Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not pick up dog poo...

757 replies

Moonfishstar · 13/02/2024 05:54

... when in a quiet forest, but to flick it with a stick into dense undergrowth instead?

I don't see any issue with this, but I've got a feeling lots will disagree with me, so I wanted to get some other opinions.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
29
Theminer · 13/02/2024 13:42

Wingham · 13/02/2024 12:56

Not to mention the ammonia generated by farm animals.( absorbed by planting trees btw)
We are a long way off from an ideal world of only organic farming and veganism.
Its all about doing what we can and a few lifestyle changes in, for example, only buying organic and reducing meat consumption would help the environment, including our woodlands ( esp given the damage pesticides do )

In terms of the OPs post, we follow the woodlands guidance.
We only use woodlands that we are allowed to as many do not give access. We do not allow children to stray off the path running over roots and disturbing nature.

We follow the guidance, which states move dog poo off the path to the side
Do not bag and hang!
One woodland has a long explanation about how long it takes ‘so-called’ biodegradable bags to actually break down. So they too prefer the flick method.

You do know there are other options than plastic bags or bags that are supposedly biodegradable but not really?

Cornstarch based, or recycled paper based etc.

It just requires people to actually bother themselves to actually research it.

surreygirl1987 · 13/02/2024 13:41

Some people intentionally don’t pick up dog poo, that’s the issue. Maybe cat poo is a significant problem for some. But I don’t see it littering streets, parks, beaches and woodland 🤢Even in front of my neighbours drive the other morning, he had to pick up dog poo before he ran his car through it or his kids stepped in it - he doesn’t even have a dog. I was putting my child in the car at the same time. Grim.

🤮 that is vile. What is wrong with people?

SweetBirdsong · 13/02/2024 13:39

Minymile · 13/02/2024 13:04

Humans including children should stay on the paths. Running all over the place off the paths has detrimental affects on tree and all plant roots along small animals and insects.
Woodlands are not there for humans and children to explore first and foremost.

What a load of absolute histrionic tripe! 😆

Playing in the woodlands, and exploring them and getting messy, getting lost, building little dens, and playing hide and seek in them etc etc etc, is a rite of passage for children. Ban children/people from the woods? Don't be ridiculous!

surreygirl1987 · 13/02/2024 13:39

Lazy and disgusting and people like you are why I stopped my kids running through forests when they were little.

Fully agree. Lazy and disguting. I fear I may have to do this too. My little boys absolutely LOVE exploring. I love seeing them explore the forests and they always have an amazing time - they make dens, play hide and seek, and play make-believe games about wxplorers and pirates etc. Three times though, recently, they've come back with dog poo on them. One time it was on my little boy's front (he was hiding in a bush). I should not have to feel that I can only let my kids play in our back garden or a playground. (Mind you, my youngest was attacked by a dog in a playground when he was 6 months old in his pram, so that wasn't great either!).

Then you have the morons who say people are getting 'hysterical' over dog poo... 🙄

nonmerci99 · 13/02/2024 13:39

SweetBirdsong · 13/02/2024 13:37

How old are these posters though?

because someone posted a link to this earlier...

At the bottom it says 'Keep our forests cleanBag and bin your dog's waste. Any public or household waste bin can take bagged dog poo.'

https://www.forestryengland.uk/dog-code

I am getting so confused now. SO many mixed messages and rules here that people keep posting that I don't know what's right or wrong now. I know one thing though - I'm glad I don't have a dog!

The posters are outdated.

SweetBirdsong · 13/02/2024 13:37

sexyandsmart · 13/02/2024 13:03

The Firestry Commiduin do indeed condone stick and flick. They promote it

How old are these posters though?

because someone posted a link to this earlier...

At the bottom it says 'Keep our forests cleanBag and bin your dog's waste. Any public or household waste bin can take bagged dog poo.'

https://www.forestryengland.uk/dog-code

I am getting so confused now. SO many mixed messages and rules here that people keep posting that I don't know what's right or wrong now. I know one thing though - I'm glad I don't have a dog!

Your Forest Dog Code

Take the lead Forests are great spaces for your dog to enjoy, just make sure you know when you need to use the lead. Keep your eyes peeled Please respect other visitors, wildlife and livestock, keep your eyes open and your dog within sight. Have good c...

https://www.forestryengland.uk/dog-code

Veronicaisaflower · 13/02/2024 13:37

Prunesqualler · 13/02/2024 13:35

Quite right @Minymile children and adults playing in the undergrowth and running all over the place, off the designated areas, is hugely detrimental.

Some forests have realised the issue and now have allocated areas which have been cleared to allow play.
Its a shame a lot of people don’t seem to get the damage that is being done.

Holy whataboutery, Batman!

pickledandpuzzled · 13/02/2024 13:36

SarcocystisFayeri · 13/02/2024 12:32

If you’re feeding raw I hope you know EXACTLY what is in it.

Here is my horse’s muscle biopsy results when she was diagnosed with a Sarcocystis Fayeri infection.

