Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to pay DS's 2022-23 school fees?

138 replies

Avery2024 · 11/02/2024 23:58

Loads of backstory here...

DS and DD both attended what is regarded as an 'elite private school' (not bragging, just giving context). Over the past 3 years, we have struggled with the fees due to my business closing during Covid and being stuck overseas for almost a year due to travel restrictions. However, the school were understanding and allowed us to enter into a payment plan, which we stuck to.

In 2022, DS entered Year 11 and was clear that he was struggling. He has ADHD (which is medicated) and homeschooling had really not worked for him. Added to this, his friend died in the most horrific circumstances, his best friend's dad committed suicide, his diving teacher was exposed as a paedophile and he was involved in two serious car accidents, all within a very short period of time.

I reached out to the Head of Learning Enhancement, Mrs G, at the beginning of the year as I felt DS needed some extra help and could we please have a short meeting. The school is very well resourced and she is in charge of coordinating any extra help that the students may need. It is a huge school with a strong emphasis on mental health. Her response was that we should speak again 'after the reports come out'. I replied that this was not for some time and that DS needed some help now as this was a very important year. She ignored my request. I emailed Mrs G a few more times but did not hear back. DS was then savagely beaten up by another boy at the school. The school to their credit dealt with it and expelled the boy. Nevertheless, DS was shaken by this and the incident just added to DS's problems.

A while later and quite suddenly, we noticed a change in DS. Although he was never what you would call an academic high flyer, nevertheless he had ambition and had planned to go to university to study industrial design. He was Design Ambassador at his previous school and it was clear that he had a flair for design. He spoke passionately about having his own design consultancy, buying a live/work unit locally that he had seen and getting a dog. He had it all planned out.

But suddenly out of the blue he started talking about leaving school as he was "too stupid for uni". He stopped caring about school work and started talking about leaving and taking on manual jobs, which isn't really him. Aside from anything else, he does not like to get dirty. He kept calling himself "dumb" and "useless". He had always been quite a confident boy and this behaviour was new. We had no idea what was going on until I finally heard from Mrs G suggesting we meet. Finally! I told DS in the car when I picked him up from school that Mrs G has finally agreed to meet with us and jokingly said I was tempted to tell her no, she had had her chance. DS then said, "Yeah! And she told [another boy's] mum that I was not the brightest!" I was so shocked I nearly crashed the car. I pulled over and DS burst into tears. He said that everybody thinks he's stupid.

We arrived home and I immediately emailed Mrs G (and the entire cc list that she had included on her email) that I was furious that she had told ANOTHER PARENT that DS was "not the brightest" and I did not want her anywhere near our son. The other people on cc (Head of Year, Head of Senior School, School Psychologist, etc) quickly organised a meeting (excluding Mrs G) and tried to put a programme together for DS. However, after a few meetings, it was clear that we had lost him. No amount of help was going to do anything now. A few months went by and DS was still completely disengaged from school.

I was still angry at Mrs G as I partly blamed her for us losing nearly a year and for her hurtful comment. We had always been very quiet parents and not ones to make a fuss. Nevertheless, I felt something needed to be done about Mrs G so DH went to see the Headmaster. At the very least, she owed DS an apology. The Headmaster was VERY defensive of Mrs G and kept saying how 'professional' she was. Honestly, that is the last word I would use to describe her. So nothing was done.

Then 2 weeks later and completely out of the blue, the School Accountant contacted us to tell us our Payment Plan was cancelled and we had until the end of the week to settle the fees for both DS and DD. I haven't mentioned DD until now as there's not a lot to say. She is a model student, quiet and well-behaved. She was in Year 5 at the time. The accountant said that if we did not pay the fees by the end of the week, DD 's place would be cancelled with immediate effect. They were allowing DS to stay on as he only had another year to go. This seemed so cruel to DD. She is such a lovely girl. It also didn't make sense. We had a Payment Plan and we were sticking to it. The demand just seemed to come from nowhere.

