Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dear dreh, Dear dreh, Dear dreh

169 replies

Toomanythalias · 11/02/2024 21:26

Following on from the Call the Midwife thread. Jeeze it's not difficult to pronounce Deirdre correctly, but so many English people continue to insult our beautiful old Irish name with that ghastly Coronation Street pronunciation. It's Dear dreh, folks, not DEEER DREEE.

OP posts:
WinterDeWinter · 12/02/2024 12:09

The Irish Deirdre I knew pron it Dear-druh.

KimberleyClark · 12/02/2024 12:08

However, not sure why everyone thinks “Dierdreh” is a beautiful name though: it literally means Sorrow or Broken-hearted!

Ditto Dolores - means pain or sorrow!

OnOtherPlanets · 12/02/2024 12:06

Anyotherdude · 12/02/2024 09:06

My pet hate for overly mis-pronounced names are A-liss-ia (gaah!) instead of A-leash-a for Alicia, Rocks-Anne instead of Rose-Anne for Roxanne, but in truth, I realise that people can use whatever pronunciation they want to!
However, not sure why everyone thinks “Dierdreh” is a beautiful name though: it literally means Sorrow or Broken-hearted!
I certainly wouldn’t want to saddle anyone with that - especially if their sibling is endowed with a name that means something joyful, such as Dominic (gift from God) or Aoife (beautiful, radiant or joyful). This is apparent in many Irish families I know!
I always wondered why the Irish, in particular, do that? (I’m of Irish extraction myself)…

Being of ‘Irish extraction’ doesn’t make you accurate, though. Deirdre doesn’t mean ‘sorrow’ unless you take those dimwit baby name sites seriously. It’s from Old Irish, and is probably from the root for ‘daughter”. It’s associated with sorrow because of Deirdre in the Ulster Cycle, but given that people of many nationalities call their children Cassandra, Jonah, Dolores and Ophelia etc all the time, I hardly think giving children names associated with misfortune is ‘an Irish thing’.

MorrisZapp · 12/02/2024 11:59

I can see Deidre now Lorraine has gone

OhItsOnlyCynthia · 12/02/2024 11:49

MoreCraicPlease · 12/02/2024 11:42

How is Llewelyn pronounced? I realise now I’m probably saying that one wrong!

It doesn't sound like Lou-Ellen, which I hear quite often.

'Ll' is a letter in the Welsh alphabet and doesn't sound like an L as you might say for Louise. I don't think I can describe it in words, but it's made by passing air over the sides of the tongue and onto your teeth. Have you heard places like Llandudno or Llanfair being said on TV?

MoreCraicPlease · 12/02/2024 11:42

How is Llewelyn pronounced? I realise now I’m probably saying that one wrong!

AnneElliott · 12/02/2024 10:44

I noticed that as well - but only because I had a work colleague who pronounced it the Irish way. It sounds so much better!

Moonmoose · 12/02/2024 10:23

Tetsuo · 12/02/2024 00:52

Ok, so I have a son called Llewelyn.

I live in England, I don't go into spasm every time someone pronounces it lew-el-in.

It's obviously nice when someone pronounces the Ll correctly, I appreciate that.

But in all honesty, he's lived in England for more than half of his life and he's happy enough with the Anglicised version.

That's very reasonable.

I'm English, but I'm pretty well familiar with the Welsh language and speak it a tiny bit. Pronouncing Ll is no problem.

However, I have to admit I'd probably not use a proper Ll sound if I met someone called Llewelyn in England (even if said Llewelyn was Welsh). I'd worry it would come across that I'm sort of putting on a Welsh accent/taking the mick a bit - especially as someone I just met would only know me as an English person and not know my personal connections to Wales.

I suppose might do a very half hearted Ll that sounds more like a muffled Cl and hope for the best Grin that may well offend a Welsh person more though for all I know!

iamveryearlytoday · 12/02/2024 10:14

If you think Dear-dree is bad...

OhItsOnlyCynthia · 12/02/2024 10:06

Is just an anglicised way of saying it isn't it, not exactly wrong, just different. Dylan is more commonly said the anglicised way, and Rhys. They're understandable variations.

LakeTiticaca · 12/02/2024 10:05

On a scale of one to ten, how many English people do you think give a shit how Deirdre should be announced?
My guess is somewhere between zero and zilch.
They are probably more concerned about their next gas bill tbh

Willyoujustbequiet · 12/02/2024 09:58

Tomatina · 12/02/2024 02:12

You can't "appropriate" a name, because names are not property. Names are constantly being borrowed and adapted from different countries and cultures, much like language in general. This has been going on for thousands of years.

This.

Language evolves. There is no right or wrong. That's why there is accepted American English now as opposed to British English. The Corrie version is pretty standard here, it's not incorrect it's just evolved into that pronunciation taking our different accents and dialects into account.

0rangeCrush · 12/02/2024 09:27

MoreCraicPlease · 12/02/2024 08:15

This is a crazy thread. Languages and accents evolve all the time and not in sync. Who actually cares?

It happens the other way around too. Some Dublin people pronounce Ethan as ETIN and Lauren as LAREN.

OP - wait till you hear how Conor is pronounced in England.. CON-AH.

Try getting a Scottish person to say Karl. It actually makes me nervous if I know I’ve to say that name. I avoid it wherever possible.

