Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

XL Bully attack | 8 year old boy seriously injured

762 replies

ThisOldThang · 11/02/2024 09:05

https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/schoolboy-8-seriously-injured-after-28610020

"A schoolboy is in a serious condition in hospital after being mauled by what is believed to be an XL bully.

Merseyside Police were called to Wadham Road in Bootle just after 5.20pm on Saturday following reports a dog had bitten an eight-year-old boy to the head in the communal area of flats nearby.

The boy was rushed to hospital with serious head injuries and required emergency surgery. He remains in hospital in a serious but stable condition."

IMHO the ban doesn't go anywhere near far enough and all XL Bullys need to be put to sleep.

AIBU?

Schoolboy, 8, seriously injured after being mauled by 'XL bully'

A man and woman were arrested following the "horrific" dog attack

https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/schoolboy-8-seriously-injured-after-28610020

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
gmor6787 · 13/02/2024 10:33

I too think all XLBullies should be PTS. They were bred for their aggression, it’s in their DNA, they are mega strong and have a powerful jaw that can hang on. They are popular obviously with brain dead humans, who use them as a weapon because they are cowards. Any rational, dog loving person who decides to choose a dog would not go for one of these hideous animals. They are ugly, powerful beasts and the breed needs wiping out. Yes there have been dogs in the past with reputations, GS, Rottweiler, Doberman, but how many actually killed a human. These Bullies are killing machines.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 13/02/2024 09:58

Noangelbuthavingfun · 13/02/2024 06:57

They are not children but the poster isn't saying they are either. They are comparing the intellectual capacity of Dogs and children to a particular age, which is entirely true and scientifically proven. You can have 2 entirely different species with brains ..that have the same intellectual capacity. As our frame of reference is only with humans, this is the age of a human that is compatible. Surely you get
That ?

That’s missing the point. Whatever the relative intellectual abilities of dogs and children - and it’s obviously a completely nonsense comparison anyway - to liken the reactions or behaviour of children to those of dogs is foolish because they have nothing in common at all.

You might as well draw an equivalence between a child and an octopus. Do you see?

2boyzNosleep · 13/02/2024 09:45

Gloriosaford · 12/02/2024 22:55

My children weren't 'leashed'
@LyingWitchInTheWardrobe
Wtf! Who refers to children as being 'leashed'
Again we see this need to blur the boundaries between children and dogs, constantly wanting to assert that their pet is equal to a human 😳

I had agreed with her comment saying that children should be taught not to approach dogs.

I merely pointed out that unfortunately despite parents and owners best efforts, things do still happen and gave an example of such an event.

A toddler suddenly darted off and grabbed a dog. (Since this has also started a debate it was a huge park and the parents were next to their child. The family were one side of an ice cream van and the dog was another, I'm sure of the parents had seen the dog it would've been a different outcome)

This poster decided that the parents were irresponsible, as her children were always 'reined'.

Using her logic I could've flipped the story and said it was the owners fault for having slack in the dogs lead, meaning it had enough room to turn and bite the child and that the dog should've basically been sat between the owners legs. Or that the owners were irresponsible for taking their dog to an area for families.

This is the sort of poster that blurs the lines between treating dogs as humans and seems to want to blame children being children. Hence why I referred to her as leashing her children.

RosePetals86 · 13/02/2024 09:15

FindingNeverland28 · 13/02/2024 05:24

I’m an animal lover, who would prefer to get rid of a rat humanely, but I’m on the ‘put them all to sleep side’. I think it’s awful that it’s come to this, but how many more attacks and deaths need to happen. Last summer, I was at a family festival and there was this bloke strutting about, shirt off with 2 XL bully’s on leads. No muzzles. He was a skinny little thing as well. If they wanted to go after something/someone he wouldn’t have been able to stop them. It takes a special kind of person to take 2 dogs like that to a family event with little kids running around. Do they not realise that people aren’t looking at them thinking ‘wow, they’re really cool and powerful’ instead they’re thinking ‘what an absolute idiot’.

Unfortunately no, they don’t have enough brain cells to generate that much self awareness! There is no good reason anyone would have one of these dogs other than to boost their own ego. The dogs are rancid looking and the damage they can do is terrifying.

ThisOldThang · 13/02/2024 07:28

Emotionalsupportviper · 12/02/2024 14:19

If a kid wants to stroke a dog they should ask the owner. If the owner says no there is a good reason.

Indeed.

I have 3 spaniels. 2 are absolute tarts and will have a cuddle off anyone. The 3rd was ill-used before we got her and terrified of everything.

The number of people who insist "Oh, but dogs like me!" "My child just wants to pet your dog. S/he won't hurt them" etc really annoys me. They can pet the other two - just leave this one alone, ffs!

