Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

I had a date with a guy I met off tinder and his arms were covered in self harm scars.

649 replies

Toffeeandfudge1 · 11/02/2024 01:41

So I’ve been talking to this man for afew weeks over WhatsApp now and he seemed really nice. We had lots in common such as love of dogs, music taste, read the same books and so on. We also have children of a similar age. Sounded too good to be true. So we met up tonight for the second time and went to Pizza Hut, and it was really hot in the restaurant so he took his hoodie off and I couldn’t help but notice his arms were covered in scars. They looked old but I was a little taken back as I don’t know anyone that this. I was trying not to look although I felt a little awkward. Am I being unreasonably judgemental or is this a red flag?

OP posts:
Bernadinetta · 11/02/2024 09:59

God there’s some right snobs on here about Pizza Hut. “If it’s the norm in your social circle” and making jokes about how eating at Pizza Hut is more concerning than having serious mental health issues. It’s just a restaurant 🙄

JMSA · 11/02/2024 09:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

The irony, blaming the OP.

He's the one who didn't have the self-awareness to 'communicate' his scars, before whipping off his hoodie.

Brexile · 11/02/2024 09:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This would be my fear too. It's certainly true of alcoholics: "I gave up drinking for you!" "I started drinking again because you drove me to it!" I don't know whether self harm is analogous, but I wouldn't want any more partners who weren't psychologically healthy. We aren't rehabilitation centres for men who can't cope with life, and you don't owe somebody a second date just because they have had problems.

DaphneMoo · 11/02/2024 09:56

You can choose not to date whoever you like. I wouldn't date someone with self-harm scars. I would listen to your instinct, twice while dating I overrode my initial feelings on the "be kind" thinking both times my initial stay clear thoughts were right.

Trulyme · 11/02/2024 09:56

I completely understand why this would ring alarm bells for you.

It would be like knowing someone was an ex alcoholic or drug addict, it’s that worry that their mental health may get worse and resort back to it.

I’m not sure I would end things completely though.
I would just keep it in the back of my mind and be aware of any other red flags.

I know quite a few people who self harmed by cutting themselves or taking drugs etc when they were younger and they’re all well rounded adults.

I also know of a woman who has scars all over her because when she was young her brother got jealous and cut her all over.
Its something she’s very self conscious of and scars aren’t easy to conceal.

FWIW I think Pizza Hut is a perfect date place.
Its not too formal and it’s an easy going place that you can leave early if you need to (no waiting for 40mins just to serve you or for the bill).

MakeMeSmile3 · 11/02/2024 09:56

It’s a tough one, and it can be hurtful, but you are entitled to make choices, and they could well be based on your own fears and personal experiences. if someone had told me my now-husband was bipolar I wouldn’t have dated him in the first place , being totally honest. I love him, but if we knew of any signs of such at the start i wouldn’t have gone there.

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 09:54

89redballoons · 11/02/2024 09:50

I am including self harm here when I talk about "mental health issues". As I said further up the thread, I self harmed as a teenager and at 37 still have some visible scars.

However, I've been mentally well and stable for decades. My children (4 and 1) don't feel or think or have a framework that their mummy isn't safe because for as long as they've been alive and for a long time before that, I have been safe.

It's possible to heal and recover from addiction, too.

Of course, both the OP and you are allowed to not date people with a history of self harm or addiction, even if they say they are recovered. Either you don't believe them , or even if you do believe them, it would be too stressful for you given your particular childhood experience to be in a relationship and constantly be thinking "what if?" That's fine.

That is not the same as telling anyone with a history of self harm that they're necessarily harming their children because of that history, though.

And when your children see and ask about your scars you honestly think that isn’t going to create fear and insecurity? If no you’re naive.

Dibbydoos · 11/02/2024 09:53

This post shows just how self absorbed we've become. I'd be concerned and would have spoken about them if they were comfortable.