Anyotherdude · 12/02/2024 09:06

My pet hate for overly mis-pronounced names are A-liss-ia (gaah!) instead of A-leash-a for Alicia, Rocks-Anne instead of Rose-Anne for Roxanne, but in truth, I realise that people can use whatever pronunciation they want to!
However, not sure why everyone thinks “Dierdreh” is a beautiful name though: it literally means Sorrow or Broken-hearted!
I certainly wouldn’t want to saddle anyone with that - especially if their sibling is endowed with a name that means something joyful, such as Dominic (gift from God) or Aoife (beautiful, radiant or joyful). This is apparent in many Irish families I know!
I always wondered why the Irish, in particular, do that? (I’m of Irish extraction myself)…

Zapss · 12/02/2024 08:53

TwirlBar · 12/02/2024 08:42

No

I'd better keep pronouncing it Deardray then, same as my very charming friend and colleague Deirdre does.

TwirlBar · 12/02/2024 08:42

No

Zapss · 12/02/2024 08:33

So is it sort of "Dear Dr-eugh," sticking my tongue out at the end?

MoreCraicPlease · 12/02/2024 08:15

This is a crazy thread. Languages and accents evolve all the time and not in sync. Who actually cares?

It happens the other way around too. Some Dublin people pronounce Ethan as ETIN and Lauren as LAREN.

OP - wait till you hear how Conor is pronounced in England.. CON-AH.

ChateauMargaux · 12/02/2024 07:34

EarringsandLipstick · 12/02/2024 06:05

forced anglicisation of all Irish names

I have a history degree, issues around British occupation interest me as much as anyone - but that's not really the exact story in terms of why so many Irish names became anglicised or more pertinently, several generations post-Famine consciously moved away from speaking Irish or naming their DC Irish names.

I think it's rather more nuanced than either my post or yours would imply..

"The Elizabethan conquest of Ireland (1565-1603) marks the first time a central government was established in Ireland. The native Brehon laws were outlawed and English law imposed. People were cleared off their land, all things Irish were despised, it became unfashionable to have an Irish name.

While the surname change process was initiated by oppression it was not the sole cause. In the new political and social climate one could only hope to ascend through the social ranks by appearing to conform to the new social order. Surname change was an imperative of survival as the alternative was to face annihilation be it social, financial or physical.

In reality many families had two names, one for official documents and another which they were commonly known by to their friends, neighbours and relations."

As recently as the 1980's it was not uncommon for Irish people to be stopped by the police and asked for the English version of their names when they gave their Irish names.

incognito50me · 12/02/2024 06:44

Heather37231 · 12/02/2024 02:04

The French “r” is not rolled though. The Spanish”r” is rolled. The Scots, and other rhotic speakers of English, roll their”r”s in a less pronounced way than the Spanish.

The French “r” is pronounced in a uniquely French way in the back of the throat which probably has a name in French but no equivalent name in English. Some people do find it very hard to replicate, and being a rhotic speaker doesn’t make it any easier.

Exactly.

My native language has rolled "r"s, so Spanish and Italian are a piece of cake. I can unroll my "r"s and pronounce them the American way (because that's where I lived for a long time and that's the variant of English I speak).

But doing the back of the throat French "r"s is difficult. I can manage it, sort of, in many words, but sometimes I really fail and either swallow it completely or say some variant of a "h" sound.
I don't even try to get the German "r" - just roll it. There are many foreigners speaking German that way, the natives are used to it and quite tolerant.

incognito50me · 12/02/2024 06:38

nokidshere · 11/02/2024 21:52

I'm sure there are millions of people the world over who are similarly frustrated by how people pronounce their names 🤷🏼‍♀️ especially since one Deidre (insert name of choice) might not be pronounced the same as another.

Years ago I knew a lady who's name badge stated she was Karen, except her name was pronounced Care-en. She spent a major portion of everyday being upset and/or correcting people.

ok, I spent many years in the US, never lived in the UK. How else do you pronounce Karen? I'm familiar with the (widespread in the US) pronunciation Care-en.

incognito50me · 12/02/2024 06:36

penjil · 12/02/2024 00:50

I very much doubt there is any country in the world that would pronounce Deirdre the Irish way.

There are many foreign names (not just Irish ones) that we don't pronounce correctly. But that is the beauty of each language. If you've never heard the correct pronunciation, you just say it as you see it, or hear it.

Lots of people say Mel-BORN.
Aussies say Melb'n.

Lots of people say Los AngeLEEEZ.
Americans say Los angeliz.

It's just flavour. No disrespect is meant.
Same with Deirdre. It'll always have the British pronunciation in the UK. In Ireland, it can have it's correct one.

Not to mention, Americans could be argued to pronounce Los Angeles wrong - it is a Spanish term - it "should be" "Los Anheles", it never is.

Catinknickers · 12/02/2024 06:33

A close relative is called Deirdre but it’s pronounced the Corrie way. Her father was a Scottish Gaelic speaker. I assume it was pronounced that way so she wouldn’t have to correct people the whole time. She was born in the 1930s.

One of my children has a name from a different language but although we use the correct pronunciation, most people do not.

It’s not appropriation to use a different pronunciation that feels more comfortable to speakers of a certain language. No one wants to correct others all the time.

inappropriateraspberry · 12/02/2024 06:31

@ChateauMargaux nope, it's definitely a ree sound on the end,

ChateauMargaux · 12/02/2024 06:26

inappropriateraspberry · 12/02/2024 06:06

Actually furore is pronounced fyoo-raw-ree, so does have that sound on the end.

Interesting that I choose such an example in my haste.. the origins of this word are Italian which adds another dimension.. and the ending is kore of an 'ay' sound than an 'ie' or even an 'ee' sound. In fact... a close approximation to the Irish sound than the Coronation Street interpretation of the 'dre' ending.