I was close to someone who cut themselves in the past. I knew them for over 20 years and I can say I would never get involved, personally ever again.
Of course every case is different but I found that it flagged up a really vulnerable, unhappy, troubled person who struggled with being mentally healthy and yet refused to get help, ignored well meaning advice and was generally in denial.
Yes, things can be fine until there is time of stress, [and this personality can be very easily triggered by things we may not understand] when the initial problem resurfaces and maybe not by cutting any longer but it takes another path, usually self destructive to themselves or a close relationship. I've observed enormous temper, vile words, resentments, being ridiculously competitive with their peer group/partner and paranoia, to say the least.
Because I think the problem, unless intensively addressed and constantly worked on, is there deep down and will need a lifetime of management. Never really gone. The problem is even complex for anyone involved in mental health services.
It has affected my own well being a lot, and now trying [and succeeding to a large extent] to heal. It's been tough. OP I think your instinct [rather than an unfair 'judgment'] is spot on. You've had a clue, an indicator of someone who is not for you and are wise enough to know that.