Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
dapsnotplimsolls · 14/02/2024 14:07

Guardian?

stomachamelon · 14/02/2024 14:03

apple.news/AZh5YRLfFQsiEIzeZ_6eUOQ

Guardian opinion piece.

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 14:03

Would you go as far as to call it genocide?

I don't think that's Israel's intention.

OP posts:
HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 14:02

MandatoryLizLemonParty · 14/02/2024 13:54

I didn't say you were the same.

You were the one who referred to the Anti-Semetic poster as "another poster with similar views to mine".

Well that's the exact opposite of what I have been posting, which makes it very odd that you think we are the same person?

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 14:00

I think that is so important. Although I don't agree that they were solely after Hamas earlier on, the ground invasion is a new level of awful. I get that the actions of Hamas are abysmal but that doesn't justify harming a single innocent in my view. And there were atrocities on both sides before the incident last autumn.

I believe that some of the actions of the UK government that allegedly represent me are evil. Does that make me and my young children a legitimate target of violence by those the UK government has wronged? I feel that this is the view aimed at Palestinians.

Most of all I am disgusted with the UK government (and obviously other governments but they don't represent me) that their priority has not been to work towards a ceasefire and peaceful resolution whatever the views of opposing sides are. If there had been unified pressure from across the world to pursue a peaceful solution and put diplomatic and commercial pressure on Israel to do so many lives could have been saved and such trauma could have been stopped.

I feel that human life is of greater importance than any aspect of the conflict.

I think that is where a lot of my frustration comes from, I think there are a lot of people who just don't want to see innocents being torn to pieces, who are being told that they are antisemitic for feeling that way.

Someonescatmum · 14/02/2024 13:56

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 13:47

In answer to someonescatmum

I think that the ground invasion of Rafah is a step too far. Where do the Palestinians go? I fully supported Israel in going after Hamas and trying to get back their hostages but the death and destruction is too much. It is not getting Israel anywhere and is losing them worldwide support.

As ever when men fight, women and children lose their lives and this happened to the Jewish people on Oct 7 and to the Palestinians ever since Israel started their campaign.

Hamas should stop firing their rockets at Israel and hand over the hostages so that a ceasefire can be brokered but I do not think that they will do this. So it will be left to Israel to negotiate a peace of sorts but I do not know how viable this is now.

Its a huge fucking mess and my heart breaks for all of the Jews and Palestinians who have been harmed and killed.

Edited

Would you go as far as to call it genocide?

MandatoryLizLemonParty · 14/02/2024 13:54

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 13:38

Oh for goodness sake are you being deliberately obtuse?
No, I am saying that I am not the user you previously referred to. Which I think you are fully aware of.

I didn't say you were the same.

You were the one who referred to the Anti-Semetic poster as "another poster with similar views to mine".

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 13:47

In answer to someonescatmum

I think that the ground invasion of Rafah is a step too far. Where do the Palestinians go? I fully supported Israel in going after Hamas and trying to get back their hostages but the death and destruction is too much. It is not getting Israel anywhere and is losing them worldwide support.

As ever when men fight, women and children lose their lives and this happened to the Jewish people on Oct 7 and to the Palestinians ever since Israel started their campaign.

Hamas should stop firing their rockets at Israel and hand over the hostages so that a ceasefire can be brokered but I do not think that they will do this. So it will be left to Israel to negotiate a peace of sorts but I do not know how viable this is now.

Its a huge fucking mess and my heart breaks for all of the Jews and Palestinians who have been harmed and killed.

OP posts:
HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 13:41

Someonescatmum · 14/02/2024 13:36

Why don't you agree with what Israel is doing?

Do I agree with their genocide against the Palestinians
No I bloody don't. I think it's evil.

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 13:38

MandatoryLizLemonParty · 14/02/2024 13:33

Right. So that one poster on 20 odd pages of posts is in the wrong. Agreed. You referred to it as though it was Ali who had inferred that.

Er... no I didn't. You asked who is blaming Jew [ish people] worldwide for Israel's actions and I told you who. I didn't even mention Ali.

Wow, there must be another poster with similar views to mine. Is that really unthinkable? Search the usernames you'll see we're not the same person.

Just an observation. And people can have multiple usernames and even multiple accounts. Not accusing you of anything, just saying.

Are you saying you have similar views to the poster who said that 'Jews control the media'.

Oh for goodness sake are you being deliberately obtuse?
No, I am saying that I am not the user you previously referred to. Which I think you are fully aware of.

Someonescatmum · 14/02/2024 13:36

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 12:41

I also note that you have dodged a question which gets to the heart of where your opinions emanate from...

I am genuinely not sure what you mean by this? Can you please explain?

In answer to your question no, I do not think that what the Israeli govt is doing now is justified.

Why don't you agree with what Israel is doing?

MandatoryLizLemonParty · 14/02/2024 13:33

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 13:18

Right. So that one poster on 20 odd pages of posts is in the wrong. Agreed. You referred to it as though it was Ali who had inferred that.

Wow, there must be another poster with similar views to mine. Is that really unthinkable? Search the usernames you'll see we're not the same person.

This level of paranoia is not healthy. Nobody is out to get you. There is no agenda. Just people who don't agree with you.

Right. So that one poster on 20 odd pages of posts is in the wrong. Agreed. You referred to it as though it was Ali who had inferred that.

Er... no I didn't. You asked who is blaming Jew [ish people] worldwide for Israel's actions and I told you who. I didn't even mention Ali.

Wow, there must be another poster with similar views to mine. Is that really unthinkable? Search the usernames you'll see we're not the same person.

