Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to say we should have a family secret Santa next Christmas instead of traditional gift giving?

58 replies

wrotemyowndeliverance · 11/02/2024 12:58

I know, I know, discussing Christmas in February, but some of my family are very keen, so really need to have this settled before summer. I’m one of three adult children, all of us married and my brother has a toddler. Every year Christmas presents get harder to think of both in terms of what I want, and what to get for other people. So many of the good gift ideas have already been used. I think having a Secret Santa between the adults would be a really great solution (and us all buying separately for my nephew), but not sure how breaking decades of tradition will go down. Money isn’t an issue, so absolutely no hard feelings from childless Aunties and Uncles (of which I am one) buying for our DN in addition. How would you feel if someone suggested this for your family?

Poll options:
YANBU: Suggest Secret Santa
YABU: Keep traditional gift exchange

OP posts:
bananaboats · 11/02/2024 14:49

All adults in our family & we have done secret santa for the last few years & it's worked really well.

SerotinaPickeler · 11/02/2024 14:47

We've done this for a couple of years but it's not popular with everyone.

  1. Adults who are good at choosing, sourcing and wrapping and put the effort in, are not always happy when their secret santa doesn't make the same effort.
  1. For single adults it may be their only present, so it needs to be something they're OK with. Or trouble. Peacemaker = mum.
  1. The (adult!) family members who are unable to 'santa' due to lack of funds, imagination, 'energy', or are unable to shop independently, have to be helped in order not to let down their recipient. Generally = mum.
  1. When recipients end up with tat someone often has to step in to keep the peace. Often = mum. Often need 'contingency' presents. (Mum).
  1. Mum is surprisingly still expected to also gift to adult kids, do stockings etc. Because tradition. It's what mum's do.
  1. Families not always able to be together on Christmas Day. SS does not work if not together, IMHO. Tendency is to buy another present (!) for boxing day/when do get together. Mum.

Actually, it's probably mum who is not keen on secret santa.

Northernlass99 · 11/02/2024 14:36

We do this and it is brilliant, no more traipsing around trying to find something for BIL! £50 per person so you only get one gift but its a good one. No cash or vouchers, but you can pass on hints/suggestions for what you want. You don't buy for a partner. And we still buy loads of stuff for the kids.

Can you suggest it by selling the time and cost saving elements, but you will still all get together to exchange the gifts so still have all the fun?

Singleandproud · 11/02/2024 14:28

We played the present game this year.
Each person bought 5 gifts, 1 pack of playing cards was split equally between each family member.
Cards were then drawn from a second pack, when your card is drawn you can take a present from the parcel pile, once the parcel pile is gone you can 'steal' a present from someone else.
Go through the pack two or three times.
This caused much hilarity and everyone enjoyed their presents, some swapped. Presents ranged from packs of novelty stationery, nice food treats, random but useful items, we set the limit at 5 presents for £15 max per person, so they were only little things but turned into one of the best parts of the day.

We had done normal presents as well but it tends to end up as the 'great Amazon gift card' swap which I find pretty pointless and think we may just do the present game with higher value or more gifts next year

LlynTegid · 11/02/2024 14:27

No presents for adults and a donation to charity might be another option.

TwattingDog · 11/02/2024 14:23

We do this with the wider family (the adults) as well all meet up on Boxing Day. £20 limit. Men buy for men, women buy for women. All parcels are dished out randomly, you don't buy for a specific person. If you aren't there that day, you don't get in on it.

Bottles of nice booze, chocolates etc are commonplace.

Kids under 16 still get gifts.

Fredbaassett · 11/02/2024 14:22

My family donate hay to sanctuaries & cash to other charities. No children yet as that would be different. Don't desire anything that we can't get ourselves.

Sodndashitall · 11/02/2024 14:22

We did this for adults this year and it worked brilliantly. We all got a very thoughtful gift (we said max £50) and it was a lot less stressful. We said that couples could buy each other pressies but they were not to be given as part of the main event. All worked a treat

JMSA · 11/02/2024 14:22

We have done adult Secret Santa in the past, but presents for all of the children from everyone.
It worked very well! The budget for each adult gift was £100, so you could be sure of receiving a really good gift. However it's still much less than we would have spent, if buying for every adult in the family. Plus, it cut down a lot of guesswork and hassle.
Go for it I say!

1offnamechange · 11/02/2024 14:20

which reminds me does anyone remember the thread on here Christmas just gone - the family had a weird version of SS whereby 1 member bought ALL the presents for the family each year? So e.g. 2019 dad bought multiple expensive presents for the mum, 3 adult DC, etc and nobody else bought anything at all.

