Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
EasternStandard · 14/02/2024 09:11

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 09:09

I would be interested to know who knew what and when but we will never find this out.

Good on the person who released it

Vile views from a few in that meeting.

Although Labour stood by after first release and only stood down on second

BIossomtoes · 14/02/2024 09:10

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 08:59

This anti-semitic rhetoric happened at a Labour Party meeting didn't it? So if your argument is that Starmer was unaware because no-one at the meeting reported it, then that means that party members there were absolutely fine with it apart from the one that blew the whistle/informed the press. Not sure which is worse really but either way it looks shit for Labour doesn't it?

Not reporting something doesn’t mean you agree with it. If that person was so unhappy, why didn’t they report it at the time instead of taking it to the most right wing paper in existence? When it was too late to replace Ali as a candidate. The timing’s just too convenient - two by elections tomorrow and too late to put up another candidate in Rochdale.

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 09:09

I would be interested to know who knew what and when but we will never find this out.

OP posts:
Grandmasswag · 14/02/2024 09:05

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 08:59

This anti-semitic rhetoric happened at a Labour Party meeting didn't it? So if your argument is that Starmer was unaware because no-one at the meeting reported it, then that means that party members there were absolutely fine with it apart from the one that blew the whistle/informed the press. Not sure which is worse really but either way it looks shit for Labour doesn't it?

Presumably it was a very grass roots level, local councils type meeting. The amount of shit that’s spouted at those meetings of all political spheres, well I doubt either Starmer or Sunak could possibly be kept abreast of every controversial thing that is said in local meetings. These things only come to light when they are reported on/leaked. Take the conservative councillors saying that people with SEN might be better being locked away in institutions for example. It’s only because the press picked up on it that anyone is any the wiser those things were said.

EasternStandard · 14/02/2024 09:04

Grandmasswag · 14/02/2024 08:45

By all accounts Ali was traditionally seen as as an ally of the Jewish community and worked closely with them to improve multicultural relations. Apparently this is quite out of character for him. The next potential storm will be who actually gets elected. I feel like it’s altogether possible that he might. What happens then?

It’s clear that in a private meeting he felt safe to express antisemitic conspiracy

Some joined in

Someone recorded and released, his own party I assume. This is all within Labour

And most of the views I’ve heard have been from Labour factions arguing their side

Unlike this thread though with supporters of the antisemitic conspiracy it’s been indefensible

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 08:59

This anti-semitic rhetoric happened at a Labour Party meeting didn't it? So if your argument is that Starmer was unaware because no-one at the meeting reported it, then that means that party members there were absolutely fine with it apart from the one that blew the whistle/informed the press. Not sure which is worse really but either way it looks shit for Labour doesn't it?

OP posts:
Grandmasswag · 14/02/2024 08:59

jasflowers · 14/02/2024 08:51

If Ali gets elected, he must be reinstated as thats democracy, the electorate have heard his views, dont consider them anti semitic and want him as their MP.

Or do we decide who people can vote for? Posters on here support Meloni/Le Penn etc after all.

After all, no one stopped Boris Johnson from being a tory MP when he came out with articles that were racist and homophobic.

Edited

I quite agree. I just fear that a this foreign conflict will inflame certain community tensions and destabilise the U.K. further.

Notsoslim · 14/02/2024 08:56

Grandmasswag · 14/02/2024 08:36

It is interesting that we know there are many racists, bigots, antisemites and Islamophobes in the Tory party (probably more than labour could dream of) and yet the right wing press never kick up a stink about that. Ali tipped over into antisemitism foolishly with the Jews control the media trope but had he simply stated that right wing press use antisemitism/anti Israeli sentiment in the Labour Party as a smear I think he’d have been bang on the money.

What he said about Israel is not remotely controversial. Supposing he had levelled similar accusations agains Putin no one would bat an eyelid. Let’s not forget that the supposed reason for the invasion of Ukraine is to ‘stamp out Nazism’. Or that America had intel about the TT (which they did) giving them the convenient reason for yet another foreign invasion. Warmongering governments do like to give excuses for the destruction they are bringing. Netanyahu is up there with the biggest psychopaths on the planet. He is a bloodthirsty warmonger who doesn’t give a shit about other people dying, Israeli or Palestinian. He has stated his aims. He wants the Palestinian state wiped out.

