Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not pick up dog poo...

757 replies

Moonfishstar · 13/02/2024 05:54

... when in a quiet forest, but to flick it with a stick into dense undergrowth instead?

I don't see any issue with this, but I've got a feeling lots will disagree with me, so I wanted to get some other opinions.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
29
MontyDonsBlueScarf · 16/02/2024 07:59

@Ritasueandbobtoo9 Perhaps I should have said to the Forestry England team, thanks for taking the trouble to come out here and give us 1-1 advice on how to behave in the environment you're responsible for, but actually I'm going to ignore it and be guided by some internet randoms instead. Seriously?!

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 16/02/2024 05:34

@MontyDonsBlueScarf

Just stop polluting the environment.

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 15/02/2024 22:40

@Ritasueandbobtoo9 not from inaccessible places because as I've already said many times, Forestry England have told me it's OK not to.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 15/02/2024 22:03

@MontyDonsBlueScarf will you pick up your dog’s shit then?

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 15/02/2024 17:40

@Elber Thank you for this post, it has made me think.

I think we will have to disagree on the meaning of 'under control'. To my mind it means the dog isn't running around causing damage, chasing wildlife or being a nuisance, and it will come back to you immediately if you ask it to. I agree you need an awareness of where it is and what it's doing, but I don't think that that necessarily means you have to have eyes on every single moment - 'he's just gone behind that tree' for example. If you are saying that it means you have to be able to pick up its poo then you might as well say it has to be on lead, surely?

I hear what you say about even one poo changing the local ecosystem and I'm wondering why, if that's the only thing to take into account, Forestry England don't ask everyone to keep their dogs on leads all the time. They do ask you to stay on the paths where possible, so it makes sense to me to think that the damage from searching for and retrieving sparsely spread poo may outweigh the damage done by leaving it where it is. If you can throw any light on this I'd be glad to see it. I hope that answers your question.

More broadly, it has got me thinking about what's 'right' when it comes to conservation, and whether there's any single right answer. Many years ago I was one of the last people to see the Lascaux cave paintings before they were sealed off for their protection. Now no-one can see them. Is that right? If no-one can see them, what's the point of keeping them at all? Nevertheless my gut feeling is that that's probably the right thing to do.

How does that apply to a landscape? It would be possible to seal it off completely to protect it, but somehow that doesn't feel equally right. Partly because it would ignore any rights that people may have to enjoy it, but also because unlike a painting, a forest is in a perpetual state of change in any case. So where do you draw the line between what's best for the landscape and what's best for the people? That's not clear cut.

As with the vegan/vegetarian/organic/any old thing spectrum, people will have different views and unless these are in some way perverse, they are equally valid. My personal view of the forest is that people and animals should be allowed to enjoy it responsibly. In deciding what that looks like I am guided by the views of Forestry England as I understand them, because I don't have the detailed knowledge necessary to decide entirely for myself. I accept that there will be some people who think that people should be permanently restricted to pathways in the forest or that dogs should only ever be allowed if they're on a lead. That's a valid view, but it's no more right or wrong than mine. I don't hold it because I think that it doesn't give sufficient weight to the rights of people and animals and to the fact that over time, it's in the nature of a forest to change. Equally there are people who think they should be allowed to ride their dirt bikes anywhere. I don't hold that view either but I accept that it's just a different point on the spectrum.

At the end of the day I am open to changing my behaviour, but that would have to be based on new evidence/information, and also be congruent with my position on the preserve it for ever just as it is/let everyone do anything they want spectrum. For the time being I will carry on following Forestry England's advice (which is why I no longer stick and flick).

Thanks for helping me think more broadly about this.

Elber · 15/02/2024 13:38

@MontyDonsBlueScarf

Because you say ‘run free but under control’ - if you aren’t able to pick up its poo, or have an awareness of where it is or what it’s doing - I would say it’s not under control. If you can’t control where it poos, then you can’t control if it’s disturbing other wildlife etc.

The photo you posted is beautiful. If anything, it makes me feel even more strongly that dogs should not be pooing in such a beautiful, natural and delicate ecosystem. I remember in Biology recording the species I found in a metre quadrat. A dog poo in that metre quadrat would undoubtably change the natural nutrient content, add bacteria and pathogens. Then the poo attracts a fox which digests it and spreads it through its own digestive system. More dog poo then attracts more foxes which eat eggs etc of nesting birds. It rains and the bacteria and pathogens from the poo leach into nearby streams and kill fish/invertebrates. Explain to me why that should be overlooked or is not important enough? When it could be avoided by controlling where you dog poos and disposing if it in a better way?

NonPlayerCharacter · 15/02/2024 11:22

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 15/02/2024 08:36

Sure, but it’s made of the surrounding ecosystem. In balance. Not factory processed slop “with chunks and jelly”.

It's also made by animals who form part of the local ecosystem and are therefore involved in its food chain and have a natural, self-regulating balance. A load of dogs coming into it every day to do nothing but shit in it upsets that balance.

SabrinaThwaite · 15/02/2024 11:00

I think this thread makes it clear why Forestry England doesn't spell that out on their website

Except Forestry England does make it very clear:

Keep our forests clean
Bag and bin your dog's waste. Any public or household waste bin can take bagged dog poo.

It doesn’t say, if your dog takes a dump miles away from you, just forget about it, does it now?

https://www.forestryengland.uk/dog-code

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 15/02/2024 10:38

oOmoonhaOo · 14/02/2024 23:01

This isn’t e remote situation though. In the area you describe I would pick it up

Exactly as @oOmoonhaOo says. We pick up near car parks and paths because 1. there are more people around likely to step in it and 2. these are the areas where there's a high concentration of dogs, and therefore a sufficiently high concentration of dog poo to threaten the environment. Neither of these applies in remote areas.

