Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

XL Bully attack | 8 year old boy seriously injured

762 replies

ThisOldThang · 11/02/2024 09:05

https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/schoolboy-8-seriously-injured-after-28610020

"A schoolboy is in a serious condition in hospital after being mauled by what is believed to be an XL bully.

Merseyside Police were called to Wadham Road in Bootle just after 5.20pm on Saturday following reports a dog had bitten an eight-year-old boy to the head in the communal area of flats nearby.

The boy was rushed to hospital with serious head injuries and required emergency surgery. He remains in hospital in a serious but stable condition."

IMHO the ban doesn't go anywhere near far enough and all XL Bullys need to be put to sleep.

AIBU?

Schoolboy, 8, seriously injured after being mauled by 'XL bully'

A man and woman were arrested following the "horrific" dog attack

https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/schoolboy-8-seriously-injured-after-28610020

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Georgeandzippyzoo · 11/02/2024 13:38

Figgygal · 11/02/2024 09:09

If it was outside shouldn't it have been muzzled? What a surprise that it wasn't

Af this point the owner should be done for attempted murder. If its not muzzled in a communal public area they ARE breaking the law and therefore should be held totally responsible, not just 'in possession of out of control dog'

BusyMummy001 · 11/02/2024 13:38

@Bruisername issue with chipping is that it can’t be controlled - lots of unscrupulous domestic breeders just don’t/won’t chip them and there’s no way to police which dogs you see in the street have or have not been done.

I personally do feel we need some sort of dog license system where you are vetted upon application (premises checked etc, just as the RSPCA/Battersea DH does before allowing you to adopt) together with a considerable charge (to fund the process). I think this would put off casual adopters, reduce the chances of needing to rehome, and possibly reduce the number of breeders as they’d be less likely to make a quick buck.

Never going to happen, though.

Whatsgoingonwithmyhead · 11/02/2024 13:38

Yet still people will talk about poor innocent fur babies blah blah blah

Anyone who continues to own these dogs should be liable for murder / GBH charges if their dog attacks

There have been enough warnings

Devilshands · 11/02/2024 13:35

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 11/02/2024 13:24

@Devilshands what is the answer then? We can’t let this unfettered dog ownership continue when it is causing inconvenience for everyone else? All these dog friendly places etc when the people using them can barely keep them under control. Continuous barking, crap everywhere, being ran at when out walking because they can’t possibly keep their fur baby on a lead they need to ‘run free’ (boak). Dogs should be classed as a luxury no one needs a dog at the end of the day other than assistance and working dogs

There isn't an answer.

However, everyone has the right to have a dog. But that doesn't mean people don't have a responsibility to ensure they have a dog that is appropriate for them and their circumstances.

Ultimately, the responsibility to ensuring that the right people have dogs rests with the individuals themselves (but it's the thicko's that are the problem, because they will get the 'hardest' dog they can and there's no educating someone with the brain the size of a goldfish') and breeders.

However, breeders cannot always accurately judge a person based off their appearance/accent/wealth/house size/job when it comes to selling them a dog. They can do their best. But it doesn't mean they will get it right. You also can't 'profile' who is going to be a responsible dog owner and who isn't. I am sure if that was the case, then I would have been profiled into not being sold a dog. And yet, I have three well-balanced, well trained dogs that are living the best life they could possibly have.

So we are at a stalemate.

You can't educate the thickos.
You cannot profile people and refuse to sell dogs to them just because you don't like how they look/sound/walk/live.
You can't licence dogs because that's not sustainable and is too costly to implement. And no way is anyone going to support the extensive costs associated when that money could go to the NHS...
You can't increase the price of dogs to price people out the market - it just results in backyard breeders
You can't just ban all dogs other than working dogs and assistance dogs because, quite frankly, that's insane and you shouldn't punish the majority just because of a few rotten eggs.

The best anyone can do is react when a new breed emerges that is a clear risk to public safety.

Gloriosaford · 11/02/2024 13:35

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 11/02/2024 13:24

@Devilshands what is the answer then? We can’t let this unfettered dog ownership continue when it is causing inconvenience for everyone else? All these dog friendly places etc when the people using them can barely keep them under control. Continuous barking, crap everywhere, being ran at when out walking because they can’t possibly keep their fur baby on a lead they need to ‘run free’ (boak). Dogs should be classed as a luxury no one needs a dog at the end of the day other than assistance and working dogs

I agree, I think the tide is turning against dogs, it's a shame for the sweet little friendly ones, I now give a very wide birth to anything over ankles height

Bruisername · 11/02/2024 13:32

How do other countries regulate?

all dogs need chips - that chip should include the breeder/rescue centre license. Breeding dogs should also have that info on their chip. When dog goes to vet it needs scanning and reporting if dogs aren’t in order. Yes vets will moan but given how much mine fleeced me I have limited sympathy!!

some exemptions for working dogs but again need a license

we need new ideas and a debate.

