Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

XL Bully attack | 8 year old boy seriously injured

762 replies

ThisOldThang · 11/02/2024 09:05

https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/schoolboy-8-seriously-injured-after-28610020

"A schoolboy is in a serious condition in hospital after being mauled by what is believed to be an XL bully.

Merseyside Police were called to Wadham Road in Bootle just after 5.20pm on Saturday following reports a dog had bitten an eight-year-old boy to the head in the communal area of flats nearby.

The boy was rushed to hospital with serious head injuries and required emergency surgery. He remains in hospital in a serious but stable condition."

IMHO the ban doesn't go anywhere near far enough and all XL Bullys need to be put to sleep.

AIBU?

Schoolboy, 8, seriously injured after being mauled by 'XL bully'

A man and woman were arrested following the "horrific" dog attack

https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/schoolboy-8-seriously-injured-after-28610020

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Stillnormal · 13/02/2024 17:02

Gloriosaford · 13/02/2024 12:20

If you have a dog that cannot cope with a toddler running around without an aggressive reaction you have a dangerous animal that has no place out in public
👏🏻

Unfortunately I have been regularly chased, jumped up at and growled at by dogs when simply minding my own business in a public area. I know the issue is not toddlers not being on reins
Me too, I'm sick to the back teeth of dogs, I wish they were dog free areas where I could guarantee not having to encounter any of them.

I love dogs but totally hear this - if you don’t love dogs it must be really annoying at times. They’re not generally allowed on RSPB / other nature reserves, so that might be somewhere to look.

bombastix · 13/02/2024 16:23

It's so absurd on dogs and the risk they present. Years ago the UK licensed owners of bengal cats F1 type given their nature and temperament as a dangerous wild animal.

Somehow the UK cannot do the same with large dogs. In the end I think socially it will be less acceptable to have one, and they will be excluded from rentals, social housing etc on the grounds of public safety.

Bookist · 13/02/2024 14:57

We need to stop classifying XL Bullies as dogs. They're much more than just dogs. They are over muscled monsters THAT HAVE KILLED SO MANY PEOPLE.

We don't allow people to keep bears or tigers as pets because THEY ARE DANGEROUS and can easily kill people.

Gloriosaford · 13/02/2024 14:32

Lots of dogs could (in theory) kill a human- if they got lucky.
It's the ones that are capable of overpowering, mauling and dismembering humans which pose a significant threat

Gloriosaford · 13/02/2024 14:09

Most dogs over 20kg are capable of killing someone
I don't disagree, in my post I suggested banning dogs which are capable of mauling and dismembering.
Do you think that most dogs over 20 kilos are capable of mauling and dismembering @Lycanthi ?

Lycanthi · 13/02/2024 14:00

Gloriosaford · 13/02/2024 13:52

Also, change the laws so that if a dog kills or mauls someone the owner is charged with manslaughter
Why not just ban animals that are capable of dismembering and mauling humans?
We don't allow people to keep other dangerous animals as pets, no one would try to argue that someone be allowed to have a bear or a panther as a domestic pet, why should it be any different for this particular canine subspecies?

Because you'll end up banning the majority of dogs. Most dogs over 20kg are capable of killing someone, if they should choose to. It becomes hard to draw the line somewhere, if you do a blanket ban on any dog over 20kg you'll end up banning labradors and golden retrievers which are some of the safest dog breeds. If you just try to ban each breed individually it becomes a monumental task since people will just breed new breeds, or cross 2 banned breeds to make a mongrel that doesnt fit either standard to get around the bans. It won't work either way since criminals will just ignore the law (like they currently do with pit bulls) and get them anyway. It just ends up with dogs being punished for human actions. I'd much rather punish the humans - should be a lot more effective.

Gloriosaford · 13/02/2024 13:52

Also, change the laws so that if a dog kills or mauls someone the owner is charged with manslaughter
Why not just ban animals that are capable of dismembering and mauling humans?
We don't allow people to keep other dangerous animals as pets, no one would try to argue that someone be allowed to have a bear or a panther as a domestic pet, why should it be any different for this particular canine subspecies?

Lycanthi · 13/02/2024 13:42

I personally do not like XL bullies and don't mind the ban, but I don't think they should all indiscriminately be put to sleep. Blanket cullings like this are not ethical. Not all XL bullies are dangerous (although I agree as a breed they are more dangerous than most dog breeds). I agree with grandfathering in the ones that currently exist in UK and ensuring that they are muzzled and leashed in public, I believe they all need to be evaluated for aggression in order to get licensed, so those that have been properly licensed shouldn't be a problem.

I do not think the ban will be very effective. The people that want XL bullies for the wrong reasons will just move on to the next breed (as they did when pit bulls were banned). Unless you're going to ban every breed that has the potential to do harm (something I also do not agree with) it's not going to work.

My solution would be banning certain people from owning the dangerous breeds. The list could include those in social housing, anyone with a criminal record, and anyone who has ever had owned a dog that attacked a person in the past. It might sound discriminatory, and I've lived in a housing association myself in the past, but the truth is its usually the lower income types living in the more crime ridden areas who get these dogs to "look hard" (perhaps because they feel vulnerable and insecure where they live?). Dogs should never be used as protection imo and that's what the "wrong type" of people are using them for. Rather, police need to police these areas better and protect residents so they don't feel the need to get a dangerous dog.

Also, change the laws so that if a dog kills or mauls someone the owner is charged with manslaughter / GBH and goes to prison for it. People won't be so keen to own a dangerous dog if they are looking at a prison sentence if the dog gets out of control.

Uricon2 · 13/02/2024 13:40

I've only been bitten by one dog, 50 years ago. It was a GSD who had an owner who I'm quite certain would be in the market for an XL these days. I'd been taught how to behave around dogs, was just walking past but this one turned round and snapped. It wasn't a bad bite by any means but made me wary of the breed for life.

However-I see GSDs and XLs completely differently. These musclebound mutants could not do the work GS's can, for a start. Their genetic/breeding history and record is atrocious to the point where I don't see how any sensible, responsible dog lover would have one and I automatically think anyone who does is thick as 2 short planks at the very, very best. Them being around children who have no choice over the actions of their halfwit parents is IMO abusive.

Fionaville · 13/02/2024 12:39

Fageyoghurt · 13/02/2024 12:17

That’s terrible. I don’t know when this was but back in the 90s and noughties you did see dogs on their own a lot more often. I find it odd that dogs that have caused injuries requiring hospital treatment aren’t automatically PTS when they’ve been reported.

And yeah that’s the issue with the muzzle orders, it’s very common for dogs to escape when the front door is opened unless the owners are really on the ball. I see it a lot and quite often if i go for a walk, I find myself scanning residential streets to check.

In my early 20s, one evening I was approached by a staffy type dog barking aggressively at me on my way home. thankfully I happened to be about 50 yards from a childhood friends home. I managed to inch past it and rang my friends doorbell. Her mum was already practically at the door, she later told me she’d actually got up to see what all the very loud barking was about. So she immediately invited me in and we waited for quite a while, but it was getting late but the dog just wouldn’t move.

My friend wasn’t in, but eventually my friends older sister walked with me to her car and the dog which was still there started barking again and following like it was going to attack one of us. It was SUCH a relief to reach her car and and she drove me home. We were both shaken up. I think I’d have been bitten if I’d not stopped in at my friends house. Grateful family helped me out.

Edited

Yes, this was 1989/90. We would often have dogs barking at us and chasing us aggressively. It was so common for dogs to be wandering the streets. I got bit a few times, less severely and used to get told "It's because they can smell your fear" However, we've always had family dogs. It wasn't dogs I was necessarily scared of, it was loose out of control dogs, that just roamed round the estates and streets. They'd just come at you when you were playing or walking along! You don't see it so much now, thankfully, but dogs do get out. I might be remembering it wrong, but I'm sure with the poor chap that got killed by a couple of XLs a few months ago, the dogs had jumped through the window.

EmpressSoleil · 13/02/2024 12:26

My mum is one of those people who put her dogs before her kids. A dog we had bit my sister quite badly (for no obvious reason) and our mum made her hide the injury from our dad as she knew our dad would (rightly) insist on the dog being PTS. So I have no trouble believing there are other mothers out there who are the same.

I don't think anyone with children should have an XL bully in the house. So if they're not willing to put their kids first, then maybe they need to be forced to. Instead they've been using their kids as "justification" as to why they have the dog, sad face stories about the dog being the child's only friend 🙄if that was the case why didn't they get a dog that wasn't capable of killing their child, one they could handle if the worst happened.

I'm in SH myself but 100% agree that SH landlords should ban them. I hate it to be so, but it's true a lot are in SH. Although thankfully there are none near me I've seen, but I'm not on an estate. It's not fair for other residents to be exposed to that risk.

Gloriosaford · 13/02/2024 12:22

Fireandflames · 13/02/2024 10:48

So does that mean all other biting dogs should be put to sleep then?, like rotties or shepherds?. Thought not.

I give any of these types of dogs an extremely wide berth and would be happy to see them banned.

Gloriosaford · 13/02/2024 12:20

If you have a dog that cannot cope with a toddler running around without an aggressive reaction you have a dangerous animal that has no place out in public
👏🏻

Unfortunately I have been regularly chased, jumped up at and growled at by dogs when simply minding my own business in a public area. I know the issue is not toddlers not being on reins
Me too, I'm sick to the back teeth of dogs, I wish they were dog free areas where I could guarantee not having to encounter any of them.

Fageyoghurt · 13/02/2024 12:17

That’s terrible. I don’t know when this was but back in the 90s and noughties you did see dogs on their own a lot more often. I find it odd that dogs that have caused injuries requiring hospital treatment aren’t automatically PTS when they’ve been reported.

And yeah that’s the issue with the muzzle orders, it’s very common for dogs to escape when the front door is opened unless the owners are really on the ball. I see it a lot and quite often if i go for a walk, I find myself scanning residential streets to check.

In my early 20s, one evening I was approached by a staffy type dog barking aggressively at me on my way home. thankfully I happened to be about 50 yards from a childhood friends home. I managed to inch past it and rang my friends doorbell. Her mum was already practically at the door, she later told me she’d actually got up to see what all the very loud barking was about. So she immediately invited me in and we waited for quite a while, but it was getting late but the dog just wouldn’t move.

My friend wasn’t in, but eventually my friends older sister walked with me to her car and the dog which was still there started barking again and following like it was going to attack one of us. It was SUCH a relief to reach her car and and she drove me home. We were both shaken up. I think I’d have been bitten if I’d not stopped in at my friends house. Grateful family helped me out.

Gloriosaford · 13/02/2024 12:16

flashmcdoodle · 13/02/2024 10:45

US Pit advocates blockading the memorial service of a victim

This is horrifying disgusting and it beggars belief 🤬😢

Fionaville · 13/02/2024 11:44

Fageyoghurt · 13/02/2024 11:29

@Fionaville thats awful. Was the owner around ? What happened to the dog?

The dog had escaped from it's house and I was just walking to the shop with my friend, it wasn't my area it was where my friend lived. The owner just came along and took the dog back, didn't do anything. I believe my friends dad went and had a word. The owner said the dog had run out the front door when somebody knocked. My parents reported it, I had to have stitches but the dog didnt get PTS. That's what worries me about the 'muzzled in public' order. Dogs get out.

Fageyoghurt · 13/02/2024 11:29

@Fionaville thats awful. Was the owner around ? What happened to the dog?

Fageyoghurt · 13/02/2024 11:22

Emotionalsupportviper · 13/02/2024 06:06

I was on a train recently and this selfish woman kept letting her dog roam around the train carriage on a long leash while she was in her phone not paying attention. Everyone was trying to ignore it. It kept coming into the floor of my seating area which was annoying. I’m sure if I had moved my legs and kicked it accidentally before I noticed it and it had bitten me, I’d have been blamed.

Why didn't you say something to her @Fageyoghurt ? People like her are aPITA but if no-one complains they'll never see any need to change their behaviour.

And I am 70 years old and have been around dogs all of my life, and can honestly say that I have only been growled at twice, and one of this occasions was when I was standing between my dog and one which wanted to get to her.

I admit that I have had badly trained dogs and silly puppies jump up at me, and I always tell them "Down", because this shouldn't be happening, I agree - I wouldn't let my dogs do it because at the very least it can spoil people's clothing, and at worst could knock someone flying, but aggressive dogs (other than these XL bully type) are very few and far between.

You have been very unfortunate if you have met more than one in your life.

I did ask her to remove the dog. She kind of blinked at me in surprise and then did so but two minutes later went back to her phone and let it start roaming again.

At that point I just stood up and grabbed my luggage, then I asked her to move her dog -which was now blocking the aisle - out of my way so I could walk by. It seems she expected me to walk over her dog while carrying luggage?? But anyway, I found a carriage with no dogs. Luckily it wasn’t a massively busy train so I didn’t have to stick to my reserved seats.

I also emailed the train company and asked them to consider having designated dog friendly carriages like they do in Finland and other countries. They said they’ll consider it but I doubt it.

But really if they allow dogs on trains they need to have enough staff to be able to enforce rules are followed like being kept under the seats, not on the seats and not in the the aisle or other peoples seating area. And perhaps they could add signs around the train reminding dog owners. That incident happened on my journey home from my friends, but on the way out there was actually another dog in my carriage. This one was completely off leash walking up and down the aisle in a crowded train. I didn’t want to start walking up and down the train with an unsupervised dog in search of of the owner. It’s just not my job. It’s not really fair customers having to confront other passengers especially as some people can be very aggressive and hostile.

Thousands of people attend NHS hospitals for dog bites every year. I’ve personally witnessed dogs be aggressive to other people and heard people tell me various stories including ones I’ve read on here which include stuff like their partners dogs growling at their children or their neighbours dog snarling each time they go out in the garden so while I don’t think most dogs are, I don’t think aggressive dogs are all that rare.

It doesn’t happen every day granted and the last time it happened to me was October on the coastal walk but then as I said I don’t really interact with dogs (except the dogs of a few trusted friends which are lovely and calm) and give most a wide berth.

Fionaville · 13/02/2024 11:11

Fireandflames · 13/02/2024 10:48

So does that mean all other biting dogs should be put to sleep then?, like rotties or shepherds?. Thought not.

I've still got the scar on my leg from a German Shepard coming out of nowhere and biting me when I was 10. So, I'd be quite happy to see any of the large and powerful breeds, banned as pets. They don't need PTS, because numbers of deaths due to these breeds aren't comparable with XL bullies, but I'd be happy to see them fazed out.

Waitingfordoggo · 13/02/2024 11:05

Fireandflames · 13/02/2024 10:48

So does that mean all other biting dogs should be put to sleep then?, like rotties or shepherds?. Thought not.

Have they killed as many people as XLBs have over the past few years? If they have, then yes I’d probably be arguing for them to all be euthanised too.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 13/02/2024 11:02

Fireandflames · 13/02/2024 10:48

So does that mean all other biting dogs should be put to sleep then?, like rotties or shepherds?. Thought not.

No, but they should all be banned as pets. Or at the very least required to be on short leads and muzzled in public.

Fireandflames · 13/02/2024 10:48

So does that mean all other biting dogs should be put to sleep then?, like rotties or shepherds?. Thought not.

flashmcdoodle · 13/02/2024 10:45

US Pit advocates blockading the memorial service of a victim

XL Bully attack | 8 year old boy seriously injured
Waitingfordoggo · 13/02/2024 10:40

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 13/02/2024 09:58

That’s missing the point. Whatever the relative intellectual abilities of dogs and children - and it’s obviously a completely nonsense comparison anyway - to liken the reactions or behaviour of children to those of dogs is foolish because they have nothing in common at all.

You might as well draw an equivalence between a child and an octopus. Do you see?

But we do make comparisons between humans and other animals (especially mammals). There’s a whole branch of psychology dedicated to it (comparative psychology). Humans are animals, after all.

Octopuses are supremely intelligent, by all accounts and may be capable of forming emotional attachments, even to humans. So comparing a human to an octopus is not a particularly strange thing to do (although I imagine octopuses are probably cleverer than us).

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 13/02/2024 10:39

Gloriosaford · 12/02/2024 22:55

My children weren't 'leashed'
@LyingWitchInTheWardrobe
Wtf! Who refers to children as being 'leashed'
Again we see this need to blur the boundaries between children and dogs, constantly wanting to assert that their pet is equal to a human 😳

It was 2boysNosleep who referred to me 'leashing' my children (put on reins). That same posters is of the view that my lines are blurred.

I know the difference between dogs and children, the only similarity between the two is that both can be unpredictable and out of control.

Swipe left for the next trending thread