DS was still talking about leaving school and becoming a labourer or something, his motivation for school was zero and so I asked the school if they would consider cancelling DS's place and keeping DD. They agreed. So DS left school. We sacrificed DS for DD but felt coerced into it. This was a year ago. Needless to say, the labouring didn't work out. He tried another blue collar job and that didn't work out either. So he's at home, jobless, sad and depressed whilst all his friends are at uni.

I just feel the school let him down. I am struggling to still pay his fees from his last year at school and I resent it so much. He could have done so well if the school had helped him rather than ridicule him to another parent. I don't want to pay the last year of fees but they've got us over a barrel with DD.

Thanks for listening. Would like to know your thoughts.

OP posts:
Onelifeonly · 12/02/2024 08:14

Pay them what you owe and focus on supporting your poor son. You are focusing on the wrong thing. What's happened has happened and can't be changed, however angry you get and whoever you choose to blame. He needs mental health support. He can get a job that isn't 'labouring' or 'blue collar' and work his way back into education when he is ready. I know several people who gained degrees long after they left their late teens / early 20s.

Glonty · 12/02/2024 08:11

Which worktops are better?
I love being able to out hot pans/dishes on ours ans it's really easy to clean

Anjea · 12/02/2024 08:10

Almost crashing your car because of an alleged comment to another parent's is incredibly over the top.

I think after all your DS went through it's impossible to pinpoint one alleged comment to his problems, poor kid.

Dolphinnoises · 12/02/2024 08:08

If you do that, they will chuck your DD out, and you know it. Bluntly, they have you over a barrel. Are you still managing the fees without the payment plan?

Your trust in this school has gone, and I don’t blame you. Is there another school your DD could go to?

Your DS needs to find his anger. Perhaps with therapy he can come to see that Mrs G is just a person, one of millions, not the final arbiter of DS’s character.

Onelifeonly · 12/02/2024 08:06

I know nothing about private schools but, like any other business, assume they have contracts and can't just waive fees for time spent in education there.

Given the trauma was caused by circumstances which had nothing to do with the school (other than Mrs G saying he wasn't that bright - how does he / do you even know this?), I can't understand why you pinned all hopes on a meeting with Mrs G? Did your son not see a GP and did you not ask for therapeutic support? I understand a school might have a counsellor or similar, but from what you say, this situation went far beyond a bit of anxiety over work or friendships and needed more specialised input.

thaegumathteth · 12/02/2024 08:04

You'll have to pay the fees so forget that line of enquiry.

I have absolutely no idea why you'd want your Dd in the school - I presume she hasn't always been there given your ds was previously in another school and he's older?

Focus on your ds. I am saying this kindly but I don't think it's just the school who has let him down. I'd be a lot less worried about qualifications and a lot more worried about mental health right now. You need to get him help and really support him and not prioritise what you see as success.

I'd 100% move your daughter. You can't afford the fees, the school and you have a bad relationship and she's young enough to do it without impacting exams.

HenndigoOZ · 12/02/2024 08:03

I am guessing that as they are an elite private school, they have a waiting list and they just decided to try and make your family disappear with the payment plan cancellation and demand you suddenly settle up, even though you were sticking to the payment schedule.

I work for an Australian private school (a low fee one) and we would never cancel a payment plan that was working. It seems very odd tbh.

Unfortunately you probably should have asked for the fee waiver at the time of asking DS’s place be cancelled, when it seems they were most keen for him to go. Did they make you sign a contract upon enrolment about paying fees in lieu of notice upon departure? If so, then legally it will be difficult to argue for non payment of fees.

I would claim financial hardship (as your business isn’t doing well and you are supporting your DS) and ask for a new, long payment plan with small amounts. Going to court would be a pain from their perspective and they would most likely prefer to opt for the new payment plan.

