Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For not allowing ex to take 1 year old to America

237 replies

MissNP196 · 12/02/2024 09:26

I have an 18 month old who my ex only started consistently having in November (he has her every Saturday, no overnight stay) which has been going well.

A few days ago, he suddenly announced that he would like to take her to America in April to celebrate his grandparents birthday. I said that as nice as it would be for her to meet her great grandparents, the trip is far too much, too soon, as she is only 1 and has never even spent a night with him. I feel this holiday would be extremely unsettling for her as she would be in an unfamiliar environment with unfamiliar people, without her mum.

Was my response unreasonable? Ex has responded angrily saying her will seek permission from court. Does anyone with experience of this know if this would likely be approved?

OP posts:
Jomasell · 12/02/2024 19:18

RatatouillePie · 12/02/2024 18:18

I wouldn't be happy about him taking her given he has never had her over night.

BUT... if he doesn't like this then he will do the same if you ever wish to take her abroad and also say no.

Can you go with them?? She stays with you and can go for the day to meet them?

You dont need permission to take your child abroad if you have PR. So mum wouldnt ever have to ask his permission. But if hes on birth cert be also has pr so same applies. If he isnt on it he would have to go to court.

Jomasell · 12/02/2024 19:14

underneaththeash · 12/02/2024 09:38

How can they build up to it gradually in two months?

OP - I’d send him an email to say that it’s just a no for now as he’s not even had an overnight yet and it would not be in her best interests.
Offer an overnight.

I agree with you. Abs no way at that age and 100% no way in these circumstances anyway.

caringcarer · 12/02/2024 19:12

Itslegitimatesalvage · 12/02/2024 10:04

They already have those powers. The CMS can remove driving licenses, remove passports, force the sale of a house, send you to prison etc. They have huge amounts of power and options. They don’t use them. They don’t have a mandate from a Tory government to actually use their powers. New legislation with these powers written a different way with a different process won’t change anything. It’s lip service. They can already do all of that.

Actually they have never been able to access a parents bank account before. If a parent says they have no money they just had to believe them. Now they will be able to access a parents bank account and check if they do have money. Also they did threaten my exh with conversation of his passport when he was claiming to be self employed but actually working for an employer. After I got the name of his employer it took a bit of time but in the end got his employer to take money from his salary. I had to write to my MP to get it pushed along though.

Ann1964 · 12/02/2024 19:11

Absolutely no way.
You are her main parent...I can't imagine the confusion she would feel.
First of all a bloody long flight to be considered, how will he cope?
Then time away from you with strange people and an inconsistent Dad...
Very odd he has suggested this in my opinion!

24hrCarer · 12/02/2024 19:02

ilovebreadsauce · 12/02/2024 16:23

So dies this mean the op broke the law taking her child abroad on holiday without her ex's consent

Legally, yes it is abduction if there is no Child Arrangements Order stating the child lives with mum but the father did not lodge an objection at the time and he wasn't involved in his daughter's life at that point.

MzHz · 12/02/2024 18:57

24hrCarer · 12/02/2024 13:30

Only needs 1 parent with PR to consent.

Uk passports yes, Irish passports no, they do require both parents to sign

viques · 12/02/2024 18:44

MissNP196 · 12/02/2024 10:49

I have already agreed to overnight stays as he mentioned that a month ago. However, I said that before he has her overnight, he needs to make sure he was all the things she requires (e.g. cot, toys etc - none of which he has!) since that conversation, he hasn't bought up overnight stays again

Then make sure you have this fully recorded, saved on an email exchange as others have suggested. You don’t want to end up in court with a she says/ he says argument. If it goes to court you want clear, dated evidence of his shortcomings as a parent, lack of maintenance, lack of regular contact, lack of willingness to prepare for overnight stays, his inconsistent behaviour eg job changing, irrational arguments about extended contact ( comparing your holiday with seeing grandparents with whom she has no previous involvement)

24hrCarer · 12/02/2024 18:18

Hereforaglance · 12/02/2024 18:11

Why did u have a child with someone you dont trust to be want anywhere near your child without you lookimg over his shoulder

OP has already said he walked out 10 days after she was born. How could she have predicted that? Then he didn't want to know until last November when he suddenly wants to take his daughter to America.

RatatouillePie · 12/02/2024 18:18

I wouldn't be happy about him taking her given he has never had her over night.

BUT... if he doesn't like this then he will do the same if you ever wish to take her abroad and also say no.

Can you go with them?? She stays with you and can go for the day to meet them?

24hrCarer · 12/02/2024 18:17

@MissNP196 That is correct. If he took your daughter out of the country without your permission (written) then he would be committing the criminal offence of abduction. You could contact the police who could then alert the airports to stop him leaving the country.

The court would definitely consider all those things and particularly the emotional needs of your daughter at the moment, whereby she is solely reliant on you for comfort and her all round care. It would be emotionally harmful to take her away from you for that long without having a solid bond established with her father yet. He has essentially only been in her life for 4 months which is nothing.