Ffs @Toffeeandfudge1 it's not a red flag it's honest conversation time then ypu can decide if its a red flag. You're not ready for a relationship imo.

Brawcolli · 11/02/2024 09:52

I have a lot of old self harm scars, some are covered with tattoos which are probably considered even worse by some mumsnetters, lol.
Of course you’re entitled to not see this guy again if you think his scars are red flags. Personally I’d be really hurt by someone judging my really old scars and would prefer not to date them!

89redballoons · 11/02/2024 09:50

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 09:12

Mental illness and mental health issues are vastly different things. A bit of mild depression or anxiety is different from self harming and other.

i never said shield a child, teaching a child about mental health issues is not the same as setting the framework that mummy / daddy is not safe.

I am including self harm here when I talk about "mental health issues". As I said further up the thread, I self harmed as a teenager and at 37 still have some visible scars.

However, I've been mentally well and stable for decades. My children (4 and 1) don't feel or think or have a framework that their mummy isn't safe because for as long as they've been alive and for a long time before that, I have been safe.

It's possible to heal and recover from addiction, too.

Of course, both the OP and you are allowed to not date people with a history of self harm or addiction, even if they say they are recovered. Either you don't believe them , or even if you do believe them, it would be too stressful for you given your particular childhood experience to be in a relationship and constantly be thinking "what if?" That's fine.

That is not the same as telling anyone with a history of self harm that they're necessarily harming their children because of that history, though.

Donmeistersleepmachine · 11/02/2024 09:50

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 11/02/2024 09:44

@Donmeistersleepmachine as I've said, people can make whatever decisions they like about their own boundaries and relationships but there's absolutely no need for all the unpleasant judgement displayed by so many posters.

Just say "it's not for me" and move one

It's a discussion at the end of the day and I think my experiences or outlook may help OP see a different perspective as may others. If everybody commented "no thanks" and that was it, the conversation would be shit and basically just a vote of WWYD. Boring. Context is everything.

It's easy to be upset or hurt because you feel targeted (not necessarily you but anybody who has experience self harming here) but it's just the truth. I used to not shower for weeks as a teen and live in squalor, and I mean absolute squalor. I don't get my hair and nails done ever, haven't had a hair cut in 10 years, I keep it long and trim the ends myself. I'd be written off by plenty of men for that, and I make peace with it. I've been sexually assaulted numerous times and had childhood trauma that let me to be very sexually expressive at a young age. Slept with a lot of people. Again, I'm a write off for some people once I share that, and I do. That's fine. Everybody has their downsides and upsides and everybody has a limit of what they are willing to take on baggage wise in a relationship as you say. I wouldn't be offended at somebody not wanting me because of the absurdly huge amounts of baggage I bring to the table. I shrug and say "fair enough".

Brawcolli · 11/02/2024 09:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What a weird thing to say. Where did you get this nonsense from ?

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 11/02/2024 09:50

I never said he should hide them, I said showing them so early in a relationship is a deliberate choice.

Deliberate in what way?

Maybe he was just hot and took his jumper off, not even thinking about his scars as they're not something that matter anymore.

BuffaloGirl · 11/02/2024 09:48

I’ve supported several people with mental
illness and self harm - it’s usually not something that just goes away, it can flare up again during stressful times.
I personally would not enter into a relationship with someone with known severe mental illness past or present.

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 09:48

Noshowlomo · 11/02/2024 09:45

Totally agree with @PaperDoIIs post. OP, you can not want to date someone for ANY reason.
It doesn’t make you judgmental if you have a feeling that you need to stop dating anyone.
To anyone saying, “it makes me sad as I have scars and if someone thought this about me…”. People are entitled to think anything they want about you. It has taken me a long 40 years to come to realise this. I’m overweight, and any man may not want to date me because of it. Up to them!
I wouldn’t go out with anyone with lots of visible scars, that’s me. I know people with scars, and they’ve all still got serious mental health issues, or drug and alcohol problems. I know not everyone with scars will have these issues, but maybe it’s just the town I live in.
Go with your gut OP. If it’s something you want to ask him about then be honest, but always go with your gut. Don’t try and force something if it’s just not there for you any more.

