Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to pay DS's 2022-23 school fees?

138 replies

Avery2024 · 11/02/2024 23:58

Loads of backstory here...

DS and DD both attended what is regarded as an 'elite private school' (not bragging, just giving context). Over the past 3 years, we have struggled with the fees due to my business closing during Covid and being stuck overseas for almost a year due to travel restrictions. However, the school were understanding and allowed us to enter into a payment plan, which we stuck to.

In 2022, DS entered Year 11 and was clear that he was struggling. He has ADHD (which is medicated) and homeschooling had really not worked for him. Added to this, his friend died in the most horrific circumstances, his best friend's dad committed suicide, his diving teacher was exposed as a paedophile and he was involved in two serious car accidents, all within a very short period of time.

I reached out to the Head of Learning Enhancement, Mrs G, at the beginning of the year as I felt DS needed some extra help and could we please have a short meeting. The school is very well resourced and she is in charge of coordinating any extra help that the students may need. It is a huge school with a strong emphasis on mental health. Her response was that we should speak again 'after the reports come out'. I replied that this was not for some time and that DS needed some help now as this was a very important year. She ignored my request. I emailed Mrs G a few more times but did not hear back. DS was then savagely beaten up by another boy at the school. The school to their credit dealt with it and expelled the boy. Nevertheless, DS was shaken by this and the incident just added to DS's problems.

A while later and quite suddenly, we noticed a change in DS. Although he was never what you would call an academic high flyer, nevertheless he had ambition and had planned to go to university to study industrial design. He was Design Ambassador at his previous school and it was clear that he had a flair for design. He spoke passionately about having his own design consultancy, buying a live/work unit locally that he had seen and getting a dog. He had it all planned out.

But suddenly out of the blue he started talking about leaving school as he was "too stupid for uni". He stopped caring about school work and started talking about leaving and taking on manual jobs, which isn't really him. Aside from anything else, he does not like to get dirty. He kept calling himself "dumb" and "useless". He had always been quite a confident boy and this behaviour was new. We had no idea what was going on until I finally heard from Mrs G suggesting we meet. Finally! I told DS in the car when I picked him up from school that Mrs G has finally agreed to meet with us and jokingly said I was tempted to tell her no, she had had her chance. DS then said, "Yeah! And she told [another boy's] mum that I was not the brightest!" I was so shocked I nearly crashed the car. I pulled over and DS burst into tears. He said that everybody thinks he's stupid.

We arrived home and I immediately emailed Mrs G (and the entire cc list that she had included on her email) that I was furious that she had told ANOTHER PARENT that DS was "not the brightest" and I did not want her anywhere near our son. The other people on cc (Head of Year, Head of Senior School, School Psychologist, etc) quickly organised a meeting (excluding Mrs G) and tried to put a programme together for DS. However, after a few meetings, it was clear that we had lost him. No amount of help was going to do anything now. A few months went by and DS was still completely disengaged from school.

I was still angry at Mrs G as I partly blamed her for us losing nearly a year and for her hurtful comment. We had always been very quiet parents and not ones to make a fuss. Nevertheless, I felt something needed to be done about Mrs G so DH went to see the Headmaster. At the very least, she owed DS an apology. The Headmaster was VERY defensive of Mrs G and kept saying how 'professional' she was. Honestly, that is the last word I would use to describe her. So nothing was done.

Then 2 weeks later and completely out of the blue, the School Accountant contacted us to tell us our Payment Plan was cancelled and we had until the end of the week to settle the fees for both DS and DD. I haven't mentioned DD until now as there's not a lot to say. She is a model student, quiet and well-behaved. She was in Year 5 at the time. The accountant said that if we did not pay the fees by the end of the week, DD 's place would be cancelled with immediate effect. They were allowing DS to stay on as he only had another year to go. This seemed so cruel to DD. She is such a lovely girl. It also didn't make sense. We had a Payment Plan and we were sticking to it. The demand just seemed to come from nowhere.

DS was still talking about leaving school and becoming a labourer or something, his motivation for school was zero and so I asked the school if they would consider cancelling DS's place and keeping DD. They agreed. So DS left school. We sacrificed DS for DD but felt coerced into it. This was a year ago. Needless to say, the labouring didn't work out. He tried another blue collar job and that didn't work out either. So he's at home, jobless, sad and depressed whilst all his friends are at uni.

I just feel the school let him down. I am struggling to still pay his fees from his last year at school and I resent it so much. He could have done so well if the school had helped him rather than ridicule him to another parent. I don't want to pay the last year of fees but they've got us over a barrel with DD.

Thanks for listening. Would like to know your thoughts.

