Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you about secondary school meals

71 replies

Moreorlessmentallystable · 11/02/2024 09:56

Posting here for traffic. My daughter is starting secondary school in August, currently she takes a snack and a packed lunch to primary school. I am not sure if this will be seen as weird in secondary school? I know you could pay for school meals but what I gather is most local school kids go to the town and get a meal deal or a Greggs. Is this what most kids do or are there a lot that stay in school for a meal? I know it sounds snobby but I worry that she'll be getting Gregg's or similar every day as it's not very healthy, also worried about her drinking fizzy juice every day as she is not allowed it apart from maybe once every month or two. Any tips?

OP posts:
aintnospringchicken · 11/02/2024 16:44

MermaidEyes · 11/02/2024 16:31

Well this thread has taught me that Scottish kids are allowed off site during the day. You learn something new every day!

Yes. I'm in Scotland too

aintnospringchicken · 11/02/2024 16:43

The pupils at my local school are allowed off site during breaks. There's a small co op nearby and they have a member f staff on the door to limit the number of kids entering .There's always a huge queue. It's even worse at lunch time.

MermaidEyes · 11/02/2024 16:31

Well this thread has taught me that Scottish kids are allowed off site during the day. You learn something new every day!

GHSP · 11/02/2024 16:20

dc take packed lunches. Ds makes himself a sandwich whereas I put hot food in a flask for dd. They can buy stuff from the canteen if needed but both are vegetarian and find the selection of suitable food is poor.

Februarydaffodil · 11/02/2024 16:17

Just to give idea on costs - last week one son spent £2.60 on a panini and the other £2.65 on a bowl of tomato pasta ( different schools)

Februarydaffodil · 11/02/2024 16:13

Children aren’t allowed out at lunchtime though I think some buy something on the walk to school . Mine take a packed lunch and decent snack as actual lunchtime isn’t until 1.40 ! They might buy from school once a week but the queues are long and food not cheap . I think school sets a limit on what they can spend but it’s maybe 5/6 pound a day . They also want food that’s quick and easy to eat standing up as they would rather chat to their friends

sheflieswithherownwings · 11/02/2024 16:08

My DS takes a packed lunch every day - he says the queue for the school canteen is too long at lunchtime, he'd spend all of it queuing up. They only get 30 minutes. The food is good, apparently. So he does sometimes get a breakfast sandwich if he gets in early enough, or he might buy a €1 panini at the end of the day if they're selling them off. Most of his friends take packed lunches. It's not cheap though, it would be easy to spend €3-4 a day on a main meal.

ColourByNumbers88 · 11/02/2024 16:08

People do a mix of things. If your daughter is used to taking a packed lunch you could continue it and she can take a walk with her friends to Greggs and eat her packed lunch with them.

In our school, the first years are not allowed out at lunch until the October break (or possibly the September weekend) so the option is school canteen or packed lunch until then.

Anyway, a packed lunch is quite common so don't worry about that.

helpfulperson · 11/02/2024 15:49

I presume you are in Scotland. Its a real cultural divide. I'm not aware of a single school here that keeps pupils in school grounds at secondary.

CeeJay81 · 11/02/2024 15:45

@penjil if you can afford it. If it was £4, that's £20 a week, plus £12ish for my primary age dd. That's £32 a Week just on lunches for the kids. I don't spend £4 a day at work.

penjil · 11/02/2024 15:37

CeeJay81 · 11/02/2024 10:02

Our school don't let them leave the premises until 6th form these days. My ds uses the school canteen which is more like a cafeteria. My only issue is he can spend over £4 a day, which I've told him off for. I wish parents could set the daily limit on it. Pack lunch is fine though.

Surely £4 a day for a meal would be pretty good value, no?

Minikievs · 11/02/2024 15:19

Y9 here. They aren't allowed off school premises.
He started off in Y7 having school dinners but that stopped and he now takes jacked lunch.
Various reasons: cost, the food choices he was making and the fact he was spending most of his lunchtime queuing up.
Most of his mates take pack up too.

The pp who said her child spent £4 a day-same here.
A break time snack, drink, lunchtime meal, comes to about £3.85 ish here.
On the odd day he doesn't have packed lunch (once in a blue moon) I put £4 on his card. It lasts him one day and possibly a break time snack the next day. That's it.

CauleyMacGlochlin · 11/02/2024 15:06

@BogRollBOGOF

I get the sense that this is a big cultural divide between England and Scotland.

Itwasfinetillitwasnt · 11/02/2024 14:49

Mine aren't allowed off site during breaks till 6th form.
It's a mix of packed lunch and school dinners.
Re snacks mine take a cereal bar as they have breakfast at 7am but lunch is not till 1.20pm. The school have staggered meal times so some years they've taken a snack other years they've had an earlier lunch and had a snack after school or not at all.