All of this!! Yes he should have focused it on the right wing press which would’ve been more accurate and fair to say. He shot himself in the foot there.

noblegiraffe · 14/02/2024 08:55

MushMonster · 14/02/2024 07:41

Hold on, I just read the article published today in the Guardian and there is a detail there I had missed. This meeting was a private meeting and held in October? So, somebody recorded and held the evidence till now? It makes no sense and sounds like manipulation to me, to be honest. Not that what they say is not wrong, but why holding on to it for months?
I had also missed the dismisal for Andy McDonald, as not following the news closely these days. Now, the sentence he said, according to the newspaper, is a wish for peace and the life of civilians in peace and harmony. If this is called anti-semitic, then it makes zero sense to me. And I do see a massive breach on the right of freedom of thought and speech on that one! That is, if his only crime is saying what is published.

Three people have just been charged with supporting terrorism for wearing images of paragliders to a pro-Palestinian march in October.

Their lawyer argued that the paraglider was an image representing peace and freedom. Do you believe that argument too?

Just because someone claims that something is a wish for peace doesn't mean that there are other reasonable interpretations.

From the river to the sea is used by Hamas to call for the eradication of Israel. A phrase best avoided.

Notsoslim · 14/02/2024 08:52

So true @jasflowers Boris et al got away with Islamophobic and anti- Black comments.

jasflowers · 14/02/2024 08:51

Grandmasswag · 14/02/2024 08:45

By all accounts Ali was traditionally seen as as an ally of the Jewish community and worked closely with them to improve multicultural relations. Apparently this is quite out of character for him. The next potential storm will be who actually gets elected. I feel like it’s altogether possible that he might. What happens then?

If Ali gets elected, he must be reinstated as thats democracy, the electorate have heard his views, dont consider them anti semitic and want him as their MP.

Or do we decide who people can vote for? Posters on here support Meloni/Le Penn etc after all.

After all, no one stopped Boris Johnson from being a tory MP when he came out with articles that were racist and homophobic.

Notsoslim · 14/02/2024 08:50

Sausage1989 · 14/02/2024 08:32

Exactly!! It wasn't anti Jewish. Its got RIDICULOUS NOW. You can't even have a discussion without being called anti semitic. You don't get this with anything else!

I’m inclined to agree, I’ve been reading through this thread and honestly don’t really get it, but don’t like speaking over peoples lived experiences. So I’m going to ask some of my pro Palestine Jewish friends and see what they think as they’re usually fairly objective compared to many others.

Perhaps I’m missing something so I’ll keep an open mind.

Grandmasswag · 14/02/2024 08:45

By all accounts Ali was traditionally seen as as an ally of the Jewish community and worked closely with them to improve multicultural relations. Apparently this is quite out of character for him. The next potential storm will be who actually gets elected. I feel like it’s altogether possible that he might. What happens then?

EasternStandard · 14/02/2024 08:44

Dogfisher · 13/02/2024 17:36

And now Graham Jones has also been suspended. It's a can of worms and it's now burst open. Vile. 🙄

Here

dapsnotplimsolls · 14/02/2024 08:41

EasternStandard · 14/02/2024 08:39

Another reiterated similar so it sounds accepted

Who was in the meeting? Was it all Labour if so a colleague released the recording

What's a reiterated similar?

EasternStandard · 14/02/2024 08:39

dapsnotplimsolls · 14/02/2024 08:36

I'd be interested to know if anybody pulled him up on his comments at the meeting.

Another reiterated similar so it sounds accepted

Who was in the meeting? Was it all Labour if so a colleague released the recording

Grandmasswag · 14/02/2024 08:39

dapsnotplimsolls · 14/02/2024 08:36

I'd be interested to know if anybody pulled him up on his comments at the meeting.

I thought I heard someone in the background saying ‘you can’t say that’ but I’ve only listened to it once. I might be mistaken.

dapsnotplimsolls · 14/02/2024 08:36

I'd be interested to know if anybody pulled him up on his comments at the meeting.

