Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not pick up dog poo...

757 replies

Moonfishstar · 13/02/2024 05:54

... when in a quiet forest, but to flick it with a stick into dense undergrowth instead?

I don't see any issue with this, but I've got a feeling lots will disagree with me, so I wanted to get some other opinions.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
29
Justpontificating · 14/02/2024 23:20

Donoteven · 14/02/2024 23:06

It is remote. I live in rural Ireland.

If you’re walking off path though you’ll still be affected by wild animals poo on your shoes.
One animals poo on your shoes is no different from another’s.
whether you’re a poo flicker or picker it’s all still poo

Prunesqualler · 14/02/2024 23:15

Kendodd · 14/02/2024 23:05

And I'm completely open to taking that risk on board and changing my behaviour. I've asked repeatedly if anyone knows of any serious academic research into this. There are benefits of 'stick and flick ' in rural locations, and harms. I would really like to know where the balance on this lies, if anyone knows?

Well we own woodlands. Our foresters and consultant wildlife conservationists prefer what they consider the lesser of two evils with flicking and so this is our accepted policy

We however offer limited access, there’s no car park or anything and just locals so we are not talking about lots of people walking through. Everyone has to keep to raised paths as well to keep off the vegetation, roots and ground nesting animals. etc. So there’s no making dens or running around throwing leaves in the air.

It’s a peaceful walk in the woods.

Theminer · 14/02/2024 23:07

Prunesqualler · 14/02/2024 22:53

Not talking about going over the speed limit in either.
Talking about going faster down country lanes.
As…The speed limit on country lanes is not as low as for built up areas.
Theres a reason for that and it’s based on risk.

Hence my example above re dangers of driving on country lanes using town speed limits.
This was the previous discussion between yourself and OOO

Actually, driving to the speed limit is one of the things that makes rural driving so dangerous- the speed limits and the road conditions rarely align. That’s why you can be charged for driving too fast for the road even if you are under the limit. pootling along at 10mph unnecessarily also isn’t a good idea (although anyone on a country road should be driving with the awareness that there could be a tractor/sheep etc in the middle of the road round the next corner.

@oOmoonhaOo

I’m more likely to kill myself on a country lane than hit another person, compared to if I was doing 40 in a town.

This is a bit of a non argument really, because in built up urban areas you don’t really get the opportunity to get much over the speed limit due of traffic. If you did drive at 40 round the traffic on the pavement then obviously you would be more likely to hit someone than you would on a country road (although its more dangerous to be a pedestrian or cyclist on a country road) but as the stats show this isn’t the reality of driving behaviour in the uk.

Donoteven · 14/02/2024 23:06

oOmoonhaOo · 14/02/2024 23:01

This isn’t e remote situation though. In the area you describe I would pick it up

It is remote. I live in rural Ireland.

Prunesqualler · 14/02/2024 23:05

Emily1583 · 14/02/2024 22:57

Of course there are different speed limits but going over that said speed limit be it country lane is the same as going over the speed limit in a built up area.

I was making a different point about highways acknowledging the lower risk in country lanes
Going over the speed limit is never ok
However just as highways acknowledge the lesser risk in country lanes by allowing a higher speed limit it’s obvious there would be a lesser risk by doing so in the country than in towns….quite obviously.

SabrinaThwaite · 14/02/2024 23:05

Besides the pure risk factor, dog shit in urban areas or places where people might step in it (even if health risks were zero) is just unpleasant and an annoyance we don't need.

Dog shit in rural areas is also unpleasant and annoying.

Like the guy who walked the Serpent Trail and picked up 40kg of dog shit over 4 days. That’s a rural long distance path and I doubt he went off piste to deliberately collect more dog shit.

It’s human nature to get lazy about picking up after their dog - if it’s perceived as OK to do that in a heavily wooded area, then that often drifts to being OK to do that in other areas too.

Kendodd · 14/02/2024 23:05

Theminer · 14/02/2024 22:27

The direct risk of a child touching/ingesting it is obviously reduced, but the risk of disease spreading to wildlife etc isn’t.

