s an awful attitude! You KNOW the damage it can cause to wildlife, you KNOW Forestry England now don’t support stick and flick, yet you still do it because of a misinformed employee.

“Wardens at the forest say leaving dog’s faeces can kill endangered birds, affect rare heathland and cause livestock to abort their young.”

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 14/02/2024 18:18

@Elber I can only suggest you take this up with Forestry England since it was one of their employees who gave the advice that I posted on here.

@Theminer the forest is not a nature reserve. They are entirely different. My guess is that what is harmful in a smaller nature reserve may be less harmful in the very much bigger open forest, probably because it's nothing like so concentrated. But in any event research on nature reserves is not automatically applicable to forests.

Elber · 14/02/2024 17:49

@MontyDonsBlueScarf

What about the damage to the natural ecosystem though? The introduction of unwanted pathogens and bacteria? That also leaches into water systems and kills wildlife? The fact that a significant percent of fox’s diet is now dog poo?

Theminer · 14/02/2024 17:37

goodkidsmaadhouse · 14/02/2024 17:35

@oOmoonhaOo
@MontyDonsBlueScarf
Fair enough if the FC have signposted not to go in but I would absolutely let my kids play in areas that have been storm damaged - given the storms we now get annually it’s a bit hard to avoid storm damage when your kids are outside daily in the forests year round.. We all know to risk assess hanging branches, fallen trees etc. Touch wood never had any injuries beyond scrapes in a decade of parenting this way.

Same here. Never so much as a sprained toe.

Risk taking ‘playgrounds’ are a thing for a reason.

goodkidsmaadhouse · 14/02/2024 17:35

@oOmoonhaOo
@MontyDonsBlueScarf
Fair enough if the FC have signposted not to go in but I would absolutely let my kids play in areas that have been storm damaged - given the storms we now get annually it’s a bit hard to avoid storm damage when your kids are outside daily in the forests year round.. We all know to risk assess hanging branches, fallen trees etc. Touch wood never had any injuries beyond scrapes in a decade of parenting this way.

surreygirl1987 · 14/02/2024 17:28

Theminer · 14/02/2024 16:53

That’s just a picture of some trees?

😆

surreygirl1987 · 14/02/2024 17:27

Theminer · 14/02/2024 17:26

Looks like a totally normal place to be walking.

Im finding it quite amusing how many posters think that going for a walk in a forest is an activity unique to them that nobody else could possibly understand.

I thought the same thing 😆

Theminer · 14/02/2024 17:26

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 14/02/2024 16:59

It's a picture of the sort of area where I walk my dogs. It's exactly what the forest I've been talking about is like. I posted it to show the impossibility of picking up absolutely everywhere and the likelihood of anyone else stepping in it.

Looks like a totally normal place to be walking.

Im finding it quite amusing how many posters think that going for a walk in a forest is an activity unique to them that nobody else could possibly understand.

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 14/02/2024 16:59

It's a picture of the sort of area where I walk my dogs. It's exactly what the forest I've been talking about is like. I posted it to show the impossibility of picking up absolutely everywhere and the likelihood of anyone else stepping in it.

Theminer · 14/02/2024 16:53

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 14/02/2024 16:52

Because in all the years I've been walking in the forest I have never seen anyone even attempting to walk in some of the areas over which my dogs run free. Maybe this picture will help explain.

That’s just a picture of some trees?

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 14/02/2024 16:52

MyOtherCarIsAPorsche · 14/02/2024 13:50

@MontyDonsBlueScarf

If they 'go' (great name for shite by the way) in your garden, you need to train them to do this before 'walkies!' (Like my mother managed to do serval times a day.) And NOT five minutes after you start your walk. Or are you so busy and important you don't ever have five minutes spare?

Dogs should not be toileted in public places. It's disgusting. (Full stop)

How on earth do you know that absolutely no one steps in your dog's waste?

Because in all the years I've been walking in the forest I have never seen anyone even attempting to walk in some of the areas over which my dogs run free. Maybe this picture will help explain.

To not pick up dog poo...
Theminer · 14/02/2024 16:51

oOmoonhaOo · 14/02/2024 16:26

Please give an example of a non plastic bag that is suitable to take in the mountains and not get damaged in the way down?

There’s loads- google it. Many different shapes and sizes, made from plant based materials, or recycled paper etc.

You are allowed to carry all manner of bags in the mountains… spoil yourself and try a few different types!

oOmoonhaOo · 14/02/2024 16:32

MyOtherCarIsAPorsche · 14/02/2024 13:50

@MontyDonsBlueScarf

If they 'go' (great name for shite by the way) in your garden, you need to train them to do this before 'walkies!' (Like my mother managed to do serval times a day.) And NOT five minutes after you start your walk. Or are you so busy and important you don't ever have five minutes spare?

Dogs should not be toileted in public places. It's disgusting. (Full stop)

How on earth do you know that absolutely no one steps in your dog's waste?

What happens when I’m wild camping Abe wake up on the side of a mountain with my dog?

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 14/02/2024 16:30

@goodkidsmaadhouse I don't think it's that the whole forest is inherently dangerous, but there are certainly areas where you wouldn't want kids to be playing unsupervised, particularly after the weather we've had lately, as @oOmoonhaOo says. Lots of partially uprooted trees, loose branches, unstable fallen trees. Many areas that are normally OK at this time of year are full of horrible viscous mud. It's fine for kids to play but you need to be mindful of where and what the current conditions are - a bit like skiing, you wouldn't let your kids ski anywhere they fancied in the mountains without supervision but you'd probably let them loose on the blue/red runs as long as the weather was OK.

oOmoonhaOo · 14/02/2024 16:26

Marchitectmummy · 14/02/2024 08:08

What makes you think plastic is the only option for poo bags?

