Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
stomachamelon · 15/02/2024 20:20

@Puzzledandpissedoff he makes other elements sound positively liberal and misunderstood.

I Don't know what's wrong with the world.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 15/02/2024 17:34

DreamVortex · 15/02/2024 16:34

He sounds unhinged tbh.

Also semi literate Confused
His ramblings aren't easy to read, but I see he managed to get the "paymasters" and "Christ killers" in there - and it's said there are more to come

Whatafustercluck · 15/02/2024 17:14

BBC seem to really be doubling down on the leader of the opposition at the moment. It's almost as if there's an election happening this year.

GRex · 15/02/2024 17:13

DreamVortex · 15/02/2024 16:34

He sounds unhinged tbh.

Unhinged is mild, utterly insane. Also reads like he's encouraging terrorist attacks, on top of the anti semitism. Why can't he spell "state" anyway?

LoveAHamSandwhich · 15/02/2024 17:13

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Why would anyone say that? It's clearly anti-Semitic.

systemthirtytwo · 15/02/2024 17:09

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Notsoslim · 15/02/2024 17:03

BIossomtoes · 15/02/2024 16:56

Busy getting stuck into the recession - which apparently is Labour’s fault.

Why the scepticism? It is! Don’t you know Gordon Brown crashed the economy
in 2008 and Conservatives have only had things back in their hands for…14 years 😆

(sarcasm btw!)

BIossomtoes · 15/02/2024 16:56

jasflowers · 15/02/2024 16:40

Our fav Tory supporters all off the thread now?

Busy getting stuck into the recession - which apparently is Labour’s fault.

Abhannmor · 15/02/2024 16:49

MushMonster · 14/02/2024 17:30

My ignorance knows no boundaries! I did not know about jewish labour members getting in trouble for antisemitism.
35 pending, 11 expelled or suspended in my first google search on the subject.
Surely this cannot be true, I would not expect jewish people to be antisemites, but surely, never that many.
This is not looking good....

Yes alas. I stumbled upon this thanks to being an Alexei Sayle fan. Afaik he hasn't been expelled himself. Despite being Jewish. Possibly was never a member? Perhaps they can evict imaginary members though. Watch this space.

jasflowers · 15/02/2024 16:40

Our fav Tory supporters all off the thread now?

DreamVortex · 15/02/2024 16:34

He sounds unhinged tbh.

Grandmasswag · 15/02/2024 16:24

We don’t know what he said. I’m thinking it must have been pretty bad and they are keeping it hush !

BIossomtoes · 15/02/2024 16:21

Puzzledandpissedoff · 15/02/2024 16:18

What's this latest one supposed to have said - anyone know?

Obviously the main issue is holding antisemitic views at all, but I swear that some of these people's brains fall out once they get on social media Hmm

They’re being very coy about what he said.

Councillor Atiqul Hoque has been expelled for sending "offensive and inappropriate comments on WhatsApp and social media", according to a statement released by the Conservative Party.

The statement from the party did not disclose the nature of the messages that were the subject of the formal complaint, but following a BBC report, the party has now confirmed to the Journal that the messages were allegedly anti-Semitic.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 15/02/2024 16:18

bombastix · 15/02/2024 12:22

I note the Mayor of Salisbury (Conservative) has left the Conservatives after his antisemitic remarks. Good

What's this latest one supposed to have said - anyone know?

Obviously the main issue is holding antisemitic views at all, but I swear that some of these people's brains fall out once they get on social media Hmm

BIossomtoes · 15/02/2024 16:08

Grandmasswag · 15/02/2024 16:02

Funny though that this one seems to have passed the Mail by completely.

Yes, that’s very odd, isn’t it?

Grandmasswag · 15/02/2024 16:02

bombastix · 15/02/2024 12:22

I note the Mayor of Salisbury (Conservative) has left the Conservatives after his antisemitic remarks. Good

Funny though that this one seems to have passed the Mail by completely.

bombastix · 15/02/2024 12:22

I note the Mayor of Salisbury (Conservative) has left the Conservatives after his antisemitic remarks. Good

jasflowers · 15/02/2024 08:08

stomachamelon · 14/02/2024 13:18

@jasflowers serious question. Do you think no one in the room mentioned it until the mail got hold of it?

I ve no idea how the DM got hold of the speech.

Its not unknown for reporters to pretend they are someone who they are not or to pay someone to do this sort of stuff, clearly it was felt though that last October was not the right time to release...

