Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think XL Bulldog ban will/is turning into a massive farace?

77 replies

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 11/02/2024 19:45

To think XL Bulldog ban will/is turning into a massive farce?

Come the warmer weather as more people go out to the parks/walks/etc you will note the owners out there with unmuzzled XL dogs and mostly likely off their lead, both items are now against the law.

For any law to succeed it has to be enforced. To easily enforce the law it has to be clear and re XL dogs the law is clear as mud and the government is aware of this. As all sensible people know, we will get different cross-breeds of dogs who will be just as powerful as the XL dogs and this will be done to by-pass the law

AIBU to expect law enforcement to the letter all Bulldog-type dogs to be muzzled in public and on leads? (Those failing to do this are fined at the very least for every breach of the law)
Along with this, all dogs being on leads in public other than an enclosed/fenced area where dog owners choose to take their dogs and take a risk?

I'm very certain when Joe Public call the cops when witnessing a breach of the law as above where no one is at immediate risk, a call to the non-emergency number may not get you very far.

I am aware a dog is a man's best friend and I have witnessed this many times when out seeing clients when I worked. I felt uncomfortable with dogs but certain breeds are more passive and will just slowly approach you stand there for you to say hi, and possibly a small pat on the dog

I am also of the view that all lawbreakers who are owners of dogs should be fined at the very least and if their dog attacks another human or another dog, a mandatory jail term must be available.

Honestly, I feel for the dogs even though a lot of dogs make me feel uncomfortable, the cause is often the owner lacking the intelligence to control it or read or acknowledge the fact not everyone is comfortable with dogs.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Janelle7 · 11/02/2024 20:09

Perhaps if the police had more power, joe public would take more notice of laws. For example if the penalty was the dog is instantly shot dead for being off the lead/unmuzzled, then they might have a bit more about them to follow the rules. How many xl bully attacks have to happen. If im on the park with my kids and some chav walks on with the xl bully, thats it were out of there. Also, if a dog attacks, regardless of breed, it should be put down and owners charged.

dimllaishebiaith · 11/02/2024 20:03

You used to be more subtle

But yes OP, I agree with your point that unless the law is enforced it just becomes a farce