Many people do treat dogs as babies, which is totally inappropriate - but many more treat kids as lords and ladies who should be able to do anything they want at all times. Every child should be taught safe behaviour around dogs, in the same way that they are taught not to play with fire etc. It's just common sense and is for everyone's safety.

So, knowing that you have this unstable dog, you always muzzle it in public don't you?

OP posts:
Noangelbuthavingfun · 13/02/2024 07:00

Anonanonanon1 · 12/02/2024 18:19

This is absolutely correct about the history of the sbt.
The breed standard is a maximum height of 16" for males and 16kg, and this is what good breeders produce, with health tests in place and temperament with people is the number one consideration.
These significantly larger bull breeds that people describe as staffies are crossed with other breeds and not bred to standard.
They are not bred with temperament in mind any more than they are health tested or created to improve on what we already have.
My first 2 staffords were rescues, and when I lost my original boy 5 years ago I spent 18 months looking for another rescue that fitted the breed standard, as I compete my dogs in agility and I like to show what a great breed they are with the right training.
Despite searching countrywide there was nothing under 4 years old that was suitable so I went on a waiting list for a health tested puppy from a breeder whose dogs I know to be an excellent type, temperament and that have successfully competed to a high level in dog obedience.
The wait was worth it as I now have a fantastic agility dog who is a great example of the breed in looks and temperament.

He is totally reliable as per the breed standard, and great around people. He ignores other dogs in group training sessions and in the highly exciting show environment.
I would not expect the same had I got a 'staffie' from the guy down the street who had put his dog to his mates bitch just because he wanted to make a few quid.

I fear that up to this point xl bullies have been bought by people wanting to cash in on their surge in popularity and equally little thought has been put into the temperament. I am afraid that any flaws in temperament would be viewed as the dog being protective and thus the creation of many ticking time bombs.
Going forward if these new laws are policed and anyone producing litters is heavily penalized then hopefully numbers will reduce, but ultimately the breeding of all dogs needs to be heavily regulated and dog ownership looked on as a privilege not a right.
Dog licenses, ownership tests, compulsory insurance.... whatever it takes to stop this downhill spiral and end the creation of newer and more dangerous weapon dogs.

100% this!!

Noangelbuthavingfun · 13/02/2024 06:57

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 12/02/2024 18:08

Dogs are not children. Comparing the two is ludicrous.

They are not children but the poster isn't saying they are either. They are comparing the intellectual capacity of Dogs and children to a particular age, which is entirely true and scientifically proven. You can have 2 entirely different species with brains ..that have the same intellectual capacity. As our frame of reference is only with humans, this is the age of a human that is compatible. Surely you get
That ?

Emotionalsupportviper · 13/02/2024 06:08

FindingNeverland28 · 13/02/2024 05:24

I’m an animal lover, who would prefer to get rid of a rat humanely, but I’m on the ‘put them all to sleep side’. I think it’s awful that it’s come to this, but how many more attacks and deaths need to happen. Last summer, I was at a family festival and there was this bloke strutting about, shirt off with 2 XL bully’s on leads. No muzzles. He was a skinny little thing as well. If they wanted to go after something/someone he wouldn’t have been able to stop them. It takes a special kind of person to take 2 dogs like that to a family event with little kids running around. Do they not realise that people aren’t looking at them thinking ‘wow, they’re really cool and powerful’ instead they’re thinking ‘what an absolute idiot’.

Do they not realise that people aren’t looking at them thinking ‘wow, they’re really cool and powerful’ instead they’re thinking ‘what an absolute idiot’.

More like "What an a-hole."

Emotionalsupportviper · 13/02/2024 06:06

I was on a train recently and this selfish woman kept letting her dog roam around the train carriage on a long leash while she was in her phone not paying attention. Everyone was trying to ignore it. It kept coming into the floor of my seating area which was annoying. I’m sure if I had moved my legs and kicked it accidentally before I noticed it and it had bitten me, I’d have been blamed.

Why didn't you say something to her @Fageyoghurt ? People like her are aPITA but if no-one complains they'll never see any need to change their behaviour.

And I am 70 years old and have been around dogs all of my life, and can honestly say that I have only been growled at twice, and one of this occasions was when I was standing between my dog and one which wanted to get to her.

I admit that I have had badly trained dogs and silly puppies jump up at me, and I always tell them "Down", because this shouldn't be happening, I agree - I wouldn't let my dogs do it because at the very least it can spoil people's clothing, and at worst could knock someone flying, but aggressive dogs (other than these XL bully type) are very few and far between.

You have been very unfortunate if you have met more than one in your life.