It comes from ingesting dog faeces that is infected with the sarcosysts, which come from eating raw horse meat (that has a Sarcocystis Fayeri infection). A very specific dog-horse cycle.

My horse will have picked it up from grazing a bit of grass in the forestry where a dog has left mess that has either been left or not cleared properly.

It cost £2700 to treat, took 6m to get to the bottom of it and meant I lost the use of my horse for most of 2022 while it was ongoing.

Raw feeders please be educated.

Is that in the uk? Mine used to eat meat I bought in the supermarket. I’ve had to go to preminced as he’s aged though. Uk dog food has to be human grade meat.

Posithor · 13/02/2024 13:36

Janiie · 13/02/2024 11:02

It isn't fine 'off the path'. People, kids, other dogs go off path.

Pick your dog shit up and dispose of it like a responsible person.

It's almost like nothing else shits in the woods 😂

Prunesqualler · 13/02/2024 13:35

Minymile · 13/02/2024 13:04

Humans including children should stay on the paths. Running all over the place off the paths has detrimental affects on tree and all plant roots along small animals and insects.
Woodlands are not there for humans and children to explore first and foremost.

Quite right @Minymile children and adults playing in the undergrowth and running all over the place, off the designated areas, is hugely detrimental.

Some forests have realised the issue and now have allocated areas which have been cleared to allow play.
Its a shame a lot of people don’t seem to get the damage that is being done.

surreygirl1987 · 13/02/2024 13:35

SabrinaThwaite · 13/02/2024 12:56

At least some National Parks are also against using ‘stick and flick’:

Leaving poo bags on trees is disgusting but ‘sticking and flicking’ really isn’t much better. We know that the vast majority of dog owners love the countryside and would be devastated to think they, and their animals were causing harm.

Dog poo is bad for people and bad for the countryside. Good dog owners know to bag and bin it – any bin will do.

https://www.southdowns.gov.uk/whats-the-scoop-on-picking-up-poop/

Little wonder when you read this:

Henry Rawlings collected more than 88lb (40kg) of faeces during a 65-mile (105km) sponsored walk of the Serpent Trail in the South Downs National Park.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-sussex-64281652.amp

Woah! Good finds, and thanks for sharing.

oakleaffy · 13/02/2024 13:34

''There is a man with a largish dog who allows his to poo on the pavement in the little park at the back of us. We have never been able to establish who it is, but in the summer it happens almost daily, it's always in the same spot.''

@HipHop63 can you not shame this man on social media into cleaning uop his shit?

WHY aren't I surprised?...a large dog and a man. Classic poo leaver.

Gross.

CactusMactus · 13/02/2024 13:33

I think flicking it into a bush is preferential over bagging it and then hanging a plastic bag full. of poo on a tree. Which is why some forest commissions have said it's ok...
Just bag it and take it with you.

surreygirl1987 · 13/02/2024 13:32

@MonsteraMama

Only on fucking Mumsnet would we descend to people being accused of gaslighting by page ten of a dogshit thread, Jesus H Christ

Only on mumsnet would people call those concerned that people aren't picking up after their dogs 'hysterical'.

You sound intelligent 🙄

oakleaffy · 13/02/2024 13:31

TempleOfBloom · 13/02/2024 13:23

I was listening to a radio 4 programme about some Heath and moor land damaged by dog poo. These are sensitive environments with plants that only thrive in very low nutrient soil. Dog walking is enough to provide soil nutrients for tougher more invasive plants, and threatening the delicate biodiversity.

This really surprised me, too.
An Ecologist friend said that dog poo and pee is nitrogen rich and this in effect 'fertilises' the ground.
I remember the Nitrogen cycle from school with the pooing bunny diagram with arrows...Just googled, they still use a pooping bunny!

Dogs are probably far more 'damaging' in the poo department, dogs aren't herbivores, either.

To not pick up dog poo...
HipHop63 · 13/02/2024 13:31

Where we live, we are a mixture of house and apartments on an estate. There is a man with a largish dog who allows his to poo on the pavement in the little park at the back of us. We have never been able to establish who it is, but in the summer it happens almost daily, its always in the same spot.

Someone has sprayed a 'clean in up' stencil onto the pavement where the dog always leaves his mess. Today I did a litter pick for an hour and got talking to the organiser that I had never met. We got talking about where I lived (about 2 miles from her) and I said we had a little park at the bottom of our estate and she told me she was the one who had stencilled the sign onto the path. What a coincidence!

SabrinaThwaite · 13/02/2024 13:27

sexyandsmart · 13/02/2024 13:03

The Firestry Commiduin do indeed condone stick and flick. They promote it

Again:

The poster on the left says Forestry Commission England - is this an old poster? The Forestry Commission England no longer exists in that name, and has been superseded by Forestry England - see the current bag it and bin it advice.

Is the poster on the right an old poster too? The Forestry Commission Scotland was dissolved in 2019 and replaced by Forestry and Land Scotland.

