Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Dogfisher · 12/02/2024 14:39

There are very good definitions of what antisemitism is. Here’s one: AJC

But the one used in the UK is by the IHRA I believe?

https://www.ajc.org/sites/default/files/pdf/2021-10/A%20Guide%20to%20Recognizing%20When%20Anti-Israel%20Actions%20Become%20Antisemitic.pdf

OP posts:
LizzieSiddal · 12/02/2024 14:39

When I heard about this my first thought was he must be sacked, but as others have said, he cant be. Starmer should be publicly condemning what this man has said in the strongest way because it’s plainly nonsense.

However I genuinely do not know why what he said was antisemitic, to me he’s clearly talking about the government, not the people of the country.

Citrusandginger · 12/02/2024 14:38

Why is Starmer standing by him? I hate to say it but maths.

However unpleasant the thought is, and however appalling antisemitism is, that area has more voters of Asian origin than Jews.

The comments won't damage the outcome.

notherday · 12/02/2024 14:38

Pretty appalling that people pretend they can’t see the anti-semitism in a conspiracy theory that has blood thirsty Jews secretly collaborating behind the scenes to be able to carry out their twisted, bloodthirsty plans. Especially a conspiracy theory that uses a racist brutal massacre against the Jewish who were its victims, by saying they connived to allow it. Thus upending Jewish victims into Jewish perpetrators.

Anti-semitism is rife and pervasive as these posters show. October 7th shone light on you all.

sorestupid · 12/02/2024 14:38

I do not think this guys words hold Israel to a different standard as exactly this daft hindsight criticism was also levied towards the USA around 9/11 and MI5 around 7/7.

which MPs believed the conspiracy theories re the above?

Dotjones · 12/02/2024 14:37

Starmer is a very weak leader. He's standing behind him in this case because of his weakness. His whole approach is not to commit to a position on anything (other than saying he's committed to a position and then going on to reverse it).

He's the reason Labour could still pull off a 1992-style cock-up in the next General Election. The trouble with him is a consequence of his legal background I think, his career was built upon the principle of argument over fact, and that's a trait he carries with him.

His only real argument is "we're not the Tories" which isn't enough for many. Truss wasn't Johnson. Biden isn't Trump, and Trump isn't Biden. Few would argue just because they were different they were/would be a particularly good replacement.

stomachameleon · 12/02/2024 14:36

@Yorkshirelass04 you do realise some posters on here don't live in the uk? There are several from Israel.

stomachameleon · 12/02/2024 14:35

@roarrfeckingroar true.

Yorkshirelass04 · 12/02/2024 14:32

It's very curious that some posters on this board are more likely to trust the Israeli government's actions than our own MPs.

Let's face it... the attack on Israel HAS allowed them to do what they want.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 12/02/2024 14:31

There are very good definitions of what antisemitism is. Here’s one: AJC

I cannot see that what this guy said - which I agree was dumb - falls under any of these and for this reason I fail to be able to classify it as antisemitism. I do not think this guys words hold Israel to a different standard as exactly this daft hindsight criticism was also levied towards the USA around 9/11 and MI5 around 7/7.

This does not detract from the awful fact that there are many horrible examples of antisemitism occurring now in connection with the Hamas attacks and subsequent action taken by Israel. And those are absolutely clearly examples of antisemitism and fit perfectly the descriptions provided by AJC.

https://www.ajc.org/sites/default/files/pdf/2021-10/A%20Guide%20to%20Recognizing%20When%20Anti-Israel%20Actions%20Become%20Antisemitic.pdf

roarrfeckingroar · 12/02/2024 14:30

Because Labour needs the Muslim vote and don't care about weeding out antisemitism.

Dogfisher · 12/02/2024 14:27

Some people will find any excuse to carry on voting for a party that consistently hurts the poor and disabled and fucks the country over. Give yourself a pat on the back 🙄

How strange that you assume my voting intentions. 🙄

OP posts:
AdrianaLaCerva · 12/02/2024 14:26

I agree with you @Dogfisher, I can’t vote for it either.

sorestupid · 12/02/2024 14:26

Because what he said doesn’t attack Jewish people for being Jewish.

Imo it’s minimising & prejudice.

It was a dumb thing to say but what he said suggests a government / intelligence organisation underperformed.

I wouldn’t say security services underperforming equals “allowing an attack so the gov can do what they want”. To me they are different things…

Even if it is a conspiracy theory it's not antisemitic to be suspicious. In the same way it's not anti American to have suspicions about 9/11 (which plenty of people do).

I don’t remember any MPs saying the American gov allowed the attack in the subsequent months?

Dogfisher · 12/02/2024 14:26

No. I will not vote for an anti-Semitic party and left the LP when Corbyn took over. I have not rejoined yet and am unlikely to in the near future.

And that's apart from the hideous misogyny in the party - a different argument for another day.

OP posts:
BloodandGlitter · 12/02/2024 14:24

Dogfisher · 12/02/2024 14:19

It's odd because those who pretend that he has said nothing wrong seem to be LP supporters and cannot see that Starmer not roundly condemning this is harming the LP badly.

I would love to go back to voting Labour but clearly anti-Semitism is still ok after all and I will not vote for that.

Some people will find any excuse to carry on voting for a party that consistently hurts the poor and disabled and fucks the country over. Give yourself a pat on the back 🙄

Yorkshirelass04 · 12/02/2024 14:20

Dogfisher · 12/02/2024 14:19

It's odd because those who pretend that he has said nothing wrong seem to be LP supporters and cannot see that Starmer not roundly condemning this is harming the LP badly.

I would love to go back to voting Labour but clearly anti-Semitism is still ok after all and I will not vote for that.

The you're cutting your nose off to spite your face.

Yorkshirelass04 · 12/02/2024 14:20

@brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr

Exactly.

Dogfisher · 12/02/2024 14:19

It's odd because those who pretend that he has said nothing wrong seem to be LP supporters and cannot see that Starmer not roundly condemning this is harming the LP badly.

I would love to go back to voting Labour but clearly anti-Semitism is still ok after all and I will not vote for that.

OP posts:
brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 12/02/2024 14:17

sorestupid · 12/02/2024 14:14

@brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr

you don’t think it’s antisemitic to say Isreal allowed the attack? Why is it not antisemitic?

Because what he said doesn’t attack Jewish people for being Jewish.

It was a dumb thing to say but what he said suggests a government / intelligence organisation underperformed.

Yorkshirelass04 · 12/02/2024 14:16

Why are you so sure it's a conspiracy theory?

Israel security so crap they had no idea that over 1000 people were going to be murdered. And multiple states lying about having warned them.

Pull the other one.

Even if it is a conspiracy theory it's not antisemitic to be suspicious. In the same way it's not anti American to have suspicions about 9/11 (which plenty of people do).

This guy is entitled to his view and I'm not going to fall about crying racism for it... or allow it to affect our own elections. Because that would be righteous and stupid:

stomachameleon · 12/02/2024 14:15

@Dogfisher ignore the baiters. The faux ignorant. The baffled.

It's obvious what he said that was wrong. He was taped saying it and has seen apologised for being grossly offensive.

Still not enough for some people.

sorestupid · 12/02/2024 14:14

@brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr

you don’t think it’s antisemitic to say Isreal allowed the attack? Why is it not antisemitic?

Dogfisher · 12/02/2024 14:12

You don't think that spouting fictitious conspiracy theories (which apparently he claims that he 'fell for') about the torture and murder of Jewish people is anti-Semitic?

OP posts:
sorestupid · 12/02/2024 14:09

It's rather more shocking that they had absolutely no idea a coordinated offensive to murder their citizens was unfolding... they really were that ignorant and caught unawares... (despite having an excellent security service)

Not shocking looking at history. The CIA repeatedly warned the US government that a big Al Qaeda attack was coming. MI5 missed an opportunity to stop the Manchester bombing. It does happen…