Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Offended MIL went for lunch with BILs GF

111 replies

DeCourtes · 12/02/2024 18:10

Hey, so I’m probably being over sensitive but I’m quite upset. DH and I have 2 DC, 4 and 2. We’ve been together 10 years, married 6.
DH has a brother who is 11 years younger, he is definitely his parents favourite, he’s a competitive sportsman (earning money I mean, pro), he’s in the early stages and still quite young, obviously as a result his parents have put all their energy into him for many years.
MIL and I aren’t close, we live 10 minutes apart and see her maybe once every 3 weeks. She does have the kids more but doesn’t actually bother with DH or I. In the 10 years we’ve been together, we have never gone for lunch or dinner or a drink without DH. My own mum is currently living in New Zealand so I’d have loved more support from MIL, however it’s clear she’s not much of a fan of me.
BIL has a new girlfriend, she’s 20, been together since summer. Due to the nature of what he does he is hardly home though, so they haven’t actually spent loads of time together. Things seemed to get serious fast though. She is definitely more MILs type (very attractive and very well off) compared to me.
Today BIL was coming back to the uk for the first time since Christmas, obviously a big deal. MIL went down to London to see him off his flight. It’s 1.5 hours on the train and his flight wasn’t due in until 4. She went down first thing and had brunch with BILs girlfriend, has sent loads of pics of them together to the family group chat and added her to it??
Im really upset she’s putting more effort in with a GF of 7 months than a wife of 10 years.
DH just thinks it is what it is?!

AIBU to be offended and upset?

OP posts:
Ellie1015 · 13/02/2024 13:21

I expect she planned to go early in case or any delays or problems with train then girlfriend suggested they meet up as that is the polite thing to do.

She will make more effort for younger son because opportunities to see him are rarer.

She obviously loves grandchildren and puts in effort with them. Do you like her? Is she someone you want to be proper friends with? If so put in some effort to make it happen. Ie make a plan, offering a tea at drop off can be inconvenient for many reasons (although still nice).

IkeaMeatballGravy · 13/02/2024 12:08

MILs are told to know their place, don't interfere and wait to be invited. You've never properly invited her out and whittled down the time she has with the grandchildren so it's no wonder you don't have much of a bond with her.

It sounds like you only want a relationship with her because she now has another potential DIL on the scene.

Worcestershirem0mmy · 13/02/2024 11:51

Have you made much effort with MIL?

Underestimated4 · 13/02/2024 11:48

I feel you, my MIL has never really liked me. I’ve never done anything but just think she looks down her nose at me. She goes above and beyond for SIL and BIL and their kids but not to the level she ever has with me and husband. It’s hard but after this amount of time I don’t expect anything to change.

Padz · 13/02/2024 11:28

Just because you’ve been married to her son for 10 years doesn’t mean she has to Iike you enough to want to go out for brunch/lunch/dinner!!

MrsSkylerWhite · 13/02/2024 11:18

Your husband is right.

Mummabee87 · 13/02/2024 11:16

Try not to get upset over this. I doubt your actually upset over this situation, but more because you feel left out. I completely understand this. My mil is the same although my BIL doesnt have a partner and im the only DIL. I always hoped for the close relationship but since having children it just hasnt worked out that way. You just have to let it go and choose your battles. Mine are great in the sense they have the kids ect. Which i fully appreciate, but they prefer everything seperate with the kids. Even DH feels left out at times. Theres always a faff if we try to do something all of us. But i chose to marry DH not his family so just rise above it all now.
Maybe try getting to no the new gf and build a relationship there instead of with the mil. Thats what i would do if BIL met someone

KreedKafer · 13/02/2024 10:36

YABU. You very obviously don’t like your MIL and you clearly don’t enjoy each other’s company. That’s fine. Why would you want to have lunch with her?

It’s not really about how ‘serious’ BIL’s girlfriend is; presumably she and your MIL clicked as people, while you and MIL didn’t. And I’m guessing the girlfriend invited her to lunch.

