Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

XL Bully attack | 8 year old boy seriously injured

762 replies

ThisOldThang · 11/02/2024 09:05

https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/schoolboy-8-seriously-injured-after-28610020

"A schoolboy is in a serious condition in hospital after being mauled by what is believed to be an XL bully.

Merseyside Police were called to Wadham Road in Bootle just after 5.20pm on Saturday following reports a dog had bitten an eight-year-old boy to the head in the communal area of flats nearby.

The boy was rushed to hospital with serious head injuries and required emergency surgery. He remains in hospital in a serious but stable condition."

IMHO the ban doesn't go anywhere near far enough and all XL Bullys need to be put to sleep.

AIBU?

Schoolboy, 8, seriously injured after being mauled by 'XL bully'

A man and woman were arrested following the "horrific" dog attack

https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/schoolboy-8-seriously-injured-after-28610020

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
14
SomeCatFromJapan · 17/02/2024 20:15

*There are all kinds of reasons those poor children were killed. And my heart breaks for those babies but I'm just giving reasons.

Things like squealing, wriggling and crying could sound like a small prey animal to a dog.

Prolonged eye contact could be a trigger. Toddlers are eye level with many dogs and often stare. The girl on the sofa could have been eye level.

Food could be a trigger, I think the teenage girl had a pie and it all escalated.

Guarding or resource guarding.*

It's certainly a stark illustration as to why they're entirely unsuitable animals to be pets.

YouHaveLostTheGame · 17/02/2024 20:11

nationallampoons · 16/02/2024 02:52

Owners of dogs that attack should be held accountable, the ones that kill should be given long prison sentences

Just look on tiktok, up until the ban people were selling them through that app, it's frightening!

They still are even after the ban. Reporting does fuck all either.

Gloriosaford · 16/02/2024 21:27

Bookist · 16/02/2024 21:12

No. The reason all those poor children were killed is because they were in the presence of a monster dog that is Inclined. To. Kill.

The teenager girl could have been eating all the pies, but if the dog had been a toy Poodle it physically couldn't have killed her for the bloody pie.

Just bloody listen to yourself.

Absolutely! The reason for the deaths is that the pet had the ability to kill! No one should have a pet like that!

Fageyoghurt · 16/02/2024 21:26

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 16/02/2024 21:23

That’s a bit frightening that such normal everyday things could provoke a dog to maim and kill.

Exactly, ultimately if the dogs can be driven to such violence by toddlers and other humans just existing and doing normal things like eating, staring or squealing it’s further evidence they are unsafe, dangerous and completely unfit to be pets .

My friends tween daughter was colouring in at the dining table when the family staffy dog went for. Her dad, and brother who were present backed up her story too.

Gloriosaford · 16/02/2024 21:24

But it's a bond
I hope we could all agree with that @EmpressSoleil 😁
Anything else is arguably us being anthropomorphic, but then as humans we can only really see through human eyes!

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 16/02/2024 21:23

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 16/02/2024 20:58

There are all kinds of reasons those poor children were killed. And my heart breaks for those babies but I'm just giving reasons.

Things like squealing, wriggling and crying could sound like a small prey animal to a dog.

Prolonged eye contact could be a trigger. Toddlers are eye level with many dogs and often stare. The girl on the sofa could have been eye level.

Food could be a trigger, I think the teenage girl had a pie and it all escalated.

Guarding or resource guarding.

That’s a bit frightening that such normal everyday things could provoke a dog to maim and kill.

EmpressSoleil · 16/02/2024 21:13

I do think animals are capable of a form of love. Is it the same as humans? Maybe not. But what I do know is I have 2 cats. I feed them and take care of all of their needs. DS lives here. He loves them and pets them but does none of the day to day care so they aren't reliant on him. He went away on holiday and one of the cats was genuinely depressed. The other not so much, granted. But the one that missed him I would say genuinely did and was so happy when he came home.

DD is away at uni and every time she comes home they're all over her! Yet they shy away from strangers so it's not as if they've forgotten her and just think she's someone new.

So yes I do believe they love us and not just because of what they're given. There's definitely recognition there. Even if it is only by scent or some other animal sense. Maybe its just a sense of safety and not love as we call it. But it's a bond.

Bookist · 16/02/2024 21:12

No. The reason all those poor children were killed is because they were in the presence of a monster dog that is Inclined. To. Kill.

The teenager girl could have been eating all the pies, but if the dog had been a toy Poodle it physically couldn't have killed her for the bloody pie.

Just bloody listen to yourself.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 16/02/2024 20:58

Rainbowunicornsparkles · 15/02/2024 05:12

So actually there have been twenty children (under the age of 18) killed by dogs since 2010.

