Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

I had a date with a guy I met off tinder and his arms were covered in self harm scars.

649 replies

Toffeeandfudge1 · 11/02/2024 01:41

So I’ve been talking to this man for afew weeks over WhatsApp now and he seemed really nice. We had lots in common such as love of dogs, music taste, read the same books and so on. We also have children of a similar age. Sounded too good to be true. So we met up tonight for the second time and went to Pizza Hut, and it was really hot in the restaurant so he took his hoodie off and I couldn’t help but notice his arms were covered in scars. They looked old but I was a little taken back as I don’t know anyone that this. I was trying not to look although I felt a little awkward. Am I being unreasonably judgemental or is this a red flag?

OP posts:
HoweverWeare · 11/02/2024 06:52

WandaWonder · 11/02/2024 04:10

Is it a red flag if women have them or only men?

I wouldn’t date anyone who had them, man or woman.

Justfinking · 11/02/2024 06:51

losingtheplot999 · 11/02/2024 06:38

What a horrible post.

It's really not. If you're dating then you should be as choosy as possible, people aren't choosy enough. Being with someone with MH issues is hard, beyond hard. Especially from what is described here, this isn't a small thing.

Porridgeislife · 11/02/2024 06:47

You are not obliged to date someone for any reason you like. I once didn’t date someone because they didn’t like hot drinks.

On a more serious note it does suggest that he has had complex mental health issues so keep an open mind about it. Supporting someone like this can be a really tough gig and it’s not for everyone.

AhBiscuits · 11/02/2024 06:46

I wouldn't date him. I also wouldn't date a reformed alcoholic or drug addict, someone unemployed, someone with children etc etc.
That's a choice I'm allowed to make and I don't care if people think it's wrong in some way.

lap90 · 11/02/2024 06:42

You're not being unreasonable, you can stop dating someone for any reason.

Mt563 · 11/02/2024 06:41

Toffeeandfudge1 · 11/02/2024 03:59

My mental health isn’t fragile, thanks.

The poster assumed your mental health was fragile based on you saying you'd had depression and tried anti depressants in the past. You're fine now, well done, but how does it make you feel that someone is judging you based on that history of mental health issues even though you're fully recovered?

Then consider the man you went on a date with may be in exactly the same position.

losingtheplot999 · 11/02/2024 06:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What a horrible post.

Copperoliverbear · 11/02/2024 06:33

Sorry i would not go on another date with him.

TripleDock · 11/02/2024 06:29

I feel terrible saying it but I would not want to date someone with self-harm scars. It’s discrimination I know. And of course they could be on meds for all sorts of illness, physical and mental that i would not know about. I don’t think I am patient enough or have the energy to support a partner with MH issues at this stage of life so it would be a no from me.

Justfinking · 11/02/2024 06:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Topee · 11/02/2024 06:24

Most people have scars, for some they are visible. If he had drunk to cope or taken drugs you would never necessarily know, he coped by harming himself.

There’s nothing to say that his mental health hasn’t been stable for decades since. It doesn’t mean he’s manipulative or unstable, he may have done a lot of work on his mental health.

Scars alone don’t make someone a bad choice of date, there’s plenty of men that are that don’t have them!

Your choice of course and you can choose not to see him again for whatever reason you like, but there seems to be a lot of misunderstanding about self harm on this thread.

Nosleepforthismum · 11/02/2024 06:20

I wouldn’t see him again, especially as you have children. No problem with Pizza Hut or a hoodie but I really don’t understand why he’d take off his hoodie and say nothing. It feels almost like he’s challenging you. My friend had cut herself in the past and even several years down the line is extremely self conscious of her scars. I don’t believe this man didn’t know exactly what he was doing and that is the bigger red flag in my opinion.

MiltonNorthern · 11/02/2024 06:18

You're not obliged to date anyone for any reason and if this is too much of a worry for you that's your right. My DH has self harmed and attempted suicide in the past when his life was very difficult. It's not something that's ever been a remote possibility since we've been together (a number of years) and is truly in his past. But I was half in love with when I found out about it so it was too late for it to be part of my decision making! If it's not worth the risk to you that's fair enough.

cakeytime · 11/02/2024 06:06

@ohgag
It sounds like you know nothing about self harming.
Maybe educate yourself?

OP, if the scars are old, I wouldn't worry about it.If he seems genuinely a good person then he shouldn't be written off just for that.

Shoxfordian · 11/02/2024 06:00

Anything can put you off this early so don't go out with him again

Nothing wrong with pizza hut and a hoodie if you're 16

thebestinterest · 11/02/2024 05:52

HoweverWeare · 11/02/2024 03:37

The Pizza Hut hoodie combo is a double red flag for me. But I guess you agreed to Pizza Hit so it isn’t for you.

I wouldn’t date someone who disclosed to me that they had serious mental health problems. Nope.

This. I wouldn’t either.

