Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Offended MIL went for lunch with BILs GF

111 replies

DeCourtes · 12/02/2024 18:10

Hey, so I’m probably being over sensitive but I’m quite upset. DH and I have 2 DC, 4 and 2. We’ve been together 10 years, married 6.
DH has a brother who is 11 years younger, he is definitely his parents favourite, he’s a competitive sportsman (earning money I mean, pro), he’s in the early stages and still quite young, obviously as a result his parents have put all their energy into him for many years.
MIL and I aren’t close, we live 10 minutes apart and see her maybe once every 3 weeks. She does have the kids more but doesn’t actually bother with DH or I. In the 10 years we’ve been together, we have never gone for lunch or dinner or a drink without DH. My own mum is currently living in New Zealand so I’d have loved more support from MIL, however it’s clear she’s not much of a fan of me.
BIL has a new girlfriend, she’s 20, been together since summer. Due to the nature of what he does he is hardly home though, so they haven’t actually spent loads of time together. Things seemed to get serious fast though. She is definitely more MILs type (very attractive and very well off) compared to me.
Today BIL was coming back to the uk for the first time since Christmas, obviously a big deal. MIL went down to London to see him off his flight. It’s 1.5 hours on the train and his flight wasn’t due in until 4. She went down first thing and had brunch with BILs girlfriend, has sent loads of pics of them together to the family group chat and added her to it??
Im really upset she’s putting more effort in with a GF of 7 months than a wife of 10 years.
DH just thinks it is what it is?!

AIBU to be offended and upset?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
crumblingschools · 12/03/2024 14:07

Would you actually like brunch with your MIL, you don’t sound like you like her very much?

Do you ever invite them round for a meal?

TenderChicken · 12/03/2024 14:03

I think as far as shit MILs go, you haven't done too badly OP. She doesn't like you but still does childcare and doesn't cause drama from the sound of it.

It definitely could be worse, having read years worth of MIL threads on here!

NotARealWookiie · 13/02/2024 21:28

It costs me £8450 per year for 2 days nursery.

My mil could take my worst enemy for brunch if she saved me that much money.

skippy67 · 13/02/2024 21:20

Odingodof · 13/02/2024 17:44

It's also beyond rude to always turn down your offer of coffee or coming into the house, extremely rude.

The OP has said she'd rather her kids went to nursery than be looked after by her MIL. So she clearly doesn't like her. Maybe MIL has picked up on this which is why she refuses OP's insincere invitations. Not rude, just not a hypocrite.

Bladwdoda · 13/02/2024 20:05

Do people have to be treated exactly the same. I mean different people have different relationships. Obviously it’s not nice if someone is scapegoated or treated badly, but this doesn’t sounds as that level. Sounds like they just maybe get along more for whatever reason.

My FIL is, and always has been, pleasant and kind to me. He really doesn’t like my SIL husband however. So the relationship between FIL and his 2 children in law is very different, but we are very different people and my SILS husbands personality clashes with FILs where as mine doesn’t.

Ellie1015 · 13/02/2024 19:28

Redpaisley · 13/02/2024 13:41

Why would OP like her when MIL has rejected her offers to meet or spend any time together in last so many years? Would you?

If OP likes her then worth investing some energy in resolving the situation. If not then why look for anything more, if that is the case accept more distant relationship and try not to care about her having lunch with bil's girlfriend.

If mil is likeable it could be habit/taking relationship with OP for granted that is the issue rather than deliberate exclusion. (I don't think one brunch proves anything either way).

Butchyrestingface · 13/02/2024 18:39

DeCourtes · 12/02/2024 18:47

Well considering I’d rather they were in nursery than with her but she insists on having them - this is unlikely.

Why do you want to spend more time with her?? You clearly can't abide the woman! 😂

Mumof2girls2121 · 13/02/2024 18:29

Iv been with my partner 20 years have 2 kids, my SIL been with Older BIL for 15 years 1 kid, younger BIL girlfriend 1 year there’s pictures up of them in MIL house but none of me and SIL 😂😂😂

Odingodof · 13/02/2024 17:45

@lizdanvers have you read the op.

I don't think you have because op says when she was younger she would always invite mil out for coffee and now she always invites her in after mil drops off the children inspite of just getting home herself!.

Far from wanting free childcare: she doesn't want mill to look after them, at all.

Odingodof · 13/02/2024 17:44

It's also beyond rude to always turn down your offer of coffee or coming into the house, extremely rude.

lizdanvers · 13/02/2024 17:31

So you use your mil for childcare twice a week but you’ve never once taken her for lunch or coffee. It sounds like you’re the problem. I regularly used to go and visit my mil with our son when my husband was working. You have to put in the effort. It seems like you want the childcare but don’t want to make any effort with her.

Odingodof · 13/02/2024 17:30

@TellySavalashairbrush.. Sure. What i can guarantee is, i wouldn't "expect" to look after my gc twice a week without their mothers consent. I wouldn't drop off the children and run away as fast as I could.
I would show the mother of my grandchildren respect at the very least.

Boomer55 · 13/02/2024 17:30

She sounds like a great MIL - not sure what your problem is.🙄

Odingodof · 13/02/2024 17:28

@DeCourtes.. What she is illustrating, is that she can make an effort if she wants too and she can be nice and inclusive.

Your the mother of her gc and she's treating you with zero respect.

Because she can.
Because your dh is enabling this also.

I'd be very unhappy with my dc spending so much time with someone who seemed to hold me in such disdain

TellySavalashairbrush · 13/02/2024 17:26

Mils cannot win ! Damned if they take too much interest in their adult children and families lives, damned if they don’t . No where is it written that grandparents are obliged to look after grandchildren , or to be be best buddies with their dil or sil. Honestly wait until your children are adults and you will maybe understand how bloody difficult it is to keep everyone happy as a mother, mother in law and grandmother.

