Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be hurt about DH and mothers day

303 replies

Dayzychains · 12/02/2024 06:11

Long time lurker. First time poster.

I am mum to a 3 month old baby and I lost my own mum 2 months ago. A couple of days ago, my husband asked me about how I felt about mothers day, and would I be up for a meal with his mum.

I have a lovely relationship with my MIL. She is wonderful and a lovely grandma to our baby. However, I really don't feel up to going out for a meal to celebrate mothers day, given how raw my loss currently feels.

I said I doubted I would be up for it and I became quite tearful. My husband apologised for bringing it up but said he felt it would be better for me to come out rather than sit home alone with the baby, as he feels its important I celebrate my first mothers day, however I feel more like a bereaved daughter than I do a new mum.

I'm a little hurt that he hasn't considered possibly just seeing his mum, giving her a present and maybe taking her out for a meal.another day - SIL could still take MIL out on the day itself. I'm still very traumatised by my mums death, however I realise my feelings may be unreasonable as I'm not his mum and his mum does deserve to be spoiled on MD. I've not said anything and have said I'm more than happy for him to take his lovely mum out, as I do feel that my feelings may be irrational.

What would you expect your husband to do in this case?

OP posts:
ZombieGirl86 · 13/02/2024 19:41

Grief isnt reasonable and its your first mothers day. Stop thinking what should you do. You should do what brings you comfort. I think this is an incredibky difficult time for you and you DH taking his mum out anither day is perfectly reasonable and supportive. Perhaps he could still pop round with flowers for her while you take some time to yourself for an hour.

PlanBea · 13/02/2024 19:24

Op, I haven't RTFT but I am sorry for your loss. Last year I lost my dad two weeks before father's day in unexpected and traumatic circumstances. My in laws invited me to go out to celebrate it with them and honestly it stung that they didn't consider it would be difficult. So I do get a bit what you're going through.

I think mother's day and father's day should be aimed at those in the trenches of parenting - you don't get much more in the trenches than a 3 month old! Yes it's nice to acknowledge the next generation up, but I know my mum isn't getting up every hour or not getting to eat with both hands or not getting to shower for days on end. Plus she's already had 30+ years of mothers day being all about her. Your DH should be treating you, and this year with grief that might just be having a quiet day and him holding the baby while you have a nap. Leaving you while he goes off for hours, dealing with your grief and a small baby, isn't fair on what is now equally if not more your day too.

Lawzy24 · 13/02/2024 19:13

I'm so sorry for your loss Hun.

I can understand both sides ... You don't want to go out to celebrate mother's day as it's still pretty raw... But he needs to celebrate his mum .. so if he takes her out while your at home with your beautiful baby... Just remember you have lost your dear mother but you are now one too... What a precious thing.. it's bitter sweet ... I hope you enjoy your day and embrace your mum too.. xx

Piwi1625 · 13/02/2024 19:11

It's a hard one, so sorry for your loss.

mynamesnotchris · 13/02/2024 19:09

I'm in tears reading this because my own beautiful mother died a week & a half before mother's day last year. Sending you so much love. I am so sorry for your loss. If I could hug you I would. xx

DocOck · 13/02/2024 17:56

It doesn't have to be all or nothing. It doesn't have to be wife versus mother.

BobbyBiscuits · 13/02/2024 17:02

I don't think he should be 'suggesting' what you do on this day really. It's clearly triggering. I hope you can talk to him and get him to see that you need him on this day. He could pop into his Mum's do with his sister for a drink/ dessert or whatever for an hour? Losing your Mum is devastating and it could take a very long time for you to adjust fully which is normal.

Bluetrews25 · 13/02/2024 16:57

This is the kind of scenario that people talk about when they get divorced.
'And he left me on my own with a velcro baby on my first mothers' day when I had only recently lost my own mother!'

BIossomtoes · 13/02/2024 16:40

nimski · 13/02/2024 16:15

Absolutely this, this is your first mothers day. My husband no longer sees his mother on mother's day as he takes me out. He will send her a card/flowers etc.

That’s crazy. You’re not his mother. And you encourage this?

nimski · 13/02/2024 16:15

FatFilledTrottyPuss · 12/02/2024 06:52

I’m a bit surprised at most of the replies so far to be honest.
It’s your first Mother’s Day as a mum yourself and you’ve so recently lost your own mum. You must be physically and emotionally exhausted. He really should be putting you and your needs first on this particular Mother’s Day, I’m sure his own mum will understand given the circumstances.
So sorry for your loss op and congratulations on your lovely baby.

Absolutely this, this is your first mothers day. My husband no longer sees his mother on mother's day as he takes me out. He will send her a card/flowers etc.

Nipsmum · 13/02/2024 15:55

Be thankful your husband wants to take you out on mother's day. My Ex husband's attitude was, your not my mother why should I buy you something. Incidentally, he didn't buy anything for his own Mum, I did.

DoILookThrilled · 13/02/2024 15:03

I think you recently losing your mum and it being your 1st Mother’s Day outweighs his mum. Especially with the update where he leaves the baby with you!

PeskyPotato · 13/02/2024 15:02

I lost my mum late in pregnancy so I can totally relate to first Mother's Day without my mum.

My husband bought me the biggest bouquet of flowers I've ever seen and we bought another bouquet and took it to the grave where I sat and cried and was held. It was such a mixture of feeling of missing my own mum and being a mum. I could not have gotten through the day without him next to me.

