Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not pick up dog poo...

757 replies

Moonfishstar · 13/02/2024 05:54

... when in a quiet forest, but to flick it with a stick into dense undergrowth instead?

I don't see any issue with this, but I've got a feeling lots will disagree with me, so I wanted to get some other opinions.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
29
happypillsareworking · 19/02/2024 08:55

Ruralrules · 13/02/2024 10:25

My dog did a large poo in the snow a week or so ago on an extremely rural walk we do every day.We cover about ten acres of woodland and moorland and noone else accesses it.
I usually pick the poo up but in this case the poo was melting through the snow and I left it. He has now rolled in his own poo in that exact place and had to be washed twice. This involves a huge retriever being manhandled into a shower, wet shitty dog smell all through the house, wet dog marks on the hall paintwork.
I've learnt my lesson.

Why didn't you pick it up when you went back?
My dog did a poo late at night and I could not find it at all (even with a torch). Went back the next day and picked it up (early in the morning). It was frozen solid so a dream to pick up 🤣

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 19/02/2024 08:20

Just to clarify, I walk my dogs round town, in country parks, and in a national park. The national park has remote places accessible from car parks, as I imagine they all do. I am bemused by the idea that the visitors need to be told not to trample everywhere by a multitude of 'please keep off the grass' signs.

Justpontificating · 16/02/2024 19:49

Theminer · 16/02/2024 19:39

She says she was told to pick up poo in the car park of that wood, so clearly it isn’t a remote-place-you-can-only-hike-to type wood.

Clearly then whoever cares for it doesn’t want signs everywhere and have decided to educate people instead. ( I can see the aesthetic benefits of this). Seems a great idea although I’ve never experienced similar.

Everywhere we walk people respect nature and keep on the paths….no signs needed,

Theminer · 16/02/2024 19:39

Minymile · 16/02/2024 19:25

It looks like @MontyDonsBlueScarf wood have chosen to educate rather than sign.
Signs in a natural wood can be out of place.
So Perhaps @MontyDonsBlueScarf wood is not the type of wood that comes with a carpark and/ or lots of signs … If it is then a sign would be great and not out of place.

However the best thing we can do to protect our natural environment is to not trample all over it.
Im assuming those who are worried and pick up poo would also understand this.

She says she was told to pick up poo in the car park of that wood, so clearly it isn’t a remote-place-you-can-only-hike-to type wood.

Minymile · 16/02/2024 19:25

Theminer · 16/02/2024 19:10

In that case they would put signs up saying not to leave the path, like they do during lambing/ground nesting etc etc.

It looks like @MontyDonsBlueScarf wood have chosen to educate rather than sign.
Signs in a natural wood can be out of place.
So Perhaps @MontyDonsBlueScarf wood is not the type of wood that comes with a carpark and/ or lots of signs … If it is then a sign would be great and not out of place.

However the best thing we can do to protect our natural environment is to not trample all over it.
Im assuming those who are worried and pick up poo would also understand this.

Theminer · 16/02/2024 19:10

Justpontificating · 16/02/2024 19:08

Good point.
Or possibly it’s because they don’t want humans traipsing through the undergrowth after their dogs, who are also traipsing through the undergrowth. That’s two sets of footfall doing or looking for a poo.
All that disturbance to the flora, fauna and ground habitats could be too much.

Better advice is for all humans to stay on the track and put your dog on a lead if they can’t too.

In that case they would put signs up saying not to leave the path, like they do during lambing/ground nesting etc etc.

Justpontificating · 16/02/2024 19:08

Theminer · 16/02/2024 13:48

They will have realised that there is no chance of people actually putting themselves out to pick up the shit unless it’s in front of their noses, so they hope people might at least be prepared to flick it off the path.

Same principle is used in public information all the time- 5 a day for example- medical professionals know that that isn’t really enough and people should eat more fruit and vegetables, but they also know that if they tell them a lower number they might try and it’s better than nothing.

If they went to the trouble of going to that place to give out information then there must have been a dog shit problem- like everything else funding means that you target interventions to where they are most needed. So there must have been shit all over and probably bags of shit left all over too and they were going for the least difficult advice that people might bother to follow, rather than the evidence backed preferred policy.

Good point.
Or possibly it’s because they don’t want humans traipsing through the undergrowth after their dogs, who are also traipsing through the undergrowth. That’s two sets of footfall doing or looking for a poo.
All that disturbance to the flora, fauna and ground habitats could be too much.