I realise it suits your narrative but there are so many biodegradable options, and have been for years.

Please give an example of a non plastic bag that is suitable to take in the mountains and not get damaged in the way down?

oOmoonhaOo · 14/02/2024 16:16

goodkidsmaadhouse · 13/02/2024 20:42

Slightly off topic but why is it dangerous for kids to play in there? My kids play in that sort of forest all the time. They climb, they scramble, they crawl…

There’s been quite alot of storm debris recently. Plus sharp, loose branches, widow makers and deep holes. Ankle breaking and eye losing territory…. The forestry commission don’t want you in there either.

Theminer · 14/02/2024 15:42

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 14/02/2024 10:36

Both my dogs have recalled from running deer, I think that counts as control though I do admit I can't control their bowels!

I have already confirmed with a forest ranger (during the aforementioned chat about dog poo and foxes) that it is perfectly fine to walk two dogs off the lead, let them run where they choose as long as they recall when asked, and pick up poo where it's close to or accessible from the car parks or the paths. A single small poo in the open forest is fine to leave, especially as tramping out to search for it is likely to damage the environment more than leaving it. I can't give you a source to check for this as it was just a conversation, but it's guidance from someone whose job it is to manage the forest and educate the public about it, which is why I'm trying to share it.

I can only assume that as pp have said, many people on here don't have much experience of proper forest as opposed to simply rural. That's the only explanation I can think of for the disgust and contempt people seem to have at the thought of a single dog poo left in the middle of a huge inaccessible area that already has horse, cow, pig, rabbit and deer poo, and no doubt a lot more that I don't know about.

The forest is open to everyone to enjoy but it's important that everyone understands that it's not a free for all car park, country park, unsupervised play area or petting zoo, it has different conservation needs, and what's appropriate in the other environments may not be appropriate here. Otherwise it's going to get destroyed.

and pick up poo where it's close to or accessible from the car parks or the paths.

Which you have already confirmed you don’t always do because you let your dogs walk behind you so you don’t notice them/can’t see them shitting.

Horse, cow, pig, rabbit and deer poo

Non of which are comparable to dog poo, either in composition or effect on the environment. It’s been explained many times on this thread, and links have been provided to show how damaging decaying dog poo is to wildlife and flora and fauna.

a forest ranger

It’s been explained, and many links to the relevant policies have been posted, that flicking dog shit about is NOT the corse of action the requisite authorities prefer, for the aforementioned reasons.

it's not a free for all car park, country park, unsupervised play area or petting zoo,

It also isn’t a dog toilet.

it has different conservation needs

Yes, which don’t include rotting dog shit. Let your dogs spread faeces over your lawn, leave it to rot, then observe the effect on the grass. Or do some research.

You can dress it up however you like- there is no reason for not picking up your dog poo other than “I can’t be arsed”.

Elber · 14/02/2024 14:16

@MontyDonsBlueScarf

The problem is though - if it’s fine for you to do it, it’s fine for all dogs to do their ‘one poo’. You have to apply the same mindset to all dog owners.

As I’ve said before:

Dog poo is very high in nutrients in a typically low nutrient ecosystem. It disturbs the balance.

It leaches into streams and rivers.

There are bacteria and pathogens in dog poo that exist even after the poo has broken down. These can cause cows to abort, the horse issue that a poster had to pay a huge bill for posted earlier, leach into rivers and kill wildlife.

A large percentage of fox diet is now dog poo, which again in unnatural and passes on the unwanted bacteria/pathogens.

A bag and binned dog poo can - at least - be controlled and put in a waste area : and not a natural ecosystem Where it disturbs the balance.

Forestry England no longer support the stick and flick method.

Mischance · 14/02/2024 13:59

There used to be someone down our open-plan-gardened cul-de-sac who used to walk her dog up to our lawn on the corner and have it shit on our grass - every bloody day.

Someone suggested I should pick it up, put it in a paper bag, place the bag on her doorstep, light it with a match, ring the doorbell and bugger off; so that she would come out, see the fire and stamp it out. I never quite had the courage to do this ......

Mischance · 14/02/2024 13:56

When I was a child there was none of this "bag it" culture. Dog poo used to be flicked into the gutter or under a hedge to rot. It was not great - we children used to regularly arrive home with dog poo on our shoes.

It is clearly a better option to bag and bin it, wherever you are, although in a wood there will of course be lots of other poo for children to hone in on like magnets: badger, deer, rabbits etc., although their poo tends to be less grim than the meat-fest superglue-like faeces produced by dogs. Hence I do not have a dog.

MyOtherCarIsAPorsche · 14/02/2024 13:50

@MontyDonsBlueScarf

If they 'go' (great name for shite by the way) in your garden, you need to train them to do this before 'walkies!' (Like my mother managed to do serval times a day.) And NOT five minutes after you start your walk. Or are you so busy and important you don't ever have five minutes spare?

Dogs should not be toileted in public places. It's disgusting. (Full stop)

How on earth do you know that absolutely no one steps in your dog's waste?

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 14/02/2024 13:35

@MyOtherCarIsAPorsche you are wrong. They go in my garden. They usually go within 100 m of the car park or within the first 5 minutes of the walk, in which case I pick up. I can't control whether they need to go again another half hour into the walk, or where they may be when that happens. If it's where I or anyone else can get to it, I pick up. If it happens 500 m from the path in the middle of nowhere there is zero chance that anyone else is going to go anywhere near it.

I'm sorry if you've had to clean up after getting mess on your shoes but I very much doubt that that's happened in the sort of areas I'm talking about.

herewegoagainy · 14/02/2024 13:32

A camera on a tree branch could also take images of children. I would be wary of doing this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread