Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think present money should be returned if marriage lasts just a few weeks

59 replies

Friedchickenrocks · 12/02/2024 21:38

Last June we were invited to a wedding... in India in August. Lad 3 doors down and we know family quite well. Declined the invitation but gave £50. Was looking forward to meeting the lass when she came. He got her visa and flight but since heard she's filing for divorce and doesn't want to come here as heard it gets cold in winter. She could have found that out easily online beforehand!! . So he's offered to live in India but no she wants a divorce. Lad, 25, is heartbroken. Arranged marriage.
Saw another neighbour who is closer than us to them and he says he gave £100 and thinks they should return all the money as they've made marriage like a joke.
What do you think? Hadn't thought of it until he said it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
XenoBitch · 13/02/2024 14:20

I went to a wedding where the couple wanted money for their honeymoon. They went on the honeymoon, and split up (with an annulment) when they got back.

There was nothing to give back.

pontipinemum · 13/02/2024 14:18

@PleaseletitbeSpring oh wow, I really can't imagine how you must have felt. It must have been an awful time .

PleaseletitbeSpring · 13/02/2024 11:22

My first H left me for a man after six weeks. I was completely devastated. My parents offered the presents back on my behalf, but nobody wanted anything returned. I think my guests realised how traumatised I was and didn't want to rub salt in the wounds. The groom, in this case, will be feeling humiliated and embarrassed, I did. Just don't ask for the money back. It will only add to his distress.

pontipinemum · 13/02/2024 10:07

Well they did actually get married so the gift stands. I'd def just leave it (like you said you will)

But WTF was the bride thinking going though with it then changing her mind because it gets cold this side of the world. I can't believe that came as a surprise to her. Also the lad offered to move.

Memba · 13/02/2024 09:46

Traditionally, if a marriage ends before formal thank you notes have been sent, then any unused gifts should be returned. Once thank you notes have been sent the gifts have been formally accepted and are assets of the couple to be disposed of or divided as they see fit.

But I think this harks back to the days when the couple didn't live together pre-marriage, and the wedding list was at Peter Jones and once the marriage ended no one wanted the dinner service and bed linen anyway.

With cash in the 21st Century I think you just need to write it off. As others have said this couple probably both have enough to deal with at the moment.

Ohnoooooooo · 13/02/2024 09:20

I can imagine keeping a list of wedding gifts so you can thank people ie thank you for your toaster etc and I could imagine making a note who gave money to thank them - but keeping a record of how much money people gave each is not something that would cross my mind. They had wedding expenses I am guessing the money went to that

SandyWaves · 13/02/2024 09:08

Hello neighbour, i saw you're back.

Plenty more fish in the sea, can I have my money back until next time?

FAKE NEWS OP

crumblingschools · 13/02/2024 08:34

I’m assuming your £50 was a drop in the ocean compared to all the wedding money they received. Nice little earner for a 5 week marriage.

Friedchickenrocks · 13/02/2024 08:25

Shoxfordian · 13/02/2024 05:05

So on top of all the upset and unhappiness, you want your 50 quid back 🙄

A gift is supposed to be unconditional not based on the marriage lasting a certain amount of time.

I don't but it's the Indian guy who gave double that who is irked and suggested it. Had a Google and thought I'd seek the opinion here too. No, have no intention of asking. Wouldn't stoop so low. OH told me only to give 30 but doesn't get much these days and they're a lovely family. Always bringing us home made samosas and pakoras, onion bhajis

OP posts:
Friedchickenrocks · 13/02/2024 08:18

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 12/02/2024 23:47

Lad lives at home with his parents - doesn't he, and it was the family cat you were feeding.

YES. We have never met her. She was supposed to be here around Christmas and he said he'd bring her along to meet us.

OP posts:
Friedchickenrocks · 13/02/2024 08:16

Slanabhaile · 12/02/2024 23:41

This makes no sense, as your previous post makes out it was an arranged marriage ...got her visa and flight but since heard she's filing for divorce and doesn't want to come here as heard it gets cold in winter. She could have found that out easily online beforehand!!

If you know them so well & fed their cat ... how did she not know it was cold in winter?

Edited

How do I know. She's never been here before. Was in Qatar doing a degree than back to India to get married then apply for the visa. She'd only met him once before the wedding day as you must do to satisfy the rules. That's the excuse that his dad gave us but we know there has to be more to it.