And I'm completely open to taking that risk on board and changing my behaviour. I've asked repeatedly if anyone knows of any serious academic research into this. There are benefits of 'stick and flick ' in rural locations, and harms. I would really like to know where the balance on this lies, if anyone knows?

oOmoonhaOo · 14/02/2024 23:01

Donoteven · 14/02/2024 22:58

I walk my dog, off path, through the forest beside us every morning. I don't want your dog's shit on my shoes or my DC's shoes even though we aren't using a path. Takes 2 seconds and no effort to scoop the poop.

This isn’t e remote situation though. In the area you describe I would pick it up

Kendodd · 14/02/2024 23:00

Emily1583 · 14/02/2024 22:54

Do you not use same said plastic bags to pick up dog shit in a built up area though??

I do. Because I don't usually walk my dog in urban areas though I use a lot fewer bags overall. Also, in urban areas the risk/benefit ratio shifts. Besides the pure risk factor, dog shit in urban areas or places where people might step in it (even if health risks were zero) is just unpleasant and an annoyance we don't need.

Donoteven · 14/02/2024 22:58

I walk my dog, off path, through the forest beside us every morning. I don't want your dog's shit on my shoes or my DC's shoes even though we aren't using a path. Takes 2 seconds and no effort to scoop the poop.

Emily1583 · 14/02/2024 22:57

Prunesqualler · 14/02/2024 22:53

Not talking about going over the speed limit in either.
Talking about going faster down country lanes.
As…The speed limit on country lanes is not as low as for built up areas.
Theres a reason for that and it’s based on risk.

Hence my example above re dangers of driving on country lanes using town speed limits.
This was the previous discussion between yourself and OOO

Of course there are different speed limits but going over that said speed limit be it country lane is the same as going over the speed limit in a built up area.

oOmoonhaOo · 14/02/2024 22:57

Emily1583 · 14/02/2024 22:53

The very same poo bags you'd pick up dog shit in a built up area with because someone might spot you...

I don’t walk my dog in built up areas.

Prunesqualler · 14/02/2024 22:56

Kendodd · 14/02/2024 22:52

You don't use a bag, pollution from the production of the bag, use of earth resources (usually oil) . Disposal of bag, truck journeys, pollution from truck, risk of rtc from trucks. Workers collecting poo getting contaminated. Disposal of poo itself (in fairness, I don't know how this happens and could possibly have some benefits, ie, could have some industrial uses). I would seriously expect the risks of picking up the poo in the remote countryside locations I walk my dog I would have a higher chance of contamination, and sickness from accidently getting poo on my hands, than there would be of a child coming across it and then getting sick.

@Kendodd
some of it is burnt
some tiny amount tho is used as fuel
the majority of councils have neither the money nor resources ( ours doesn’t) and it goes to landfill.

Emily1583 · 14/02/2024 22:54

Kendodd · 14/02/2024 22:52

You don't use a bag, pollution from the production of the bag, use of earth resources (usually oil) . Disposal of bag, truck journeys, pollution from truck, risk of rtc from trucks. Workers collecting poo getting contaminated. Disposal of poo itself (in fairness, I don't know how this happens and could possibly have some benefits, ie, could have some industrial uses). I would seriously expect the risks of picking up the poo in the remote countryside locations I walk my dog I would have a higher chance of contamination, and sickness from accidently getting poo on my hands, than there would be of a child coming across it and then getting sick.

Do you not use same said plastic bags to pick up dog shit in a built up area though??

Prunesqualler · 14/02/2024 22:53

Emily1583 · 14/02/2024 22:47

Taking about speeding, aka going above the designated speed limit, not driving at a legal speed that another might consider merely as inconvenient. Going over the speed limit in a country lane has the potential devastating result as that of going over the speed in a built up area.

Not talking about going over the speed limit in either.
Talking about going faster down country lanes.
As…The speed limit on country lanes is not as low as for built up areas.
Theres a reason for that and it’s based on risk.

