Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dear dreh, Dear dreh, Dear dreh

169 replies

Toomanythalias · 11/02/2024 21:26

Following on from the Call the Midwife thread. Jeeze it's not difficult to pronounce Deirdre correctly, but so many English people continue to insult our beautiful old Irish name with that ghastly Coronation Street pronunciation. It's Dear dreh, folks, not DEEER DREEE.

OP posts:
inappropriateraspberry · 12/02/2024 06:11

KimberleyClark · 12/02/2024 06:06

As a Welsh person the mispronunciation of Lowri (Welsh form of Laura) annoys me. It is not pronounced like the artist from Salford. The low part rhymes with flow.

What about David Bowie? I'm never sure how to say it! 😆

Devonshiregal · 12/02/2024 06:08

Omg such a boring topic. Do you tell French people off when they can’t pronounce English words properly? Or Spanish? People have different palates. Our mouths literally can’t pronounce other sounds the same if we didn’t grow speaking them. I can’t sound Irish nor can I sound Italian so I pronounce names the best I can in my accent. I can’t perfectly pronounce all my friend’s names who are from Mexico or Latvia just as they can’t pronounce mine perfectly either. Also appropriation? What a fucking divisive laugh you’re having there - you have zero idea who is Irish hence called an Irish name. Many people in England/across the uk have Irish ancestry so have Irish names in their family. You’re either racist or just spreading hate because you’re bitter about something else in your life. There are literally so many problems in this world and you chose.to chastise someone for not pronouncing something and “cultural appropriation”. It would have been soooo easy for you to post say “did anyone know in Ireland we pronounce it this way?” But no, you want to make everyone who pronounced it “wrong” feel like bad bad people. What a lovely person you are

KimberleyClark · 12/02/2024 06:06

As a Welsh person the mispronunciation of Lowri (Welsh form of Laura) annoys me. It is not pronounced like the artist from Salford. The low part rhymes with flow.

inappropriateraspberry · 12/02/2024 06:06

ChateauMargaux · 12/02/2024 06:00

There are no words in English ending in re that are pronounced 'rie' or 'ry' like flowery.

(Bracing myself for correction but I looked at all 1197 in the fun with words list).

In fact, most words ending in re are preceeded by a vowel, future, furore, mire, which makes a significant difference to pronunciation... but nothing approximating 'rie'.

The other 're' form in English comes from French words ending in re which in English is pronounced er.. Theatre.. pronounced Theater. Applying this method would be much closer to the Irish pronounciation.

It also annoys me that it is often spelt without the first r.. Dear Deidre in the Sun for example.

And yes... it is much more painful to Irish ears than Barcelona or Paris because there is a history of occupation, suppression of the Irish language and forced anglicisation of all Irish names which was a deliberate policy to conquer and subdue an entire population.

Actually furore is pronounced fyoo-raw-ree, so does have that sound on the end.

EarringsandLipstick · 12/02/2024 06:05

forced anglicisation of all Irish names

I have a history degree, issues around British occupation interest me as much as anyone - but that's not really the exact story in terms of why so many Irish names became anglicised or more pertinently, several generations post-Famine consciously moved away from speaking Irish or naming their DC Irish names.

ChateauMargaux · 12/02/2024 06:00

There are no words in English ending in re that are pronounced 'rie' or 'ry' like flowery.

(Bracing myself for correction but I looked at all 1197 in the fun with words list).

In fact, most words ending in re are preceeded by a vowel, future, furore, mire, which makes a significant difference to pronunciation... but nothing approximating 'rie'.

The other 're' form in English comes from French words ending in re which in English is pronounced er.. Theatre.. pronounced Theater. Applying this method would be much closer to the Irish pronounciation.

It also annoys me that it is often spelt without the first r.. Dear Deidre in the Sun for example.

