Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For not allowing ex to take 1 year old to America

237 replies

MissNP196 · 12/02/2024 09:26

I have an 18 month old who my ex only started consistently having in November (he has her every Saturday, no overnight stay) which has been going well.

A few days ago, he suddenly announced that he would like to take her to America in April to celebrate his grandparents birthday. I said that as nice as it would be for her to meet her great grandparents, the trip is far too much, too soon, as she is only 1 and has never even spent a night with him. I feel this holiday would be extremely unsettling for her as she would be in an unfamiliar environment with unfamiliar people, without her mum.

Was my response unreasonable? Ex has responded angrily saying her will seek permission from court. Does anyone with experience of this know if this would likely be approved?

OP posts:
Stormyweathr · 13/02/2024 11:59

MissNP196 · 13/02/2024 11:37

The time difference is not the sole reason I don't think the trip is a good idea 😂

Just out of interest, would you be happy for your one year old to travel to America for 2 weeks with people she barely knows? @Stormyweathr

Yes of course in an ideal world, mums and dads are equals, however in this case, my ex has not been an equal parent.

I would be happy yes
as I know my child’s dad loves my child just as much as me and would keep them safe

its also a chance of a lifetime for a child and something I could never afford

I would miss them and struggle whilst they were gone but the conditions on taking them would be daily FaceTimes and dad to have enough money to move/rebook the flight home if the child really didn’t settle whilst they were there

Toadstool1985 · 13/02/2024 11:53

Stormyweathr · 13/02/2024 11:45

just to summarise the point of me posting to you

  • solicitors drag out a process to take your money
  • give dad a chance to prove himself before saying no. if he is a dead beat dad then he himself will prove that he is not capable
  • try to avoid court and be amicable as your child will suffer if you and dad cannot co-parent.
  • if it does go to court remember that they don’t care about the issues you and dad have they look at the best for a child in the long run

Op has done all of those things and actively said she has set out a plan for him to build up to more contact. Her childs father has had 18 months to mostly ignore her so far. Op has not obstructed anything.... Sorry to speak for you, op lol

Fageyoghurt · 13/02/2024 11:48

Well done OP, ignore the naysayers this was definitely the right decision and no court would back your partner taking your little one abroad in April.

Toadstool1985 · 13/02/2024 11:46

Stormyweathr · 13/02/2024 11:30

A court would see a mum using time difference for a two year old as excuse not go as a obstruction

Edited

Eh? Have you read the thread, that's not why??? 🤔

GingerIsBest · 13/02/2024 11:45

Stormyweathr · 13/02/2024 11:25

So firstly family court don’t take any money into account that’s separate

secondly courts see both parents as equals

i have experience of this and dad got everything he asked for at court and the arguments from mum were exactly the same as yours

courts want the best for a child and most judges believe that the best thing for a child is for both parents to be in a child’s life equally
they go to town on anyone who tries to obstruct

I agree that the courts want to see both parents as equal. But I don't think that in this situation that's relevant as the dad clearly is NOT equal. Certainly in the case of my friend, the judge threw him out of court as there was no way it was in the interests of their young children to be separated from their mother for 2 weeks when he'd only done one overnight a month and routinely didn't turn up for his court approved contact.

Re the money - I don't know enough about how courts work but I'd imagine it would be at least a small factor albeit unlikely to be an actual LEGAL factor. So all things being equal, no CMS payments won't change the dial, but in the context of a father who has been largely absent etc, it might be an additional nail in the coffin as it were.

Stormyweathr · 13/02/2024 11:45

just to summarise the point of me posting to you

  • solicitors drag out a process to take your money
  • give dad a chance to prove himself before saying no. if he is a dead beat dad then he himself will prove that he is not capable
  • try to avoid court and be amicable as your child will suffer if you and dad cannot co-parent.
  • if it does go to court remember that they don’t care about the issues you and dad have they look at the best for a child in the long run
MissNP196 · 13/02/2024 11:37

The time difference is not the sole reason I don't think the trip is a good idea 😂

Just out of interest, would you be happy for your one year old to travel to America for 2 weeks with people she barely knows? @Stormyweathr

Yes of course in an ideal world, mums and dads are equals, however in this case, my ex has not been an equal parent.