Not criticising the DM by the way, its important these people are driven out of all parties, as the Tories have just down with their council leader in Salisbury who has abhorrent views too.

noblegiraffe · 15/02/2024 00:21

Different peoples perspectives are relevant. They can make us over or under sensitive to things.

AND it can make people know more about things than other people.

People who have experience of things know more about it than other people.

My lived experience is of being outraged at death and injury in Gaza and vocally calling for a peaceful way forward and having people attempt to gaslight me into believing this is antisemitic.

This dude was complaining about the actions of Jews in the media. It doesn't take much experience of antisemitism to know that this is a thing.

If you don't know that this is a thing then you perhaps should do more research into antisemitism.

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 15/02/2024 00:06

noblegiraffe · 14/02/2024 23:02

What is interesting is that you accept that some people who have been on the receiving end of antisemitism have a different lived experience of antisemitism to you and therefore might interpret things in a different way while completely ignoring that their lived experience of antisemitism might be exactly the reason why you should shut up and listen to them instead of telling them that they're wrong.

Different peoples perspectives are relevant. They can make us over or under sensitive to things.
The problem is that when someone has a negative lived experience it can make them more likely to a particular interpretation, which is not necessarily more accurate.
The issues being discussed affect everyone because our government are taking a stance and decisions around the conflict.
Nobody affected by the issues needs to shut up. Everyone needs to listen to each other.
My lived experience is of being outraged at death and injury in Gaza and vocally calling for a peaceful way forward and having people attempt to gaslight me into believing this is antisemitic.
This is nothing at all to the horrific lived experiences of those in Gaza.
If you want to share your lived experience please do, it would more useful to shared understanding of those issues than telling people to shut up.

Thanks to the UK government insisting on standing by and allowing genocide, and actively attacking those who stand against it, I have teenagers who are genuinely worried that the will be conscripted into the army or that there will be some sort of terrorist attack in the UK triggered by this.

I have seen a comment up thread saying 'its ok to be antisemitic but not anti-Islamic,' showing that the dialogue of not being able to criticise Israel and their allies, for fear of accusations of anti-semitism are emboldening those who clearly harbour anti-Islamic' sentiment.

I am going to leave this thread. There are several posters who are clearly.only used to hearing discussions in an echo chamber and refuse to see that other perspectives may be relevant.

noblegiraffe · 14/02/2024 23:02

What is interesting is that you accept that some people who have been on the receiving end of antisemitism have a different lived experience of antisemitism to you and therefore might interpret things in a different way while completely ignoring that their lived experience of antisemitism might be exactly the reason why you should shut up and listen to them instead of telling them that they're wrong.

MandatoryLizLemonParty · 14/02/2024 22:26

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 22:04

Getting angry isn't helping you.
There are indeed vocal groups who label any criticism of Israel as antisemitic and this perspective is propagated by large sections of the media. You are interpreting what he said as controlling the media.
I disagree.
Getting agitated isn't going to change that.
Listen to the venom in your post 'how the fuck'...'twisted'...'wilfully blind'.
I am not blind to those tropes but I don't believe that is what is happening here.

People should not be accused of something because of a trope related to their protected characteristics.
However if someone's actions indicate they might be guilty of something it is ok to say that.

I'm from a city where there are lots of tropes about gangs and crime. Would it be wrong to label me a criminal because of the city I'm from. Of course not.
Would it be ok to call me a criminal if I were caught climbing out of someone's window with a bag of nicked goods. Absolutely, that's not discrimination.

No group religiously, ethnically, culturally or otherwise is beyond reproach for their actions.

I feel very angry that for a long time, those opposed to Israel's atrocities in Gaza have been labelled antisemitic. I am angry that that accusation is still coming loudly through the media. That does not mean I think someone is controlling the media.

And let's not forget we had a prime minister who referred to islamic women in hijab as letterboxes, black people as having watermelon smiles etc ... I hope you were suitably vocal when faced undisputable blatant racism as when someone says something which, some people are interpreting as antisemitic.

I'm not angry, or agitated. If anything I'm sad. Sad that people like you still exist, you go out of your way to claim that what any reasonable person can see is anti-Semitism isn't. Who dedicates their time into gaslighting people I to believing that saying "Jewish people in the media" doesn't mean "Jewish people in the media".

And let's not forget we had a prime minister who referred to islamic women in hijab as letterboxes, black people as having watermelon smiles etc ... I hope you were suitably vocal when faced undisputable blatant racism as when someone says something which, some people are interpreting as antisemitic.

Well that says it all doesn't it? If it's against Jewish people it's not blatant racism, it's a thing which some people interpret as anti-Semitic.

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 22:04

MandatoryLizLemonParty · 14/02/2024 21:49

"The media, and some of the people in the media from certain Jewish... er... quarters were giving him shit about what he said".

TBH I'm not sure how the fuck you twisted that into to "the media have reported on some Jewish groups being vocal about their belief that criticism of Israel is automatically anti-Semitic".
"The media, and some of the people in the media from certain Jewish... er... quarters were giving him shit about what he said".

He's clearly saying that Jewish people in the media are giving Andy McDonald crap. I mean you have to be really willfully blind to interpret "Jewish people in the media" as "the media reporting on Jewish people".

To be fair, if you have been on the receiving end of assumptions based on anti Semitic tropes i can see why you would be more likely to see that in your interpretation, due to your loved experience.

You don't have to be Jewish to know that the idea of Jewish people controlling the media is widespread and goes back decades if not centuries. Don't pretend you're not aware of this.

Getting angry isn't helping you.
There are indeed vocal groups who label any criticism of Israel as antisemitic and this perspective is propagated by large sections of the media. You are interpreting what he said as controlling the media.
I disagree.
Getting agitated isn't going to change that.
Listen to the venom in your post 'how the fuck'...'twisted'...'wilfully blind'.
I am not blind to those tropes but I don't believe that is what is happening here.

People should not be accused of something because of a trope related to their protected characteristics.
However if someone's actions indicate they might be guilty of something it is ok to say that.

I'm from a city where there are lots of tropes about gangs and crime. Would it be wrong to label me a criminal because of the city I'm from. Of course not.
Would it be ok to call me a criminal if I were caught climbing out of someone's window with a bag of nicked goods. Absolutely, that's not discrimination.

No group religiously, ethnically, culturally or otherwise is beyond reproach for their actions.

I feel very angry that for a long time, those opposed to Israel's atrocities in Gaza have been labelled antisemitic. I am angry that that accusation is still coming loudly through the media. That does not mean I think someone is controlling the media.

And let's not forget we had a prime minister who referred to islamic women in hijab as letterboxes, black people as having watermelon smiles etc ... I hope you were suitably vocal when faced undisputable blatant racism as when someone says something which, some people are interpreting as antisemitic.

MandatoryLizLemonParty · 14/02/2024 21:49

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 14/02/2024 20:51

No.

Some people have interpreted that as an accusation that 'Jews control the media'.
I don't. I interpret it as pointing out that some (emphasis on some) Jewish groups are very vocal about their belief that criticism of Israel is automatically antisemitic and this has been widely reported 'in the media'. As have the views of very vocal opponents of Israel's actions (who Infront believe 'control the media' either.

Is there a reason why you consider your interpretation should be given precedence?

To be fair, if you have been on the receiving end of assumptions based on anti Semitic tropes i can see why you would be more likely to see that in your interpretation, due to your loved experience.

If you are confident your interpretation just explain that, you undermine yourself with comments such as 'says more about you than other people.' similarly phrases such as 'ashamed' and 'disgusted' up thread.

You will notice that I am explaining my viewpoint without lowering myself to commenting on what your opinion 'says about you'. It says you have a different opinion. No more, no less. I suspect that you mainly discuss this issue with people who share your viewpoint entirely in something of an echo chamber, hence your absolute outrage that other people don't see things exactly as you do, and this could only be explained by them being morally inferior.

"The media, and some of the people in the media from certain Jewish... er... quarters were giving him shit about what he said".

TBH I'm not sure how the fuck you twisted that into to "the media have reported on some Jewish groups being vocal about their belief that criticism of Israel is automatically anti-Semitic".
"The media, and some of the people in the media from certain Jewish... er... quarters were giving him shit about what he said".

He's clearly saying that Jewish people in the media are giving Andy McDonald crap. I mean you have to be really willfully blind to interpret "Jewish people in the media" as "the media reporting on Jewish people".

To be fair, if you have been on the receiving end of assumptions based on anti Semitic tropes i can see why you would be more likely to see that in your interpretation, due to your loved experience.

You don't have to be Jewish to know that the idea of Jewish people controlling the media is widespread and goes back decades if not centuries. Don't pretend you're not aware of this.