Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

XL Bully attack | 8 year old boy seriously injured

762 replies

ThisOldThang · 11/02/2024 09:05

https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/schoolboy-8-seriously-injured-after-28610020

"A schoolboy is in a serious condition in hospital after being mauled by what is believed to be an XL bully.

Merseyside Police were called to Wadham Road in Bootle just after 5.20pm on Saturday following reports a dog had bitten an eight-year-old boy to the head in the communal area of flats nearby.

The boy was rushed to hospital with serious head injuries and required emergency surgery. He remains in hospital in a serious but stable condition."

IMHO the ban doesn't go anywhere near far enough and all XL Bullys need to be put to sleep.

AIBU?

Schoolboy, 8, seriously injured after being mauled by 'XL bully'

A man and woman were arrested following the "horrific" dog attack

https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/schoolboy-8-seriously-injured-after-28610020

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Anonanonanon1 · 12/02/2024 18:19

Emotionalsupportviper · 12/02/2024 16:01

Not quite @Fionaville - they were bred to 'bait" a bull. Worry at it and anger it to provide "sport" for the men watching. Several dogs would be set on a single bull. They were bred for courage and tenacity - people used to bet on how long a dog could keep its grip on the bull's flesh once it got a hold, for instance, or which dog would get the first grip on the bull's nose. Bulls weren't killed every time (or even very often - a bull is expensive). It was believed IIRC that tormenting a bull before slaughter made the meat more tender. Dogs were also pitted against each other in fights. A high tolerance for pain was obviously also valued.

However they were also bred to be biddable - nobody wanted a fighting dog that was likely to rip their arm off when they took it out of the ring - and dogs were treated as dogs, not children, so they knew their place in the home.

But you are right in that they were much smaller and lighter than most of the staffies we encounter nowadays, and with smaller heads - more like a Plummer terrier build

So you had a courageous, tenacious animal which didn't give up, but which could be trusted around people (though not always around other dogs).

This is absolutely correct about the history of the sbt.
The breed standard is a maximum height of 16" for males and 16kg, and this is what good breeders produce, with health tests in place and temperament with people is the number one consideration.
These significantly larger bull breeds that people describe as staffies are crossed with other breeds and not bred to standard.
They are not bred with temperament in mind any more than they are health tested or created to improve on what we already have.
My first 2 staffords were rescues, and when I lost my original boy 5 years ago I spent 18 months looking for another rescue that fitted the breed standard, as I compete my dogs in agility and I like to show what a great breed they are with the right training.
Despite searching countrywide there was nothing under 4 years old that was suitable so I went on a waiting list for a health tested puppy from a breeder whose dogs I know to be an excellent type, temperament and that have successfully competed to a high level in dog obedience.
The wait was worth it as I now have a fantastic agility dog who is a great example of the breed in looks and temperament.

He is totally reliable as per the breed standard, and great around people. He ignores other dogs in group training sessions and in the highly exciting show environment.
I would not expect the same had I got a 'staffie' from the guy down the street who had put his dog to his mates bitch just because he wanted to make a few quid.

I fear that up to this point xl bullies have been bought by people wanting to cash in on their surge in popularity and equally little thought has been put into the temperament. I am afraid that any flaws in temperament would be viewed as the dog being protective and thus the creation of many ticking time bombs.
Going forward if these new laws are policed and anyone producing litters is heavily penalized then hopefully numbers will reduce, but ultimately the breeding of all dogs needs to be heavily regulated and dog ownership looked on as a privilege not a right.
Dog licenses, ownership tests, compulsory insurance.... whatever it takes to stop this downhill spiral and end the creation of newer and more dangerous weapon dogs.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 12/02/2024 18:15

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 12/02/2024 17:56

Excuse me but, if your child comes shrieking and waving their arms at my dog and you or their guardian are not reprimanding them then they'll be put straight by me. Your child, you control them. I will keep my animal under control.

When did children NOT learn about safety in approaching other people's animals? We we taught this as children (in my 50s now) and parents took responsibility for what their children did.

They can be “put straight” by you, though I’d hope you’d be sensible enough to understand that children don’t have mature judgement. So some kind, non-threatening advice would be best, don’t you think?

But if you attack a child you’ll be in trouble. And if your dog attacks a child you’ll also be in trouble.