This!

ironically those with scars taking this personally don’t even realise they’re proving the point I have made.

Noshowlomo · 11/02/2024 09:45

Totally agree with @PaperDoIIs post. OP, you can not want to date someone for ANY reason.
It doesn’t make you judgmental if you have a feeling that you need to stop dating anyone.
To anyone saying, “it makes me sad as I have scars and if someone thought this about me…”. People are entitled to think anything they want about you. It has taken me a long 40 years to come to realise this. I’m overweight, and any man may not want to date me because of it. Up to them!
I wouldn’t go out with anyone with lots of visible scars, that’s me. I know people with scars, and they’ve all still got serious mental health issues, or drug and alcohol problems. I know not everyone with scars will have these issues, but maybe it’s just the town I live in.
Go with your gut OP. If it’s something you want to ask him about then be honest, but always go with your gut. Don’t try and force something if it’s just not there for you any more.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 11/02/2024 09:44

@Donmeistersleepmachine as I've said, people can make whatever decisions they like about their own boundaries and relationships but there's absolutely no need for all the unpleasant judgement displayed by so many posters.

Just say "it's not for me" and move one

10ThousandSpoons · 11/02/2024 09:41

Dogdilemma2000 · 11/02/2024 09:23

OP - my concern here would be how he seemingly so brazenly showed his scars.

As someone with scars I take massive efforts to hide them from anyone other than people I know really well. I always wear long sleeves. I’m meticulous in planning outfits.

He’s had a short sleeve shirt and a hoodie on a date to a restaurant. Anyone could predict they’d be too hot in a hoodie.

So my feelings here are that he’s shown his scars early in a “take me of leave me” style. He’d rather know now if you’ll accept him as he is or not.

Personally I’d not date someone with active major mental health issues. But if it was in the past and they are mentally well adjusted now possibly.

Only you can decide if you want to go ahead. Either you decide it’s a no or you have a very open and real face to face conversation about it.

Or he's got hot and taken his hoodie off. Why should people with any sort of scars cover them up?

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 09:41

Donmeistersleepmachine · 11/02/2024 09:35

Most people tend to want to be with someone similar to them in the important ways. Some people want mental stimulation, so want equal intelligence. Some people want equal ambition. Some people want equal stability. I think those who are offended are just hurt the pool of people willing to date them may be smaller. But that's a bad way of looking at it because there are people you yourselves would not consider due to their lifestyle/looks/personality/work ethic and so on.

I wouldn't want to be with someone with a servere history of mental illness, no. Sorry? I wouldnt bat an eyelid at somebody missing a leg, or someone with mild ADHD or autism. Severe Austim? No, because I want somebody likeminded to me who has the capacity to debate, reason, succeed, in the things that are important to me.

We ALL have preferences. People need to reign in their offence. By what some people here are saying they'd happily go for anybody with any lack of mental capacity, or serious mental illness, or difference in personality, or strongly not their physical type, just becuase they "get along" and "like the same music" and "had a good chat". No.

Exactly this.

10ThousandSpoons · 11/02/2024 09:40

Parisiennes · 11/02/2024 09:23

A hoodie
Pizza Hut
Scars

Is that the best he can do- wear a hoodie and suggest Pizza Hut?

Hardly making an effort unless that's the norm for yours and his social circle.

What's wrong with scars.

This is getting offensive now.

People have scars. For all sorts of reasons.

seafoamgreenhair · 11/02/2024 09:39

What if he was a smoker, and she found out he was a smoker, and it put her off? (Oh, Be Kind!) It is just bizarre the way the OP is being taken to task over this.