And yes... it is much more painful to Irish ears than Barcelona or Paris because there is a history of occupation, suppression of the Irish language and forced anglicisation of all Irish names which was a deliberate policy to conquer and subdue an entire population.

inappropriateraspberry · 12/02/2024 05:56

On the Beaulieu note, I always wonder if Doublebois (Dubble-boys) in Cornwall was originally the French pronunciation. I'd rather visit Doo-blue-bwah!

CoalTit · 12/02/2024 05:02

EdithStourton · 11/02/2024 22:16

where Beaulieu is pronounced bewley
@CoalTit how are you supposed to pronounce it?

@EdithStourton
Bewley to other locals, and Beau lieu ("beautiful place" in French, pronounced something like Bo Lee er) to bewildered French tourists trying to find it on a map at your New Forest B&B. The B&B owner said she had spent time in France, but she told these poor French people to go to Bewley, and of course they didn't associate the word Beaulieu with Bewley.

TheOriginalEmu · 12/02/2024 04:42

TwirlBar · 12/02/2024 02:56

I don't know about pp but for me Órla sounds strange said as Awla even though I realise it's down to accent.

Imagine someone from a different country pronouncing Harry as Ha-wee, for example.
You know it's because of their different accent, and it's not deliberate or anything, but it still does sound odd.

Yeah I get what you mean. I shall make more effort, it just never occurred to me before for some reason!

Mystro202 · 12/02/2024 04:13

I'm from ROI originally but live in NI and even here I know a few Deirdre's and they pronounce it "Deerdree" too. Where I'm from we say "Deerdra" but I wouldn't pronounce it as that as they don't say it that way.

Salaaaaaaaah · 12/02/2024 04:13

theduchessofspork · 12/02/2024 02:11

Deirdre has been used in the UK for quite some while, it’s taken on a separate pronunciation. Language changes, and languages adopt and adapt words from other languages. that’s just how language works.

In Germany they pronounce Charlotte Char-lot-uh, it would be pretty weird if French people were bothered about this.

You're right which is why OP is being unreasonable. I'm Irish (northern) and I know it's pronounced here as she said it is, but to expect other nationalities to suddenly alter their accent and pronounce it the same is ridiculous.

I speak much like Nadine from Girls Aloud, so me trying to say an English name the way someone from London would is not happening. You either have your own accent or you drop it and adopt someone elses; no reasonable person would expect the latter.

Get in the car:

English say: "get in the kaa"... I would say it like "get in the kee-are" (not sure if I've written that right but that's close to how I say it)

So yeah, accents OP, they're different. shock horror lol

TwirlBar · 12/02/2024 02:56

TheOriginalEmu · 12/02/2024 02:10

@Toomanythalias as an aside, something I was thinking about recently, the name Orla, does it bother Irish people when people with non-rhotic accents (so the welsh and the English mostly in the U.K.) pronounce it without the R. In my accent I’m English Rs before consonants and at the end of words are ignored so I naturally say Aw-La. But in Irish R is pronounced so really I should say it more like Or-La. It’s never occurred to me before.

I don't know about pp but for me Órla sounds strange said as Awla even though I realise it's down to accent.

Imagine someone from a different country pronouncing Harry as Ha-wee, for example.
You know it's because of their different accent, and it's not deliberate or anything, but it still does sound odd.

JMSA · 12/02/2024 02:49

It could never be a beautiful name Grin

EarringsandLipstick · 12/02/2024 02:16

Deirdre has been used in the UK for quite some while, it’s taken on a separate pronunciation. Language changes, and languages adopt and adapt words from other languages. that’s just how language works.

On balance I agree with this. (Irish, living in Ireland, who usually is up in arms at the mangling of Irish names. And I have a specifically Irish name that is very hard for anyone not Irish to pronounce, from just seeing it!)

I hate 'Dear-dree' but see it as an adaptation not mispronouncing the Irish version

A lot of people I know who are called 'Deirdre' here, are Gaelgóirs & so pronounce it as Gaeilge so 'Dare-Dreh' which I prefer.