2boyzNosleep · 12/02/2024 18:08

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 12/02/2024 17:56

Excuse me but, if your child comes shrieking and waving their arms at my dog and you or their guardian are not reprimanding them then they'll be put straight by me. Your child, you control them. I will keep my animal under control.

When did children NOT learn about safety in approaching other people's animals? We we taught this as children (in my 50s now) and parents took responsibility for what their children did.

Completely agree with making sure children are taught.

However we can never fully control a young child or an animal, nor can we be 100% prepared for any situation

Once I saw a couple queuing for an ice cream with their dog (on a lead, not a dangerous dog). A toddler quietly came out of nowhere and grabbed the dog from behind (the child was excited about the dog). The child was with his parents but had made a quick breakaway due to being excited and they hadn't caught him in time- literally just grabbing him and he grabbed the dog.

The dog, surprised bit the child's hand (luckily not badly).

In this situation it was no one's fault, but a child was still bitten.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 12/02/2024 18:08

Emotionalsupportviper · 12/02/2024 17:50

Intellectually and emotionally a dog is a perpetual 3-yo. (Though most dogs have better manners than the average pre-school child)

Would you expect a 3yo not to react if another child came barrelling unto them? Some would cry, some would cower, some would react aggressively.

The difference is that with the vast majority of dogs aggression is their very last resort.

Dogs are not children. Comparing the two is ludicrous.

2boyzNosleep · 12/02/2024 17:59

todayshappening · 11/02/2024 17:27

I have an xl, a cockapoo, cocker spaniel and a yorkie so yes us types do buy those breeds too 😏

I do think you are aware of the 'type' I'm referring to.

The majority of people that want an XL bully are the ones that i referred to, that want the 'look' and the street cred and sometimes see it as quick money by breeding them. The same sort of people that really want rottweilers, staffy's, etc before xl bully's became popular.

Also, theres far too many people now that want dogs and do not train them or carry for them properly. Especially the small dogs that people think can't do much damage.

Yes there are plenty of responsible owners out there that would do plenty of research of the breed and their needs and obviously do want an XL bully and would train it (and any other dog appropriately). But there are far too many idiots that do not do this.

Yes any dog can snap and I don't think children and any type of dog is a good mix.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 12/02/2024 17:56

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 12/02/2024 17:31

And a lot of children don't just "approach" dogs - they charge up to them, often shrieking and waving their arms.

I’m sorry but I don’t believe that’s any basis for justifying a dog reacting to a child, whether by frightening or attacking. A dog should be fully capable of restraint in public if this sort of thing happens.

And whoever mentioned ‘nanny dogs’, it’s rubbish. The term was a marketing ploy by breeders and bull breed fanciers.

Excuse me but, if your child comes shrieking and waving their arms at my dog and you or their guardian are not reprimanding them then they'll be put straight by me. Your child, you control them. I will keep my animal under control.

When did children NOT learn about safety in approaching other people's animals? We we taught this as children (in my 50s now) and parents took responsibility for what their children did.

Emotionalsupportviper · 12/02/2024 17:50

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 12/02/2024 17:31

And a lot of children don't just "approach" dogs - they charge up to them, often shrieking and waving their arms.

I’m sorry but I don’t believe that’s any basis for justifying a dog reacting to a child, whether by frightening or attacking. A dog should be fully capable of restraint in public if this sort of thing happens.

And whoever mentioned ‘nanny dogs’, it’s rubbish. The term was a marketing ploy by breeders and bull breed fanciers.

Intellectually and emotionally a dog is a perpetual 3-yo. (Though most dogs have better manners than the average pre-school child)

Would you expect a 3yo not to react if another child came barrelling unto them? Some would cry, some would cower, some would react aggressively.

The difference is that with the vast majority of dogs aggression is their very last resort.

PetuniaT · 12/02/2024 17:46

All of these dogs should be put down and all of their owners lifestyle and means of living investigated as I bet 99 out of a hundred are criminals.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 12/02/2024 17:31

And a lot of children don't just "approach" dogs - they charge up to them, often shrieking and waving their arms.

I’m sorry but I don’t believe that’s any basis for justifying a dog reacting to a child, whether by frightening or attacking. A dog should be fully capable of restraint in public if this sort of thing happens.