OP posts:
NewFriendlyLadybird · 13/02/2024 07:46

fedupwithbeinghot · 12/02/2024 21:49

You can't understand her? You really can't understand that the poor girl might have been in love with someone else and detested her arranged marriage? That she might have been scared of telling her parents? That on seeing the husband and spending the wedding week with him she finally found the courage to say "fuck this"!

Arranged marriage doesn’t mean forced marriage.
We don’t know what happened but can’t assume it was like this.

PerfectTravelTote · 13/02/2024 07:34

I'm surprised at the responses. I thought that the protocol was to return the gifts under such circumstances. Filing for divorce after a few weeks (if that is actually what happened - your information is second hand and the wedding was 6 months ago) is much the same as cancelling the wedding.

tara66 · 13/02/2024 07:34

The ''form'' certainly used to be in these circumstances was that gifts were returned to sender - they were WEDDING gifts - so if marriage ended soon after - gifts were returned. This is known.

malificent7 · 13/02/2024 07:31

Gifts are gifts and should be no strings.. infortunately they are normally about the giver....not the reciever.

2mummies1baby · 13/02/2024 07:29

Slanabhaile · 12/02/2024 23:41

This makes no sense, as your previous post makes out it was an arranged marriage ...got her visa and flight but since heard she's filing for divorce and doesn't want to come here as heard it gets cold in winter. She could have found that out easily online beforehand!!

If you know them so well & fed their cat ... how did she not know it was cold in winter?

Edited

Huh? You realise it was the OP who fed the cat, right? Not the girl the son was engaged to?

Moonpig82 · 13/02/2024 07:27

No I wouldn’t. I’d say there is something behind it, everyone assumes people live in abject poverty in places like India and are desperate to come to England. More often than not these people’s standards of living are high and the thought of your education not being transferable, living in a smaller house with no house help, in a cold foreign country isn’t attractive.

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 13/02/2024 07:12

Good on the girl for realising it wasn't for her and being strong enough to put and end to her......that must take a lot of strength, she's done him a massive favour.

And no, I wouldn't be nagging him for the money back. That's weird.

whathappenedno · 13/02/2024 06:23

Nothing has changed. They got married and you gifted them. The fact that they are splitting is irrelevant

BobbyBiscuits · 13/02/2024 05:55

You're phrasing it almost as if the girl was being unreasonable to not want to stay married to a near stranger and move to a cold country where she knows no-one.
I would think if you do have sympathy for the lad then the last thing you should do is start hounding him for the return of your gift. Unless you literally think the whole thing was a ruse/scam to get loads of money off people?
I'd definitely not be asking for it back. I might not give a gift the 'next time' he has a wedding (Hopefully with someone who likes him this time?)

hopscotcher · 13/02/2024 05:30

I can see where your neighbour's coming from - morally they could think about returning money and gifts - but it's been given now, so needs to be written off, as with any gift given to a couple who later divorce.
I wouldn't ask for it back but you haven't said you're planning to - just posed the question to see what people think.

Readytoevolve · 13/02/2024 05:17

No the marriage happened!!

A good friend called off her (small intimate, abroad, family only) wedding the week before it. I had sent out about 300 to her with her sister…..
It took months to get it back. It was eventually transferred electronically (she lives in Canada) and she made me take the hit on the cost of the transfer losing about 30 quid.

Sour taste.

Zanatdy · 13/02/2024 05:12

Well if it’s a matter of weeks then yes really they should return the money / gifts. I personally would. A friend of mine was married for 5wks, father of her 2 DC and went on a work trip and met someone. End of marriage. Other mutual friends kicked off a bit, spent money on a hotel, outfit and gift but I personally just supported her. No money was returned as it was all spent on a honeymoon that was happening in the next summer hols but the money was lost as the husband found out about the affair the night before due to go, so it was all lost to the holiday company. She’s actually married to the guy she left her husband for now, 12yrs or so on, two children with him.

SunflowerSeeds123 · 13/02/2024 05:08

He can keep it. Maybe use the collection of money to go on holiday or something to help him heal from the rejection. Poor bloke.

Shoxfordian · 13/02/2024 05:05

So on top of all the upset and unhappiness, you want your 50 quid back 🙄

A gift is supposed to be unconditional not based on the marriage lasting a certain amount of time.

Swipe left for the next trending thread