Emotionalsupportviper · 13/02/2024 05:57

Gloriosaford · 12/02/2024 22:55

My children weren't 'leashed'
@LyingWitchInTheWardrobe
Wtf! Who refers to children as being 'leashed'
Again we see this need to blur the boundaries between children and dogs, constantly wanting to assert that their pet is equal to a human 😳

No-one is saying that a pet is equal to a human.

What we are saying is that we all have to take responsibility - if you have a vulnerable family member - eg a toddler, a child who has learning difficulties etc - than you make damn sure that they are safe beside you, and not "darting off" anywhere.

Dogs are not the only threat - there is traffic, bigger children who might be running around excitedly and cannon into them, which could seriously hurt a small child, they could badly hurt themselves falling over play equipment - there is any number of hazards. If they "dart off" in the street, the could go under a bus. Or, God forbid, be the next James Bulger.

If a dog is on leash, under control and behaving well it is considerably less dangerous than any of the other hazards I've mentioned. A parent has the responsibility to keep their child away from dogs, just as much as a dog owner has a responsibility to train, socialise and control their pet.

SinnerBoy · 13/02/2024 05:35

Or, "Bloody Hell, I'm scared of those dogs."

FindingNeverland28 · 13/02/2024 05:24

I’m an animal lover, who would prefer to get rid of a rat humanely, but I’m on the ‘put them all to sleep side’. I think it’s awful that it’s come to this, but how many more attacks and deaths need to happen. Last summer, I was at a family festival and there was this bloke strutting about, shirt off with 2 XL bully’s on leads. No muzzles. He was a skinny little thing as well. If they wanted to go after something/someone he wouldn’t have been able to stop them. It takes a special kind of person to take 2 dogs like that to a family event with little kids running around. Do they not realise that people aren’t looking at them thinking ‘wow, they’re really cool and powerful’ instead they’re thinking ‘what an absolute idiot’.

SinnerBoy · 13/02/2024 04:34

Bruisername · Yesterday 20:42

How about cats? My friend at school stroked a cat on the street and it scratched in the face. She still has the scar.

How are a cat and an XL Bully in any way comparable?

MyNavyFox · 13/02/2024 00:06

It’s the owners that should be muzzled and on a leash and pts!

Fageyoghurt · 12/02/2024 23:37

@Eleganz completely agree with all of this.

Sunak and co just wanted to look as if they were actually doing something without actually doing something. We really need some kind of dog licensing scheme that will pay to put more dog wardens back on our streets and more stricter laws . It seems every other week this year someone has been seriously injured or killed by an XL.

Last week in Battersea park a woman‘s baby and toddler were attacked by an XL. The dog ran up and tried to get into the pram. The useless owner was on the other side of the park while the dog was biting this woman’s kids. Fully agree if your dog can’t be around children they shouldn’t be out unleashed especially not in public parks, or crowded places . And if it’s going for children surely it can turn on a small adult making sharp movements . So not really fit to be around people.

I don’t interact with dogs at all and don’t go near them unless I can help it, I even avoid parks and dog friendly coffee shops nowadays to minimise my contact with them, but yes I’ve been jumped up and snarled at too. Last time was on a coastal path on holiday. Having a lovely time walking along with my boyfriend and this woman with two dogs growled and lunged at us. She was really struggling to keep them away from us as the path was narrow, but I’m grateful at least they were leashed and to be fair she did apologise. But it did kind of ruin the walk a bit as I got such a fright. We waited until she was a long way away from us before we continued the walk so as to put distance between us.

I was on a train recently and this selfish woman kept letting her dog roam around the train carriage on a long leash while she was in her phone not paying attention. Everyone was trying to ignore it. It kept coming into the floor of my seating area which was annoying. I’m sure if I had moved my legs and kicked it accidentally before I noticed it and it had bitten me, I’d have been blamed.

Some owners need to take things more seriously.

Eleganz · 12/02/2024 23:17

It seems we have a government that can pass laws banning these animals but not fund effective enforcement of these laws meaning that those that don't voluntarily follow them will continue to put others at risk. Given that we are not going to enforce laws that allow the responsible owning of these animals they need to go.

This nonsense trying to blame toddlers and parents for a dog's aggressive reactions is pathetic. A toddler cannot kill an XL bully but an XL Bully can make a short work of a toddler as could many large dog breeds. Onus is therefore rightly on dog owners to control their animals when around others including toddlers. If you have a dog that cannot cope with a toddler running around without an aggressive reaction you have a dangerous animal that has no place out in public.

Unfortunately I have been regularly chased, jumped up at and growled at by dogs when simply minding my own business in a public area. I know the issue is not toddlers not being on reins.