And whoever mentioned ‘nanny dogs’, it’s rubbish. The term was a marketing ploy by breeders and bull breed fanciers.

Emotionalsupportviper · 12/02/2024 16:01

Not quite @Fionaville - they were bred to 'bait" a bull. Worry at it and anger it to provide "sport" for the men watching. Several dogs would be set on a single bull. They were bred for courage and tenacity - people used to bet on how long a dog could keep its grip on the bull's flesh once it got a hold, for instance, or which dog would get the first grip on the bull's nose. Bulls weren't killed every time (or even very often - a bull is expensive). It was believed IIRC that tormenting a bull before slaughter made the meat more tender. Dogs were also pitted against each other in fights. A high tolerance for pain was obviously also valued.

However they were also bred to be biddable - nobody wanted a fighting dog that was likely to rip their arm off when they took it out of the ring - and dogs were treated as dogs, not children, so they knew their place in the home.

But you are right in that they were much smaller and lighter than most of the staffies we encounter nowadays, and with smaller heads - more like a Plummer terrier build

So you had a courageous, tenacious animal which didn't give up, but which could be trusted around people (though not always around other dogs).

TallulahBetty · 12/02/2024 15:50

Enough is enough. Shoot them all.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 12/02/2024 15:48

Emotionalsupportviper · 12/02/2024 15:01

I occasionally used to take my dogs until I left one outside a shop once and came out to find her running towards me- lead still attached to the rail I'd fastened her to.. I couldn't understand how she was loose and asked the girl in the tobacco kiosk (which was beside the door) if she'd seen anything, and apparently a smartly dressed middle aged man had unfastened her - the girl in the shop just assumed it was his dog - and by sheer good luck I had come out of the other door and she'd seen me and shot towards me.

The bloke had just walked away.

I've never tied a dog up outside anywhere since.

That sends shivers through me. So glad that you got there in time. Some people just have no respect for anything or anyone.

Fionaville · 12/02/2024 15:45

Whatafustercluck · 12/02/2024 14:25

The thing is, Staffies used to be bred for fighting and there was a time they were used as status symbols for undesirables. They too are a strong, tenacious breed that is banned in places like France. Yet these days, with the right ownership, they're a placid, gentle nanny dog that is great with children. Before staffies, it was Rotties. Before that, Alsatians and Dobermans. XL Bullies are a big, strong, dangerous breed because they're enjoying popularity with a criminal element in society who raise them to be aggressive. Who knows what they're like brought into a home as a pup and raised, trained and loved as a family dog, because that's not the kind of people who are drawn to them.

If you look at very old photos of Staffies, from a time they were referred to as the nanny dog, they are a lot smaller for one thing. Most of the staffie dogs people have now, have larger bully breeds in their lineage. I've only known one staffie that was close to an original staffie. It was smaller and it didn't have as large a head.
Even so, staffies were originally bread to be powerful enough to bring down a bull. That's were bull breeds came from. So, imagine that then adding in the bigger, more aggressive elements into bully breeds. These big dogs aren't meant to be family pets. You may as well bring a 'well trained' tiger into the house.

TrixieFatell · 12/02/2024 15:37

I think noone should be able to own a pet they cannot physically restrain. No matter what. There are some large breeds I love but if you cannot stop it or pull it away then you don't have them. I chose my dog specifically if he turns we can easily restrain him, all you have to do is stand on a high surface. He can bite, any dog has that potential but you'd get him off the person easily.

Emotionalsupportviper · 12/02/2024 15:20

We'll have to agree to differ @WhatsTheUseOfWorrying - because there are many, many idiots who insist on being able to touch any dog they like. And a lot of children don't just "approach" dogs - they charge up to them, often shrieking and waving their arms.

Every dog should have the right to defend itself. Usually it doesn't take anything more than a grumble to put people off - though there are some than then complain that it is a "nasty" dog. No, it's not - it's saying "I am ill/ unhappy/ frightened/ blind/ old and don't want people I don't know mucking me about". That is what a growl is for.

I will also add that very few dogs actually intentionally bite. Most will warn with a growl, and will try to get out of the way. If someone insists on being "in their face", they will air snap. If they do get forced into a situation where they feel they have no option, they snap at hands.