PuttingDownRoots · 11/02/2024 14:44

They aren't allowed out at DDs school either... probably don't want to scare the tourists! (Joking aside... no where for them to go) However the chippy, Indian takeaway, and convenience shop do a roaring trade from the sixth form college.

Its a mix of packed lunch and canteen food at DDs school... although some packed lunches are no doubt purchased from the shop on the way in and are definitely not healthy.

dementedpixie · 11/02/2024 14:43

I'm in Scotland and they are allowed to leave the grounds although it is quite a walk to get to nearby shops. My ds takes a snack and packed lunch to school. He often takes a food flask so he can have a hot lunch; usually pasta.

BogRollBOGOF · 11/02/2024 14:38

CauleyMacGlochlin · 11/02/2024 13:48

Not allowed off the school premises? What? How would they stop them? Round here the streets are swarming at lunchtime with kids in school uniform.

When I was at school OP most days the kids I hung about with brought food in but we'd usually go out on a Friday and get something from the chippy. I'd send her with a lunch and some money and she can figure out something with the kids she's pals with.

Schools surrounded by high fencing with electric gates operated by passes/ reception.

Keeps unwelcome people out.

Also stops vulnerable young people going out. They may need protecting for their own wellbeing (e.g. self-harming, or SENs) or from external risks around the school area such as gang culture, grooming, county lines or just old-fashioned anti-social behaviour. It also cuts truancy from people not bothering to return, or dodging out of chunks of the school day. That's just brought back a memory of the fire bells going off and revealing that a group had dodged out since morning regestration which was easy through the numerous gaps in the waist-height fencing.

School lunch times are often awkwardly short anyway, often 30-45 mins, so little time to go anywhere productive anywhere.

Few schools I've known in the past 20 years have allowed pupils out freely below 6th form. School sites have been becoming more secure since the mid-90s.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 11/02/2024 13:53

Pupils at my son's secondary are not allowed off premises for the most of the first year but at the end of first year and onward can, and do, leave for lunch. Very few take packed lunches, some eat in the canteen and many go down the street to the local shop and/or bakery (not Greggs as none where we live, but not any healthier and probably more expensive). It's common to see them eating absolute rubbish for lunch, day after day, and also throwing litter behind them. This is in Scotland and S1 is around age 12 (though some a little younger). Apparently the canteen food isn't great, plus some of them like to get out of the building too. I suppose you need to find out what happens at her specific school by asking the school/parents of older pupils, because clearly different things are more normal at different schools.

SecondUsername4me · 11/02/2024 13:52

My dc secondary only permits sixth formers off grounds at lunchtimes. Gates shut the rest of the time.

Mine gets school meals (£2.95 meal deal, hot or cold) a day as I cba making packed lunches. Plenty dc take packed lunches.

CauleyMacGlochlin · 11/02/2024 13:50

Chickenfeed67 · 11/02/2024 10:17

The borough I live in doesn’t allow children off site, but I used to work in another borough where they were allowed to leave at lunchtime. I was pretty shocked, tbh, that kids as young as 11 were allowed to wander around by themselves - I know 11 year olds that sadly can’t tell the time, so how would they know when to head back to school?

I must be living on another planet. What 11 year old can't tell the time? They'll learn pretty quick when they get a bollocking for being late back.

I've lived all over Scotland and never hear anything like this. Is this an English thing?

CauleyMacGlochlin · 11/02/2024 13:48

Not allowed off the school premises? What? How would they stop them? Round here the streets are swarming at lunchtime with kids in school uniform.

When I was at school OP most days the kids I hung about with brought food in but we'd usually go out on a Friday and get something from the chippy. I'd send her with a lunch and some money and she can figure out something with the kids she's pals with.

0rangeCrush · 11/02/2024 13:34

I am really surprised at people being shocked at 11 year olds not being allowed to walk outside school grounds unattended. I do remember my own parents being a little nervous about it; but it really is a safe environment to build trust and responsibility.

needswine · 11/02/2024 13:32

English secondary here no kids allowed off site

Mine have school lunch, but tbh when I check scopay they are basically snacking, no proper meals.

They have a good hot meal at home in the evening and there are loads of snacks and fruit for after school

CeeJay81 · 11/02/2024 13:29

@0rangeCrush exactly. It all adds up. DS is nearly 15 and about 5'9, he can eat way more than me.

CeeJay81 · 11/02/2024 13:27

@Moreorlessmentallystable it's not just one meal. The canteen is open at break time aswell as lunch. Its like a cafe, there's wraps, pasta pots, cakes etc all priced individually, aswell as the main meal and pudding which is £2.60. Plus he often buys a drink instead of taking one. Sometimes he'll pop into coop and get a meal deal on his way to school for around £2.60(staff discount), instead of buying something at school but I have to check the parent pay app regularly, as I can't trust him not to spent silly amounts. Totally different from primary which is a set amount for a meal.