Better advice is for all humans to stay on the track and put your dog on a lead if they can’t too.

goodkidsmaadhouse · 16/02/2024 18:41

Kendodd · 16/02/2024 18:28

Your children wade through nettles and then five foot high brambles? Even if arms and legs are completely covered with thick safety clothing, their hands and faces must be cut to ribbons.

I find it very hard to believe that everyone ‘sticks and flicks’ into nettles and brambles. Those aren’t ubiquitous plants! Indeed one of the photos posted upthread was of the type of Scottish forest we spend our time in and you’d be hard pressed to find either nettles or brambles in great quantities there. I’m talking about general undergrowth, as were PPs.

Kendodd · 16/02/2024 18:28

goodkidsmaadhouse · 16/02/2024 17:22

@Kendodd My DC have several times come back from playing in undergrowth with dog poo on them. So I don’t think that’s a ridiculous claim! That said I was still on the side of the leave it simply because of the environmental impact of bagging - I don’t have my own dog, just take care of my friends’ dog when they’re away, and I agree that it is thought provoking to learn about the impact of leaving it (I always bury it when I have their dog and genuinely thought that was better for the environment - now I’ve no idea).

Your children wade through nettles and then five foot high brambles? Even if arms and legs are completely covered with thick safety clothing, their hands and faces must be cut to ribbons.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 16/02/2024 18:24

Leaving or burying it still gets washed into the water courses!

goodkidsmaadhouse · 16/02/2024 17:22

@Kendodd My DC have several times come back from playing in undergrowth with dog poo on them. So I don’t think that’s a ridiculous claim! That said I was still on the side of the leave it simply because of the environmental impact of bagging - I don’t have my own dog, just take care of my friends’ dog when they’re away, and I agree that it is thought provoking to learn about the impact of leaving it (I always bury it when I have their dog and genuinely thought that was better for the environment - now I’ve no idea).

Theminer · 16/02/2024 15:14

SabrinaThwaite · 16/02/2024 14:53

@Theminer Or possibly that they had risk assessed the off path areas and concluded that it was unsafe for the public to access to pick up after their dogs. But then in that scenario then I’d probably be advising that in those areas dogs should be on a lead and not be allowed to stray off the path.

If that were the case I think they would have put signs up telling people not to leave the path, but the poster hasn’t mentioned that.

SabrinaThwaite · 16/02/2024 14:53

@Theminer Or possibly that they had risk assessed the off path areas and concluded that it was unsafe for the public to access to pick up after their dogs. But then in that scenario then I’d probably be advising that in those areas dogs should be on a lead and not be allowed to stray off the path.

Theminer · 16/02/2024 13:48

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 16/02/2024 13:25

@SabrinaThwaite you seem to have missed the point that I'm not disregarding specific advice, I'm disregarding general advice in favour of specific advice.

I take your point that employees aren't always fully up to date, but surely it's unlikely that a team sent out on a specific, unusual, public information mission wouldn't have been fully briefed on the information they were supposed to be imparting. Or has that also been your experience over the years? If so you've been particularly unlucky.

They will have realised that there is no chance of people actually putting themselves out to pick up the shit unless it’s in front of their noses, so they hope people might at least be prepared to flick it off the path.

Same principle is used in public information all the time- 5 a day for example- medical professionals know that that isn’t really enough and people should eat more fruit and vegetables, but they also know that if they tell them a lower number they might try and it’s better than nothing.

If they went to the trouble of going to that place to give out information then there must have been a dog shit problem- like everything else funding means that you target interventions to where they are most needed. So there must have been shit all over and probably bags of shit left all over too and they were going for the least difficult advice that people might bother to follow, rather than the evidence backed preferred policy.

SabrinaThwaite · 16/02/2024 13:44

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 16/02/2024 13:25

@SabrinaThwaite you seem to have missed the point that I'm not disregarding specific advice, I'm disregarding general advice in favour of specific advice.

I take your point that employees aren't always fully up to date, but surely it's unlikely that a team sent out on a specific, unusual, public information mission wouldn't have been fully briefed on the information they were supposed to be imparting. Or has that also been your experience over the years? If so you've been particularly unlucky.

It’s less “being unlucky” and more like 30 years experience of working as an HSE professional and ensuring that all staff are up to date with and following current guidance and best practice. Including what the organisation is publishing as its policy.