Grandmasswag · 14/02/2024 08:36

It is interesting that we know there are many racists, bigots, antisemites and Islamophobes in the Tory party (probably more than labour could dream of) and yet the right wing press never kick up a stink about that. Ali tipped over into antisemitism foolishly with the Jews control the media trope but had he simply stated that right wing press use antisemitism/anti Israeli sentiment in the Labour Party as a smear I think he’d have been bang on the money.

What he said about Israel is not remotely controversial. Supposing he had levelled similar accusations agains Putin no one would bat an eyelid. Let’s not forget that the supposed reason for the invasion of Ukraine is to ‘stamp out Nazism’. Or that America had intel about the TT (which they did) giving them the convenient reason for yet another foreign invasion. Warmongering governments do like to give excuses for the destruction they are bringing. Netanyahu is up there with the biggest psychopaths on the planet. He is a bloodthirsty warmonger who doesn’t give a shit about other people dying, Israeli or Palestinian. He has stated his aims. He wants the Palestinian state wiped out.

GRex · 14/02/2024 08:32

madderthanahatter · 14/02/2024 07:52

I don't see what he said is antisemitic?
9/11 apparently had previous Intel.
It has been proven fact that bombings in NI had been known about previously. Governments are sometimes odd.

I'm going to say this again, because apparently it needs to keep being said. In discussion about Israel, this man encouraged hatred of ordinary British journalists and other British citizens based only on their religion, by suggesting they must be shadowy figures of power influencing political activity. This is not the Israeli government, nor even Israeli citizens, nor even any specific named individuals linked with any specific action, this is purely and deliberately stoking general hatred towards British Jewish people.

With the most generous and supportive view of the man, his "Jewish media" statements cannot be interpreted as anything but an attempt to cause anti-semitic hatred.

Sausage1989 · 14/02/2024 08:32

CackleQueen · 12/02/2024 18:11

Isn’t what he said similar to what people said about Pearl Harbour in WW2, i.e. that the American’s ignored the warnings as they wanted a reason to join the war?

That wasn’t anti-American, so I’m struggling to see how this was anti-Semitic? He was very silly to share conspiracy’s , which calls his intelligence into question, but he didn't say he didn’t like Jewish people?

Exactly!! It wasn't anti Jewish. Its got RIDICULOUS NOW. You can't even have a discussion without being called anti semitic. You don't get this with anything else!

jasflowers · 14/02/2024 08:30

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 08:13

The DM probably waited until they could cause maximum damage

Which they would not have been able to do had the Labour Party acted on this as soon as it had happened. See how this works?

I might be missing something that hasn't yet been revealed, you are suggesting the Labour party knew about what was said in October and did nothing about it?

I was under the impression the Mail had this recording and kept it under wraps, which is rather abhorrent in itself, they ve effectively thwarted the democratic process, in denying the people of Rotherham a decent Lab candidate.

BIossomtoes · 14/02/2024 08:27

why the fuck did the Labour Party keep this quiet, not act on it and hope that these vile men would get away with this for so long?

Because it’s only now (very conveniently) that the evidence has been produced? The Telegraph is castigating Starmer this morning for dithering for a whole five hours - not days or months - over what to do about it. That doesn’t suggest knowing about it and hoping it will just go away.

Violetparis · 14/02/2024 08:24

Of course the right wing press will try a smear campaign against Labour, it's what they do and have always done. What Labour has to do is ensure they don't hand it to them on a plate by having unsuitable, wreckless candidates. No use whining about smear tactics, this is the reality of the right wing press.

EasternStandard · 14/02/2024 08:17

Dogfisher · 14/02/2024 08:12

This meeting was a private meeting and held in October? So, somebody recorded and held the evidence till now? It makes no sense and sounds like manipulation to me, to be honest. Not that what they say is not wrong, but why holding on to it for months?

I think that your question should actually be, why the fuck did the Labour Party keep this quiet, not act on it and hope that these vile men would get away with this for so long?

And to those squeaking feebly that this is not anti-semitism and that it's all a smear campaign - there are no fucking words .
All one can assume from that is that you are happy for this disgusting anti-semitism to be spouted these men and think that there should be no sanctions?
I have to admit that I was unaware of just how much anti-Jewish sentiment is seemingly accepted as fine in the UK until October 7 really opened my eyes. The Labour Party continues to have a massive blind spot on this and it is being exposed. Good.

Yes thanks for this post. It’s repugnant

Swipe left for the next trending thread