OP posts:
CliffsofMohair · 12/02/2024 06:49

Lougle · 12/02/2024 04:20

I am sorry he has had such a hard time. What a lot to cope with. However, I think your description of 'blue collar job' says a lot and it sounds like he has taken on feelings of failure because of the value you place on academic success.

I agree that an EHCP is the way forward.

This.
rightly or wrongly there are huge wealth/class based assumptions of what he ‘should’ have achieved based on the calibre of the school he was attending. I can’t work out where he should be Years wise, but I would echo recommendations for some trauma counselling and some decent career guidance with a lens broader then just university courses.

user1492757084 · 12/02/2024 06:47

How does your DD feel?
Do you wish to swap her school?

I think you should apply for a waiver for your son's fees.

The school; council should bring up your case at a meeting at the very least. A polite, well written informative letter with dates etc that encompasses all of your son's interactions in his final two years should give the council enough knowledge to make a decision. Include the fact that you did NOT sue after DS was beaten while in the school's care.

You need those funds to encourage your DS entrance through non university ways (TAFE, polytech) into a qualification that will sustain him for life.
I'm so sad for your DS.

As an artistic person myself, I highly advise getting your son to enroll in any class for artistic expression that interests him.
Apprenticeships in house painting, stone masonry, cabinet making or certificates in drafting etc. might fuel his desire to create and design objects of beauty and usefulness.
Flower arrangeing, print making, glass blowing, landscape gardening assistant,Interior design and decorating assistant, wallpaper designer.
There are so many crafts that could light his fire and recognise his abilities.

Have you ever been to an ancient crafts exhibition or fair?
I went to one near the National Arboritum near Doughton

theeyeshaveit82 · 12/02/2024 06:43

and to think this entire situation is as a result of one comment? good lord. What the hell does your son think when you discuss that with him. He will know it is about so much more than that and the beef between you and the teacher is…. well just that…

stuckasastuckthing · 12/02/2024 06:41

Mumof2teens79 · 12/02/2024 05:58

Are you in England? Or possibly Australia? That might explain more. England doesn't really make sense as he would have had to stay in education to 18.
You say DS had a previous school...fairly recently? When did he move and why?
I think a bit more of a timeline
March 2020 covid hits?
You (all?) Got stranded overseas? Until 2021?
Sept(?) 2022 move into Y11? Or Jan 2022
Then Jan 2023 DS leaves school....in Y11? Or Y12?

I think your son has had a terrible time but I think elite private schools don't cope well with kids that are high fliers.

Australia does sound more likely if there is a 'Head of learning enhancement' and a diving instructor.

theeyeshaveit82 · 12/02/2024 06:39

I know you have no doubt been very very anxious and stressed about your son

but in my opinion you have approached this entirely wrong. This school ultimately is a business, and you have seen it as some kind of personal relationship where you basically stamp your feet and get what you want.

ThePure · 12/02/2024 06:35

Well you could ask. I expect they will say no
I think the assault is your best line of argument rather than a hearsay comment by a teacher as they accept that did happen on their watch

It's always difficult when a complaint is bound up with money because it makes it look that your complaint is purely financially motivated even if it is not.

If you do want DD to stay then is it really worth going to war over? I assume you are still on a payment plan for her fees which they could withdraw at any point. It kinda undermines your position that you are happy for your daughter to still attend a school that let your son down so badly that you should be compensated financially (which is in essence what you are arguing)

I actually would interpret the whole thing as your son being depressed. This is much more likely the cause of his school failure than one alleged comment from a teacher. If she did say it at all then it hit home more because it chimed with his pre existing beliefs about himself. I think he needs an antidepressant and therapy. Let him get the dog and explore some apprenticeships or vocational courses.

Sadly this scenario is not uncommon at 'elite private schools' where DC are under huge pressure for academic achievement

Winterstormm · 12/02/2024 06:33

Your son really needs to see a therapist asap. I don't think it's just the teacher's comments that have made your son feel this way. You could go private for therapy and send your son to a state college to do an apprenticeship and send your dd to a state primary to complete year 6. Do you really want to keep her at this school? It doesn't sound like a great place.

2mummies1baby · 12/02/2024 06:27

Avery2024 · 12/02/2024 01:30

Thanks for all your replies. I would like to request a waiver of Fees for Year 11 and half of Year 12. They totally let him down.

I don't think you have any justification in asking for the Year 11 fees to be waived, as you chose to keep him on for Year 12.

Out of interest, did you investigate after your son told you what Mrs G said? Did you ask whether he'd overheard the comment, or been told by his friend?

My heart is breaking for your poor son, who has been through a terrible few years and must be feeling so lost right now. What mental health support have you sought for him? Are you supporting him in finding a sixth form college to enrol in for September?

