Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 21:47

All your waffle aside HelloWorld it is very clear what this man meant and you are pretending not to see it. You do you.

OP posts:
HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 20:51

MandatoryLizLemonParty · 14/02/2024 20:34

If you think considering making disparaging comments about "people in the media from certain Jewish quarters" to be anti-Semitic is tenuous then that says far more about you than everyone else.

No.

Some people have interpreted that as an accusation that 'Jews control the media'.
I don't. I interpret it as pointing out that some (emphasis on some) Jewish groups are very vocal about their belief that criticism of Israel is automatically antisemitic and this has been widely reported 'in the media'. As have the views of very vocal opponents of Israel's actions (who Infront believe 'control the media' either.

Is there a reason why you consider your interpretation should be given precedence?

To be fair, if you have been on the receiving end of assumptions based on anti Semitic tropes i can see why you would be more likely to see that in your interpretation, due to your loved experience.

If you are confident your interpretation just explain that, you undermine yourself with comments such as 'says more about you than other people.' similarly phrases such as 'ashamed' and 'disgusted' up thread.

You will notice that I am explaining my viewpoint without lowering myself to commenting on what your opinion 'says about you'. It says you have a different opinion. No more, no less. I suspect that you mainly discuss this issue with people who share your viewpoint entirely in something of an echo chamber, hence your absolute outrage that other people don't see things exactly as you do, and this could only be explained by them being morally inferior.

MandatoryLizLemonParty · 14/02/2024 20:34

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 19:39

There has been some tenuous interpretation though

If you think considering making disparaging comments about "people in the media from certain Jewish quarters" to be anti-Semitic is tenuous then that says far more about you than everyone else.

noblegiraffe · 14/02/2024 19:40

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 19:39

There has been some tenuous interpretation though

In your opinion.

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 19:39

noblegiraffe · 14/02/2024 19:35

Yes. However other people do.

There has been some tenuous interpretation though

Someonescatmum · 14/02/2024 19:35

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 17:58

So someone saying Israel is guilty of genocide is antisemitic is it, how?

So you WERE being sarcastic. My apologies, I thought you may have been engaging in good faith.

Um no, im asking you to answer a question.

You don't think that what Israel is doing is right, though you also don't think they intend to commit genocide?

Is accusing Israel of genocide antisemitism or not.

noblegiraffe · 14/02/2024 19:35

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 19:16

And as stated previously, I don't see that any of these things has happened.

Yes. However other people do.

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 19:17

maudelovesharold · 14/02/2024 18:25

What’s more important - intention or outcome? Is it ok to obliterate a people, as long as that isn’t your primary intention? How much collateral damage is acceptable? Is there no point at which the world will say ‘this far and no further’? I thought there would be, but it seems not…
Genocide or not - just semantics. Look at what’s actually happening to the people.

Honestly, I don't think it's possible to cause that much suffering without serious intent.

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 19:16

noblegiraffe · 14/02/2024 18:44

Here you go, here's the definition of antisemitism that the Labour Party have signed up to.

https://holocaustremembrance.com/resources/working-definition-antisemitism

It includes: "

  1. Making mendacious, dehumanizing, demonizing, or stereotypical allegations about Jews as such or the power of Jews as collective — such as, especially but not exclusively, the myth about a world Jewish conspiracy or of Jews controlling the media, economy, government or other societal institutions."

And as stated previously, I don't see that any of these things has happened.

stomachamelon · 14/02/2024 19:06

apple.news/AfTBVpqahSMCnHSigNJmh6g

ITV news. (And I double-checked)

noblegiraffe · 14/02/2024 18:44

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 17:51

If it is being used as a legally recognised term, and people can lose jobs etc if accused of it (and rightly so where discrimination/ racism have occured), dialogue about what constitutes antisemitism must include those across society.
I have seen someone up thread quote the American Jewish Committee's definition of anti-Semitism as though it is definitive. Yet the landing page of the website clearly states that one of their aims is to support Israel.
If the term is to be legally recognised in that way (and it absolutely should be) there needs to be much more robust consideration to it's meaning.