MarnieMarnie · 11/02/2024 13:25

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

indigovapour · 11/02/2024 13:25

JustJessi · 11/02/2024 09:08

Enough is enough! Put them all to sleep. I was just having this conversation with a group of friends, and they all said the same thing.

Agree - the owners along with the dogs as far as I'm concerned!

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 11/02/2024 13:24

@Devilshands what is the answer then? We can’t let this unfettered dog ownership continue when it is causing inconvenience for everyone else? All these dog friendly places etc when the people using them can barely keep them under control. Continuous barking, crap everywhere, being ran at when out walking because they can’t possibly keep their fur baby on a lead they need to ‘run free’ (boak). Dogs should be classed as a luxury no one needs a dog at the end of the day other than assistance and working dogs

Devilshands · 11/02/2024 13:21

There seems to be far more irresponsible dog ownership than responsible these days

Social media has a lot to answer for IMO. Because it IS social media that has done the damage. People see people having things and they instantly want them. You couldn't really do that twenty years ago - social media wasn't such a 'thing' and peoples jealousy/envy wasn't as bad.

Now its: "She has a dog. I deserve a dog. She has a nice house. I deserve a nice house. She has lots of money. I deserve lots of money. She has a nice car. I deserve a nice car."

Sadly, dogs are just considered another 'luxury item' too many people out there.

But, licensing won't work. There's no real way to implement it in an already stretched system.

BusyMummy001 · 11/02/2024 13:20

Sadly the failure to nip this issue in the bud is impacting the perception of all dogs and their owners. I now have a ‘note’ on my Amazon Prime delivery record that we have ‘potentially dangerous dogs’ - when we have a 6mo spaniel puppy and an adolescent sprocker who barks when the doorbell goes (given my neighbour was burgled this week, I am not inclined to discourage the barking).

Neither are allowed into the hallway when we answer the door out of consideration for delivery staff who may be wary of animals and - frankly - because it is easier to take parcels in without tripping over two excited dogs.

However, we have had staff refuse to come onto our driveway and literally call us from outside to collect items from the pavement. I’ve had to stop using them as a result - irritating as hell for us, but clearly fuelling anxiety and fear-inducing for delivery staff.

It is irresponsible dog ownership that has got us here - and the desire to own a Bully XL is a major indicator of that mindset.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 11/02/2024 13:18

I’m agree these dogs need to just be put down now, the vast majority are of a certain type so aren’t going to follow the law anyway.

i also agree that all dogs should be licensed and it made as inconvenient and expensive as possible which might make the irresponsible think twice. You see it time and again that rescues turn people down (not always for good reason of course) but there is obviously something stopping them giving them a dog so what do they do? Get a puppy from a dodgy background instead of stopping and thinking maybe now isn’t the right time, Instant gratification without thought for the next 10+ years. There seems to be far more irresponsible dog ownership than responsible these days

Bargello · 11/02/2024 13:10

Nobody's claiming that the owners are blameless, they are choosing to own these beasts because they like the fact it makes them look hard and that other people are intimidated by their animal.

The breed in itself is ALSO a problem though, these things are too strong, too powerful, too unpredictable to have living in homes.

Gloriosaford · 11/02/2024 13:02

It is the owner who choose to breed and buy these dogs.
@icelolly12
Well said 👏🏻
These creatures should not be kept as pets, they have no place in society.
I'm sure there's some areas and estates police just avoid as it's too much hassle and nothing will ever change
I do feel that this is unfair on the police though, is it not more the case that they don't have the resources to deal with the problems? Remember it's very difficult to defend yourself against an attack from one of these animals, your only chance is if you have a firearm.
We might as well have leopards roaming our streets, Jesus wept.

Bruisername · 11/02/2024 12:51

flashmcdoodle · 11/02/2024 12:17

Thanks. A lot of bull terrier/pit bull

icelolly12 · 11/02/2024 12:51

The issue is that it is the owner not the dog.

It is the owner who choose to breed and buy these dogs.