Regarding this comment from you:

However, after a few meetings, it was clear that we had lost him. No amount of help was going to do anything now.
**
This is a very defeatist attitude to have about someone so young, and is not helpful to him at all. He needs your support in getting his life back on track. * *

hattie43 · 12/02/2024 06:11

Ohnoooooooo · 12/02/2024 02:51

At my daughter’s private school you could send a complaint into the board and ask for fees to be waivered or reduced - could you do that?
I’m sorry it sounds like your son has had a horrendous time. I am wondering though did you speak to the other parent who apparently had told you son Mrs G said he as not bright? I am wondering if your son’s friend said his mum said that…and there is a case of Chinese whispers changing things slightly or the other boy said this to put down your son?

This was my first thought . OP firing off emails on the basis of hearsay .
Were the actual facts established.
The OP's son had far more going on than a hearsay comment by a teacher the headmaster is fully supporting .
Sounds like the OP is digging for reasons not to pay

Mumof2teens79 · 12/02/2024 05:58

Are you in England? Or possibly Australia? That might explain more. England doesn't really make sense as he would have had to stay in education to 18.
You say DS had a previous school...fairly recently? When did he move and why?
I think a bit more of a timeline
March 2020 covid hits?
You (all?) Got stranded overseas? Until 2021?
Sept(?) 2022 move into Y11? Or Jan 2022
Then Jan 2023 DS leaves school....in Y11? Or Y12?

I think your son has had a terrible time but I think elite private schools don't cope well with kids that are high fliers.

Lighrbulbmo · 12/02/2024 05:56

The longer he is out of school the harder it will be to convince himself he is not dumb, he has survived and is stronger than he knows. The best flowers need the right living conditions to thrive, he didn’t have that, it doesn’t mean he can never have that. Get him online learning, open university degrees are fantastic with a worldwide reputation to match. He can go to university, whilst staying at home, getting a little part time job. If he wants, what are his goals? I agree, he needs counseling. Many many schools now are little hot houses, any instability and they do not have the pastoral support.

You need to pay the fees though, you don’t pay for results and outcomes and pay to access and participate. Besides, you trust the school with your dd so they must be doing something right.

Best wishes and I hope your gets himself into something he loves.

theeyeshaveit82 · 12/02/2024 05:54

Avery2024 · 12/02/2024 01:30

Thanks for all your replies. I would like to request a waiver of Fees for Year 11 and half of Year 12. They totally let him down.

go for it
but not a cat’s chance in hell they will agree to this

Stopsnowing · 12/02/2024 05:48

If I have I understood correctly they cancelled the payment plan suddenly after you raised concerns? Might it be with checking with a lawyer the terms of the plan? I suspect the school may have discretion to cancel the plan at any time but on the other hand it should not act unreasonably.

10ThousandSpoons · 12/02/2024 05:44

What were the T&Cs for the payment plan?

Mumof2teens79 · 12/02/2024 05:34

Avery2024 · 12/02/2024 01:30

Thanks for all your replies. I would like to request a waiver of Fees for Year 11 and half of Year 12. They totally let him down.

I thought he left before Y12? Didn't he leave a yearvago half way through Y11?

MCOut · 12/02/2024 05:08

Your poor DS. What is their complaints procedure, is there someone you can escalate to above the head? They are punishing you for advocating for your child so it’s completely understandable for you not to want to pay but I think you will have to negotiate on that.

Your DS needs some therapy and then see if you can insist that he retakes Yr 12 & 13 in a more supportive environment. Especially with older children it’s hard to do but try because him doing blue collar work is completely OTT, don’t entertain it. I had a friend who was struggling so our school held her back a year and she’s now got a PhD. There are retake specialist places.

DomPom47 · 12/02/2024 04:48

Did your son sit his GCSE’s? Grades?
If he hasn’t done so he needs to speak to a professional about how he is feeling and work on his self confidence.
He does not need to go to university and he has not enjoyed the jobs he attempted.
Have you/he thought about apprenticeships linked to design?
https://www.apprenticeships.gov.uk/apprentices/browse-by-interests/creative-design#

Creative and design

https://www.apprenticeships.gov.uk/apprentices/browse-by-interests/creative-design#

Frangipanyoul8r · 12/02/2024 04:31

He’s had an awful time of it but it sounds like his school issues in isolation wouldn’t have derailed him from his studies alone. It’s everything that’s happened out of school that’s been the issue.

It sounds like there’s a melting pot of family and financial issues happening for you at the moment. Unfortunately you just have to keep going through it all, don’t waste too much energy on this one issue.