10ThousandSpoons · 11/02/2024 09:38

PaperDoIIs · 11/02/2024 09:19

What I find highly ironic is that for every thread where a woman has some doubts and niggles and she's told she's ignorant and awful and stupid and of course everything will be fine, there are a dozen more asking why women are dating men that at best, aren't ok.

This is why. Because we are told we're crazy and awful and judgemental. Because we are told to ignore our boundaries and inner voices. Because we are told to be kind and understanding and put time and effort in dating and getting to know a man that for whatever reason makes us uncomfortable.

And when it all goes wrong we all get high and mighty because of course she should've known and never dated him in the first place.

if she's uncomfortable of course she doesn't have to date him. No one is owed some sort of pity date.* *

WomanintheAttic · 11/02/2024 09:36

I would personally avoid dating anyone that had MH issues as I have enough of my own. I actively avoid going to MH support groups because I found being around other mentally unwell people seems to make my condition worse.

There is also the worry of a relapse, just like an alcoholic could turn to drink again.

@89redballoons Some do recover and some don’t . I can manage my condition now but it takes a monumental effort. For instance I can never drink alcohol as it induces mania but I will never be cured.

Life is difficult, you are on the precipice of a choice that has the possibility of making your life harder or not. I would advise you don’t as you have a child. I have met a lot of self harmers, all hid their scars. The only one I ever met who didn’t was a man who enjoyed distressing other service users.

10ThousandSpoons · 11/02/2024 09:36

Donmeistersleepmachine · 11/02/2024 09:13

My ex had scars too, old ones, no active ones. I'm not saying everyone who self harms is the same or in the same place mentally because there's lots of avenues you can go down to end up at self harm. However, all it took was one argument and because it was so normal to him to cut when upset, even though he had been talking to his ex I had to drive to the woods, bring him home, tend to his massive cut ALL over his thigh done with a rusty can .. I would have thought before this his cutting was well in the past. Basically, from experience, I wouldn't be with someone who had previously been so mentally unstable they were cutting themselves enough to cover their arms. One or two yes. But not covered in them - purely because it's too much of a risk for in my mind to go through that again. I have terrible choices in men but I wouldn't go near somebody romantically who has self harmed before - I myself have been through lots of trauma and only once ever have a taken anything to my body to hurt myself. It was a butter knife and I brought myself to reality quite quickly. But mentally troubled enough to cover arms, I'll personally be passing, and that's from experience.

You're welcome to, as a stable or strong person who hasn't experienced somebody like that, ignore what I'm saying because you think I'm being harsh. I just find those who have used cutting therapeutically for a prolonged period are quite inclined to do it again if emotions are heightened or you threaten to leave or if the situation is very heavy. Which is a huge stress for somebody stable who wouldnt ever do such things.

You're assuming I'm not with someone who's arms are covered in self harm scars.

Donmeistersleepmachine · 11/02/2024 09:35

UnimaginableWindBird · 11/02/2024 09:29

Let's be honest, though. A person who wouldn't date someone with self-harm scars is also going to refuse to date anyone who isn't neurotypical.

Most people tend to want to be with someone similar to them in the important ways. Some people want mental stimulation, so want equal intelligence. Some people want equal ambition. Some people want equal stability. I think those who are offended are just hurt the pool of people willing to date them may be smaller. But that's a bad way of looking at it because there are people you yourselves would not consider due to their lifestyle/looks/personality/work ethic and so on.

I wouldn't want to be with someone with a servere history of mental illness, no. Sorry? I wouldnt bat an eyelid at somebody missing a leg, or someone with mild ADHD or autism. Severe Austim? No, because I want somebody likeminded to me who has the capacity to debate, reason, succeed, in the things that are important to me.

We ALL have preferences. People need to reign in their offence. By what some people here are saying they'd happily go for anybody with any lack of mental capacity, or serious mental illness, or difference in personality, or strongly not their physical type, just becuase they "get along" and "like the same music" and "had a good chat". No.