Just an observation. And people can have multiple usernames and even multiple accounts. Not accusing you of anything, just saying.

Are you saying you have similar views to the poster who said that 'Jews control the media'.

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 13:21

You re clearly loving this embarrassment for Labour, thats very clear.
As you seem to quite like speculating that Labour knew all about this months ago and that they knew about Ali's anti-Semitic views.
Yet cannot produce any evidence for your two allegations whatsoever.

Seriously? 😂

OP posts:
stomachamelon · 14/02/2024 13:18

@jasflowers serious question. Do you think no one in the room mentioned it until the mail got hold of it?

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 13:18

MandatoryLizLemonParty · 14/02/2024 13:01

Who on earth is blaming Jews worldwide for Israel's actions?

There was a post earlier in the thread that did exactly that.

It's interesting that you popped up shortly after the poster talking about Jews controlling the media disappeared.

Right. So that one poster on 20 odd pages of posts is in the wrong. Agreed. You referred to it as though it was Ali who had inferred that.

Wow, there must be another poster with similar views to mine. Is that really unthinkable? Search the usernames you'll see we're not the same person.

This level of paranoia is not healthy. Nobody is out to get you. There is no agenda. Just people who don't agree with you.

jasflowers · 14/02/2024 13:16

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 09:16

If that person was so unhappy, why didn’t they report it at the time instead of taking it to the most right wing paper in existence?

How did you know that they didn't report it though? Big assumption to make.

PLUS - Labour have only themselves to blame for this, they selected this anti-semite presumably well aware of his views. Of course the press are going to go for maximum impact - they want to sell papers and get clicks! Had the Labour Party not supported this man there would be nothing to see here.

You re clearly loving this embarrassment for Labour, thats very clear.

As you seem to quite like speculating that Labour knew all about this months ago and that they knew about Ali's anti-Semitic views.

Yet cannot produce any evidence for your two allegations whatsoever.

bombastix · 14/02/2024 13:14

@Grandmasswag - I get that. But equally, the actions of the UK, its allies, long term foreign policy would all make that not a surprise to me.

Gaza really bothers me because it's the first time in my life I have seen something in the UK that is very similar to other divided societies in the world, where there are protests along religious lines, and that overwhelms national identity. It's going nowhere good if you say to people, yes, your religious identity is greater than your national identity, your obligation to neighbours and the wider community. People should think very carefully about where this will go in the end if they want a multiculturalism that has depended on non political discussion. It is absolutely foolish to imagine you can start asserting your religious identity can mean a greater leverage over a debate than anyone else. We are one society. Moral disgust at the conflict in Israel can be addressed in many ways. Politically you can address it and support peace. But putting religious identity as the why is a disaster for everyone.

noblegiraffe · 14/02/2024 13:07

So there's a non-Jewish poster trying to overrule Jews on what should be considered antisemitic?

MandatoryLizLemonParty · 14/02/2024 13:01

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 10:07

Who on earth is blaming Jews worldwide for Israel's actions?
I think there are some who would judge Jewish people negatively for continuing to support Israel, but I have seen nothing holding Jewish people to account.
The explanations of how disapproving of Israel's actions means you are anti-Semitic are becoming ever more tenuous...

Who on earth is blaming Jews worldwide for Israel's actions?

There was a post earlier in the thread that did exactly that.

It's interesting that you popped up shortly after the poster talking about Jews controlling the media disappeared.

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 13:00

FrancisSeaton · 14/02/2024 12:55

It seems we can only be anti semitic these days- you can't be anti Islamic though

I think most people would find both abhorrent.
I think this is an example of you doing what you accuse others of, peddling tropes.

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 12:59

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 12:53

HelloWorld I notice that you ignore my question re the Jewish control of the media.

Also nowhere on this thread has anyone said that criticising the govt of Israel is anti-semitic.

Unfortunately it is clear what you believe from your posts. I also find you to be very disingenuous so will leave others to engage with you from now on.

Edited

I have looked through everything you have liked and posted and can't find any reference to Jewish control of the media.
Just reference to some groups being vocal, which I agree there are some very vocal groups on both sides of the conflict.
I have missed this.phrase can you link to it specifically, because it does feel like this is your interpretation.
And if you have negative experiences of people applying that trope to you or people in your community, I understand how that has happened.
Of I have missed a phrase in the articles and quotes ( I have read them quickly) I stand corrected but I have looked again and cannot see any reference to 'Jewish control of the media'. Of I have missed that do you want to quote the phrase or paragraph where you have seen that phrase?

FrancisSeaton · 14/02/2024 12:55

It seems we can only be anti semitic these days- you can't be anti Islamic though

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 12:53

HelloWorld I notice that you ignore my question re the Jewish control of the media.

Also nowhere on this thread has anyone said that criticising the govt of Israel is anti-semitic.

Unfortunately it is clear what you believe from your posts. I also find you to be very disingenuous so will leave others to engage with you from now on.

OP posts:
EasternStandard · 14/02/2024 12:49

Division isn’t just in the UK

It will be hard for any society not to have similar views come to the surface

As many EU countries and US are finding out

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 12:49

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 12:43

He said that Labour's suspension of another MP was 'driven by people in the media from certain Jewish quarters'. And you think that had he 'fact checked' he would not have said this?

Can you answer my question above please HelloWorld? I suppose that this is also not an anti-semitic trope? 🙄

But there has been well documented claims from some Jewish groups (and I emphasise some) that to criticise Israel is antisemitic.

That is factually correct.