Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel ripped off (garage)?

58 replies

TheAverageJoanne · 13/02/2024 01:49

During the icy weather I damaged the door handle on my car driver's side door so it was hanging off. I did some googling and found it's a design fault (Fiat 500) and reading a lot of posts on an owners' forum I joined they advised posters to ask a garage to source a genuine Fiat part and not buy "Chinese rubbish" from eBay or Amazon for £20 or thereabouts as they don't last and you have to start over again, or the screws and fittings aren't right.

I need the car for my job (not just travel to work) so I found somewhere local to where I'd be based today and they ordered the handle and fitted it today. I was remiss in not getting a quote first I know but the total bill is £297.65. For fitting a bloody door handle.

I can't not pay. But is it excessive? I'd have thought a garage would have been able to get a Fiat part for trade cheaper than me. I'm going to ask for a breakdown of costs but it seems everyone is ripping everyone off when they can just using "cost of living" as the same excuse as covid.

OP posts:
As476 · 13/02/2024 08:33

also if you want to find out if the labour is reasonable, I’m happy to take your reg via pm and quote you from my garage for labour only. Our rate is £70 per hour plus VAT. I know door handles involve a lot of work as it all needs stripping. I think the last one I did was a Kia and took me an hour and a bit.

Mindymomo · 13/02/2024 08:32

My Sons fiesta wing mirror was damage due to someone driving past and knocking it off during the night. Rang our garage who said it would be £240, thought expensive but went ahead and told them to order it. It actually was cheaper to order not painted and they painted it themselves. Had it fitted yesterday, it was £240, plus labour £78 plus VAT so nearly £400 in all.

Laughingfaceemoji · 13/02/2024 08:26

It’s such an annoying fault with fiat 500s. I had a local garage use an unofficial part and they charged £120 but that was about 5 years ago now.

Bonesy1 · 13/02/2024 08:25

the same happened to my son’s car. He’s not particularly practical, but in an effort to save money ordered part off eBay, watched a YouTube video and did it himself

DragonGypsyDoris · 13/02/2024 08:22

Total cost is £248 without VAT. The part cost £147 so £101 for labour. It will take about 1.5 hours, which is £67 per hour. Totally reasonable cost.

TheAverageJoanne · 13/02/2024 08:20

Sprig1 · 13/02/2024 08:14

Maybe you could do it yourself next time. It doesn't sound unreasonable to me.

Very helpful. Not.

OP posts:
icelollycraving · 13/02/2024 08:20

Sounds reasonable. If they get it cheaper, surely they don’t pass on to you the saving. You should have asked for an estimate before the works. Yabu.
You are not only paying for the part but the experience and know how.

CHEESEY13 · 13/02/2024 08:18

I have long believed that when a woman takes her car to a garage for whatever then the mechanic/proprietor automatically mentally shoves at least another £50 onto the bill.
Women drivers are, still in this day and age, treated as the dumbest of village idiots.
Funny how repair garages think our money is OK though......

As476 · 13/02/2024 08:16

Phone a fiat dealer and ask them to quote you for that part. I work in a garage and we get a 2% discount on main dealer parts. Unless you specialise and order massive quantities of parts you don’t get things much cheaper.

Sprig1 · 13/02/2024 08:14

Maybe you could do it yourself next time. It doesn't sound unreasonable to me.

TheAverageJoanne · 13/02/2024 08:11

TheSalesGirl · 13/02/2024 02:39

OP what will you do when you get the cost breakdown?

I'll be informed. I'd no idea about the cost of the item or labour. Yes I should have asked.

OP posts:
Gymmum82 · 13/02/2024 08:05

£150 for the part. £50 for labour. Plus VAT. Seems reasonable enough to me

PiperBoo · 13/02/2024 08:02

Given that the part is £147, I dont think you've been overcharged no.

TheAverageJoanne · 13/02/2024 07:46

Hollowgast · 13/02/2024 03:04

Which garage did you use? A dealer can be 150 per hour + vat for labour, and there's a likely a minimum 1h labour charge for any job they do. It sounds reasonable to me. In the past I've tried to fix things myself, and I always found it amazing how the garage were able to do stuff so quickly.