Lwrenn · 13/02/2024 10:29

Can you use this as a chance to say, "Hey MiL, I'd love us to do something together? Could I treat you to lunch when you're free?", just be honest you'd enjoy more of a relationship than her just having the kids. If she doesn't want that you know where you stand, no harm done is there? You get to know for definite that it's never going to be the relationship you'd have liked and you move on.

SecondUsername4me · 13/02/2024 08:18

Why not invite her to stay for dinner once a month on the days she drops dc off?

You suggested coffee but "nothing ever came of it" why? "Hey, are you at a loose end any of the next few Saturdays? We could take a walk to town and grab coffee if you like?"

Coconutter24 · 13/02/2024 08:13

Nantescalling · 12/02/2024 21:40

Sounds as though she is doing quite a lot of negative things : taking your kids when you would prefer nursery school; never inviting you for a meal in 10 years and more. It sounds as though she has somehow written you off in the same way as the younger brother is out ofI ope you can turn the page. the limelight. Som comments say it's just jealousy - I would say more hurt. After so long, I would stop worrying about it and decide she is a pretty poor example of family unity. Seeing your family are elsewhere, it should have been obvious to her that she had a role to lay in your life. She hasn't bothered so don't let this become an issue with your hubby. There's nothing worse for a guy as being the umpire in a ping pong match between spouse and MIL !

MIL doesn’t just take the kids, OP’s husband also has a say in his children’s childcare and he’s happy for his mum to have them so OP said there was compromise there. MIL doesn’t just come and take the kids it’s agreed she can look after them. Your putting a lot of negativity on a grandma who see’s her grandkids kids twice a week to help the family, just because OP who is happy to see MIL every 3 weeks has said she’s upset she didn’t get invited out for brunch. The same OP who doesn’t make effort with MIL either (I don’t count “we should get coffee sometime” said once as much of an effort in 10 years)

Sighhhhh · 12/02/2024 23:19

The same way she insists on looking after your children, you should insist on spending time with her if that’s what you’d like.

However, I wonder what kind of energy and time you gave to her in the early stages of your relationship with your now-husband, and when your children were babies. If it was the typical MN “my MIL is now a stranger to us and is not allowed anywhere near my newborn but my mum and dad can practically live with us” but then years later “I’m upset that PILs treat us differently…and I’m also eyeing up inheritance from them”….then I’m not surprised.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 12/02/2024 23:19

she doesn’t sound very nice anyway
Yes, awfulness here abounds! That for x2 kids x2 weekly would be at £120 a day for both be a massive help to me!!

Easipeelerie · 12/02/2024 23:11

You can’t make her like you. You could insist on nursery as you’re uncomfortable sending your children to someone who has such antipathy towards their mother.

Silverbirch7 · 12/02/2024 23:04

Can't compute the bit about you'd rather they're in nursery but she insists. 🤷‍♀️

juanitasolis · 12/02/2024 22:59

Maybe she suggested they go for brunch as MIL was alone in London for a few hours. You say you said "we should" get a coffee, but you never actually followed it up with an invitation. Maybe text and say next time MIL is doing a drop off you have some cake and a cup of tea if she would like to come inside. A clear invitation, involving the children so its nice and easy. While eating ask her what he favourite cake is, then after that if you want to take it further you could message her the next month and say youve found a cafe that does a great favourite cake and would she like to meet there on X day.

Saschka · 12/02/2024 22:31

KrisAkabusi · 12/02/2024 20:01

You dislike her to the extent that you would rather your child went to nursery instead of spending time with their grandmother. No wonder she doesn't want to spend time with you!

Echoing this I’m afraid. If you don’t like her, and it doesn’t sound like you do, why on earth does it matter to you if she doesn’t want brunch with you?