Hence my example above re dangers of driving on country lanes using town speed limits.
This was the previous discussion between yourself and OOO

Emily1583 · 14/02/2024 22:53

oOmoonhaOo · 14/02/2024 22:47

Poo bags in landfill

The very same poo bags you'd pick up dog shit in a built up area with because someone might spot you...

Kendodd · 14/02/2024 22:52

Emily1583 · 14/02/2024 22:41

What are the benefits of not picking up dog shit exactly?

You don't use a bag, pollution from the production of the bag, use of earth resources (usually oil) . Disposal of bag, truck journeys, pollution from truck, risk of rtc from trucks. Workers collecting poo getting contaminated. Disposal of poo itself (in fairness, I don't know how this happens and could possibly have some benefits, ie, could have some industrial uses). I would seriously expect the risks of picking up the poo in the remote countryside locations I walk my dog I would have a higher chance of contamination, and sickness from accidently getting poo on my hands, than there would be of a child coming across it and then getting sick.

oOmoonhaOo · 14/02/2024 22:51

Theminer · 14/02/2024 22:49

It does. Speeding kills more people on rural roads than urban ones (and rural roads kill more people in general).

But the risk to others is less. Which @Emily1583 is saying. That’s who I replying to.

I’m more likely to kill myself on a country lane than hit another person, compared to if I was doing 40 in a town.

Theminer · 14/02/2024 22:49

oOmoonhaOo · 14/02/2024 22:48

No it doesn’t!

It does. Speeding kills more people on rural roads than urban ones (and rural roads kill more people in general).

oOmoonhaOo · 14/02/2024 22:48

Emily1583 · 14/02/2024 22:47

Taking about speeding, aka going above the designated speed limit, not driving at a legal speed that another might consider merely as inconvenient. Going over the speed limit in a country lane has the potential devastating result as that of going over the speed in a built up area.

No it doesn’t!

Theminer · 14/02/2024 22:48

Rural roads are more dangerous for all users- more people die from speeding related accidents on rural roads (as well as more dying there in general).

oOmoonhaOo · 14/02/2024 22:47

Emily1583 · 14/02/2024 22:41

What are the benefits of not picking up dog shit exactly?

Poo bags in landfill

Emily1583 · 14/02/2024 22:47

Prunesqualler · 14/02/2024 22:43

Emily if you drove @ 30mph down a country lane you would cause more problems than anyone actually driving at the actual speed limit.
Apreciate what you’re saying but you would not only cause road rage the amount of people trailing behind you ( as you drive well below the speed limit ) and subsequently trying to get past you could easily cause a crash.

I see it all the time when sheep are on the way to market or tractors of hay, at least they realise they are going too slow and pull to the side though..

Going so far under the speed limit is Far more likely to cause an accident.

Taking about speeding, aka going above the designated speed limit, not driving at a legal speed that another might consider merely as inconvenient. Going over the speed limit in a country lane has the potential devastating result as that of going over the speed in a built up area.

Prunesqualler · 14/02/2024 22:43

Emily1583 · 14/02/2024 22:31

Can't be bothered to pick up dog shit. Thinks speeding down country lanes doesn't have the same consequences as driving in a built up area. Both purely based upon ones 'risk assessment'....I win this moral argument hands down.

Emily if you drove @ 30mph down a country lane you would cause more problems than anyone actually driving at the actual speed limit.
Apreciate what you’re saying but you would not only cause road rage the amount of people trailing behind you ( as you drive well below the speed limit ) and subsequently trying to get past you could easily cause a crash.

I see it all the time when sheep are on the way to market or tractors of hay, at least they realise they are going too slow and pull to the side though..

Going so far under the speed limit is Far more likely to cause an accident.

Emily1583 · 14/02/2024 22:41

Kendodd · 14/02/2024 22:39

No it's not. I'm also a H&S professional. Risks have to be balanced against benefits. Prime example- skiing.

What are the benefits of not picking up dog shit exactly?

Swipe left for the next trending thread