Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Car insurance- how is this increase possible?!

119 replies

forjustnow · 12/02/2024 11:36

Context-
40 year old female
Held a clean license for 21 years
NEVER claimed on car insurance (have the maximum NCB)
Car valued at £7k
Parked in drive during the day.
No other named drivers.
Fully comp.

With the AA last year my premium was £297, paid annually.
My auto renew option came today- no changes other than me/the car being a year older and another year of NCB.....
Quoted premium this year....£502.

What on earth is driving (excuse the pun!) this horrendous price hike?

Obviously I've just had a quick look elsewhere and can get id down to £400 ish but, still. Bloody hell!

OP posts:
OhmygodDont · 12/02/2024 14:07

It’s all a con let’s face it. Most people never bloody claim but are paying for others accidents. Electric cars costing a fortune for any bump because of the battery pushing up costs for every bugger else.

You think your car getting older and worth less and you getting another year experience with no accidents meant something but not these days. Dh’s goes up every year despite the above.

heaven forbid the fat cats pay rise or bonus is a little smaller aye.

Mountainpika · 12/02/2024 14:07

Our car insurance renewal quote went up a lot. I looked on Compare the Market and found quotes with the same conditions as our current insurance but for far less than the quote we'd had.
But the best quote was from - the company we were already insured with.
Mr Pika phoned them and told them there was a better offer online - from them. They gave us the lower price. They could have offered that in the first place.

Itsverydifficult · 12/02/2024 14:01

DRS1970 · 12/02/2024 13:26

I have had a similar experience with home insurance as you have had with car insurance OP. Renewal came through from LV and it was 43% more expensive than the previous year. I telephoned to confirm it wasn't a mistake, only to be told it was correct and due to the recent storms. I was then told the only way I could get the renewal price cheaper was to reduce my cover, and a slight dig that I wouldn't find it cheaper anywhere else. So I hung up, went online, and within 15 minutes had found a policy with better cover, and for about £3 less than last year's premium with LV. Why do these companies treat existing customers like cash cows. Surely it is far cheaper to retain an existing customer, than it is to entice a new one.

I have just had a very similar conversation with LV. My policy has gone up by over 130% , no claims made and been with them for years. They couldn’t have been less interested 😔. I do have a legal issue with my house but haven’t taken it up with the insurance formally yet, as not sure how it will progress. I have rung to ask for advice previously. I apparently now have to ask them to take it up before renewal or it won’t be covered if I cancel ☹️. Not sure whether to just pay their extortionate price?

Superscientist · 12/02/2024 14:01

Looking too soon or too late can increase the premiums.
Looking a certain times of day can be cheaper
Doing too many searches with slightly different figures can make it go up as they start to think you are telling them what they want her hear to get her best quote rather than the truth

We got stung a few years ago when we had accident that wrote off our car in the 11th month of our policy. They paid out but terminated the policy so we had to start from scratch. As we desperately needed the car it was just 2 days between seeing it for the first time and collecting it. We didn't get confirmation on the collection day until the day before and out quotes were double the amount from the test quote before going to see it. It went up 40% between viewing the car on the Thursday and buying the insurance on the Friday evening. It went up 10% half way through purchasing the insurance as it clicked outside of working hours by a minute.
When we came to insure it the following year they put it up by the standard amount but didn't take off the extra amounts we had to pay for arranging it with short notice until we contacted them with quotes nearly half the price. We moved to a different provider

Same car a few years on and we have just had a reasonable quote just under 10% higher than last year so not complete universal that prices are high

Snozzlemaid · 12/02/2024 13:59

@forjustnow get some other quotes from comparison sites.

21 days before your renewal date is the prime time to get the cheapest quotes.

Martin Lewis always says this and it was true when I was helping dm to get quotes a short while ago.

Bagwyllydiart · 12/02/2024 13:59

Mine went up 35p last renewal

NorthCliffs · 12/02/2024 13:58

Ours went up 30%. No claims ever. I'm old enough to remember that your car insurance went down each year you didn't have a claim ...

Kalevala · 12/02/2024 13:57

Vettrianofan · 12/02/2024 13:48

It's getting ridic.

I checked the insurance premium for my 17yo for when he starts driving - estimate £3k. No joke!

How are young people supposed to get started in their driving career? Driving lessons are going to keep increasing each year so it's best to start as soon as possible.

Mine's coming up to his test and I'm feeling sick with anxiety about how he's going to stay on the road to keep in practice after he passes, let alone if he gets an apprenticeship and needs his own car. Bet there will be kids passing then not driving for years.

Kalevala · 12/02/2024 13:54

It's ridiculous, the poor are going to be priced out of driving because the rich want to drive their Fabergé eggs on the public roads and we all have to pay for it.

IncompleteSenten · 12/02/2024 13:49

My son's went up by several hundred this year too.

His financial advisor (we're not rich he's got a pi trust fund) said that it's linked to the increase of electric cars. Don't know how true that is but he said that the move to electric vehicles means that a crash involving one will cost £££££££ and so we can all expect higher premiums from now on even if we aren't (yet) driving one ourselves.

Like I say, this is just what he said, I have no way of independently verifying that.

Vettrianofan · 12/02/2024 13:48

It's getting ridic.

I checked the insurance premium for my 17yo for when he starts driving - estimate £3k. No joke!

How are young people supposed to get started in their driving career? Driving lessons are going to keep increasing each year so it's best to start as soon as possible.

AristotelianPhysics · 12/02/2024 13:46

Mine went from £500ish to nearly £800 in a year for no reason at all. Very annoying.

Higgeldypiggeldy35 · 12/02/2024 13:42

Same here. Last years quote 240 this year 450. So annoying

Roundtoedshoes · 12/02/2024 13:42

Whilst costs have gone up, insurance companies are being greedy and profiteering.

Don’t like the price? Shop around - you might get lucky, but they are all putting their prices up with nothing in place to prevent them from doing so - the sky is the limit. Result, some people will stop insuring. Result of that, we all pay even more. Such a racket.

MindHowYouGoes · 12/02/2024 13:41

Jovacknockowitch · 12/02/2024 13:34

easy to blame “greedy” companies but actually a lot of insurance companies are in a bad way right now - not raking it in

Awww the poor lambs, perhaps they'd like a nice cup of tea.

You might think your silly comment is valuable but it’s not.

pickledandpuzzled · 12/02/2024 13:41

Insurance doesn’t only cover your car, so if cars get more expensive or harder to repair then Insurance goes up across the board.

Cars got more expensive during Covid.
EV are more expensive
Parts are harder to come by
Inflation at an unusual high- so policies and repairs are impacted, double whammy.

And- we all pay to cover the uninsured driver fund, which covers e-scooters and so on.

Kalevala · 12/02/2024 13:40

winewinewine23 · 12/02/2024 11:41

Also EVs. Even a minor bump can mean the car is written off as there's no way to tell that the battery is undamaged. More write-offs equal higher premiums.

Are EV drivers being subsidised by other drivers then? If so, that's not right!

user1497207191 · 12/02/2024 13:39

@DRS1970

Surely it is far cheaper to retain an existing customer, than it is to entice a new one.

Most of the insurance firms are just "shop fronts" for a very small number of actual real insurers in the background. It's all just branding. Often it's the same staff in the background doing the work, but just using different "front" names, stationery, phone numbers, email addresses, etc. The "shop front" firms just have slightly different algorithms for pricing etc, but the real firms in the background don't really care which shop front sells you the policy as they get your business anyway if you change, just from a different route!

The shop fronts don't care if you move to a different firm, as they'll have a steady stream of new customers via the comparison sites.

If you enter the same driver details onto a comparison site, but try with two different cars, you'll almost certainly find the "top 10" will be the same names, but in a different order, that's because they create artificial "points of difference" in their pricing algorithm.

My son works for one of the UK's biggest insurance firms (a "proper" firm, not a front) and he tells me which of the "fronts" use them as the real insurer - it's a lot! Even his firm "re-sell" partial blocks of policies to other "proper" insurers to spread the risk, and in turn, his firm "buy" partial blocks of policies from other proper insurers - it's just like betting shops who "place" bets with other shops to "hedge their bets".

You'd be surprised how little "genuine" competition there is in the insurance market. The comparison websites are all "smoke and mirrors" to give the illusion of lots of competition and choice, but it's not genuine!

Lovelynames123 · 12/02/2024 13:37

Mine went from £330 to £500, 26 years driving, clean licence, good postcode...everything is just going up, up, up!

Stevesellsshells · 12/02/2024 13:35

Mine was roughly the same price this year. All other quotes were higher so renewed.

House insurance went up by about £100 though.

Jovacknockowitch · 12/02/2024 13:34

easy to blame “greedy” companies but actually a lot of insurance companies are in a bad way right now - not raking it in

Awww the poor lambs, perhaps they'd like a nice cup of tea.

GymBergerac · 12/02/2024 13:32

Increases across the board I believe, but very much so for the AA. I've been with them for five years, very happily with little increase, but I've just had my renewal and it's gone up from £150 to £260. I'll be phoning them to see if they can reduce it enough to convince me to stay, but I've got two other offers of new quotes at £150 so I suspect they'll be losing a loyal customer. So frustrating 😤

user1497207191 · 12/02/2024 13:28

Costs of accidents have shot up, recovery costs a lot more, bodyshop time is more expensive, parts are more expensive, and add to all that, the labour shortage and delays in parts supply chain means repairs take longer and that means them having to finance a courtesy car for longer.

When our car damaged and off the road because of an idiot neighbour crashing into it when parked, it was two months before we got it back. That was two months of the insurance company having to finance a courtesy/hire car. The bodyshop guy said the parts needed had doubled in price within a year as they were in such short supply and besides that, he couldn't get any staff as literally no one applied when he advertised!!

DRS1970 · 12/02/2024 13:26

I have had a similar experience with home insurance as you have had with car insurance OP. Renewal came through from LV and it was 43% more expensive than the previous year. I telephoned to confirm it wasn't a mistake, only to be told it was correct and due to the recent storms. I was then told the only way I could get the renewal price cheaper was to reduce my cover, and a slight dig that I wouldn't find it cheaper anywhere else. So I hung up, went online, and within 15 minutes had found a policy with better cover, and for about £3 less than last year's premium with LV. Why do these companies treat existing customers like cash cows. Surely it is far cheaper to retain an existing customer, than it is to entice a new one.

OneMoreTime23 · 12/02/2024 13:23

Can be more expensive if it’s parked in a driveway now. Because the thieves know which house the keys are in where they don’t know if it is on the street.

Swipe left for the next trending thread