Would you actually enjoy having brunch one on one with her? Because I can’t imagine you would.

chrisfromcardiff · 12/02/2024 22:27

DeCourtes · 12/02/2024 18:10

Hey, so I’m probably being over sensitive but I’m quite upset. DH and I have 2 DC, 4 and 2. We’ve been together 10 years, married 6.
DH has a brother who is 11 years younger, he is definitely his parents favourite, he’s a competitive sportsman (earning money I mean, pro), he’s in the early stages and still quite young, obviously as a result his parents have put all their energy into him for many years.
MIL and I aren’t close, we live 10 minutes apart and see her maybe once every 3 weeks. She does have the kids more but doesn’t actually bother with DH or I. In the 10 years we’ve been together, we have never gone for lunch or dinner or a drink without DH. My own mum is currently living in New Zealand so I’d have loved more support from MIL, however it’s clear she’s not much of a fan of me.
BIL has a new girlfriend, she’s 20, been together since summer. Due to the nature of what he does he is hardly home though, so they haven’t actually spent loads of time together. Things seemed to get serious fast though. She is definitely more MILs type (very attractive and very well off) compared to me.
Today BIL was coming back to the uk for the first time since Christmas, obviously a big deal. MIL went down to London to see him off his flight. It’s 1.5 hours on the train and his flight wasn’t due in until 4. She went down first thing and had brunch with BILs girlfriend, has sent loads of pics of them together to the family group chat and added her to it??
Im really upset she’s putting more effort in with a GF of 7 months than a wife of 10 years.
DH just thinks it is what it is?!

AIBU to be offended and upset?

F

Noseybookworm · 12/02/2024 22:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

skippy67 · 12/02/2024 22:16

Nantescalling · 12/02/2024 21:40

Sounds as though she is doing quite a lot of negative things : taking your kids when you would prefer nursery school; never inviting you for a meal in 10 years and more. It sounds as though she has somehow written you off in the same way as the younger brother is out ofI ope you can turn the page. the limelight. Som comments say it's just jealousy - I would say more hurt. After so long, I would stop worrying about it and decide she is a pretty poor example of family unity. Seeing your family are elsewhere, it should have been obvious to her that she had a role to lay in your life. She hasn't bothered so don't let this become an issue with your hubby. There's nothing worse for a guy as being the umpire in a ping pong match between spouse and MIL !

Blimey, you must be dizzy from all that spin.

ShippingNews · 12/02/2024 21:46

Back when I was younger I’d always say “we should get a coffee together”, she always said maybe and it never happened.

Is that really what you'd call "inviting her to brunch" though ? It's a very half-heated invitation to be honest. Try saying something like "Hey MIL, would you like to have lunch one day next week ? I've heard that new cafe in town is great ! " and see how she reacts.

Nantescalling · 12/02/2024 21:40

Sounds as though she is doing quite a lot of negative things : taking your kids when you would prefer nursery school; never inviting you for a meal in 10 years and more. It sounds as though she has somehow written you off in the same way as the younger brother is out ofI ope you can turn the page. the limelight. Som comments say it's just jealousy - I would say more hurt. After so long, I would stop worrying about it and decide she is a pretty poor example of family unity. Seeing your family are elsewhere, it should have been obvious to her that she had a role to lay in your life. She hasn't bothered so don't let this become an issue with your hubby. There's nothing worse for a guy as being the umpire in a ping pong match between spouse and MIL !

Tourmalines · 12/02/2024 21:37

chiwwy · 12/02/2024 21:25

Did you even read OP’s posts? OP has made an effort with MIL but has been rebuffed.

Any ‘conscientious’ effort should be made by MIL.

“how about going for a coffee sometime “ many years ago is hardly booking something in . Popping in for tea after looking after 2 kids all day is maybe not ideal for MIL either . And as far as MIL effort , well , she’s not the one on MN complaining .

MiddleClassProblem · 12/02/2024 21:37

I’m a bit confused. You see her every 3 weeks which seems like a lot and you’ve never tried arranging anything with her yourself other than a vague we should get coffee some time.

Maybe the GF knew she was coming and asked her to brunch? Maybe she liked GF showing an interest in her?

It’s hard to say if she just doesn’t like you if you haven’t made much effort yourself.

Nanny0gg · 12/02/2024 21:29

We 'should' have coffee isn't an invitation

Swipe left for the next trending thread