Lougle · 12/02/2024 04:20

I am sorry he has had such a hard time. What a lot to cope with. However, I think your description of 'blue collar job' says a lot and it sounds like he has taken on feelings of failure because of the value you place on academic success.

I agree that an EHCP is the way forward.

businesshelp · 12/02/2024 03:56

This sounds like an awful situation to be in. Poor DS. I second looking into an apprenticeship - you don't have to be very academic to get in and there's so much variety.

Ohnoooooooo · 12/02/2024 02:51

At my daughter’s private school you could send a complaint into the board and ask for fees to be waivered or reduced - could you do that?
I’m sorry it sounds like your son has had a horrendous time. I am wondering though did you speak to the other parent who apparently had told you son Mrs G said he as not bright? I am wondering if your son’s friend said his mum said that…and there is a case of Chinese whispers changing things slightly or the other boy said this to put down your son?

dorajean · 12/02/2024 02:44

@Avery2024
I’m very sorry to hear about all that your DS has been through.
I think the priority now is helping his mental health & maybe helping him start some activities he enjoys.
For mental health - it sounds like he needs some kind of therapy/counselling/maybe CBT (Cognitive Behavioural Therapy). I think he needs to contact his GP. Also see if he can get a referral to mental health services in your area - often GPs refer or he might be able to self-refer if he feels able to.
I suggest looking at some websites that might help for mental health ideas, e.g. Mind, Young minds, ADHD Foundation etc.
He might find some mental health apps useful. There are many different types - e.g. Headspace is well recommended as is the Samaritans app. Find what works for him.
The website ‘get self help’ is a great starting place to try to help yourself if you are waiting for a referral to mental health services. E.g.

This overview on low self-esteem and self help.
https://www.getselfhelp.co.uk/media/r3zllrdf/selfesteemqr.pdf

This worksheet on depression and self help.
https://www.getselfhelp.co.uk/docs/DepressionSelfHelp.pdf

They also have an ADHD self help webpage (disclaimer - it’s very long so I haven’t read it all - you might want to read it all yourself before passing it to your DS).
https://www.getselfhelp.co.uk/adhd-self-help/

I also think you and your DS should get together and brainstorm any activities he’d like to do/try. This could be anything to help get his spirits up. Something with a routine will probably be particularly helpful. E.g. any clubs he’d like to try? Running club, football club, choir, orchestra, craft club, IT club, programming club etc. etc.
Any general activities he’d like to try? Maybe he would like to try going to the gym or going swimming etc.
Any volunteering opportunities that might interest him? E.g. volunteering in a nature conservation organisation, volunteering at a local museum he’s interested in, volunteering in a charity shop etc.
Absolutely no pressure if he’s not ready for this yet, but he might like to think about any jobs that would interest him - that could be a part-time job in his favourite shop that he wants to apply for, to a longer-term career/job goal he’d like to begin to pursue.

Also there might be ADHD support groups he could access (online or in your local area).

Also, it’s so easy to compare himself to ‘all his friends at uni’ but there’s likely some people he knows that aren’t at university now. Even so, I was reminded of the phrase ‘comparison is the thief of joy’. As hard as it is, it is probably healthier for you and him to focus on his life now and what steps he wants to take to improve his life, than thinking of ‘all his friends having fun at uni without him’.

Best wishes to you and your DS

https://www.getselfhelp.co.uk/docs/DepressionSelfHelp.pdf

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 12/02/2024 01:46

Avery2024 · 11/02/2024 23:58

Loads of backstory here...

DS and DD both attended what is regarded as an 'elite private school' (not bragging, just giving context). Over the past 3 years, we have struggled with the fees due to my business closing during Covid and being stuck overseas for almost a year due to travel restrictions. However, the school were understanding and allowed us to enter into a payment plan, which we stuck to.

In 2022, DS entered Year 11 and was clear that he was struggling. He has ADHD (which is medicated) and homeschooling had really not worked for him. Added to this, his friend died in the most horrific circumstances, his best friend's dad committed suicide, his diving teacher was exposed as a paedophile and he was involved in two serious car accidents, all within a very short period of time.

I reached out to the Head of Learning Enhancement, Mrs G, at the beginning of the year as I felt DS needed some extra help and could we please have a short meeting. The school is very well resourced and she is in charge of coordinating any extra help that the students may need. It is a huge school with a strong emphasis on mental health. Her response was that we should speak again 'after the reports come out'. I replied that this was not for some time and that DS needed some help now as this was a very important year. She ignored my request. I emailed Mrs G a few more times but did not hear back. DS was then savagely beaten up by another boy at the school. The school to their credit dealt with it and expelled the boy. Nevertheless, DS was shaken by this and the incident just added to DS's problems.