Nine were under one year of age

Two under the age of two

Two two / three year olds

Three victims aged ten

Three four year olds

One in her teens

So even if we assume fault of some kind in the victims aged two and above (they weren’t, one four year old was lying on the sofa when she was attacked) I think we’d mostly all agree babies can’t be ‘blamed’. And they make up the majority of the victims.

There are all kinds of reasons those poor children were killed. And my heart breaks for those babies but I'm just giving reasons.

Things like squealing, wriggling and crying could sound like a small prey animal to a dog.

Prolonged eye contact could be a trigger. Toddlers are eye level with many dogs and often stare. The girl on the sofa could have been eye level.

Food could be a trigger, I think the teenage girl had a pie and it all escalated.

Guarding or resource guarding.

IsEveryUserNameBloodyTaken · 16/02/2024 20:46

Stillnormal · 15/02/2024 20:23

This idea that living animals should be rounded up and killed because they are physically and theoretically capable of being dangerous but without evidence that they are individually prone to cause harm, whilst cars driven by dickheads cause many times more unnecessary deaths - and the risk of harm from cars is much greater, but justified on the basis that cars suit her. Massive twattery.

They (pit bull and their counterparts) should not have been bred in the first place.They are not suitable for general population.

IsEveryUserNameBloodyTaken · 16/02/2024 20:43

MatchingBedding · 16/02/2024 13:35

@SomeCatFromJapan like this one? Poor little thing ran to get away straight under a car.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13086977/Moment-pensioners-Jack-Russell-killed-attack-street-Mastiff-dog.html

Yes I have seen that elsewhere and it is absolutely appalling
It took several grown men quite a while to get the savage dog off the poor little dog that was being attacked and then the poor attacked dog ran in front of a car.Horrific.
Thats the thing though with the breed apologists for the bully breed.They claim there have not been that many human deaths….one is too many, but the amount of other animals that are mauled to death by these fighting breeds are just ignored and covered up by them.Its literally on a daily basis if not more that this is happening.

Waitingfordoggo · 16/02/2024 19:44

I appreciate that @Gloriosaford, thank you. I apologise for being overly emotive and miserable. I’ve just been out to teach a weights class and that’s made me feel tons better.

My mum used the phrase ‘cupboard love’ too!

Gloriosaford · 16/02/2024 19:27

Waitingfordoggo · 16/02/2024 18:39

@Gloriosaford- you don’t need to apologise but thank you. I’ve been feeling quite low today- that’s probably why I wrote what I did. I’m not usually oversensitive.

I’m middle-aged, I’m perimenopausal, I’m anxious. My DH is a good man but we’re both just busy and working and doing all the chores. My teenagers are busy with their lives. I’ve realised that I do all this nurturing of other people and I don’t feel nurtured at all, so sometimes it feels like the dog is the only one who actually looks at me with what appears to be affection 😂 It might or might not be ‘love’ but it looks and feels like it!

I guess it depends on how you define love! I think dogs have strong positive bonds with humans, and it seems as if there is a good deal of loyalty and devotion there, my mother always used to refer to it as 'cupboard love'😁
( I hope you feel more uplifted soon🙏)

Stillnormal · 16/02/2024 18:58

Bookist · 16/02/2024 18:38

Yes. Grew up with dogs and my Mum bred them for a while. Still don't think dogs love in the way that humans do.

I liked waitingfordoggo’s post - I think of love as a verb, as much as an emotion. I love my humans and dogs in so many different ways and they sometimes love me back - there are as many iterations of love as there are loving relationships.

Waitingfordoggo · 16/02/2024 18:44

I apologise for derailing but this thread has gone in some interesting directions.

Waitingfordoggo · 16/02/2024 18:44

Thinking on it more though, I think perhaps our pets do ‘love’ us.

Love is abstract isn’t it? I love my kids, my husband, my brother, my friends, my dog. But my feelings for all of those individuals are quite different to each other. I call it love in every case but it’s not the exact same feeling across the board. What it boils down to is chemical reactions in the brain isn’t it? I know that’s not romantic but it’s what I understand ‘love’ to be. If my dog is getting dopamine or whatever from being with me, then in my book he loves me. Not that it matters at all- he behaves as if he loves me and that’s a nice feeling.

Waitingfordoggo · 16/02/2024 18:39

@Gloriosaford- you don’t need to apologise but thank you. I’ve been feeling quite low today- that’s probably why I wrote what I did. I’m not usually oversensitive.

I’m middle-aged, I’m perimenopausal, I’m anxious. My DH is a good man but we’re both just busy and working and doing all the chores. My teenagers are busy with their lives. I’ve realised that I do all this nurturing of other people and I don’t feel nurtured at all, so sometimes it feels like the dog is the only one who actually looks at me with what appears to be affection 😂 It might or might not be ‘love’ but it looks and feels like it!