Lavender14 · 16/02/2024 13:37

I generally take the rule of thumb that if i can reasonably get to where my dog has gone then I will lift the poo. So if you're walking along a trail etc then yes of course you lift it. My dog loves running through undergrowth etc. I don't need him coming out in your dogs shit.

The only caveat is if he goes somewhere I genuinely can't get to, like he's in behind a hedge or in a thicket then I can't do much about that. But if I have the means to lift it then I lift it.

bookfacebaby · 16/02/2024 13:35

The thought of trying to skewer a piece of dog poo like some sort of devils s’more makes me heave!

mylovelytulips · 16/02/2024 13:33

I wonder how far you can actuall flick it away from the path. what do you do with the shitty stick? leave it by the way for a toddler to pick up or do you throw it into the forest?

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 16/02/2024 13:25

@SabrinaThwaite you seem to have missed the point that I'm not disregarding specific advice, I'm disregarding general advice in favour of specific advice.

I take your point that employees aren't always fully up to date, but surely it's unlikely that a team sent out on a specific, unusual, public information mission wouldn't have been fully briefed on the information they were supposed to be imparting. Or has that also been your experience over the years? If so you've been particularly unlucky.

Theminer · 16/02/2024 13:24

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 16/02/2024 11:02

@SabrinaThwaite maybe I should have done, but as I didn't and you want to know the answer, why don't you find out from Forestry England and post it on here? As @Kendodd says it's not easy to know all the factors we need to take into account and where to draw the cost/benefit balance, and the more information we all have, the better.

That's exactly why I shared my conversation in the first place, so that people could be aware that Forestry England believes that blanket policy statements on the internet don't always cover specific situations, so they find it worthwhile to divert employees from their normal duties to give more nuanced advice. I'm sorry it's upset so many people but I'm pleased that others have found the discussion useful.

They will have realised that there is no chance of people actually putting themselves out to pick up the shit unless it’s in front of their noses, so they hope people might at least be prepared to flick it off the path.

Same principle is used in public information all the time- 5 a day for example- medical professionals know that that isn’t really enough and people should eat more fruit and vegetables, but they also know that if they tell them a lower number they might try and it’s better than nothing.

SabrinaThwaite · 16/02/2024 11:37

@MontyDonsBlueScarf

Or, people could just be honest that they disregard specific HSE advice when it suits them?

I don’t actually need to know the answer - I believe in following the published advice. I have also had enough experience over the years to know that employees aren’t always up to date with working practices.

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 16/02/2024 11:02

@SabrinaThwaite maybe I should have done, but as I didn't and you want to know the answer, why don't you find out from Forestry England and post it on here? As @Kendodd says it's not easy to know all the factors we need to take into account and where to draw the cost/benefit balance, and the more information we all have, the better.

That's exactly why I shared my conversation in the first place, so that people could be aware that Forestry England believes that blanket policy statements on the internet don't always cover specific situations, so they find it worthwhile to divert employees from their normal duties to give more nuanced advice. I'm sorry it's upset so many people but I'm pleased that others have found the discussion useful.

SabrinaThwaite · 16/02/2024 10:19

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 16/02/2024 07:59

@Ritasueandbobtoo9 Perhaps I should have said to the Forestry England team, thanks for taking the trouble to come out here and give us 1-1 advice on how to behave in the environment you're responsible for, but actually I'm going to ignore it and be guided by some internet randoms instead. Seriously?!

Perhaps you should have asked the Forestry England staff why they are giving advice that contradicts their employer’s publicly available dog code?

Kendodd · 16/02/2024 09:22

With regard dog poo leaching into the environment, if you bag it and bin it, do you know how it's then disposed? In my own garden, I also flick dog poo into the undergrowth and let is dissolve. I've googled, and found articles on the damage dog poo does to the environment but nothing comparing this to the damage bagging does and weighing them against each other.

I have actually learnt a lot from this thread. Setting aside the frankly ridiculous claims that a child will wade through nettles and thick brambles to step in it, the environmental damage is a concern and was actually the main reason I DIDN'T bag in such a setting. It's thought provoking to think I may have got this cost/benefit balance wrong. I know the bottom line, having a dog is bad for the environment, full stop. I love my dog though and she adds enormously to my life.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 16/02/2024 09:17

@MontyDonsBlueScarf

Yes, you’ve been given plenty of evidence.