Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 12:47

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 12:41

I also note that you have dodged a question which gets to the heart of where your opinions emanate from...

I am genuinely not sure what you mean by this? Can you please explain?

In answer to your question no, I do not think that what the Israeli govt is doing now is justified.

And are their actions unjustified because they are Jewish, or because they are awful human beings.
This is what people are getting at...there will be someone along in a minute to tell you that holding that view is antisemitic.
That is the source of the outrage, that open discussion and debate is being shut down with shouts of antisemitism.
You don't hold that view because are disgusting and you should not feel ashamed of it.
Can you see why the discussion of Israel's verified and claimed actions need to be discussed without shouting antisemitism every time a view that people disagree with is expressed if it happens to involve people who happen to be Jewish.

Grandmasswag · 14/02/2024 12:47

bombastix · 14/02/2024 12:39

Rochdale is a very bad sign. You have George Galloway targeting this enraged Muslim vote. Division. Simon Danczuk for Reform which will be tacitly anti Islam, and then Ali who is morally useless. This is a pattern of division we could have in many other places in the UK. Very concerning

I agree. We are in for much more division. It’s similar I suppose to the trans issue in that it’s almost impossible to have a stance on it without greatly offending one ‘side’. The reason it’s a big issue for British Muslims is because Britain is actively supporting the massacre of thousands of innocent people. If we’re were a neutral bystander I don’t think it would have the same impact. For example the ethnic cleansing that’s going on in China isn’t a massive political issue here. It’s a very difficult situation for labour and they will lose votes over this. They’ve already lost 100’s of councillors haven’t they. Which is what prompted this meeting.

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 12:43

He said that Labour's suspension of another MP was 'driven by people in the media from certain Jewish quarters'. And you think that had he 'fact checked' he would not have said this?

Can you answer my question above please HelloWorld? I suppose that this is also not an anti-semitic trope? 🙄

OP posts:
Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 12:41

I also note that you have dodged a question which gets to the heart of where your opinions emanate from...

I am genuinely not sure what you mean by this? Can you please explain?

In answer to your question no, I do not think that what the Israeli govt is doing now is justified.

OP posts:
bombastix · 14/02/2024 12:39

Someonescatmum · 14/02/2024 12:36

@bombastix Exactly, we are in a right mess and we seem to get waylaid in culture wars and cancelling others.

Rochdale is a very bad sign. You have George Galloway targeting this enraged Muslim vote. Division. Simon Danczuk for Reform which will be tacitly anti Islam, and then Ali who is morally useless. This is a pattern of division we could have in many other places in the UK. Very concerning

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 12:39

I also note that you have dodged a question which gets to the heart of where your opinions emanate from...

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 12:38

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 12:33

I think he's words may have been wrong as he had not fact checked.
I do not believe he was antisemitic

He said that Israel 'deliberately took the security off ' and 'allowed the massacre' to happen. And you think that he should/could have fact checked this?

He said that Labour's suspension of another MP was 'driven by people in the media from certain Jewish quarters'. And you think that had he 'fact checked' he would not have said this?

Either you are extremely naive or something much worse but you seem unable to recognise anti-semitic tropes when they are staring you in the face.

Edited

You will clearly see everyone who disagrees with you as seeing things through 'antisemitic tropes'.
I feel that the negative comments about Israel's actions (including claims that they may have allowed events to happen) come from disgust at their actions so far, and their actions so far indicating that this wouldn't be unthinkable. There is a guardian article linked up thread around why this is a credible theory, and it isn't because the Israeli happen to be Jews, fit negative tropes etc.
You feel that such negative accusations against Israel could only come from prejudice and anti semitism.

Someonescatmum · 14/02/2024 12:36

@bombastix Exactly, we are in a right mess and we seem to get waylaid in culture wars and cancelling others.

EasternStandard · 14/02/2024 12:35

Someonescatmum · 14/02/2024 12:19

This thread reminds me of one of the TERF / gender wars threads.

Everyone shouting and people being 'disgusted' at others having nuanced views of the situations.

It seems like many on here are pro Israel no matter what, and they don't really care about the Labour Party candidates, it's just another opportunity to take the moral high ground about racism and antisemitism (regardless of whether justified) with a 'no debate' mentality.
I find a lot of the pro-trans enclave to be exactly the same.

There’s much ‘nuance’ around antisemitic conspiracy

Why do you want there to be?

What antisemitic conspiracy do you want to air?

bombastix · 14/02/2024 12:34

Someonescatmum · 14/02/2024 12:19

This thread reminds me of one of the TERF / gender wars threads.

Everyone shouting and people being 'disgusted' at others having nuanced views of the situations.

It seems like many on here are pro Israel no matter what, and they don't really care about the Labour Party candidates, it's just another opportunity to take the moral high ground about racism and antisemitism (regardless of whether justified) with a 'no debate' mentality.
I find a lot of the pro-trans enclave to be exactly the same.

It's an interesting point but basically I would not want to be represented by Ali or indeed someone on the other extreme, ie pro Israeli to the point of groupthink. I understand from the polling in Rochdale that for Muslim voters, Gaza is the number one issue. The UK has big problems if it's voters think like this, rather than focussing on local and national issues. It's a recipe for a divided society and it's not even one the UK can do much about. Look at the mess we are in, and yet this is apparently relevant.

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 12:33

stomachamelon · 14/02/2024 12:30

@HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou that's an emotive question.