Scarletttulips · 12/02/2024 08:02

There is a failure to educate law - I don’t know much about it, but as the school is a business and you are required to pay fees, maybe suggest that?

As far as your sons concerned I would get him some councilling and consider a college coarse for September - or if he’s still wants a job maybe a low end retail position would be a good starting point?

Viviennemary · 12/02/2024 08:02

The point is private schools need to balance their budgets. If the payment plan wasnt guaranteed then they can terminate it. It doesn't sound the right school for your DS. But if there are financial issues at home and you are unable to pay the school fees then that's more stress for the family and not really the schools fault.

theeyeshaveit82 · 12/02/2024 08:00

Did you actually establish what Mrs G said?

of course the OP didn’t

SausageRollsWithMustard · 12/02/2024 07:58

Did you actually establish what Mrs G said?
It all sounds a bit 'he said she said' to me.

Although what you need to do is to focus on your son. He needs some therapy, maybe tutoring, or to concentrate on his design or related hobbies for a while, to build up his confidence.
And a 'labourer 'type job (as you describe it) is not the worst. People like builders, electricians etc are very skilled and potentially can earn a lot! It actually might work very well if he has an eye for design.

Ggttl · 12/02/2024 07:57

CatchAButterfly · 12/02/2024 07:50

Your DS has had a horrific time and I hope he is now doing ok. But honestly, sounds like you’re just looking for an excuse not to pay. You were already struggling with the fees and it does sound like you think you’ve found a reason to save money. But seeing as this happened when he was in year 11, and you’re talking about trying to avoid year 12 fees too, it clearly wasn’t that big a deal to you as otherwise you would have pulled him out.

YANBU to be annoyed at Mrs G. YABU to not pay school fees.

I agree with this. It doesn’t sound like the right place for your son but you were not forced to keep him there. Presumably the school has been providing lessons, food, facilities etc. so I don’t think you will be able to get your money back.

NotQuiteNorma · 12/02/2024 07:57

I agree. It does seem a case of looking for reasons not to pay. Possibly a bit pissed that her DD has also been cancelled. Half of the original post doesn't really seem relevant to be honest. If you are going to decide to ask for a waiver on fees because you think the school let your child down then you need proof at the very least, not hearsay. You still benefited from the academic year. From the schools point of view, if you have indeed gone off on one based on gossip you can't verify as fact against Mrs G, why would they want your kids to remain?

MustBeNapTime · 12/02/2024 07:53

FlamingoQueen · 12/02/2024 07:39

Personally, I would remove my dc from the school. If it was the local state school that had treated your ds badly, you would have removed him ages ago. The staff sound awful and stuck up (well, Mrs G is the worst). Your son is having no education there at all, get him out whilst you still can.
I’m sorry that this has happened - it must be so stressful.

You might want to actually read ALL of the OP's one and only post before you comment... 😉

CatchAButterfly · 12/02/2024 07:50

Your DS has had a horrific time and I hope he is now doing ok. But honestly, sounds like you’re just looking for an excuse not to pay. You were already struggling with the fees and it does sound like you think you’ve found a reason to save money. But seeing as this happened when he was in year 11, and you’re talking about trying to avoid year 12 fees too, it clearly wasn’t that big a deal to you as otherwise you would have pulled him out.

YANBU to be annoyed at Mrs G. YABU to not pay school fees.

Namechangenamechanged · 12/02/2024 07:50

Do you know exactly what Mrs G said though? It could have been something like ‘he’s not the brightest but he is very hard working or resilient or literally any other nice thing about your son. It is unprofessional of her to comment on your child to another parent though. I’d be reluctant to take a second hand comment out of context and blame your sons entire woes on that, because he’s been through a lot that is likely to have affected him just as much if not more so. He needs therapy to help him process the traumatic events, not just blaming the school. And you owe them money and their contract is likely to be tight.