A while later and quite suddenly, we noticed a change in DS. Although he was never what you would call an academic high flyer, nevertheless he had ambition and had planned to go to university to study industrial design. He was Design Ambassador at his previous school and it was clear that he had a flair for design. He spoke passionately about having his own design consultancy, buying a live/work unit locally that he had seen and getting a dog. He had it all planned out.

But suddenly out of the blue he started talking about leaving school as he was "too stupid for uni". He stopped caring about school work and started talking about leaving and taking on manual jobs, which isn't really him. Aside from anything else, he does not like to get dirty. He kept calling himself "dumb" and "useless". He had always been quite a confident boy and this behaviour was new. We had no idea what was going on until I finally heard from Mrs G suggesting we meet. Finally! I told DS in the car when I picked him up from school that Mrs G has finally agreed to meet with us and jokingly said I was tempted to tell her no, she had had her chance. DS then said, "Yeah! And she told [another boy's] mum that I was not the brightest!" I was so shocked I nearly crashed the car. I pulled over and DS burst into tears. He said that everybody thinks he's stupid.

We arrived home and I immediately emailed Mrs G (and the entire cc list that she had included on her email) that I was furious that she had told ANOTHER PARENT that DS was "not the brightest" and I did not want her anywhere near our son. The other people on cc (Head of Year, Head of Senior School, School Psychologist, etc) quickly organised a meeting (excluding Mrs G) and tried to put a programme together for DS. However, after a few meetings, it was clear that we had lost him. No amount of help was going to do anything now. A few months went by and DS was still completely disengaged from school.

I was still angry at Mrs G as I partly blamed her for us losing nearly a year and for her hurtful comment. We had always been very quiet parents and not ones to make a fuss. Nevertheless, I felt something needed to be done about Mrs G so DH went to see the Headmaster. At the very least, she owed DS an apology. The Headmaster was VERY defensive of Mrs G and kept saying how 'professional' she was. Honestly, that is the last word I would use to describe her. So nothing was done.

Then 2 weeks later and completely out of the blue, the School Accountant contacted us to tell us our Payment Plan was cancelled and we had until the end of the week to settle the fees for both DS and DD. I haven't mentioned DD until now as there's not a lot to say. She is a model student, quiet and well-behaved. She was in Year 5 at the time. The accountant said that if we did not pay the fees by the end of the week, DD 's place would be cancelled with immediate effect. They were allowing DS to stay on as he only had another year to go. This seemed so cruel to DD. She is such a lovely girl. It also didn't make sense. We had a Payment Plan and we were sticking to it. The demand just seemed to come from nowhere.

DS was still talking about leaving school and becoming a labourer or something, his motivation for school was zero and so I asked the school if they would consider cancelling DS's place and keeping DD. They agreed. So DS left school. We sacrificed DS for DD but felt coerced into it. This was a year ago. Needless to say, the labouring didn't work out. He tried another blue collar job and that didn't work out either. So he's at home, jobless, sad and depressed whilst all his friends are at uni.

I just feel the school let him down. I am struggling to still pay his fees from his last year at school and I resent it so much. He could have done so well if the school had helped him rather than ridicule him to another parent. I don't want to pay the last year of fees but they've got us over a barrel with DD.

Thanks for listening. Would like to know your thoughts.

My Dd dropped out of school in Year 12. She’s got AUDHD. She hadn’t been through the same as your ds but was totally traumatised by school and refused to set foot in a school ever again.

12 months later she has an EHCP and is going to an ASD 6 th form. One or 2 children to
a teacher. Quiet, easy relaxed but very supportive staff. Each child has their own support mentor. Anything less like a school is hard to imagine.

Give him time. You need an EHCP.

BananaSpanner · 12/02/2024 01:43

He needs to apply for a local college for courses that interest him, they don’t have to be hugely academic but something related to his interests.

To be honest, given the way the school have treated you re this payment plan, I would be withdrawing DD from there also. You are not going to be able to argue anything with them in relation to fees if you have another one still there and it sounds like the relationship has broken down anyway. If she would be due to start y7 in September, this summer would be a good time to move her.

Testina · 12/02/2024 01:37

What country are you in? If he was England / Wales, no elite private school would have let him enter Y12 without very good GCSE results in Y11. As you’re asking a legal point on refusing to pay, it would help to know. And for posters like the one above with direct experience in private school debt repayment, and again it could make a difference in another country, what normal practice was.

I think you would be hard pressed to get a waiver on Y11, because you would be deemed “happy” with what they delivered, when you kept him there for Y12, until he withdrew.