OP posts:
Stormyweathr · 13/02/2024 11:30

Toadstool1985 · 13/02/2024 11:27

But she's not obstructing? It's a ridiculous suggestion on his part

A court would see a mum using time difference for a two year old as excuse not go as a obstruction

Toadstool1985 · 13/02/2024 11:27

But she's not obstructing? It's a ridiculous suggestion on his part

Stormyweathr · 13/02/2024 11:25

So firstly family court don’t take any money into account that’s separate

secondly courts see both parents as equals

i have experience of this and dad got everything he asked for at court and the arguments from mum were exactly the same as yours

courts want the best for a child and most judges believe that the best thing for a child is for both parents to be in a child’s life equally
they go to town on anyone who tries to obstruct

MissNP196 · 13/02/2024 11:23

Stormyweathr · 13/02/2024 11:18

A solicitor will tell you that as they want to take your money

I am not having a go here just telling you from past experience what courts are like

they would deem your ex taking your child on holiday as the same unknown environment as when you took your child on holiday (minus mum but courts don’t take a primary care giver into account as they see both mum and dad as equal) therefore if mum can take a child to strange place then dad could too it’s no different

as I say I am not having a go I am just speaking from experience of a long long family court process, solicitors will also drag out the process to get more money from you

It really isn't the same as me taking her on holiday as she's been with me everyday of her life as opposed to her dad who she's only spent one day a week with since November!

OP posts:
Toadstool1985 · 13/02/2024 11:21

Stormyweathr · 13/02/2024 11:18

A solicitor will tell you that as they want to take your money

I am not having a go here just telling you from past experience what courts are like

they would deem your ex taking your child on holiday as the same unknown environment as when you took your child on holiday (minus mum but courts don’t take a primary care giver into account as they see both mum and dad as equal) therefore if mum can take a child to strange place then dad could too it’s no different

as I say I am not having a go I am just speaking from experience of a long long family court process, solicitors will also drag out the process to get more money from you

Why would they deem it the same when it's the complete opposite - parent who has looked after her every day of her life so far vs parent in name only who has met her a handful of times and doesn't contribute, including financially to her care? Equally sufficient parents should have equal rights

Stormyweathr · 13/02/2024 11:18

A solicitor will tell you that as they want to take your money

I am not having a go here just telling you from past experience what courts are like

they would deem your ex taking your child on holiday as the same unknown environment as when you took your child on holiday (minus mum but courts don’t take a primary care giver into account as they see both mum and dad as equal) therefore if mum can take a child to strange place then dad could too it’s no different

as I say I am not having a go I am just speaking from experience of a long long family court process, solicitors will also drag out the process to get more money from you

RandomMess · 13/02/2024 11:18

The op has suggested a plan which shows that she is very willing to work with him to increase his contact whilst being child centric. So long as it's reasonable that won't go against her.

JMSA · 13/02/2024 11:16

YANBU Flowers

MissNP196 · 13/02/2024 11:11

Stormyweathr · 13/02/2024 11:05

I think instead of a straight no you should give him a chance to prove that he is consistent and reliable for your child (as in tell him if overnights go well etc then yes) also just to add technically you would of needed his permission to take your child on holiday (as he has pr and you do not have a child arrangement order)

if he takes you to court this holiday will probably will be ordered unless there is a massive concern over dad and the welfare of the child

talking from experience here of a lot of court battles over a child, the judges don’t look at anything but what’s best for a child, even not having a cot etc wouldn’t be a reason to not allow overnight stays, if they have a place to sleep then dad should be allowed a overnight

the courts hate parent conflicts and will favour the parent who are the most co-operative and the least confrontational

You also mentioned the courts will look at 'what's best for the child'... so is being shipped off to America in an unfamiliar environment with unfamiliar people, in a completely different time zone without her primary caregiver what's best for my 18 month old?