Neither poster is applicable in England, which is where OP said they are.

oakleaffy · 13/02/2024 13:24

SarcocystisFayeri · 13/02/2024 13:19

Gosh this is the most nannyish thing I’ve read in a while.
Of course children should be allowed to explore and get dirty (not dog poo obvs) and not have to stick to the paths.

You would have an attack of the vapours at my 1970s childhood which involved exploring woods, fields, rivers, reservoirs on our own, all day, with sandwiches carried in an old bread bag with no mobile phones! That’s why my friend and I are pretty resilient.

Yes, my childhood was like this, too...out all day , on my own, zero phones, hunger and thirst drove me back home at the end of the day..I remember being so hungry that I wished I could eat grass!
Zero snacking was allowed - If I found a few empty pop bottles, you could take those back to get the 5p deposit and buy a new bottle.

In all those wandering days {here and Europe} I only once met someone who made my alarm bells ring.... I was going to explore a deserted farm in South of France...and a German man was following me saying 'Hello..Hello..'..

I'd walked a long way to get to the farm, but decided to not risk it..and ran like the clappers to get away from him.

Prunesqualler · 13/02/2024 13:24

RaisingTheDead · 13/02/2024 11:56

Not picking it up is lazy. You’re looking for excuses. I guess you’ve found it by ignoring all the research and having someone on an estate tell you to leave it.

Carry on wrecking the environment, have a lovely time.

Very rude as we grow and manage our woodlands
We are also fully organic, and are vegans so our impact on the environment is much smaller than others.
We work very hard to protect all wildlife and the environment and have researched heavily into how those who we allow to walk amongst our woodlands and wetlands should act.
Everything we do is fully researched waying up the best possible course of action.
The best course is to not allow people to walk amongst the land at all in order to fully preserve the wildlife, flora and fauna. However we decided people should be able to enjoy it in designated areas and to not stray off these areas, as such our pathways are raised off the undergrowth and all, including children, are not allowed to stray off these.

In terms of dog poo again it has been fully researched, not by me but by the wildlife conservationists and foresters that we use. We are happy to follow their guidance. I can only assume the FC have such a large footfall that they can’t cope with it.
We don’t. As we restrict access to certain days and times of year paying particular attention to periods of growth, both plant and animal.

TempleOfBloom · 13/02/2024 13:23

I was listening to a radio 4 programme about some Heath and moor land damaged by dog poo. These are sensitive environments with plants that only thrive in very low nutrient soil. Dog walking is enough to provide soil nutrients for tougher more invasive plants, and threatening the delicate biodiversity.

Floralnomad · 13/02/2024 13:21

YABVU , as previously stated Forestry England say to pick up not flick . We had the misfortune to visit Hemsted forest ( Kent) last week , we walked about 50 yards from the car park and then turned round and went back as there was literally dog excrement everywhere and I was having trouble keeping my own dog out of it . Disgusting .

ILoveHugeAckman · 13/02/2024 13:19

Given virtually all my dog-walker friends do this too, I suspect like most MN threads, the responses are highly self-selecting.

Then you and your friends are part of the "happy to be vile and selfish" group that cause people a lot of problems.

If only children walked in straight lines, didnt want to play hide and seek in the undergrowth and thus trample in your dog poo, then we would be kind of ok.

But they do wander/ run/ hide and if it is close enough to be flicked by a stick, it is close enough for kids to walk in.

Stop being so lazy-arsed and start thinking of others. I can promise you the 20 seconds it takes you to pick it up is much less than the time it takes to try and get poo off my kids wellies.

oakleaffy · 13/02/2024 13:19

LiveLaughCryalot · 13/02/2024 12:41

Yep, my father being one of them im sorry to say. I worm his dog. You would be surprised at the amount of people that don't bother to regularly worm.

Good for you for worming his dog.

WHY people are so ignorant of this very basic need?

ALL puppies are born with worms, even if their mother has been regularly wormed.

The lifecycle of the roundworm means that when a bitch is pregnant, worm larvae from the mother's tissues migrate to the pups and into the milk after birth.

Just because adult worms aren't seen, doesn't mean that they are not there.

We had a vet once who used to sell cheap but effective wormers for dogs and cats as he said he'd rather people used them than children were put at risk from 'visceral larval migrans' that can potentially cause blindness from the roundworm cats and dogs can carry.

SarcocystisFayeri · 13/02/2024 13:19

Minymile · 13/02/2024 13:04

Humans including children should stay on the paths. Running all over the place off the paths has detrimental affects on tree and all plant roots along small animals and insects.
Woodlands are not there for humans and children to explore first and foremost.

Gosh this is the most nannyish thing I’ve read in a while.
Of course children should be allowed to explore and get dirty (not dog poo obvs) and not have to stick to the paths.

You would have an attack of the vapours at my 1970s childhood which involved exploring woods, fields, rivers, reservoirs on our own, all day, with sandwiches carried in an old bread bag with no mobile phones! That’s why my friend and I are pretty resilient.