Gloriosaford · 12/02/2024 22:55

My children weren't 'leashed'
@LyingWitchInTheWardrobe
Wtf! Who refers to children as being 'leashed'
Again we see this need to blur the boundaries between children and dogs, constantly wanting to assert that their pet is equal to a human 😳

TheTimeIsNowMaybeNow · 12/02/2024 22:46

Ds1 was saying last night that he knows someone who breeds them and paid over 14k . God knows what will happen to them now he can't make money off them

unicornpower · 12/02/2024 22:28

Poor boy, I hope he makes a good recovery.

enough is enough. I saw a young lad walking one today without a muzzle. He wouldn’t have had a chance of stopping that dog pulling him off his feet. I was driving else would’ve reported it.

whats sickening is Vicky bloody pattinson constantly posting about the plight of these ‘lovely fur babies’. No mention of attacks or deaths. Completely thick and tone deaf

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 12/02/2024 21:57

2boyzNosleep · 12/02/2024 21:11

You really missed the bloody point i was making., sometimes things happen.

You really mean to tell me that you kept your toddlers leashed at all times in a open area for families? Clearly you did otherwise you would realise that sometimes they do just run off bloody fast when you don't expect it.

Not once has one of your children at any age done something when you least expected it? You are 100% aware of every possible outcome?

I apologise as you seem to think I should have said 'neglectful parents let their child scream in dogs face'.

It was a huge park, the child was coming around the back of the van. Nowhere near a road and the truck was stationed for the day. Yes, for the dog the child appeared out of nowhere.

Yes the toddler was with 2 parents. They were enjoying a sunny day out having a stroll. The boy was right next to them, he just ran off I a different direction.

It was a bloody private park where toddlers should run around freely. It wasn't your typical park where people take dogs to throw balls, dogs had to be kept on leads and could nor access all areas. Not that it matters but this was also about 20 years ago before every other person owned a dog.

Regardless of you wanting specific details of the whole scene, the fact is regardless of how well you've taught your child or trained your dog, bad unpredictable events happen.

This event was one of them, where it was no ones fault. I'm not sure why you can't understand that or why I had to explain the whole situation in more detail.

I don't need anything from you, no need for your ranty, incoherent post.

There were two parents who missed that their toddler had darted off. Kids do that but that's down to whomever is caring for the child. In this case, two of them.

My children weren't 'leashed', they wore reins. As it was mostly me on my own it was safer.

Please don't explain again.

Fionaville · 12/02/2024 21:36

I feel really sorry for the families who live on the estates and streets, where these dogs are prevalent. It must be terrifying! Even if the owners appear to be complying and muzzle them when they leave the house, knowing that they could escape at any minute would be so awful.
People shouldn't have to live in fear of their children being mauled, because some dickheads want a killer dog.

Gloriosaford · 12/02/2024 21:15

Dogs in public should never present a risk whatever happens. That’s the long and short of it
Agree 100% @WhatsTheUseOfWorrying

Lindyloomillion1 · 12/02/2024 21:12

Yes, a long sleep for all these dogs is warranted

2boyzNosleep · 12/02/2024 21:11

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 12/02/2024 18:30

2boyzNosleep, no, toddlers do not 'appear out of nowhere'. There were two parents (according to your post). The fault lies with them, no excuses. The result could have been far worse than being nipped by a dog. Darting out onto a road and run over?

My children were on reins; they darted precisely nowhere.

You really missed the bloody point i was making., sometimes things happen.

You really mean to tell me that you kept your toddlers leashed at all times in a open area for families? Clearly you did otherwise you would realise that sometimes they do just run off bloody fast when you don't expect it.

Not once has one of your children at any age done something when you least expected it? You are 100% aware of every possible outcome?

I apologise as you seem to think I should have said 'neglectful parents let their child scream in dogs face'.

It was a huge park, the child was coming around the back of the van. Nowhere near a road and the truck was stationed for the day. Yes, for the dog the child appeared out of nowhere.

Yes the toddler was with 2 parents. They were enjoying a sunny day out having a stroll. The boy was right next to them, he just ran off I a different direction.

It was a bloody private park where toddlers should run around freely. It wasn't your typical park where people take dogs to throw balls, dogs had to be kept on leads and could nor access all areas. Not that it matters but this was also about 20 years ago before every other person owned a dog.

Regardless of you wanting specific details of the whole scene, the fact is regardless of how well you've taught your child or trained your dog, bad unpredictable events happen.

This event was one of them, where it was no ones fault. I'm not sure why you can't understand that or why I had to explain the whole situation in more detail.

bombastix · 12/02/2024 21:07

Bloody hell I would have put her away for longer than that - everything about her actions tells you she didn't give a damn about anyone else except herself. As if she would become a better mother in prison. She has ruined several peoples lives with her simple minded loyalty to her boyfriend and his vicious dog which was more important.