I'm not a lawyer but I've been through the family court around 10 times (me as a mother and DH regarding his son) and that advice lines up with what I know about the court system.

When my DH son was just over 1 year old, the court didn't feel it would be in his best interests to stop overnights and this is even with DH living with his son for the first 10 months of his life. The court said that overnights can be built up over time when his son was able and ready to cope with it.

I honestly don't think a court would allow him to do it.

Hereforaglance · 12/02/2024 18:11

Why did u have a child with someone you dont trust to be want anywhere near your child without you lookimg over his shoulder

tolerable · 12/02/2024 18:01

no. because. hows that child focused.?in HER best intrest?... ? Hes being ridiculous. selfish twat. She wont remember- meet the great grandparents(just the trauma anxiety of sudden longhaul flight seperation and no familiar face?-twattery)
Yes YOU CAN say no. so will court. You could be eurotunnels most frequent border crossers- HES ONLY just showed up. emptyhanded.
tell him to get her a stars n stripes dress surround her wi balloons and let her blow a candle cake out n clappahandies birthday video.
grt grandparents be just as delighted with that "effort"
is he on birth cert?
cheeky git

Headinthesand21 · 12/02/2024 17:57

Think it would be cruel for the poor child and so irresponsible of him to even suggest it. She’s just a baby and she’s not even staying overnight with him in this country, let alone America.

I can’t imagine any court in the land would sanction him taking her or feel it’s in her best interests.

If he can afford America then why is he not paying maintenance?!!!

Think you are completely in the right OP.

MeridianB · 12/02/2024 17:50

What a deadbeat this guy is.

He won't take you to court because he can barely manage to hold down a job and failed to see his DD for most of her life. So let him spin his wheels while you keep notes on everything and apply for CMS immediately.

coxesorangepippin · 12/02/2024 17:47

And yes, go to CMS.

Because he obviously needs it.

coxesorangepippin · 12/02/2024 17:47

When he demonstrates that he's a responsible parent I.e. Paying for his child on a reliable, regular basis, then perhaps you could you consider him taking her for longer. Not on vacation.

He sounds utterly feckless, let's face it.

wildernesssw · 12/02/2024 17:41

It would be reasonable to ask him to give you a suggested plan that he would commit to, to work towards him being able to take your DD on holiday.

This would specify what he will put in place before having her over night, within what timeframe. How he sees an overnight building up into several nights, again, with time frames (not a couple of months! enough time to prove his commitment to being a responsible parent that you and DD can trust).

Basically, what he plans to do to turn himself into a sort of father who could safely care for his daughter on an overseas trip, and can be the starting point to try to come to an agreement about what are the milestones he needs to reach.

I suspect he won't come up with one - but you can show you are open to him developing the sort of relationship where this could be beneficial to your DD.

If he does the work, over a period of time, then that would be the point where you can consider whether the specific trip he is suggesting is one you can agree to with your DD's best interests at heart.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 12/02/2024 17:36

No way, she’s far too little.
If you haven’t already (let’s hope he hasn’t!) do apply for a passport for her PDQ, and make sure he can’t get his hands on it!

Underestimated4 · 12/02/2024 17:25

Courts wouldn’t agree to this. My ex wanted to with my 2 year old, the judge said it’s not something he would agree to with any child under 5.

Sjh15 · 12/02/2024 17:21

No.
I think, if i had to, I would allow my son to go with his dad to a different country without me, our son is 2 and us 3 all live together and I would just about okay it.
equally I think our son would miss his dad if I took him out the country alone.
not even had an overnight? No chance!
as for no child maintenance I’d be fuming he can afford to go America!

Andthereyougo · 12/02/2024 17:21

If he can’t even supply a cot etc at his own home how does he think they will magically appear at his grandparents ? Or maybe he expects them to arrange everything.
And he thinks he’ll cope with a one year old on a 7-8 hour flight? 😂

MissNP196 · 12/02/2024 17:18

@ilovebreadsauce no I didn't break the law. I did get his permission and had a letter

OP posts:
clpsmum · 12/02/2024 17:18

MissNP196 · 12/02/2024 09:38

He also "can't afford" child maintenance but has the money for a trip to the US!

And money to take you to court! He won't get permission to take her. Got to CMS x

IOnlycreatedaccountforthispost · 12/02/2024 17:10

I would not allow this. If he wishes to take you to court and a judge rules on it then so be it. But I would not allow it until then. What happens if he doesn’t bring her back to the UK?

Theunamedcat · 12/02/2024 17:03

TonTonMacoute · 12/02/2024 16:58

Ex has responded angrily saying her will seek permission from court.

Well, that would be the clincher in my mind. He's just a bully

Family court won't get involved in maintenance.

Maybe not, but no harm in pointing out to this total arse that threatening court works both ways.

When will women learn to stop having babies with such terrible men? Sorry, to say that but jeez.

Sorry that last paragraph is victim blaming my ex husband was "a good guy" right up until we had children its not something anyone who knew us predicted