It is the owner who chooses to keep potentially dangerous animals around children

It is the owner who keeps them confined, doesn't exercise and doesn't train them

It is the owner who keeps them unmuzzled

It is the owner who likes a dangerous dog as a status symbol

and so on...

(yes I'm aware that some owners are highly responsible, but lets be real most normal people don't want to own a potential killing machine, they go for a cockapoo or a labrador)

And the wider societal issue is how on earth do we police these owners when the ones owning the dogs that attack probably don't give two hoots about the law, probably keep their dog inside / in their yard most of the time, probably terrify their neighbours who wouldn't dare complain for fear of being targeted, probably have mates who have similar aggressive dogs, probably live on sink estates where drugs, child abuse, child neglect and other crimes are a police and slocial worker priority not checking on dog breeds.

It's easy to say 'lets ban all xl bullies' but that is just going to be a green light for the type of person who owns them- they'll become a bigger status symbol, be hidden away more and not get exercise making them more aggressive and so on. We have massive anti social behaviour in this country that is what is terrifying. I'm sure there's some areas and estates police just avoid as it's too much hassle and nothing will ever change.

Waitingfordoggo · 11/02/2024 12:48

Thanks @Gloriosaford, I’ll take a look at Reddit. Interested to know if the US Government is trying to deal with the problem.

abesnt · 11/02/2024 12:47

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 11/02/2024 10:13

All dogs a toddler cannot beat in a fight can get in grave.

I can't think of any dog breed a toddler could fight?

TomeTome · 11/02/2024 12:47

I think they should be removed from the community, just as it became illegal to own other dangerous animals. They will have to be destroyed because it’s not like there is an appetite for dangerous dog zoos.

Waitingfordoggo · 11/02/2024 12:46

If dogs are so great why don't you go and live in dog city where all the businesses are staffed by dogs all the cars are driven by dogs etc.

This is what I’m picturing and it sounds amazing. I’m packing my bags as we speak.

XL Bully attack | 8 year old boy seriously injured
Gloriosaford · 11/02/2024 12:45

Waitingfordoggo · 11/02/2024 12:41

Are there an equivalent number of dangerous dog attacks in other countries? I wonder how other governments are approaching the problem. Someone posted earlier about Spain saying that there are a much smaller number of XL Bullies there, and I would imagine the same is true for most European countries. Surely lots of people in the US have large, dangerous dogs though (given that this is a place where some people think it’s reasonable to keep big cats as pets). Perhaps people just shoot them and it’s the one and only situation where it’s an advantage to live in a country where so many people have guns?!

Yes if not more so the USA is particularly bad for Pitbull type animals, check out Reddit ban pit bulls, it is horrifying

Gloriosaford · 11/02/2024 12:43

Animals haven’t destroyed the planet through greed and laziness. They just follow their instincts
This is because instincts are all they have, they are just as greedy and lazy as humans but without the enhanced brain capacity, coupled with physical and linguistic dexterity that would allow them to extend themselves in the way that we do.

Waitingfordoggo · 11/02/2024 12:41

Are there an equivalent number of dangerous dog attacks in other countries? I wonder how other governments are approaching the problem. Someone posted earlier about Spain saying that there are a much smaller number of XL Bullies there, and I would imagine the same is true for most European countries. Surely lots of people in the US have large, dangerous dogs though (given that this is a place where some people think it’s reasonable to keep big cats as pets). Perhaps people just shoot them and it’s the one and only situation where it’s an advantage to live in a country where so many people have guns?!

Gloriosaford · 11/02/2024 12:41

Fageyoghurt · 11/02/2024 12:37

You’re both spot on. It’s a very worrying and strange mindset. And explains why sometimes when a dog has fatally attacked a child or adult member of the family, the remaining family members fight to keep it alive.

There are cases where someone has been seriously mauled by their own dog, had their arm torn off, serious disfigurement etc and they have still kept the animal. I'm inclined to think that they have developed some sort of trauma bond with the creature?

SilverTay · 11/02/2024 12:40

Gloriosaford · 11/02/2024 12:07

I don't think a breed is inherently bad
It doesn't make sense to talk about dogs (or any other animals) as being inherently good or bad, they are animals and as such they are not capable of making moral choices.
I will say that these large powerful canine predators are inherently dangerous.
I had hoped that we could relax a bit, that the danger, the threat from these animals would significantly reduce after the ban, sadly it doesn't seem to be the case.

I agree the dogs aren't inherently bad, and neither is a bear or a tiger. Both animals I wouldn't have as a pet in my living room.