Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
notherday · 12/02/2024 16:18

Yorkshirelass04 · 12/02/2024 16:06

Careful about criticising Israel killing children for the past 4 months. That's probably antisemitic as well.

But you know... better not vote Labour, just in case!

Thank you for this. It so neatly illustrates the dishonest, diversionary tactics in argument that I referred to earlier.

stomachameleon · 12/02/2024 16:17

@sorestupid tell me your antisemitic without telling me eh?
Just one big humongous pot. Better give Bibi a bell!

sorestupid · 12/02/2024 16:15

The Israeli government does not get a free pass from criticism. And criticising them doesn’t make anyone anti semitic. I will defend my right to criticise any government until I’m blue in the face. Christ knows I criticise the Tories enough!

Nobody is arguing that you cannot criticise the Israeli government, I certainly do. However do you believe the Tories allowed the Manchester bombing to happen to strengthen their campaign & retain power?

Baileyscream · 12/02/2024 16:15

I'm local to Rochdale. It's definitely tactical. Many Labour voters are turning to Galloway and by allowing this to be said clearly Labour hope to get some of the voters back. I personally hope Tulley wins or Paul Ellison both are local to my area and want change. I really hope Ali or Galloway don't get in but to be honest that's what I think will happen.

sorestupid · 12/02/2024 16:11

I'm disappointed that the Jewish community worldwide is not demanding a more moderate government in Israel, not least because the current policy in Israel is putting a target on the back of Jews all over the world.

Basically everything is the fault of the Jews but no antisemitism here people 🧐

stomachameleon · 12/02/2024 16:11

@Yorkshirelass04 that was in answer to your question.

It's very curious that some posters on this board are more likely to trust the Israeli government's actions than our own MPs.

MrTiddlesTheCat · 12/02/2024 16:08

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 12/02/2024 14:05

What did he say that was antisemitic ?

He said that Israel reduced security to allow the attacks to justify going into Gaza. Portaying jews as 'deceitful conspirators' is literally part of the definition of antisemitism, as set out by the IHRA.

Yorkshirelass04 · 12/02/2024 16:06

LizzieSiddal · 12/02/2024 15:12

The anti-Semitism comes from the fact that Israel definitely knew an attack was coming and DELIBERATELY allowed it, so that they could destroy Israel. As I said above, its this caricature of Jews as bloodthirsty and secretly collaborating behind the scenes, this reversal of Jews as victims to Jews as perpetrators, that makes it anti-Semitic.

The Israeli army have killed 10 THOUSAND children in the past few months. They are coming across as pretty bloodthirsty to me. That does not mean I think all Jewish people are bloodthirsty.

Edited

Careful about criticising Israel killing children for the past 4 months. That's probably antisemitic as well.

But you know... better not vote Labour, just in case!

Yorkshirelass04 · 12/02/2024 16:02

stomachameleon · 12/02/2024 14:36

@Yorkshirelass04 you do realise some posters on here don't live in the uk? There are several from Israel.

I don't understand what that has to do with it? But may explain the bias.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 12/02/2024 16:01

Soupit · 12/02/2024 15:54

I clicked on this thread expecting to see universal condemnation of this man and Labour's failure to suspend him.
I should have known better. Is it just MN that is riddled with anti semitism or is it representative of British society? I despair.

Because what he said is not antisemitic.

EasternStandard · 12/02/2024 16:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

notherday · 12/02/2024 15:59

MorrisZapp · 12/02/2024 15:46

I have never in my life considered Jewish people to have shared character traits, and the idea that I might consider them 'blood thirsty' is laughable. However, in this conflict Israel has murdered thousands of innocent adults and children, so I do consider the current government of Israel to be blood thirsty. They are demonstrating this through their internationally verified actions. Are we supposed to pretend it isn't happening because of historical tropes?

This thread is about an MP saying that Israel knew the Oct 7th attacks were happening and connived to allow them, for their own ends.

Its helpful to read and understand the thread before responding to others. It helps prevent misplaced attacks.

EasternStandard · 12/02/2024 15:59

Soupit · 12/02/2024 15:54

I clicked on this thread expecting to see universal condemnation of this man and Labour's failure to suspend him.
I should have known better. Is it just MN that is riddled with anti semitism or is it representative of British society? I despair.

Same

AdamRyan · 12/02/2024 15:56

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-67958260.amp

For years, units of young female conscripts had one job here. It was to sit in surveillance bases for hours, looking for signs of anything suspicious. In the months leading up to the 7 October attacks by Hamas, they did begin to see things: practice raids, mock hostage-taking, and farmers behaving strangely on the other side of the fence.It was clear to some of these women that Hamas was planning something big - that there was, in Noa's words, a "balloon that was going to burst".

We do have free speech in this country. Given all the reports like this^^ I'm not surprised some people feel the security services of Israel must have deliberately ignored the signs (I'm in the cock up rather than conspiracy camp personally; I think the IDF wrongly assumed their defences couldn't be breached and were complacent).

The candidate has fully apologised now and there isn't time to take him off the ballot. I think this is being used as a smear building on the Labour reputation for antisemitism.