Just a local garage. I needed to be able to walk to and from work.

OP posts:
TangoinTokyo · 13/02/2024 07:05

The labour includes ordering the part and receiving the order- not just the workshop time

Possibly shipping costs for just 1 item as well.

Seems very reasonable

wombat1a · 13/02/2024 06:28

Seems reasonable to me, stipping the door down, removing the old one, fitting the new one, putting the door back together would easily be more than an hours work.

Bearbookagainandagain · 13/02/2024 05:55

@TheAverageJoanne I don't think the cost is excessive, but they should have called you to approve the repairs (with the cost) before they do anything to your car. It is perfectly fine to ask them the cost of the part, but with labour and vat it adds up quickly.
If they haven't, you ask them to reverse anything they have done on the car and get it back, but I doubt this is really what you want?

Bearbookagainandagain · 13/02/2024 05:51

TheSalesGirl · 13/02/2024 02:15

I don't think it's excessive at all.

I think you're being very cheeky asking for a breakdown of costs. They charge what they charge. You should have found out beforehand what the bill would be.

Why should they 'source things more cheaply' or do it for no labour charge?

Don't be ridiculous, it's not "cheeky" to ask for a breakdown when you pay for a repair service, their invoice should show the cost the parts and the cost of labour anyway.

Simonjt · 13/02/2024 05:44

I replaced a handle on my car, it isn’t like replacing a handle in a house. You have to remove the internal panel on the door, this can take sometime, then you have to remove the wires for the electric locking system before you can remove the old handle. Put the new one on, re-wire, test everything works properly and rescure the panel.

Our handle was about £160, just for the actual handle, that didn’t include fixings etc that were needed as well. I got a few quotes for ours ans the cheapest was I think £380.

HeraSyndulla · 13/02/2024 05:28

Take your Mercedes back to a main dealer if you want to my make your eyes water 👀!.

Netaporter · 13/02/2024 05:19

Ex-dealer here. @TheAverageJoanne i don’t think you realise the work required to ‘just’ fit a door handle. Inevitably the work will require removal of the inner door panel,clips holding the panel, removing the panel, not disturbing the wiring loom, taking off the old handle, unboxing and putting on the new handle, then replacing all of the inner panel again, wiping down the area. This doesn’t take into account, mats, seats covers, moving the car on site to get into the workshop etc. If you go to a main dealer, they are also duty bound to check your car for any manufacturer safety recalls regardless of the car’s age, ditto warranty recalls (all of these are free of charge and one of the more compelling reasons to use a main dealer). A main dealer will also wash and vacuum your car f.o.c and will collect and deliver/provide a courtesy car. So £147 for a part that cost £150 to be fitted properly by a trained technician really isn’t that excessive when you strip out the 20% VAT they are required by law to charge you.

Longsight2019 · 13/02/2024 05:04

How do you think these garages continue to trade when they have the overheads that they do. Machinery. Tools. Training. Wages. Huge premises. You’ve paid for a service and an expensive part. What would have been acceptable, a £50 labour charge which wouldn’t even cover their costs?

Suck it up and move on.

Oblomov23 · 13/02/2024 03:50

That's nothing for car repairs, the part itself , labour for : the taking it off, fitting it, linking it in your all the electrics, plugging computer in it and making sure it all dynamics work. That's cheap. And you were foolish to not get a quote. The first thing to do when ringing any garage is to get a quote. Ring 3 garages to get quotes. That's basics.

19lottie82 · 13/02/2024 03:08

You should receive a breakdown of costs in your invoice. Parts + Labour + VAT.

Labour at an independent garage is often £60 ph + VAT so if it took two hours to fit the handle, then the total price isn’t too extortionate.
Possibly the whole door needed to stripped and rebuilt.

Hollowgast · 13/02/2024 03:04

Which garage did you use? A dealer can be 150 per hour + vat for labour, and there's a likely a minimum 1h labour charge for any job they do. It sounds reasonable to me. In the past I've tried to fix things myself, and I always found it amazing how the garage were able to do stuff so quickly.