FlamingoQueen · 12/02/2024 07:39

Personally, I would remove my dc from the school. If it was the local state school that had treated your ds badly, you would have removed him ages ago. The staff sound awful and stuck up (well, Mrs G is the worst). Your son is having no education there at all, get him out whilst you still can.
I’m sorry that this has happened - it must be so stressful.

mitogoshi · 12/02/2024 07:26

I'm guessing not U.K. since I can't advise on any specific legal matters, there's bodies in the U.K. that can mediate, check for the jurestriction you are in.

Poirott · 12/02/2024 07:18

Another one here confused by the timelines. Year 11 2022 entry means he is sitting his A levels next year so his friends should still be in school?

Dancerprancer19 · 12/02/2024 07:14

As upsetting as it all is there is really nothing to be gained by attempting not to pay (you would end up paying anyway).

The most sensible course of action is to apply for good state secondary schools for your daughter so you get rid of the financial pressure and to support your son emotionally. My priority would be trauma therapy too.

ThePure · 12/02/2024 07:05

My DH is a successful industrial designer despite failing maths and some of his other GCSEs. I think he got a U for French (back in the day). His parents had also paid for posh private school where he felt a fish out of water. They kicked him out after his GCSEs which did not help his self esteem. He is dyslexic and can't spell for toffee which many artistic people are. He has a huge range of talents in art, music and design but these are not things the exam system credits. I didn't know him then but I think it was a very rough patch for him and he felt he had let his parents down as they had stretched to pay private fees.
Fortunately he was able to retake maths and do A levels part time at an FE college whilst also playing in bands and doing session musician work which boosted his confidence and in the end he went to uni and got a design degree.
So it can work out.

Soontobe60 · 12/02/2024 07:01

Blimey, this all sounds a bit much!
I would assume that you followed the schools complaints procedure when the staff member failed to respond? As a parent concerned about her child, that’s what I would have done - can’t get a response from HOY, escalate to their line manager. As for this teacher commenting on your DSs abilities to another student’s parent, I seriously doubt this has happened.
Your responsibility to your DS is to get him some therapy. I’d remove my DD from the school too - you can’t afford it and her staying there is just rubbing your DSs nose into it.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 12/02/2024 06:59

Avery2024 · 12/02/2024 01:30

Thanks for all your replies. I would like to request a waiver of Fees for Year 11 and half of Year 12. They totally let him down.

They're not going to let you get away with not paying for an entire year of education when you kept him in the school for at least some of following year Confused

It sounds like you're under huge financial stress with your business and just can't afford to pay.

Your son shouldn't have been kept at a school where he miserable.

confusedbythesystem · 12/02/2024 06:57

user1492757084 · 12/02/2024 06:47

How does your DD feel?
Do you wish to swap her school?

I think you should apply for a waiver for your son's fees.

The school; council should bring up your case at a meeting at the very least. A polite, well written informative letter with dates etc that encompasses all of your son's interactions in his final two years should give the council enough knowledge to make a decision. Include the fact that you did NOT sue after DS was beaten while in the school's care.

You need those funds to encourage your DS entrance through non university ways (TAFE, polytech) into a qualification that will sustain him for life.
I'm so sad for your DS.

As an artistic person myself, I highly advise getting your son to enroll in any class for artistic expression that interests him.
Apprenticeships in house painting, stone masonry, cabinet making or certificates in drafting etc. might fuel his desire to create and design objects of beauty and usefulness.
Flower arrangeing, print making, glass blowing, landscape gardening assistant,Interior design and decorating assistant, wallpaper designer.
There are so many crafts that could light his fire and recognise his abilities.

Have you ever been to an ancient crafts exhibition or fair?
I went to one near the National Arboritum near Doughton

Really refreshing advice here.

ThePure · 12/02/2024 06:57

Did you ever put in a formal complaint using the complaints procedure? I think you need to do that first without mentioning any money and then if you have officially upheld findings then you have a bargaining chip for negotiating on the money. At the moment you don't seem to really have anything.