Bookist · 16/02/2024 18:38

Stillnormal · 16/02/2024 18:14

Have you ever had a dog?

Yes. Grew up with dogs and my Mum bred them for a while. Still don't think dogs love in the way that humans do.

Stillnormal · 16/02/2024 18:14

Bookist · 16/02/2024 17:38

Love is an abstract concept between humans. Dogs don't love you. Stop applying complex human emotions to dogs.

Have you ever had a dog?

SomeCatFromJapan · 16/02/2024 18:09

Love is an abstract concept between humans. Dogs don't love you. Stop applying complex human emotions to dogs.

Of course animals love. Their brains produce the same chemicals ours do, and you can see it observationally.
We're also just animals ultimately, apes with not a lot of body hair. Any notion of humans as somehow spiritually elevated is more of a religious than a scientific one.

Emotionalsupportviper · 16/02/2024 18:04

Bookist · 16/02/2024 17:38

Love is an abstract concept between humans. Dogs don't love you. Stop applying complex human emotions to dogs.

Animals have very deep emotional lives.

And love is one of the most basic (though admittedly complex) emotions there is.

Emotionalsupportviper · 16/02/2024 18:03

Fageyoghurt · 15/02/2024 09:12

Tragic as it is, the children killed in their own homes have died because their parents/ carers left them with dogs

No-one is blaming the tragic victims of these horrible attacks, but looking at that heartbreaking list, every one of those attacks was preventable.

@Emotionalsupportviper I agree with you that you owners/adults present do have a responsibility to supervise children and dogs - be it your own child or a visitor - but in many cases it really would only have been preventable if they didn’t have said dog.

I don’t know each of these cases inside and out but very often in dog attack incidents you’ll find there was an adult present. They didn’t “leave the child with dogs”.

The issue is many of these dogs are so bold and powerful that even a grown man will struggle to defend his own child.

I only have one friend whose (staffy mix) dog attacked their (9 year old) child and in that incident her older brother and Dad were present. It was a dog they’d had for several years as well. Luckily the Dad reacted quickly and got the dog off although she did have to receive hospital care. the kid was just colouring in minding her own business when the dog went for her as well.

I was furious they kept the dog until she attacked their child a second time and then they finally gave it away and who knows if that new owner keeps it away from people knowing it’s bite history !

I agree with everything you have said here.

And your story of the family who kept the dog after it had attacked their child - and then re-homed the animal after a second attack is shocking.

If I had a dog which bit a family member I'd have it euthanised straight away. I wouldn't risk re-homing even to a child-free home, because who knows if they will have a young visitor? I'd feel totally responsible if anything further happened.

in many cases it really would only have been preventable if they didn’t have said dog.

I especially agree with this. Some breeds are not appropriate with children.

Most breeds (other than the subjects of this thread, and in my own experience, Akitas) give warning that they aren't happy. That's when the adults present should intervene and put the dog in another room - and if it persists re-home the dog before it gets a chance to air-snap, let alone bite.

Bookist · 16/02/2024 17:38

Love is an abstract concept between humans. Dogs don't love you. Stop applying complex human emotions to dogs.

Gloriosaford · 16/02/2024 17:34

Tahinii · 16/02/2024 14:42

Um excuse me, I am very special…..when I’m holding the bag of treats. If someone else is holding it, they’re also very special.

On a serious note, dogs can bond with humans and be very loving and attached but it is in a doggy way. We humans project our perspective onto them.

I agree!
You are very special to your dog, because the dog has very basic & limmited criteria by which it determines what is important to it.
The reason it doesn't judge you, or exploit you or undermine you etc (like humans do) isn't because it is morally superior to humans rather it is because the dog is too dumb to do so (ie it doesn't have the kind of brain that would allow such functions) .

Gloriosaford · 16/02/2024 17:27

Waitingfordoggo · 16/02/2024 14:27

’Don’t flatter yourself. It doesn’t love you because you’re special’ is unnecessarily patronising and unkind.

I know damned well I’m not special. There is literally nothing special about me at all. But spending time with my dog makes me feel good and helps keep my mental health on an even keel. I expect you think that’s pathetic but so be it.

I’m sure you can understand why some people who are lonely or largely ‘invisible’ to the humans they share the world with might enjoy the feeling of being loved by their pet (even if it’s only an illusion).

Very sorry, I dont mean that you or anyone else is not special, I mean that the dog has very simple needs, it loves you adoringly & unconditionally because it is totally dependent on you. It's level of cognitive functioning is orders of magnitude below that of a human.
I understand that dogs are valuable human companion animals, but I think humans would do well to recognize & mitigate the very strong impulse to anthropomorphize!

Swipe left for the next trending thread