If a dog goes for the face it is because it actually is a bad/aggressive dog, or because the face is too close to the dog's - eg a toddler face (and the adults there should have kept dog and baby apart), or one of these twats who thinks it's very clever to approach a dog, walking stiffly and growling at it until face-to-face to "dominate" it. (IMO any adults doing this deserve what they get, but I wouldn't want my dog put down because of them, so I wouldn't let this happen.). The dogs also retreat once they have made their "aggressor" (for that's what they see them as) back off.

Cesar Milan has a lot of stupid, threatening, needlessly provocative behaviour to answer for, and people copying his techniques are often asking to get bitten IMO.

Edited to add: This particular type of dog is dangerous because they don't give any warning or an attack - and when they do attack, it IS an attack, not defensive behaviour. And because it is an attack they go for the vulnerable parts of the body - they'll bite at legs or use their weight to bring the victim down, and will often then turn the attention to the head and neck. They aren't attempting to escape a threat- they are prey-driven.

BebbanburgIsMine · 12/02/2024 15:16

I'm in Scotland so different rules here, but I think they should all be PTS.

Horrible things.

Bruisername · 12/02/2024 15:07

I have no time for aggressive dogs. Ultimately it’s more likely that my dog will be the victim.

but I have had multiple cases of kids trying to stroke the dog from behind or without asking and the two times kids tried to hit him.

I have a well behaved dog and I think children should be well behaved! I hate seeing kids trying to stamp on pigeons or throw sticks at squirrels. Basic respect for animals is important be they pets or wild

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 12/02/2024 15:02

Emotionalsupportviper · 12/02/2024 14:26

Really?

So if a dog had bitten the little shits who left him with little chip shop forks stuck in his face outside a chemist's while the owner got a prescription, he should have been put down?

He didn't. The vicious little bastards ran off laughing when I challenged them, and I stayed to comfort the dog for the few minutes it took for the owner to return.

Poor dog was shaking like a leaf. And he was a staffie. Frankly, if I could have caught the little sods I would have bitten them myself!

Yes, really. Nobody - at least nobody in their right mind - would defend that sort of cruelty to a dog, whoever does it.

But what if the staffy had attacked whoever did this? Would flesh wounds to the assailants be ok? Loss of an eye? Both eyes? Huge disfigurement for life? Throat ripped out?

And how could you know the dog wouldn’t attack someone else in range, not the offender?

No dog should ever attack anyone. We might have more sympathy for a dog that reacts to concerted vicious torture, but that’s going to be exceptionally rare from strangers (most serious mistreatment of dogs is by their owners). And it’s not the point.

What MN dog lovers harp on about is children rushing up and stroking and poking. I do not believe that any dog should react violently to that. If it does it’s not fit to be in public.

(In any event, I don’t believe children do approach dogs in that way anything like as much as the dog lovers on here say. It’s mostly made up bollocks IMO, to try to justify out of control, antisocial behaviour of dogs and their owners’ condoning it.)

Emotionalsupportviper · 12/02/2024 15:01

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 12/02/2024 14:39

Poor dog. To be honest, I don't understand why people take their dogs shopping. Not that they can't or that they shouldn't, just for the safety of the dog. I would rather leave them at home. Not for the kids, for the dog.

I wouldn't have a minute's peace being in a shop or chemist knowing that my dog was outside on their own, I'd fear them being stolen.

In the good old days, people (mostly) left things along that didn't belong to them. Not any more. Substandard people breeding substandard offspring. So, so many of them.

I occasionally used to take my dogs until I left one outside a shop once and came out to find her running towards me- lead still attached to the rail I'd fastened her to.. I couldn't understand how she was loose and asked the girl in the tobacco kiosk (which was beside the door) if she'd seen anything, and apparently a smartly dressed middle aged man had unfastened her - the girl in the shop just assumed it was his dog - and by sheer good luck I had come out of the other door and she'd seen me and shot towards me.

The bloke had just walked away.

I've never tied a dog up outside anywhere since.

Bookist · 12/02/2024 14:57

Nanny dog? No. No. No. This is an absolute crock of shit.

Dogs are beautifully behaved.....until they're not. And if that dog is physically capable of mauling people then that's when tragedies happen.