We have every year taken his mum out for lunch before and since, but I don't think anyone, including his mum, expected us to that year. And if you MIL is as good as mine, she won't expect it either.

I think yiu need a frank conversation about hard this day is going to be and how much you need them.

winnieanddaisy · 13/02/2024 14:52

I know exactly how you feel . I had been married 32 years when my mother died( 20 years ago this week ) and was devastated. Obviously I had known my MIL all that time and got on really well with her but I couldn’t bring myself to visit her for several months never mind go out for a celebration meal with her . She must have been hurt by my behaviour but never said anything about it and just gave me the time I needed to grieve.
I was similar with my step father because he still lived in my mother’s house and I couldn’t go there.
they both forgave me for my behaviour when lost my lovely mum .

Longma · 13/02/2024 09:13

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

Beefcurtains79 · 13/02/2024 06:15

MartinsSpareCalculator · 12/02/2024 19:36

Well, nothing. It's supposed to be about the child(ren) appreciating their mother. I honestly don't see the point if its from your husband because you're not his mother.

Each to their own though. Appreciate we all approach things differently.

Lovely, so she gets fuck all then. You must know this opinion is in the minority? I can’t imagine any decent MIL thinking this.

applesandmares · 12/02/2024 20:11

I'm really sorry for your loss OP, that must have been shattering, especially given you were so newly postpartum.

My view is that you should be your husband's priority everyday, but especially this Mother's Day given your circumstances. I would have thought that MIL won't be expecting to see you on Mother's Day given your recent loss, and by association, your husband who will be supporting you.

It sounds as though your husband means well and had put some thought into what would be best for you, but has unfortunately come to the wrong conclusions. I know you want him to just "know" what you need, but grief is a funny thing, and it can be challenging to navigate supporting someone if they aren't making their needs clear.

If I were you, I'd tell him that you'd been thinking about how you'd like to spend Mother's Day and have come up with your ideal. Take the guesswork out of it! X

AfraidToRun · 12/02/2024 19:42

I have a feeling that when you raise your needs and wants, you do so in a very mild manner that leaves lots of ambiguity.

Just tell him, be direct. Broken record.

saraclara · 12/02/2024 19:39

Maybe join his Mum for pudding and drinks afterwards.

I've been waiting until I'd finished reading the thread, to post that.

I don't know why this guy is getting so much flack. OP has made it clear that he's being supportive and his suggestion was tentative.

@Dayzychains I know you want him to come to the right decision by himself, but unfortunately even the most loving husband can't read your mind. And as you've said, what he would do and want in your position is different from what you want to do.

When you say that he said you should have the baby with you on Mother's Day, I read that as him thinking you'd offered something that you didn't really want. That you'd offered him the baby to take so that his mum saw him, as a gesture.

You both sound like lovely people, and you clearly love your in-laws. I'm glad that that you have them in your life.
But just talk to your DH. Explain that him going to part of the family get together and taking the baby with him will give you some quiet time alone to remember and grieve your mum.

MartinsSpareCalculator · 12/02/2024 19:36

Nanny0gg · 12/02/2024 11:38

Well the baby can't do it yet can they?

It's going to be years before anything can be organised by the child/ren

So what happens till then?

Well, nothing. It's supposed to be about the child(ren) appreciating their mother. I honestly don't see the point if its from your husband because you're not his mother.

Each to their own though. Appreciate we all approach things differently.

LouOver · 12/02/2024 19:31

Removing the loss of your mum which ofcourse Has a huge impact and I'm very sorry.

But it very much reads that your DH hasn't twigged that HE'S responsible for your mother's day and not your 3 month old. Especially the comment about how it's important the baby is with you when you outright suggested taking the baby.

Is Baby arranging your card as well? I'm sorry but once your partner has your children they trump your own mum. In this instance it doesn't need to be either or.

He has massively got this wrong and more importantly in what you say about your MIL she might be the first person to point this out to him ON mother's day.

Hankunamatata · 12/02/2024 19:22

My first mothers day dh took the baby and went to is mum so I could sleep Baby didn't have a clue, granny got loads of cuddles and I slept, it was bliss

Hankunamatata · 12/02/2024 19:21

Tell him you would like him to take the baby so you can rest and be sad and grieve without upsetting the baby.

Banrion · 12/02/2024 19:15

OP your husband is being selfish. He's having a nice child free family lunch while you mind baby. Is it mother's day or fathers day.
You're being completely reasonable under the circumstances. He should bring baby to the lunch and your mother's day present will be to relax on your own or he comes back after 2 hours and spends the rest of the day pampering the mother of his child.
You need to make him see this.
You're perfectly entitled not to want to spend the day with mil but that doesn't mean he fs off and leaves you.

FishersGate · 12/02/2024 17:24

BIossomtoes · 12/02/2024 13:33

Not spot on actually. I’m firmly on @Dayzychains side and I suspect her Mil would be too if she was given the chance to give her opinion. I won’t be seeing my adult son on Mothers’ Day and it’s fine. I’m 70, by the way.

In these circumstances her opinion doesn't really matter in regards to op. Her DH shouldn't have to ask permission to put his wife first in these circumstances. Plenty of opportunities to see her in sat or take her for a coffee or breakfast.

Swipe left for the next trending thread