SammyScrounge · 12/02/2024 02:13

LizFromMotherland · 11/02/2024 21:48

Do the Scots and the Welsh pronounce it the Irish way OP?

In Scottish Highlands I have heard it pronounced Deer-dra

Tomatina · 12/02/2024 02:12

Toomanythalias · 11/02/2024 21:57

I disagree. If you appropriate a name from a different country or culture at least bloody pronounce it correctly.

You can't "appropriate" a name, because names are not property. Names are constantly being borrowed and adapted from different countries and cultures, much like language in general. This has been going on for thousands of years.

theduchessofspork · 12/02/2024 02:11

mathanxiety · 12/02/2024 00:26

I'm going to take issue with this.

If English people can wrap their heads around Charlotte and Marguerite they can manage Deirdre.

Simon and Laura are names that are 'native' to most countries in western Europe. They have biblical and classical origins amd have been absorbed into many cultures. Deirdre is a name that is very region-specific, along with many other names - Angharad, Eilidh, Noortje, Lahja, Silke, and many others. They have not spread widely except to countries next door.

It is apparently asking too much that a namenfrom next door is pronounced properly.

Deirdre has been used in the UK for quite some while, it’s taken on a separate pronunciation. Language changes, and languages adopt and adapt words from other languages. that’s just how language works.

In Germany they pronounce Charlotte Char-lot-uh, it would be pretty weird if French people were bothered about this.

BusyMummy001 · 12/02/2024 02:10

Unless you’re Irish… in which case it may be pronounce dear - dra.

TheOriginalEmu · 12/02/2024 02:10

@Toomanythalias as an aside, something I was thinking about recently, the name Orla, does it bother Irish people when people with non-rhotic accents (so the welsh and the English mostly in the U.K.) pronounce it without the R. In my accent I’m English Rs before consonants and at the end of words are ignored so I naturally say Aw-La. But in Irish R is pronounced so really I should say it more like Or-La. It’s never occurred to me before.

TheOriginalEmu · 12/02/2024 02:04

yes, I feel the same about the name Seren which is beautiful until it gets mangled into Seh-run.
its painful

Heather37231 · 12/02/2024 02:04

UneFoisAuChalet · 12/02/2024 00:12

No offence OP but no one in England can pronounce my name in the U.K. - because it’s French!

I could also start a thread whinging ‘why can’t anyone say it properly’? But that would be me basically forcing a group of people to conform (to more precisely roll their rrrrrrs).

I keep in mind that if they were to go to my home country, most wouldn’t be able to pronounce their English names.

It’s all even Stevens, hills to die on, battles to pick 🤷‍♀️

Edited

The French “r” is not rolled though. The Spanish”r” is rolled. The Scots, and other rhotic speakers of English, roll their”r”s in a less pronounced way than the Spanish.

The French “r” is pronounced in a uniquely French way in the back of the throat which probably has a name in French but no equivalent name in English. Some people do find it very hard to replicate, and being a rhotic speaker doesn’t make it any easier.

HollyKnight · 12/02/2024 01:50

What about "Mary"? I work with two of them. One is Mare-ry and the other is Meer-ree.

theduchessofspork · 12/02/2024 01:48

Toomanythalias · 11/02/2024 21:46

It's probably more Deahr dreh. Very soft, not the harsh English sounding pronunciation.

Edited

Probably depends on the accent, it doesn’t sound especially soft in NI. I don’t much like either but Deer-drie isn’t worse IMO. Prefer Caitlin in its anglo phonetic form too. Shoot me now…

TheHateIsNotGood · 12/02/2024 01:40

And don't forget folks, the oldsters in the Bay Area, CA pronounce San Francisco as "The City". Just sayin.......

MeinKraft · 12/02/2024 01:19

Funny I had just been thinking today of when Deirdre Barlow had the fling with Dev. And then there was the whole 'free Deirdre Barlow' campaign when she went to jail for something or other.