Female soldiers who guarded Israel's border

They were Israel's 'eyes on the border' - but their Hamas warnings went unheard

A unit of young female soldiers warned of a big attack. They were among the first Hamas killed on 7 October.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-67958260.amp

stomachameleon · 12/02/2024 15:55

@Growlybear83 Galloway that pretended to be a cat on big brother? Can't see why he wouldn't be taken seriously?

Soupit · 12/02/2024 15:54

notherday · 12/02/2024 15:44

Incredible isn't it?

But not only that, that poster is blaming Jews for the anti-Semitism they are facing. Anti-Semites aren't even responsible for their own racism, Jewish people are.

How can these people not hear themselves?

I clicked on this thread expecting to see universal condemnation of this man and Labour's failure to suspend him.
I should have known better. Is it just MN that is riddled with anti semitism or is it representative of British society? I despair.

Kazzyhoward · 12/02/2024 15:53

Apart from being anti-Jew, it also shows he's particularly stupid either for falling for such a stupid conspiracy theory, or for believing others are so stupid for believing he fell for a stupid conspiracy theory. Do the voters in his area really want an elected representative to be so stupid??

Goldenbear · 12/02/2024 15:52

Dotjones · 12/02/2024 14:37

Starmer is a very weak leader. He's standing behind him in this case because of his weakness. His whole approach is not to commit to a position on anything (other than saying he's committed to a position and then going on to reverse it).

He's the reason Labour could still pull off a 1992-style cock-up in the next General Election. The trouble with him is a consequence of his legal background I think, his career was built upon the principle of argument over fact, and that's a trait he carries with him.

His only real argument is "we're not the Tories" which isn't enough for many. Truss wasn't Johnson. Biden isn't Trump, and Trump isn't Biden. Few would argue just because they were different they were/would be a particularly good replacement.

You have got that the wrong way round, the Tories manifesto is, 'attack' what are their policies, oh hang on tax cuts which we can't afford and won't work!

Skodacool · 12/02/2024 15:50

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 12/02/2024 13:53

But again, why is it antisemitic ? It’s certainly a dumb thing to say.

You’re right. Criticism of Israel is not, as many seem that believe, automatically antisemitic. He put it clumsily but it isn’t beyond the realms of possibility that Netanyahu would do it to cling onto power.

MorrisZapp · 12/02/2024 15:46

notherday · 12/02/2024 15:40

Criticising a government based on stuff it actually is doing = probably not anti-Semitic.

Fabricating stuff about a government based on long-standing racist tropes = anti-Semitic.

Body swerving in a debate by swivelling onto a different area when you can't defend your position anymore = not terribly honest debating technique.

I have never in my life considered Jewish people to have shared character traits, and the idea that I might consider them 'blood thirsty' is laughable. However, in this conflict Israel has murdered thousands of innocent adults and children, so I do consider the current government of Israel to be blood thirsty. They are demonstrating this through their internationally verified actions. Are we supposed to pretend it isn't happening because of historical tropes?

notherday · 12/02/2024 15:46

MissyB1 · 12/02/2024 15:43

Agreed. I will judge Israel on their actions, and yeah bloodthirsty does seem to fit the bill at the moment!
The Israeli government does not get a free pass from criticism. And criticising them doesn’t make anyone anti semitic. I will defend my right to criticise any government until I’m blue in the face. Christ knows I criticise the Tories enough!

Does your criticism of the Conservative party involve making up lies about Tories based on racist tropes? If not, its not really comparable to what is being discussed on this thread.

notherday · 12/02/2024 15:44

LoveAHamSandwhich · 12/02/2024 15:39

So, once again, we are blaming jews worldwide for the actions of Israel?

You know what that is, don't you...

Incredible isn't it?

But not only that, that poster is blaming Jews for the anti-Semitism they are facing. Anti-Semites aren't even responsible for their own racism, Jewish people are.

How can these people not hear themselves?

MissyB1 · 12/02/2024 15:43

MorrisZapp · 12/02/2024 15:34

My position too. I don't understand how criticising a government must be banned because of historic tropes. Israel is as Israel does, tropes have nothing to do with it.

Agreed. I will judge Israel on their actions, and yeah bloodthirsty does seem to fit the bill at the moment!
The Israeli government does not get a free pass from criticism. And criticising them doesn’t make anyone anti semitic. I will defend my right to criticise any government until I’m blue in the face. Christ knows I criticise the Tories enough!

WhatWhereWho · 12/02/2024 15:43

Growlybear83 · 12/02/2024 15:24

The Guardian link backs up exactly what I've been hearing from my daughter and her Palestinian husband since 7 October. Now that this has emerged in a credible newspaper, I suspect that far more will follow. The Labour Party candidate only voiced what many people have known for the last four months. I don't think he should have apologised. But if it's the case as another poster suggested that the labour vote is all going to George Galloway, then I would be delighted. He's been out of parliament for too long.

That you are a fan of Galloway speaks volumes about you, none of it good.

EasternStandard · 12/02/2024 15:40

LoveAHamSandwhich · 12/02/2024 15:29

Indeed they don't. They are antisemitic conspiracists.

Yes and I’m sorry people have to read it and see it supported politically