Livelifelaughter · 13/02/2024 17:08

The girlfriend is 20. Your MIL is basically treating her like a niece, I doubt it's a relationship that's equal. And I expect the girlfriend is sucking up a bit too...and your MIL is flattered by it all.
I get why you're upset but really, leave them to it. It doesn't sound as though you are that compatible anyway. But I do understand why you are upset.

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 13/02/2024 17:00

So OP didnt make efforts, nor did mother in law. Are you suggesting a 20 year old is making a lot of efforts with the mother of his bf?

"We should meet for coffee" isn't an invite. As explained it can come across a bit as "I'm making a courtesy offer but have no plans to actually do this"

We don't know for sure but it seems reasonable to assume GF offered to go out as they were in the same place at the same time... making an effort

Atichen · 13/02/2024 16:12

Not sur how to quote...you said "She is definitely more MILs type ... compared to me"

is that not your answer?

There are some people in my office I get on really well with, we can chat need stuff (spotted a mug on one girls desk in my first week and we’ve been work besties ever since) others who have a silliare sense of humor,/love to gossip/music taste and some who are just daft together i'd happy hang out outside of work (friends in real life) ... there are others I worked closely for a long time, chat in the office would go to a work do with but there's no shared interest, so conversation revoles around work and 'polite chitchat' (how's there kids doing etc holidays planned)

What are you &mil both passionately about, what are your shared intrestes (outside of you being related/the children)? Do you both love yoga or the kardashians or excited to reade vouge or starwars, do you want to swap makeup tips?

Redpaisley · 13/02/2024 16:11

GingerIsBest · 13/02/2024 14:03

I sort of understand why you're hurt except for this: Back when I was younger I’d always say “we should get a coffee together”, she always said maybe and it never happened.

If someone says, "oh, we should do coffee sometime" I take that to mean, "I like you and I want to maintain friendly relationships with you but I don't really have the time or inclination to make a proper effort so I'm not actually ever going to have coffee with you, I'm just making it clear that in theory, I would have a coffee if that ever came up."

If someone wants to have a coffee with me they'd say, "we should have a coffee - I'm usually free on Wednesday and Thursday mornings - would that ever work for you?"

So OP didnt make efforts, nor did mother in law. Are you suggesting a 20 year old is making a lot of efforts with the mother of his bf?

Reality is many people have different attitudes to / relationship with their children (and partners) if there is a huge gap between siblings. And usually the older siblings get the rawer deal as parents, and irrespective of the reasons, older children feel excluded or accept it as they are so used to it like Op's dh here. The first emotional bond people have with their parents and it hurts when for whatever reason there is a difference in how you are treated to your siblings. Op does not have her family here, so she wanted to be close to her MIL but MIL didnt show interest, maybe she was waiting for a gold plated invitation card for 8 course dinner as DIL asking her to stay for tea/ coffee was not proper enough. Now 10 years down the line, she is more open to the golden child and his potential partners, after all golden child must be more fun, have exciting stories, better places to invite.

Bladwdoda · 13/02/2024 14:07

Maybe they just get on more. Sadly you can’t guarantee that you get on with every family member the same way.

GingerIsBest · 13/02/2024 14:03

I sort of understand why you're hurt except for this: Back when I was younger I’d always say “we should get a coffee together”, she always said maybe and it never happened.

If someone says, "oh, we should do coffee sometime" I take that to mean, "I like you and I want to maintain friendly relationships with you but I don't really have the time or inclination to make a proper effort so I'm not actually ever going to have coffee with you, I'm just making it clear that in theory, I would have a coffee if that ever came up."

If someone wants to have a coffee with me they'd say, "we should have a coffee - I'm usually free on Wednesday and Thursday mornings - would that ever work for you?"

Cosyblankets · 13/02/2024 13:45

Someone you're not close to had lunch with someone else

Redpaisley · 13/02/2024 13:42

Padz · 13/02/2024 11:28

Just because you’ve been married to her son for 10 years doesn’t mean she has to Iike you enough to want to go out for brunch/lunch/dinner!!

True but OP can still feel bad about it.

Redpaisley · 13/02/2024 13:41

Ellie1015 · 13/02/2024 13:21

I expect she planned to go early in case or any delays or problems with train then girlfriend suggested they meet up as that is the polite thing to do.

She will make more effort for younger son because opportunities to see him are rarer.

She obviously loves grandchildren and puts in effort with them. Do you like her? Is she someone you want to be proper friends with? If so put in some effort to make it happen. Ie make a plan, offering a tea at drop off can be inconvenient for many reasons (although still nice).

Why would OP like her when MIL has rejected her offers to meet or spend any time together in last so many years? Would you?

Redpaisley · 13/02/2024 13:39

All the people making excuses for MIL and blaming OP, have never experienced a damily exclusion, hence all the comments OP soynds jealous, etc.

There are women who want to spend time with their grandkids but do not like the mothers of those grandchildren.

OP said she made efforts with MiL and that MIL prefers to spend time children.
I understand OP how it feels. My own granmother wanted to raise me, wanted me to call her mummy but didnt like my mother.

You are not unreasonable to feel rejected by your MIL, especially now you can see that she is friendlier with BIL's new gf. It is a bit strange she can find some kind of common ground with a 20 year old, who just turned adult but not with you, who has also given her precious grandchildren.
Maybe she does value her golden child a lot more to make more efforts to anyone who comes in his life. Maybe she will be more affectionate to his kids and forget abour yours (as she did about her elder son )when they are in picture.

Maybe it's time for you to accept that she does not value you and like you said you prefer to send kids to nursery, do that.