Here you go, here's the definition of antisemitism that the Labour Party have signed up to.

https://holocaustremembrance.com/resources/working-definition-antisemitism

It includes: "

  1. Making mendacious, dehumanizing, demonizing, or stereotypical allegations about Jews as such or the power of Jews as collective — such as, especially but not exclusively, the myth about a world Jewish conspiracy or of Jews controlling the media, economy, government or other societal institutions."

What is antisemitism?

With the IHRA working definition of antisemitism, the IHRA built international consensus around an answer to the question, what does antisemitism mean?

https://holocaustremembrance.com/resources/working-definition-antisemitism

dapsnotplimsolls · 14/02/2024 18:29

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 18:24

Labour are still better than the Tory scum

Is that you Angela?

No, but I wonder if she was at the infamous meeting.

maudelovesharold · 14/02/2024 18:25

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 14:03

Would you go as far as to call it genocide?

I don't think that's Israel's intention.

What’s more important - intention or outcome? Is it ok to obliterate a people, as long as that isn’t your primary intention? How much collateral damage is acceptable? Is there no point at which the world will say ‘this far and no further’? I thought there would be, but it seems not…
Genocide or not - just semantics. Look at what’s actually happening to the people.

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 18:24

Labour are still better than the Tory scum

Is that you Angela?

OP posts:
bombastix · 14/02/2024 18:21

@TempestTost - it's a ridiculous theory. The Israeli Government doesn't need an excuse. Legally, their position has always been that it is a disputed terrority, and they have always been clear that they would use military force if they wanted. This is obviously greatly at odds with the UN and many other countries politically including the UK, who would not agree with that.

Israel does not need any excuses. What I think people did not expect from them is the use of Russian/Syrian military tactics where you obliterate the infrastructure and people with it.

dapsnotplimsolls · 14/02/2024 18:16

I suspect there's more to come from that same meeting.

dapsnotplimsolls · 14/02/2024 18:16

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 18:14

dapsnotplimsolls you clearly think that there is more anti-semitic crap to come from Labour otherwise why say that more recordings will come out? And yet you will vote for them?

Yes, I don't base my vote on a single issue. Labour are still better than the Tory scum.

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 18:14

dapsnotplimsolls you clearly think that there is more anti-semitic crap to come from Labour otherwise why say that more recordings will come out? And yet you will vote for them?

OP posts:
dapsnotplimsolls · 14/02/2024 18:09

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 17:56

If the by-elections go badly for the Tories tomorrow, I'm sure there'll be more recordings etc splashed all over the right-wing press on Friday

You have a pretty low opinion of the Labour Party don't you?

Eh? I'll probably vote for them. Even though it's pointless where I live.

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 18:07

Tempest he has said further things which are very clearly anti-semitic.

OP posts:
TempestTost · 14/02/2024 18:03

So this guy heard that Israel had been warned of the attacks ahead, and he thought they had failed to act on this because they wanted to have an excuse to attack Hamas?

It's not just speculation, but pretty accepted, that Hamas is quite happy to draw attacks on the Palestinian people so as to create sympathy for them, and turn people against Israel.

States do things like this too, and it would not shock me to find Israel had done something similar. The question is whether it is true. But I'd not dismiss it out of hand.

If Ali really believed this is what happened, I don't think it would have to suggest any kind of antisemitism. If he repeated it despite knowing it wasn't true, that might suggest antisemitism.

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 17:58

So someone saying Israel is guilty of genocide is antisemitic is it, how?

So you WERE being sarcastic. My apologies, I thought you may have been engaging in good faith.

OP posts:
Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 17:56

If the by-elections go badly for the Tories tomorrow, I'm sure there'll be more recordings etc splashed all over the right-wing press on Friday

You have a pretty low opinion of the Labour Party don't you?

OP posts:
HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 17:51

noblegiraffe · 14/02/2024 13:07

So there's a non-Jewish poster trying to overrule Jews on what should be considered antisemitic?

If it is being used as a legally recognised term, and people can lose jobs etc if accused of it (and rightly so where discrimination/ racism have occured), dialogue about what constitutes antisemitism must include those across society.
I have seen someone up thread quote the American Jewish Committee's definition of anti-Semitism as though it is definitive. Yet the landing page of the website clearly states that one of their aims is to support Israel.
If the term is to be legally recognised in that way (and it absolutely should be) there needs to be much more robust consideration to it's meaning.