Reposting my photo of a typical dog walking area in the hope of clarifying what we're talking about. I'm interested to know how you would locate and pick up poo left in the middle distance when you're standing on the path from which the picture was taken. 2 seconds and no effort? You'd have to have superpowers.

Added to which, Forestry England asks people to stick to the paths. I trust them to have evaluated the risk of collecting a poo from a remote place against the risk of leaving it to damage the environment in order to come to that decision.
I think this thread makes it clear why Forestry England doesn't spell that out on their website - there's a huge difference of opinion over what a remote place looks like, and blanket advice based on that would simply be unworkable.

Before anyone comes on to say dogs should stick to the paths too - at certain times and in certain ares they are indeed asked to stick to the paths to protect ground nesting birds. The rest of the time they're OK to run free provided they're under control. Those are Forestry England rules, not mine, so if you disagree please take it up with them.

To not pick up dog poo...
Elber · 15/02/2024 09:34

@Flickersy

The nutrient content of the soil is typically low nutrient. Dog poo is high nutrient. It disturbs the natural nutritional content of the soil so that certain plant species die and are over taken by bracken.

There are pathogens and bacteria in dog poo that can cause livestock to abort, and invertebrates/fish in rivers/streams to die when it leaches into the water.
A significant proportion of fox diet is now dog poo. So the dog poo attracts larger number of foxes which can then kill the eggs/chicks of birds - or nesting near a discarded dog poo that attracts the fox.

@oOmoonhaOo

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 15/02/2024 09:17

Dog owners routinely fail to pick up and fail to cleanly flick. How will they dig holes successfully?

oOmoonhaOo · 15/02/2024 09:08

What if I dug a 6 inch hole which is recommended for human waste?

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 15/02/2024 09:01

if your dog eats exactly the same stuff as the local deer and foxes etc, gets no medication etc then it would just be part of the ecosystem, right ? If you’re bringing alien materials in then it’s not. Dog shit is like human shit, and we don’t like humans leaving their shit everywhere.

oOmoonhaOo · 15/02/2024 08:46

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 15/02/2024 08:36

Sure, but it’s made of the surrounding ecosystem. In balance. Not factory processed slop “with chunks and jelly”.

So it depends on what your dog eats?

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 15/02/2024 08:36

Flickersy · 15/02/2024 08:14

There's shit everywhere in the countryside. Thinking the natural world has no shit on it is your first mistake. Soil is worm shit.

Sure, but it’s made of the surrounding ecosystem. In balance. Not factory processed slop “with chunks and jelly”.

Flickersy · 15/02/2024 08:14

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 15/02/2024 07:23

“Mmm, here’s a beautiful place with no shit on it. I will flick shit on it so that I can enjoy having an animal at the end of my piece of string. It is worth putting shit somewhere where there was no shit before because it means I can have a living creature at the end of my piece of string”

There's shit everywhere in the countryside. Thinking the natural world has no shit on it is your first mistake. Soil is worm shit.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 15/02/2024 07:23

“Mmm, here’s a beautiful place with no shit on it. I will flick shit on it so that I can enjoy having an animal at the end of my piece of string. It is worth putting shit somewhere where there was no shit before because it means I can have a living creature at the end of my piece of string”

Moonfishstar · 15/02/2024 05:32

Donoteven · 14/02/2024 22:58

I walk my dog, off path, through the forest beside us every morning. I don't want your dog's shit on my shoes or my DC's shoes even though we aren't using a path. Takes 2 seconds and no effort to scoop the poop.

Thank you to those on this thread who've provided good arguments why "stick and flick" has potential environmental issues.

However, I'm not flicking on to places where people would ever go, so there's no need to be concerned that people would ever walk in it, because they couldn't unless they got secateurs or a machete and hacked their way in to the undergrowth!

OP posts:
Treehugger22 · 15/02/2024 00:54

Your dog poo yes
It sounds weird but I cant touch (with a bag of course) cold dog poo it makes me heeve so if its not mine, I would flick it to

hothotheatbag · 15/02/2024 00:31

I'm a stick and flick, but then I'm literally miles away from anyone. I would imagine it's a case of seeing if it's likely to impact on others? Then decide.

But middle of the countryside off paths etc putting poo in plastic is crazy.

SabrinaThwaite · 15/02/2024 00:19

I haven't seen anyone say it's Ok to leave dog shit on trails.

That’s because you’ve completely missed my point.

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 15/02/2024 00:12

This reply has been hidden

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 15/02/2024 00:11

SabrinaThwaite · 14/02/2024 23:05

Besides the pure risk factor, dog shit in urban areas or places where people might step in it (even if health risks were zero) is just unpleasant and an annoyance we don't need.

Dog shit in rural areas is also unpleasant and annoying.

Like the guy who walked the Serpent Trail and picked up 40kg of dog shit over 4 days. That’s a rural long distance path and I doubt he went off piste to deliberately collect more dog shit.

It’s human nature to get lazy about picking up after their dog - if it’s perceived as OK to do that in a heavily wooded area, then that often drifts to being OK to do that in other areas too.

I haven't seen anyone say it's Ok to leave dog shit on trails. What puzzles me is how anyone walking on a trail finds it unpleasant and annoying to think that there may be dog shit several hundred yards away in an area of open forest that's only accessible if you're willing to scramble down steep banks covered in gorse bushes, and through muddy areas at the bottom where you need knee high wellies. Dogs like to investigate places like that but people, on the whole, don't.

Maddy70 · 14/02/2024 23:22

Pick n flick is desirable really As long as it moved from paths and is placed where it can degrade naturally is much better than putting it in a single-use plastic bag