Itscatsallthewaydown · 12/02/2024 14:46

Whatafustercluck · 12/02/2024 14:25

The thing is, Staffies used to be bred for fighting and there was a time they were used as status symbols for undesirables. They too are a strong, tenacious breed that is banned in places like France. Yet these days, with the right ownership, they're a placid, gentle nanny dog that is great with children. Before staffies, it was Rotties. Before that, Alsatians and Dobermans. XL Bullies are a big, strong, dangerous breed because they're enjoying popularity with a criminal element in society who raise them to be aggressive. Who knows what they're like brought into a home as a pup and raised, trained and loved as a family dog, because that's not the kind of people who are drawn to them.

Nope. I’m fed of this apologist BS. Put them all down.

Blathermoa · 12/02/2024 14:45

Whatafustercluck · 12/02/2024 14:25

The thing is, Staffies used to be bred for fighting and there was a time they were used as status symbols for undesirables. They too are a strong, tenacious breed that is banned in places like France. Yet these days, with the right ownership, they're a placid, gentle nanny dog that is great with children. Before staffies, it was Rotties. Before that, Alsatians and Dobermans. XL Bullies are a big, strong, dangerous breed because they're enjoying popularity with a criminal element in society who raise them to be aggressive. Who knows what they're like brought into a home as a pup and raised, trained and loved as a family dog, because that's not the kind of people who are drawn to them.

There's no such thing as a nanny dog. There are many, many examples of bullies being treated as loving family dogs and turning on their owners, often their children, because that's what they are hardwired to do.

Matronic6 · 12/02/2024 14:41

Whatafustercluck · 12/02/2024 14:25

The thing is, Staffies used to be bred for fighting and there was a time they were used as status symbols for undesirables. They too are a strong, tenacious breed that is banned in places like France. Yet these days, with the right ownership, they're a placid, gentle nanny dog that is great with children. Before staffies, it was Rotties. Before that, Alsatians and Dobermans. XL Bullies are a big, strong, dangerous breed because they're enjoying popularity with a criminal element in society who raise them to be aggressive. Who knows what they're like brought into a home as a pup and raised, trained and loved as a family dog, because that's not the kind of people who are drawn to them.

A friend of mine is a dog trainer, runs a doggy day care and doggy 'hotel' and he thinks there is also an element of the XL Bully temperament that is completely unpredictable. He has helped to train some XL Bullys but now refuses them for doggy day care and hotel stay as he has seen sudden aggressive responses out of a few and doesn't trust them around smaller dogs or his kids.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 12/02/2024 14:39

Emotionalsupportviper · 12/02/2024 14:26

Really?

So if a dog had bitten the little shits who left him with little chip shop forks stuck in his face outside a chemist's while the owner got a prescription, he should have been put down?

He didn't. The vicious little bastards ran off laughing when I challenged them, and I stayed to comfort the dog for the few minutes it took for the owner to return.

Poor dog was shaking like a leaf. And he was a staffie. Frankly, if I could have caught the little sods I would have bitten them myself!

Poor dog. To be honest, I don't understand why people take their dogs shopping. Not that they can't or that they shouldn't, just for the safety of the dog. I would rather leave them at home. Not for the kids, for the dog.

I wouldn't have a minute's peace being in a shop or chemist knowing that my dog was outside on their own, I'd fear them being stolen.

In the good old days, people (mostly) left things along that didn't belong to them. Not any more. Substandard people breeding substandard offspring. So, so many of them.

Emotionalsupportviper · 12/02/2024 14:34

FieldInWhichFucksAreGrownIsBarren · 11/02/2024 23:19

FFS, stop persecuting breeds. We're on a cycle, Doberman, Rottweiler, Akita, XL Bully Staffordshire Bull Terrier. Look at all these reports and LOOK at the owner. No we DO NOT need to eradicate these dogs. Listen to yourself, put down an innocent healthy animal? Fuck off 😞

You show me a way to ensure that all of these dogs are properly bred from safe, good-natured stock, and purchased by responsible owners who will train, restrain, and socialise them, and then I will support your opinion.

Until then, keep your idiocy to yourself.

If the owners can't be controlled, the dogs have to be culled.

Swipe left for the next trending thread