OP posts:
MissNP196 · 13/02/2024 11:10

Stormyweathr · 13/02/2024 11:05

I think instead of a straight no you should give him a chance to prove that he is consistent and reliable for your child (as in tell him if overnights go well etc then yes) also just to add technically you would of needed his permission to take your child on holiday (as he has pr and you do not have a child arrangement order)

if he takes you to court this holiday will probably will be ordered unless there is a massive concern over dad and the welfare of the child

talking from experience here of a lot of court battles over a child, the judges don’t look at anything but what’s best for a child, even not having a cot etc wouldn’t be a reason to not allow overnight stays, if they have a place to sleep then dad should be allowed a overnight

the courts hate parent conflicts and will favour the parent who are the most co-operative and the least confrontational

As stated previously in the thread, I did get his permission to take her on holiday last year.

I spoke to a solicitor yesterday who said it would be unlikely that it would be approved in court due to the reasons I've stated on here.

OP posts:
Stormyweathr · 13/02/2024 11:05

I think instead of a straight no you should give him a chance to prove that he is consistent and reliable for your child (as in tell him if overnights go well etc then yes) also just to add technically you would of needed his permission to take your child on holiday (as he has pr and you do not have a child arrangement order)

if he takes you to court this holiday will probably will be ordered unless there is a massive concern over dad and the welfare of the child

talking from experience here of a lot of court battles over a child, the judges don’t look at anything but what’s best for a child, even not having a cot etc wouldn’t be a reason to not allow overnight stays, if they have a place to sleep then dad should be allowed a overnight

the courts hate parent conflicts and will favour the parent who are the most co-operative and the least confrontational

MissNP196 · 13/02/2024 10:18

I have now sent a clear, concise email detailing my reasons as to why I feel this trip would not be in DD's interests and a plan of what he can do to build up to being able to take her on holiday in the future.

Thank you for all the advice - you have all been very helpful ❤️

OP posts:
SpatulaSpatula · 13/02/2024 07:13

Court would never say he could take her. She's far too young to be away from her main carer for more than a few hours. Instead they'd start questioning his lack of financial support. He sounds dangerous and I'd get the court involved immediately.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 13/02/2024 00:58

MissNP196 · 12/02/2024 10:58

@CadyEastman yes, mentioned all of that in a text conversation

If you have an email address for him Id email him making sure its really clear so he can't just claim it got lost in the texts. I'd reiterate as per your text last month you're happy for him to have overnight stays as soon as he has a safe and appropriate set up for her with cot, toys, car seat etc. Then once he has her consistently for a weekly overnight you'd be happy to make a plan to increase that working towards him being able to take her to see the grandparents when the relationship between him and DD is sufficiently developed so that DD can comfortably and confidently travel with him. Then if he takes you to court you can show that you've been very reasonable and tried to facilitate her relationship with her father and it's been his choices stopping him and DD from having a closer relationship.

SamPM · 12/02/2024 23:24

Yes he does need this. Hague Treaty. Stops non custodial parents absconding with children. And they take it seriously in the US. I was grilled every time I traveled with my daughter.

SamPM · 12/02/2024 23:19

He cannot take her without your permission, end of. And that's what court will say. Plus he will need to get her a passport and be cannot do that without your permission either. Frankly I would be very reluctant for this to happen. It's hard to travel with a baby that young especially on a transatlantic flight and I would not trust him.

Lurkerusually · 12/02/2024 22:49

Just no way! Not until he pays regular maintenance and has his own place setup for her to even stay overnight.

Court will not side with him anyway given his current level of ‘responsibility’.

Fageyoghurt · 12/02/2024 22:30

BruFord · 12/02/2024 21:52

@Fageyoghurt But that would involve admitting to his GP’s that his daughter barely knows him-and I’d put money on them paying for the entire trip (by that I mean that they’re paying to fly him and DD out there, without realizing the situation).

Edited

I agree, I think this is the case. His grandparents won’t have a clue and because they’re older and are not in good health they probably didn’t notice he wasn’t sending them regular photo updates of his daughter for a large chunk of time.

My friend’s ex had a good relationship with his family in Nigeria independently of him, and it’s through her (the mother) the family abroad communicated with the kid, so I think they were all aware he wasn’t the most consistent father.