Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
LizzieSiddal · 12/02/2024 15:02

@Neriah Using " it's antisemitic" as a weapon to shut down discourse is anti-democratic. There is legitimate discourse to be had about the tactics of both Hamas and Israel. Trying to shut down that discourse won't solve the issues of the Middle East. He was insensitive, but not antisemitic. But of course you are perfect, so would never make an error...

I agree with this, there are many antisemtic tropes which are disgraceful but to use that to say it is antisemitic to condemning an ultra right wing government, (who only a few months ago had many protests against their policies,) does nobody any good.

Dogfisher · 12/02/2024 15:00

Starmer is prioritising votes over principle. I think it will backfire… it might lead to a win in this particular constituency, but it’s an own goal from a wider perspective because it shows the electorate that all his banging on about rooting out anti-Semitism from the party was bullshit

I agree.

OP posts:
Dogfisher · 12/02/2024 14:59

But of course you are perfect, so would never make an error...

An error? FFS. That's what you call his disgusting comments?

OP posts:
notherday · 12/02/2024 14:59

Itscatsallthewaydown · 12/02/2024 14:55

And for those saying ‘I don’t see how it’s antisemitic’, then go and google antisemitic tropes.
Jewish people are fucking sick of having to explain it to you.

This.

This thread is really showing the truth of that phrase that if you don't teach people history, then history will repeat itself.

So here we have ancient anti-Semitic tropes in full light, and people seemingly can't recognise them.

Is this stuff not taught in history lessons anymore?

notherday · 12/02/2024 14:57

Itscatsallthewaydown · 12/02/2024 14:53

He’s either antisemitic, or he’s a moron easily taken in by conspiracy theories. Either way he’s not fit to be a candidate.

He's an an anti-semitic moron easily taken in by conspiracy theories.

Neriah · 12/02/2024 14:56

Dogfisher · 12/02/2024 13:48

In the recording, which has not been heard by the BBC, Mr Ali is alleged to have said: "The Egyptians are saying that they warned Israel 10 days earlier... Americans warned them a day before [that] there's something happening... They deliberately took the security off, they allowed... that massacre that gives them the green light to do whatever they bloody want."

I consider this to be anti-Semitic and I guess he did too otherwise why proffer his fulsome apology?

The question is why Starmer has not sacked him.

Neither support8ngb him, nor Starmer.... but I read the same, or similar, comments on the BBC website weeks ago, suggesting that Israel had been warned about an impending attack. Not seeing what is antisemitic about it. Wrong it may be ( I don't know what warning they did or didn't have, nor would a warning be of any help unless it was specific) but not antisemitic. I do not agree with what Israel is doing in Gaza. That doesn't make me antisemitic. A lot of Jews don't agree either - did that make them antisemitic?

Using " it's antisemitic" as a weapon to shut down discourse is anti-democratic. There is legitimate discourse to be had about the tactics of both Hamas and Israel. Trying to shut down that discourse won't solve the issues of the Middle East. He was insensitive, but not antisemitic. But of course you are perfect, so would never make an error...

stomachameleon · 12/02/2024 14:56

@SquirrelsStars that even more concerning.

EasternStandard · 12/02/2024 14:56

Itscatsallthewaydown · 12/02/2024 14:55

And for those saying ‘I don’t see how it’s antisemitic’, then go and google antisemitic tropes.
Jewish people are fucking sick of having to explain it to you.

Well said

(not Jewish but agree entirely)

AdrianaLaCerva · 12/02/2024 14:56

Starmer is prioritising votes over principle. I think it will backfire… it might lead to a win in this particular constituency, but it’s an own goal from a wider perspective because it shows the electorate that all his banging on about rooting out anti-Semitism from the party was bullshit.

LoobyDop · 12/02/2024 14:55

The majority of Labour activists are more concerned about islamophobia than they are about antisemitism. Not saying that’s the case with Starmer himself, but that’s where his foot soldiers are, and that’s the audience he needs to keep onside.

Itscatsallthewaydown · 12/02/2024 14:55

And for those saying ‘I don’t see how it’s antisemitic’, then go and google antisemitic tropes.
Jewish people are fucking sick of having to explain it to you.

Itscatsallthewaydown · 12/02/2024 14:53

He’s either antisemitic, or he’s a moron easily taken in by conspiracy theories. Either way he’s not fit to be a candidate.

LizzieSiddal · 12/02/2024 14:51

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 12/02/2024 14:43

I think it's possible to think it was wrong to say what he said and at the same time not think it's anti semetic/be anti semetic, surely?

Agree very much with this.

oursdhjf · 12/02/2024 14:50

Another not understanding how it's antisemitic

SquirrelsStars · 12/02/2024 14:49

Starmer kicked Corbyn out after he lost the election for them big time. Before that, he was quite happy to sit in his cabinet (unlike some other MPs) and enthusiastically campaigned for him to be PM.

And Azhar Ali is not just some also-ran councillor, he is the leader of the Labour party group at Lancashire County Council and made these comments at a meeting of the Lancashire Labour group where he presumably thought these comments would be welcome.

notherday · 12/02/2024 14:48

LizzieSiddal · 12/02/2024 14:43

I’m not pretending!

So with your example if I was to say something awful about the government of Pakistan, that would be Islamophobia?

You're right that some people may genuinely be ignorant of the long history of the nature of anti-Semitism and have absorbed anti-Semitic beliefs without realising it.

I suggest you read up on the sort of anti-Semitic tropes that have been in existence for centuries so that you can see this latest one as the clear part of that continuum that it is.

roarrfeckingroar · 12/02/2024 14:48

Dogfisher · 12/02/2024 14:39

There are very good definitions of what antisemitism is. Here’s one: AJC

But the one used in the UK is by the IHRA I believe?

Exactly

sorestupid · 12/02/2024 14:47

I’m a member of the Labour Party and I’m aghast.I don’t believe a word of his apology, and he needs to go immediately.

His excuse is stupid.

LizzieSiddal · 12/02/2024 14:45

SquirrelsStars · 12/02/2024 14:43

Starmer is standing behind him because he doesn't really care about anti-semitism in the Labour party - after all, he was right behind Corbyn and wanted him to be leader not so long ago. Also, he knows the party hasn't really changed and there is still a lot of support for those sort of views both within the party and also from some voters.

It's one of two reasons I would never vote Labour - the other being the wholesale destruction of women's rights and safety on the trans altar.

Starmer is married to a Jewish woman and kicked Corbyn out of the party as soon as he had the power to do so.

Itscatsallthewaydown · 12/02/2024 14:44

I’m a member of the Labour Party and I’m aghast.
I don’t believe a word of his apology, and he needs to go immediately.

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 12/02/2024 14:43

I think it's possible to think it was wrong to say what he said and at the same time not think it's anti semetic/be anti semetic, surely?

SquirrelsStars · 12/02/2024 14:43

Starmer is standing behind him because he doesn't really care about anti-semitism in the Labour party - after all, he was right behind Corbyn and wanted him to be leader not so long ago. Also, he knows the party hasn't really changed and there is still a lot of support for those sort of views both within the party and also from some voters.

It's one of two reasons I would never vote Labour - the other being the wholesale destruction of women's rights and safety on the trans altar.

LizzieSiddal · 12/02/2024 14:43

notherday · 12/02/2024 14:38

Pretty appalling that people pretend they can’t see the anti-semitism in a conspiracy theory that has blood thirsty Jews secretly collaborating behind the scenes to be able to carry out their twisted, bloodthirsty plans. Especially a conspiracy theory that uses a racist brutal massacre against the Jewish who were its victims, by saying they connived to allow it. Thus upending Jewish victims into Jewish perpetrators.

Anti-semitism is rife and pervasive as these posters show. October 7th shone light on you all.

Edited

I’m not pretending!

So with your example if I was to say something awful about the government of Pakistan, that would be Islamophobia?

Dogfisher · 12/02/2024 14:42

I agree with you notherday. It's bloody grim.

OP posts:
EasternStandard · 12/02/2024 14:40

stomachameleon · 12/02/2024 14:15

@Dogfisher ignore the baiters. The faux ignorant. The baffled.

It's obvious what he said that was wrong. He was taped saying it and has seen apologised for being grossly offensive.

Still not enough for some people.

God this thread I’m surprised

Constituency probably op