Then 2020 the mum bought everything, then 2021 one of the DC etc. Except last year the sibling whose turn it was to buy said they didn't want to do it, (despite having happily received the last 5 years!). It was an excellent example of the 'people on MN will argue the opposite point even if it's completely unjustifiable to any normal person just to be contrary' thread!

jackstini · 11/02/2024 14:18

We have done this for the past few years and it's brilliant - much easier and preferred by all

Kids are bought for until they are 18, then they join in the adult secret Santa

People decide each year whether they want to opt in and we use Draw Names
You can ban certain people who you would buy for, so for example DH & I are both in it, but we wouldn't get each other in the draw

1offnamechange · 11/02/2024 14:16

I suggested exactly the same as you - also in same position only childless one but happy to buy for nephew/niece as well as whoever I get for secret santa, but was shot down in flames because my siblings (all adults with children of their ow btw!) like having lots of presents to open.

Pisses me off a bit, I buy for mum, dad, siblings x 3, 2 of their partners and 4 children so 11 in total (which is expensive on a single income) but only get 4 presents back. I'd be more than happy to get no presents at all and skip the stress of finding something they will like for 11 people, so thought each adult getting 1 nice present each and no change for the kids was a good compromise but no apparently it's 'scroogy!'

persisted · 11/02/2024 14:15

Siblings and I have done secret Santa for years now.
5 of us, we do wish lists, the draw happens through a website in mid-November so plenty of time to order things.

It works much better, we all get something that we want and can use. And there's lots of secret Santa chat in the run up to Christmas which is fun.

TigerJoy · 11/02/2024 14:05

Just suggest it

When I did about 8 years ago everyone jumped at it. Also from a family of thoughtful gifts, but many of us (and many children).

We have a budget of £50,although I slightly overspent last year.

I love my secret santa presents and it gives me joy to use them. Makes christmas presents feel more special somehow!

Doje · 11/02/2024 14:01

We do this. I'm one of four and we all have partners. We do secret Santa amongst the 'grown up' kids and concentrate on presents for the proper kids.

Quizine · 11/02/2024 13:43

Our family hasn't done presents for many years by mutual agreement. (vouchers for the younger ones only).

So liberating. And then we pack ourselves off to Estepona in Southern Spain for three weeks - ten days before and ten days after Christmas. Never doing Christmas at home again. I know I'm fortunate, but we don't have kids though.

Daftasabroom · 11/02/2024 13:40

We do a third option.

Each of us buys for one other adult. The draw is normally Autumn, the budget is £50 to £100. It's not secret which means you can call your "Santa" and tell them what you'd really like. We'd all much rather a single decent present than six or seven cheapies.

Meadowfinch · 11/02/2024 13:37

I take pleasure buying my siblings presents that I know they will appreciate. I enjoy it, I don't regard it as a chore. It's only once a year.

I wouldn't join in with Secret Santa because it seems so dismissive and uninterested. And would deny me a lot of enjoyment.

But families are different. You do you.

dreamingofsun · 11/02/2024 13:37

I suggested this to my husband but he said no as MIL likes to see everyone open presents. so we all have to pretend we wanted a massive load of tat. how i would love a Boots box of toiletries each year - at least you can use them. Even the second hand shop are sniffy sometimes.

suggest and see what everyone says.

EveryOtherNameTaken · 11/02/2024 13:36

100%

Suggesting it early on too so people can start considering it. I think it's a great idea.

It's still thoughtful present giving but so much money saved for everyone.

spriots · 11/02/2024 13:34

We did this for a while - the main issue was that there was a bit of a divide between some family members who shared wishlists and wanted everyone to do the same and family members who wanted a surprise.

We were in the latter camp - I think wishlists take all the fun out of it - but I think the main thing is everyone being on the same page

Muffintopper · 11/02/2024 13:32

We did it Christmas just gone after years of debating whether to or not, best decision all round! We generated names through a secret santa website for the adults then stuck to buying the little ones a prezzie each. We've decided going forward this will be our new tradition x

KreedKafer · 11/02/2024 13:29

I don’t see why just suggesting it would be an issue. If people aren’t keen they can just say no.

SummaLuvin · 11/02/2024 13:23

Similar for me, I actually suggested it as a throw-away comment after Christmas, mentioning it could be good for next year (I had a hard time even thinking of ideas for myself this time!!!), and some family responded positively, but my mum especially seemed like she wasn’t keen. I’m not sure if to push it again and put feelers out or not.

OtterlyMad · 11/02/2024 13:21

We actually had this discussion as a family last year and agreed that Secret Santa was the way to go. Instead of spending £30-£50 on each person, we now spend £100 on one couple (we chose to give and receive as couples instead of individuals as that way it’s easier to buy things like spa days, theatre tickets, meals out etc. for 2). Saved us all a fortune and the run up to Christmas is so much less stressful now!