It's quite factual.
As arguably was the question asked of me.
If you ask such questions of others you should be prepared to answer them.
Or should different people be treated differently?

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 12:33

I think he's words may have been wrong as he had not fact checked.
I do not believe he was antisemitic

He said that Israel 'deliberately took the security off ' and 'allowed the massacre' to happen. And you think that he should/could have fact checked this?

He said that Labour's suspension of another MP was 'driven by people in the media from certain Jewish quarters'. And you think that had he 'fact checked' he would not have said this?

Either you are extremely naive or something much worse but you seem unable to recognise anti-semitic tropes when they are staring you in the face.

OP posts:
stomachamelon · 14/02/2024 12:30

@HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou that's an emotive question.

noblegiraffe · 14/02/2024 12:28

Someonescatmum · 14/02/2024 12:19

This thread reminds me of one of the TERF / gender wars threads.

Everyone shouting and people being 'disgusted' at others having nuanced views of the situations.

It seems like many on here are pro Israel no matter what, and they don't really care about the Labour Party candidates, it's just another opportunity to take the moral high ground about racism and antisemitism (regardless of whether justified) with a 'no debate' mentality.
I find a lot of the pro-trans enclave to be exactly the same.

Well it certainly isn't short of posters who are willing to sail in and tell everyone else what their opinions are and why they are terrible people.

BobbyBiscuits · 14/02/2024 12:26

I don't know his reasoning, but I can only imagine that this bloke is very popular in his constituency and KS is banking on it being more beneficial to support him than not. Of course, nationally the decision will be very damaging for him. No politician should be calling for the death of innocent people simply based on their race. It's grim and vile. I don't know what KS stance is on going to war. I'm scared he might be like Blair on that but who knows.

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 12:25

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 12:23

Do you believe that Ali was wrong and that his words were anti-semitic?

I think he's words may have been wrong as he had not fact checked.
I do not believe he was antisemitic.

Whilst we are firing closed questions based on assumed beliefs, do you believe that Israel's genocide against the Palestinians to be justified?

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 12:23

Do you believe that Ali was wrong and that his words were anti-semitic?

OP posts:
HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 12:20

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 11:58

HelloWorld you are blatantly wrong here. I wonder what your motivation is for posting this stuff? I would be ashamed.

That's a really interesting take.
Ashamed.
I feel my views are balanced. My views are not negative about who any individual or group of people, who they are intrinsically, their beliefs, lifestyle etc
I hold negative views about those whose actions I consider morally wrong, regardless of what community, religious or otherwise, they belong to.
I do not feel that those who hold different beliefs to me should feel ashamed and quickly label them to be discriminatory.
I hold human life and wellbeing to be higher than any religious or cultural belief.
If you feel I should be ashamed of that perspective that is how you feel.
I would argue that you have internalised some preconceived ideas that you consider to be fact such as the idea that anyone criticising Israel or those who support their actions must be doing so under the influence of prejudice against Jews as opposed to an objective judgement.

Someonescatmum · 14/02/2024 12:19

This thread reminds me of one of the TERF / gender wars threads.

Everyone shouting and people being 'disgusted' at others having nuanced views of the situations.

It seems like many on here are pro Israel no matter what, and they don't really care about the Labour Party candidates, it's just another opportunity to take the moral high ground about racism and antisemitism (regardless of whether justified) with a 'no debate' mentality.
I find a lot of the pro-trans enclave to be exactly the same.

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 11:58

HelloWorld you are blatantly wrong here. I wonder what your motivation is for posting this stuff? I would be ashamed.

OP posts:
GRex · 14/02/2024 11:44

MandatoryLizLemonParty · 14/02/2024 11:27

Some people think that nothing short of murdering Jewish people while screaming 'I hate jews' can be anti-Semitic.

Although given some of the comments I've seen about 7/10, maybe not even then.

That's why I keep posting this one remark, because this is really just the easiest example of all. If anyone can't spot the anti semitism in what Ali said, they will not see it anywhere.

MandatoryLizLemonParty · 14/02/2024 11:27

Some people think that nothing short of murdering Jewish people while screaming 'I hate jews' can be anti-Semitic.

Although given some of the comments I've seen about 7/10, maybe not even then.

stomachamelon · 14/02/2024 11:25

Why issue this apology then?

Why is Starmer Standing by Azhar Ali?
GRex · 14/02/2024 11:24

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 11:13

You haven't linked to anything with the phrase 'Jewish media'.

I summarised the quote "media from certain jewish quarters", which was given up the thread many times.
Maybe the Daily Mail is easier for you to understand?
www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13075993/anti-Semitic-comments-Labours-Rochdale-candidate-Sir-Keir-Starmer-ditch-man.html
in the recording, Mr Ali said Mr McDonald 'shouldn't have been suspended' before adding: 'The media – and some of the people in the media from certain Jewish quarters – were giving crap about what he said.'

Or listen for yourself: www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2024/02/13/azhar-ali-audio-recording-labour-party-rochdale-by-election/.

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 11:18

dapsnotplimsolls · 14/02/2024 11:14

Offensive, inaccurate and anti-semitic would be better.

It is a criticism of the Israeli government rather than anti-Semitic. Offensive? If you are a member of the Israeli government maybe.
It can only be offensive to all Jewish people, if you are working on the premise that criticism of the Israeli government is a criticism of all Jewish people. I reject that. I despise the Israeli government's actions. I have absolutely no negative feelings towards people who are Jewish. I judge people who support the actions of Israel negatively.

Swipe left for the next trending thread