Lwrenn · 11/02/2024 05:50

I'd struggle with this and I'd worry to much about it.
I'd constantly scare myself that something beyond my control may trigger him to relapse almost and he'd harm himself again.
I'd never date anyone (again) with any addiction issues either.
It sounds very judgey and cruel but the old saying of not pouring from an empty cup springs to mind like yourself I'm a mum, I don't have the energy to worry about a new partner who may hurt themselves again in those capacities and whilst it feels horribly unfair to rule people out due to their past experiences, our little people need messy and uncomplicated lives. Whilst he may be completely uncomplicated and not remotely problematic, the risk for me is I'd find out a few years in and bring a layer of adversity I could have avoided to my child's life.
If I was a man and I met me I'd never date myself, not just because I've loads of children but I've a chaotic wee brain and whilst best intentioned, I often miss the mark. I'd not put up with my own bat shittery and just because it's not from a place of malice or anything, doesn't mean it can't make our lives more difficult with working myself up over things. So whilst I appreciate it's not nice to be ruled out, it's also tough honestly. We're allowed to know with what we could cope with.

But against the grain - pizza hut is great for a chill date! 😂

thebestinterest · 11/02/2024 05:48

As another pp said, you have every right to be judge mental in this scenario. You’re talking about spending your time with someone you don’t know… honestly, things should be going smoothly not leaving you questioning things. It’s never a good thing when a date leaves us ‘taken aback’

The scars would put me off. Sorry, I know people recover and such, but, it’s a risk factor that they could go back to that should a veíais arise. So you really want to get bogged down in that?

there are 8 + billion people
worldwide: you can find someone who ticks all those boxes and doesn’t come with this dark baggage.

neverfair · 11/02/2024 05:41

I dated a guy for 5 years who self harmed, I personally would avoid unless you are happy to sacrifice your life and energy for this person.

bradpittsbathwater · 11/02/2024 05:39

It would put me off tbh. You're allowed to be put off by anything when dating somebody. Unlike everything else in life you're allowed to discriminate.

JMSA · 11/02/2024 05:37

I think it's a bit much that he took off his hoodie, and just left you to take that in with no prior explanation.
It's a bit 'this is me - deal with it'. And that's a bit much for a second date.

VerityUnreasonble · 11/02/2024 05:35

Self harm is just a coping mechanism. Lots of younger people use it as a way to cope as they have BIG FEELINGS but don't have the emotional maturity to have learnt how to manage them.

As adults we tend to have better coping strategies (although most people still have a few that aren't that healthy, smoking, over eating, over exercising, drinking to feel better even if not this isn't alcoholism). We also tend to feel some things less intensely, it isn't the absolute end of the world if we can't get a particular pair of shoes or fall out with a friend - young people aren't being dramatic, they genuinely feel like that in the moment. So adults don't need to self harm by cutting as much. Obviously, there are some that still do, but just because someone did it as a younger person really doesn't mean they will do it now or go back to it when things are tough.

Intriguedbythis · 11/02/2024 05:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

GroClock · 11/02/2024 04:39

I think you’re questioning it for a reason. Listen to your gut.

It would be a no from me. Carrying someone else’s past emotional baggage so early just wouldn’t be worth it.

kkloo · 11/02/2024 04:34

TooFondOfBooks · 11/02/2024 04:14

Self harm is incredibly common. Given the rate of rise recorded between 2007 & 2014 in England (I assume Covid did for 2021’s survey) I’d be astonished if we weren’t now close to a third of women in the 16-24 age bracket having self-harmed (from the 1/4 in 2014); & a more dramatic rise from the 10% of men in that age bracket who’d self-harmed in 2014.

The Samaritans disagree about self-harm being manipulative behaviour btw. It shouldn’t be confused/conflated with threats to deliberate harm oneself if eg a relationship is ended - that absolutely is abusive behaviour; & frequently enacted by individuals with no history of self-harm &/or suicidal ideation.

Some people scar very badly & the scars do not fade. I have chickenpox scars from over 30 years ago; & I didn’t have chickenpox badly, I just scar badly. Chickenpox, cat scratches, a burn from Home Economics class… I have friends who self harmed & are very badly scarred; & friends who haven’t a mark on them now.

His scars are visible, unlike the vast majority of MH issues. The fact they’re scars not wounds suggests that he probably no longer engages in self-harm: it is also common to effectively “grow out of” using it as a coping strategy (albeit a negative one) as people gain agency, independence, & maturity.

Imagine you had to wear a label saying “had depression & had to take [name of medication]”. Would you want that to be what people judged you on? For it to be considered a “red flag”? He might not be right for you; & at some point, if you pursue a relationship, you’ll need to discuss his scars. But leaping to wild conclusions (& what’s worse, if he in fact fell through a window or whatever you’ll feel an absolute buckeejit for deciding the scars are self harm) & writing him off when you didn’t get a bad vibe even seems foolish, to say the least.

The Samaritans also say:

Myth: People who say they are going to take their own life are just attention seeking and shouldn’t be taken seriously.

Fact: Talking openly about suicide to a loved one, colleague, professional or a Samaritan can help someone work through their thoughts and help them find a way to cope. People who say they want to end their lives should always be taken seriously. It may well be that they want attention in the sense of calling out for help and helping them get support may save their life. Being able to talk openly about suicide can help someone work through their thoughts.

They don't talk about the possibility of manipulation, even though it is extremely common. And I understand why they don't, because they want to prevent suicide, but their myths/facts are extremely biased for a reason, they're not necessarily the truth.

My ex self harmed in front of me as a form of manipulation, and also threatened suicide to manipulate me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread